Couch Tomatoes

Watchmen: Loving Remix or a Step Too Far From the Source?

Couch Tomatoes host Naz Perez is joined by Collider's Roxy Striar and Buzzfeed's Unsolved's Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara to talk Watchmen's best moments, most killer performances, and the biggest changes from the source material.

by | October 30, 2019 | Comments

The world is currently obsessed with HBO’s Certified Fresh Watchmen, the new TV series based on Alan Moore’s landmark graphic novel of the same name. But it’s that “based on” part that has some fans engaged in feverish debates following the show’s first two episodes. Showrunner Damon Lindelof‘s series takes bold risks, extending Moore’s universe rather than recreating the novel’s narrative and characters. For some the payoffs have been rewarding: Critics are loving this interpretation, with its risky dive into current affairs, narrative switch-ups, and killer performances – especially from Regina King and Don Johnson. For some Watchmen devotees, however, eyebrows have been raised. The series has become something of an, ahem, Rorschach Test.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And can’t we all just get along? We’re going deep on Watchmen in the latest episode of Couch Tomatoes. Host Naz Perez is asking the big questions and talking the series’ best moments with Collider’s Roxy Striar as well as Buzzfeed’s Unsolved‘s Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara; plus the panel is poring over fan theories and Easter Eggs and sharing the directions in which they’d like to see Lindelof steer the show.

With each episode of Couch Tomatoes, we dig into a major series or event and provide Fresh picks of great shows to help you cut through the clutter and only binge the best.

Watchmen airs Sundays on HBO. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Watchmen: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: 103.905%
Critics Consensus: Bold and bristling, Watchmen isn't always easy viewing, but by adding new layers of cultural context and a host of complex characters it expertly builds on its source material to create an impressive identity of its own.
Synopsis: Damon Lindelof (The Leftovers, Lost) creates a modern-day re-imagining of Alan Moore's groundbreaking graphic novel about masked vigilantes.... [More]

Tag Cloud

Lionsgate Spectrum Originals stoner Elton John BAFTA spinoff dceu 71st Emmy Awards Discovery Channel Writers Guild of America composers zero dark thirty Musicals LGBT indie Ovation Comic Book films critics Animation Emmy Nominations Set visit renewed TV shows See It Skip It Mary poppins Drama Song of Ice and Fire video on demand dc Ghostbusters blockbuster Marathons Universal Comedy Tumblr Creative Arts Emmys Crunchyroll cooking tv talk Marvel Studios werewolf Western elevated horror Mindy Kaling movies joker Sundance Now cancelled TV shows Epix cancelled Turner Travel Channel Fantasy El Rey Countdown Nominations Action television comiccon Cannes CBS witnail Extras Binge Guide Amazon Prime Video SDCC Sundance TV quibi boxoffice batman spanish language nature parents cancelled TV series Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt YouTube Premium Women's History Month New York Comic Con crime what to watch hispanic singing competition Crackle psychological thriller blaxploitation Disney Biopics criterion crime drama Tomatazos disaster unscripted space Britbox supernatural Starz Best and Worst foreign Netflix Christmas movies Tubi Disney+ Disney Plus Cartoon Network TV Character Guide Comedy Central mutant 2019 ABC TLC YouTube Red Rocky transformers Pop documentaries BBC One cancelled television TNT CMT Emmys AMC indiana jones Paramount Network Infographic GLAAD facebook Watching Series FOX christmas movies series National Geographic TCA 2017 APB HBO Schedule aliens IFC dogs chucky Film Festival Black Mirror Pop TV robots Superheroes adventure FX IFC Films breaking bad 24 frames Avengers NYCC asian-american versus FXX teaser zombies NBC Sneak Peek cats Election based on movie travel 45 politics child's play casting cinemax Marvel Television Pet Sematary HBO Max all-time MSNBC Awards Tour crime thriller Apple Lifetime Christmas movies children's TV Rock Stephen King movie Video Games American Society of Cinematographers TCA Awards PaleyFest franchise TCA Teen sitcom twilight Holidays Turner Classic Movies south america Paramount Premiere Dates X-Men San Diego Comic-Con Winter TV Holiday Disney Channel award winner Awards PlayStation Year in Review BET social media SundanceTV golden globes Arrowverse period drama Valentine's Day Anna Paquin Superheroe RT History game show A&E festivals news serial killer harry potter Endgame The Witch PBS Walt Disney Pictures Esquire Freeform Pride Month CBS All Access Nickelodeon doctor who WGN GIFs Syfy Mudbound Thanksgiving Television Academy Star Trek spain TruTV Hallmark Christmas movies 2016 Brie Larson 21st Century Fox Spike political drama book theme song Martial Arts The Walking Dead Kids & Family spider-man mission: impossible Bravo scary movies Captain marvel revenge Classic Film VOD Shudder Funimation jamie lee curtis romance streaming free movies Sundance name the review animated documentary toy story zombie medical drama discovery screenings Red Carpet HBO Go adaptation The CW OWN TCM Oscars universal monsters DC streaming service vampires ITV Reality war police drama Baby Yoda concert OneApp MCU Disney Plus crossover comics Apple TV Plus true crime CW Seed science fiction latino stand-up comedy ratings Food Network Lucasfilm 2015 Mary Tyler Moore historical drama anthology Quiz Film Sci-Fi TCA Winter 2020 Fox News Spring TV Hulu Polls and Games Certified Fresh Adult Swim halloween cults 2017 die hard Warner Bros. ABC Family Ellie Kemper Musical Podcast independent sag awards Comics on TV Showtime slashers sports Opinion dragons FX on Hulu binge cars ghosts DirecTV justice league 2018 Country First Look technology screen actors guild CNN RT21 DC Comics E! anime BBC cops Fall TV Disney streaming service psycho Mystery BBC America diversity Amazon Studios reviews Peacock VH1 Trivia TIFF Academy Awards canceled biography Nat Geo Amazon Prime Box Office Columbia Pictures Chilling Adventures of Sabrina kids rotten movies we love Trophy Talk ESPN Masterpiece Music Rocketman Pirates BET Awards Star Wars thriller 20th Century Fox Summer 4/20 mockumentary Rom-Com Apple TV+ docudrama Tarantino History Horror reboot strong female leads E3 best YA comedies satire richard e. Grant Interview SXSW Logo romantic comedy TBS YouTube a nightmare on elm street Vudu First Reviews green book natural history VICE Toys Reality Competition cartoon Sony Pictures game of thrones GoT Winners 2020 Amazon Cosplay USA Network LGBTQ Netflix MTV Black History Month Lifetime spy thriller DC Universe DGA Television Critics Association Shondaland Heroines Christmas miniseries video sequel finale WarnerMedia dark Dark Horse Comics President Photos hist Super Bowl Acorn TV The Arrangement Pixar directors A24 emmy awards Family Marvel talk show Chernobyl The Purge TV renewals TV Land canceled TV shows Grammys USA Calendar comic Hear Us Out dramedy Mary Poppins Returns Trailer Hallmark 007