Couch Tomatoes

Watchmen: Loving Remix or a Step Too Far From the Source?

Couch Tomatoes host Naz Perez is joined by Collider's Roxy Striar and Buzzfeed's Unsolved's Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara to talk Watchmen's best moments, most killer performances, and the biggest changes from the source material.

by | October 30, 2019 | Comments

The world is currently obsessed with HBO’s Certified Fresh Watchmen, the new TV series based on Alan Moore’s landmark graphic novel of the same name. But it’s that “based on” part that has some fans engaged in feverish debates following the show’s first two episodes. Showrunner Damon Lindelof‘s series takes bold risks, extending Moore’s universe rather than recreating the novel’s narrative and characters. For some the payoffs have been rewarding: Critics are loving this interpretation, with its risky dive into current affairs, narrative switch-ups, and killer performances – especially from Regina King and Don Johnson. For some Watchmen devotees, however, eyebrows have been raised. The series has become something of an, ahem, Rorschach Test.

Who’s right? Who’s wrong? And can’t we all just get along? We’re going deep on Watchmen in the latest episode of Couch Tomatoes. Host Naz Perez is asking the big questions and talking the series’ best moments with Collider’s Roxy Striar as well as Buzzfeed’s Unsolved‘s Shane Madej and Ryan Bergara; plus the panel is poring over fan theories and Easter Eggs and sharing the directions in which they’d like to see Lindelof steer the show.

With each episode of Couch Tomatoes, we dig into a major series or event and provide Fresh picks of great shows to help you cut through the clutter and only binge the best.

Watchmen airs Sundays on HBO. 

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Watchmen: Season 1 (2019)

Adjusted Score: 104.421%
Critics Consensus: Bold and bristling, Watchmen isn't always easy viewing, but by adding new layers of cultural context and a host of complex characters it expertly builds on its source material to create an impressive identity of its own.
Synopsis: Damon Lindelof (The Leftovers, Lost) creates a modern-day re-imagining of Alan Moore's groundbreaking graphic novel about masked vigilantes.... [More]

Tag Cloud

Year in Review Tarantino TCA children's TV Masterpiece Winter TV TCA Winter 2020 politics Sneak Peek doctor who Ovation PBS American Society of Cinematographers green book dragons GLAAD Cosplay Crunchyroll rotten movies we love cops streaming HBO Max anime Podcast X-Men Watching Series Anna Paquin Ellie Kemper based on movie The Arrangement 2019 Mary Poppins Returns miniseries YouTube Red USA Network Freeform Pet Sematary anthology Logo Black Mirror Music SXSW CW Seed mutant hist Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt psycho docudrama Nominations toy story halloween comic Turner TIFF Schedule Teen boxoffice Trivia Kids & Family Stephen King period drama The Purge crossover witnail Marvel Horror batman richard e. Grant Disney+ Disney Plus Disney Channel award winner foreign ABC New York Comic Con breaking bad vampires animated ESPN Pirates video LGBTQ MTV Star Wars Mary Tyler Moore WGN Epix Tomatazos Song of Ice and Fire YA Tumblr Hulu finale FOX romantic comedy Lifetime Christmas movies Columbia Pictures cinemax Apple blaxploitation Emmy Nominations Awards Adult Swim El Rey Netflix Red Carpet 21st Century Fox cults Extras justice league Mary poppins Acorn TV Endgame historical drama Country police drama spain Sci-Fi Drama versus Creative Arts Emmys 2016 Action festivals LGBT 2015 canceled TV shows The CW Comics on TV DC Universe Marathons what to watch Superheroes Academy Awards adventure Food Network Nat Geo ITV Heroines Ghostbusters reboot hispanic Universal crime thriller thriller ABC Family Starz game of thrones USA golden globes Writers Guild of America DirecTV joker transformers Television Academy Cannes binge BET Marvel Television crime Britbox Election Comedy CBS All Access Winners spinoff Amazon Prime renewed TV shows AMC werewolf free movies Calendar TCA 2017 Spectrum Originals Showtime TV Land Rocky Pop Thanksgiving zero dark thirty A24 Arrowverse A&E disaster cooking Polls and Games biography cancelled television kids dramedy mockumentary DC Comics science fiction Elton John sitcom YouTube Crackle screenings TV renewals Fall TV Lifetime Superheroe independent war travel Sundance TruTV book Reality Competition Christmas Lionsgate indie zombies NBC Nickelodeon Paramount Warner Bros. cats Quiz Film Festival Marvel Studios WarnerMedia series MCU Pride Month See It Skip It 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies Rom-Com facebook Sundance TV Super Bowl sports cancelled 2018 serial killer Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TLC First Look Reality TBS Family Netflix Christmas movies Martial Arts cartoon Apple TV Plus Grammys slashers Tubi History VH1 Paramount Network spanish language FXX Apple TV+ Mindy Kaling discovery YouTube Premium social media HBO San Diego Comic-Con Premiere Dates harry potter Dark Horse Comics 2020 south america MSNBC E3 The Witch Shondaland Esquire Rock Disney streaming service The Walking Dead game show GoT quibi Bravo Classic Film OneApp elevated horror 2017 zombie psychological thriller PaleyFest sag awards FX Holiday talk show Musicals DGA Peacock spy thriller Amazon Trailer nature TCM Comic Book CMT Syfy Turner Classic Movies crime drama television Mudbound Toys CBS theme song President Interview SundanceTV name the review true crime cancelled TV shows dceu aliens Pixar technology Fox News stand-up comedy VICE Trophy Talk dc CNN Mystery Countdown movies comiccon Sundance Now NYCC Opinion Fantasy Valentine's Day Spike political drama BBC America Western directors Biopics Film Character Guide 45 Box Office Vudu natural history Set visit Animation Musical Awards Tour comics Photos revenge Disney Plus ratings First Reviews Cartoon Network Binge Guide robots IFC Films adaptation supernatural RT21 Best and Worst IFC canceled latino medical drama National Geographic Amazon Prime Video blockbuster E! jamie lee curtis cancelled TV series GIFs Infographic Women's History Month christmas movies 007 romance diversity Discovery Channel APB Sony Pictures TV TNT Comedy Central spider-man Baby Yoda Disney Certified Fresh BBC Emmys Rocketman teaser space Lucasfilm Captain marvel cars Summer sequel ghosts SDCC Walt Disney Pictures Star Trek Chernobyl DC streaming service Holidays Oscars OWN unscripted Spring TV composers Brie Larson Shudder screen actors guild Hallmark 24 frames singing competition Avengers strong female leads casting 20th Century Fox RT History tv talk Video Games