Black Panther Reviews: More Than Just Another Marvel Triumph

by | February 6, 2018 | Comments

(Photo by Walt Disney Studios)

We are 18 movies into the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and the franchise is as hot as ever. Black Panther has been one of the most anticipated titles in the series, ushering in the world of Wakanda and its predominantly black ensemble of characters. And as we see from the first wave of reviews, Marvel does not disappoint even the highest of expectations.

Below is a breakdown of what the critics are saying about the action, villain, costumes, scene-stealing actresses and more.

How does Black Panther compare to other Marvel movies?

Black Panther is the best Marvel film thus far.
Joelle Monique, Polygon

Ryan Coogler delivers the best Marvel movie so far.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

Marvel’s boldest movie yet, and fortunately, it’s also one of its best.
Haleigh Foutch, Collider

Not only holds its own, but improves on the formula in several key respects, from a politically engaged villain to an emotionally grounded final showdown.
Peter Debruge, Variety

This isn’t just one of the best movies in the MCU – it caps off the franchise’s best run of movies ever, which started last year with Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2.
Angie Han, Mashable

One of the best superhero films I have seen in decades.
Clay Cane, News One

[Will satisfy] newcomers who probably haven’t seen a Marvel film but want to experience seeing Black excellence on the big screen.
Wilson Morales,

How is Chadwick Boseman in the lead?

Boseman dazzles as T’Challa, portraying him as the regal yet vulnerable character he is.
Tonja Renee Stidhum, Shadow and Act

Boseman, a stunningly versatile actor… digs so deep into T’Challa that you can feel his nerve endings.
Peter Travers, Rolling Stone

An impeccable actor, Boseman brings the quality of belief he’s brought to playing real people like Jackie Robinson, James Brown and Thurgood Marshall to the role.
Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles times

Boseman might be the least interesting part of the movie as the titular lead, which says a lot about how well the rest of the characters are written and cast.
– Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

How is the villain?

Jordan’s Kilmonger is the strongest villain in the MCU thus far.
Wilson Morales,

The most satisfying comic-book adversary since Heath Ledger’s Joker.
Peter Debruge, Variety

Jordan completely takes over Black Panther every single time he’s onscreen. We’re talking Jack Nicholson in Tim Burton’s Batman levels of domination, where the bad guy is so compelling he almost makes you forget that the movie is actually supposed to be about someone else.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

He is a menacing yet charismatic presence who thanks to a nuanced script is a character injected with a sympathetic edge. Even when he’s at his most terrifying and rage-fueled his anger is understandable.
Katherine McLaughlin, SciFiNow

I have never cared for a villain the way I care for Michael B. Jordan’s Erik Killmonger… He is the crown jewel of an incredibly wealthy project.
Joelle Monique, Polygon

Who else steals the movie?

It’s the women… ohhhh, the women, who truly help Wakanda shine.
Tonja Renee Stidhum, Shadow and Act

Played by Letitia Wright, Shuri is a revelation. Wright steals every scene with her bright smile and perfect comedic timing…I cannot fully express the joy of seeing a smart, carefree, nonsexualized young black woman on the big screen.
Joelle Monique, Polygon

There’s no beating the smarts and sass of the wonderous Letitia Wright, who brings scene-stealing to the level of grand larceny as Princess Shuri… Wright is a star in the making, who makes damn sure that Shuri will be a role model to young girls for years to come.
Peter Travers, Rolling Stone

Wright would be able to hold a Shuri Black Panther solo movie on her own.
Jamie Broadnax, Black Girl Nerds

It’s The Walking Dead’s Gurira who steals the show as the ferocious Okoye, gloriously swinging her spear in a billowing red gown.
Emma Simmonds, Radio Times

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

 How is the action?

The action scenes in Black Panther are definitely a step up from what I’ve seen in previous Marvel movies.
Jamie Broadnax, Black Girl Nerds

Black Panther features at least one sequence that out-007s the recent James Bond movies…among that sequence’s thrilling aspects is Black Panther riding on top of a driverless sports car.
– Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

Even by Marvel’s standards, the action in Black Panther is subpar.
Matt Singer, ScreenCrush

It’s not just that the choreography in Black Panther lacks coherence, but also that every fight scene is undone by awful CG.
David Ehrlich, IndieWire

[The action scenes] almost feel obligatory. It’s obvious Ryan Coogler didn’t direct Black Panther to make an action movie.
Mike Ryan, Uproxx

How is Ryan Coogler’s directing?

Like Christopher Nolan, who was 35 when he reanimated the Batman franchise, the 31-year-old Coogler has a gift for putting his own spin on genre, for making popular culture worlds his own.
– Kenneth Turan, Los Angeles times

Coogler’s directing strengths are more intimate. There are sequences in Black Panther that may make you cry because of where they go and what they say, but also because of the sensitivity he brings to them.
– Manohla Dargis, New York Times

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

How does the movie look?

Black Panther is alive with visual miracles.
– Peter Travers, Rolling Stone

From start to finish, costume designer Ruth Carter’s vibrant colors for the characters and Hannah Beachler’s dazzling production values makes this a beautiful film.
– Wilson Morales,

As imagined by production designer Hannah Beachler, Wakanda is all bright colors, contrasting textures, and jaw-dropping tech. It’s fantastical enough to inspire wonder, and grounded enough to awaken yearning. It’s a tantalizing glimpse at what might have been, in some alternate reality not defined by white society.
– Angie Han, Mashable

Production design, costumes, and of course, visual effects are all on point, and newly minted Oscar-nominee Rachel Morrison shoots every frame to embrace the sumptuous detail.
– Haleigh Foutch, Collider

DP Rachel Morrison delivers a plethora of gorgeous vistas that wash over the screen and each one holds specific meaning.
– Katherine McLaughlin, SciFiNow

What else is great about Black Panther?

[This is] a Marvel film that actually feels like it takes place in the real world…you believe — maybe for the first time — that the MCU actually matters.
– David Ehrlich, IndieWire

[Wakanda] is a fully realized world, worth visiting over and over… if Disney ever wants to give Marvel a truly immersive theme park treatment, it should start by creating a Wakanda expansion land.
– Bryan Bishop, The Verge

It’s a testament to the writing that you could go long on each of these characters, who they are, their motivations and their emotional interiors; Black Panther knows how to give three-dimensional life to supporting characters with very limited space to do so.
– Rodrigo Perez, The Playlist

There’s so much to enjoy about Black Panther that it is hard to know where to stop.
– Joelle Monique, Polygon

(Photo by Marvel Studios)

Just how important is this movie?

What it means is everything, especially to any kid who has never put the words “African” and “king” together in the same sentence. Or to any young woman who was ever discouraged from chasing a life in science and technology. To anyone who was ever told “you fight like a girl.”
Marc Bernardin, Nerdist

It is the power of representation in its best form. It is empowerment on a higher level. It is inspiration to a different degree. It is black excellence exemplified that will leave audiences yearning to inhabit Wakanda forever.
Tonja Renee Stidhum, Shadow and Act

Black Panther is as powerful for Black women as Wonder Woman was for white women.
Clay Cane, News One

Race matters in Black Panther and it matters deeply, not in terms of Manichaean good guys and bad but as a means to explore larger human concerns about the past, the present and the uses and abuses of power.
– Manohla Dargis, New York Times

It’s a vital moment in cinema history and a heartfelt, thoughtful exploration of the scars of colonialism and the hope for healing.
Haleigh Foutch, Collider

[This] feels like a turning point, one where the studio has finally recognized that its movies can be about more than just selling the next installment.
Bryan Bishop, The Verge

Black Panther opens everywhere on Friday, February 16. Read all the reviews for it here.

Tag Cloud

green book robots Logo Adult Swim History Podcast cancelled TV series Animation Set visit Fantasy zero dark thirty die hard mockumentary A24 First Look Musical Martial Arts Nickelodeon Polls and Games supernatural crime drama stand-up comedy Holidays Quiz spider-man Hulu dogs VICE crime thriller TBS Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt political drama dc mutant SXSW Musicals miniseries Ghostbusters Tomatazos a nightmare on elm street FOX FXX comic quibi screen actors guild Fall TV VH1 Sneak Peek diversity hispanic 45 IFC Films stoner Biopics justice league DC Universe Cannes zombies singing competition casting Marvel Studios zombie Endgame Tubi Countdown DC Comics Watching Series The Purge reboot Disney Channel Marvel Television spinoff Reality Binge Guide halloween dragons Classic Film Nominations Shondaland IFC blockbuster E! Mindy Kaling American Society of Cinematographers Mary Tyler Moore Emmys Comedy Central tv talk PaleyFest HBO Max LGBTQ Apple TV+ comiccon Disney streaming service Action Christmas 71st Emmy Awards Pixar spanish language 2015 sports renewed TV shows Disney Plus screenings Sundance TV President Apple Western The Arrangement Calendar Box Office Mary Poppins Returns Grammys cults Crunchyroll Amazon Studios APB Winners Nat Geo MTV reviews Rocky Brie Larson Marathons television Warner Bros. Captain marvel Spring TV adventure El Rey OWN Esquire based on movie Ovation true crime witnail 21st Century Fox transformers ghosts WarnerMedia 2017 Women's History Month vampires TruTV Tumblr werewolf Columbia Pictures Syfy universal monsters Disney+ Disney Plus cops The CW cars Kids & Family composers blaxploitation SDCC Sony Pictures First Reviews festivals Walt Disney Pictures YouTube DC streaming service Trailer Superheroes documentary Masterpiece Mudbound Britbox natural history Super Bowl Star Trek cats comics toy story franchise name the review versus war Country Turner Classic Movies NYCC Creative Arts Emmys psycho YouTube Red USA Network dceu Year in Review 20th Century Fox Mystery theme song boxoffice A&E ABC Family richard e. Grant Awards Tour aliens Stephen King Pride Month parents facebook Paramount travel joker batman Infographic serial killer children's TV Valentine's Day Horror cancelled television Film Festival hist Drama The Witch Teen finale space Starz jamie lee curtis criterion TCA Winter 2020 E3 comedies YA game of thrones Pop TV kids thriller ratings Awards animated Holiday Interview Peacock Photos Star Wars doctor who SundanceTV Hallmark Christmas movies Summer Travel Channel crime Anna Paquin police drama Crackle YouTube Premium Turner cartoon unscripted Amazon Prime Spectrum Originals revenge Apple TV Plus adaptation GIFs AMC Hallmark New York Comic Con strong female leads Academy Awards indie Toys mission: impossible Amazon Pet Sematary latino sag awards cooking Election 007 TIFF Disney Comics on TV Schedule Red Carpet Epix disaster series Hear Us Out harry potter canceled TV shows Reality Competition Acorn TV GoT Avengers movies Sci-Fi Chernobyl Chilling Adventures of Sabrina golden globes canceled Writers Guild of America slashers 2018 CNN MCU social media HBO Oscars Film Marvel TNT Dark Horse Comics rotten movies we love cinemax south america Music historical drama anthology Universal MSNBC Winter TV See It Skip It Trivia romance ESPN dark anime talk show child's play award winner Cartoon Network breaking bad spain christmas movies directors CBS DGA concert video what to watch Tarantino technology Pop ITV game show CMT scary movies Arrowverse Character Guide biography 4/20 TV renewals RT21 Thanksgiving RT History PBS book Best and Worst BBC Sundance Now streaming cancelled Comedy Opinion Discovery Channel Vudu LGBT politics crossover Emmy Nominations science fiction Rom-Com USA TV Land 2020 Superheroe Showtime TV TCM dramedy free movies docudrama Freeform nature Shudder Lucasfilm BET 2019 FX independent Lifetime Christmas movies Bravo Premiere Dates Amazon Prime Video Extras psychological thriller Mary poppins Food Network Paramount Network medical drama Ellie Kemper Family romantic comedy Song of Ice and Fire Cosplay Funimation Elton John discovery TCA Spike TCA 2017 BBC America spy thriller Rock Baby Yoda cancelled TV shows Lionsgate GLAAD Sundance San Diego Comic-Con sitcom elevated horror 24 frames Pirates movie binge Rocketman period drama DirecTV chucky 2016 TLC ABC Black History Month OneApp Lifetime The Walking Dead teaser Television Academy Comic Book X-Men NBC best CW Seed Certified Fresh WGN FX on Hulu Netflix Fox News Trophy Talk National Geographic Heroines sequel Black Mirror Netflix Christmas movies Video Games asian-american foreign CBS All Access