News

The 21 Best TV Premieres of the Past 21 Years

From Lost to The O.C., The Wire to Game of Thrones, Rotten Tomatoes ranks the very best TV pilots of the past two-plus decades.

by | March 8, 2019 | Comments

LOST, (from left): Josh Holloway, Terry O'Quinn, Daniel Dae Kim, Yun Jin Kim, Naveen Andrews, Dominic Monoghan, Malcolm David Kelley, Harold Perrineau, Matthew Fox, Evangeline Lilly, Jorge Garcia, Maggie Grace, Ian Somerhalder, (Season 1), 2004-2010. photo: Bob D'Amico / © ABC / Courtesy: Everett Collection

(Photo by Bob D'Amico / © ABC / Courtesy: Everett Collection)

In 2019, Rotten Tomatoes turns 21, and to mark the occasion we’re celebrating with a series of features that look back at the brightest moments on screen of the past two decades – and one year – and the things that have us excited for the future. 

The first episode of a TV series is the most crucial episode of the entire show: It introduces the characters and the plot, sure, but most importantly, it helps viewers decide immediately whether they want to keep watching.

In the Peak TV era, that’s more important than ever — especially since the internet means literally any TV series that ever existed is usually just a few clicks away from streaming directly into your brain (OK, not yet, but soon).

Rotten Tomatoes consulted the Tomatometer and more than a half-dozen reputable best-of lists to very scientifically rank the top 21 TV pilots of the past 21 years (no, seriously, there were spreadsheets involved). We also applied a touch of editorial discretion to make some big calls, leaning into which have stood the test of time. What resulted is a list that includes series dating from 1999 to 2017. They’re sci-fi classics, beloved sitcoms, teen dramas, and dystopian commentary. And they all have one thing in common: They’re brilliant, re-watchable television.


Pushing Daisies 96%


Rank: 21
Network: ABC
Premiere date: October 3, 2007
Stars: Lee Pace, Anna Friel, Kristin Chenoweth

Creator Bryan Fuller’s distinct, quirky style is on full display in the pilot of his canceled-too-soon Pushing Daisies. The pun-tastic episode name alone — “Pie-lette” — shows you exactly what tone to expect from the bright, fun series (which, since it’s actually about star-crossed lovers who can’t touch because one possesses a supernatural gift that would lead to the death of the other, is quite a feat).


Alias 86%


Rank: 20
Network: ABC
Premiere date: September 30, 2001
Stars: Jennifer Garner, Bradley Cooper, Michael Vartan, Merrin Dungey

Jennifer Garner may have at one time been married to Batman, but the true action star of that marriage was definitely the woman also known as Sydney Bristow. Garner was smart and funny and badass as the CIA double agent working to bring down an evil alliance — plus she had a collection of wigs that The Americans’ Elizabeth Jennings would envy. The pilot episode not only showed off Garner’s badassery, but also allowed the world to fall in love with the girl next door who happened to be one of the world’s most accomplished spies.


Orphan Black 93%


Rank: 19
Network: BBC America
Premiere date: March 30, 2013
Stars: Tatiana Maslany, Tatiana Maslany, Tatiana Maslany, Tatiana Maslany

The opening minutes of Orphan Black are intriguing enough, with British twentysomething Sarah Manning encountering a troubled woman on a subway platform moments before she commits suicide — but the shock when the woman turns around and looks identical to Sarah is just as surprising to the audience as it is to Sarah, who soon uncovers a global conspiracy and learns that the woman is one of many who look like her. They’re clones. It’s the first glimpse at the incredible work star Tatiana Maslany does as the seestras, and a fascinating start to an expansive, imaginative modern sci-fi series.


The West Wing 75%


Rank: 18
Network: NBC
Premiere date: September 22, 1999
Stars: Bradley Whitford, Allison Janney, Martin Sheen, Richard Schiff

This behind-the-scenes look at politics is not only smart and funny — Aaron Sorkin at his best — but it also managed to tackle current politics and world affairs in a way that few other shows had been able to before. And while Sorkin’s writing is a direct response to what was going on in the country at the time, it never feels dated. It was instantly thrilling to be transported into the Beltway in the pilot. Part of that can be attributed to the show’s famous walk-and-talk technique, which was established in the first episode.


Six Feet Under 81%


Rank: 17
Network: HBO
Premiere date: June 3, 2001
Stars: Peter Krause, Lauren Ambrose, Frances Conroy, Michael C. Hall

The finale of Alan Ball’s family drama has one of the best closing sequences of all time — just try to listen to Sia’s “Breathe Me” and not cry, we dare you — but what’s sometimes lost is how original and even magical the pilot is as well, setting up the story of the Fisher family and their journeys through life and death.


The O.C. 67%


Rank: 16
Network: Fox
Premiere date: August 5, 2003
Stars: Ben McKenzie, Adam Brody, Mischa Barton, Rachel Bilson

“Welcome to the O.C., bitch.” The pilot for The O.C. is, in some ways, incredibly, painfully 2003 — the fashion alone makes it very apparent when the series takes place — but it’s also a fascinating look at a very specific time in life (high school), with class commentary to boot.


Atlanta 97%


Rank: 15
Network: FX
Premiere date: September 6, 2016
Stars: Donald Glover, Brian Tyree Henry, Zazie Beetz, Lakeith Stanfield

Donald Glover’s love letter to his hometown is a slice-of-life look at a group of friends who are just trying to get by. And, despite the series’ humor, it doesn’t devolve into sitcom theatrics, but portrays its inhabitants, setting, and situations authentically. The visually stunning pilot, directed by Hiro Mirai, also showcases honest writing and superb music by Glover, who now has five Grammys as music artist Childish Gambino.


Homeland 85%


Rank: 14
Network: Showtime
Premiere date: October 2, 2011
Stars: Claire Danes, Mandy Patinkin, Damian Lewis

The premiere of Showtime’s long-running CIA drama would’ve been a tense, compelling episode of television no matter what, but Claire Danes’ performance as troubled CIA field operative Carrie Matheson gave us a strong, complex character, and one of TV’s all-time greats.


The Shield 90%


Rank: 13
Network: FX
Premiere date: March 2, 2002
Stars: Michael Chiklis, Walton Goggins

Chiklis won an Emmy for his performance in the pilot as Det. Vic Mackey, a dirty cop who will do anything to keep the streets of Los Angeles free from crime, including commit some himself. Creator Shawn Ryan seemingly wrote himself into a corner in the pilot, when Mackey shoots a fellow cop, but, in truth, Ryan set high expectations that the series would go on to live up to and more over the course of seven seasons.


Friday Night Lights 97%


Rank: 12
Network: NBC
Premiere date: October 3, 2006
Stars: Kyle Chandler, Connie Britton

Words spoken to many a person about the Texas-set drama: “It’s not about football, though.” And while the first episode of the critically acclaimed series is, yes, about a high school football team and, yes, culminates at a high school football game, it’s also clear that this is a series about family, emotion, class, dedication, and other universal themes.


Mr. Robot 94%


Rank: 11
Network: USA
Premiere date: June 24, 2015
Stars: Rami Malek, Christian Slater, Carly Chaikin, Portia Doubleday

Mr. Robot is a show ostensibly about technology (and, you know, the pitfalls of capitalism), but, as made clear from its first episode, it’s not a show you can watch while scrolling on a smartphone. It’s a show that demands complete attention, something that’s hard to come by in an increasingly distracted world.


The Wire 94%


Rank: 10
Network: HBO
Premiere date: June 2, 2002
Stars: Dominic West, Idris Elba, Wendell Pierce, Michael K. Williams

Tired of friends asking you if you’ve seen The Wire? That’s probably because you haven’t. If you had, you’d join them in gushing about the five-season HBO series about the drug scene in Baltimore. David Simon’s series opens with an hour that perfectly sets a tone that the show admirably maintains throughout its run.


Arrested Development 74%


Rank: 9
Network: Fox
Premiere date: November 2, 2003
Stars: Jason Bateman, Will Arnett, Portia de Rossi, Michael Cera

Plenty of TV shows take a bit of time to find the perfect rhythm and tone, but not Arrested Development. From Ron Howard’s narrator to the eccentric Bluths, every character is fully formed in this practically perfect half hour of television.


Battlestar Galactica: The Plan (2009) 83%


Rank: 8
Network: Syfy
Premiere date: December 8, 2003
Stars: Edward James Olmos, Mary McDonnell Katee Sackhoff, Tricia Helfer, Jamie Bamber

While plenty hail the official first episode of the Battlestar Galactica reboot, “33,” as one of TV’s all-time best episodes, that hour owes much of its success to the miniseries that essentially served as a four-hour pilot for the show. The miniseries built a world and introduced characters in much greater detail and depth than any 42-minute broadcast ever can. Is that cheating? Maybe, but it also was directly responsible for the renewed interest in the classic sci-fi property that allowed it to become one of TV’s most critically acclaimed series.


Game of Thrones 89%


Rank: 7
Network: HBO
Premiere date: April 17, 2011
Stars: Emilia Clarke, Peter Dinklage, Kit Harington, Sean Bean

“Winter Is Coming” is both the title of the sprawling HBO drama’s premiere and, as the motto of House Stark, also the promise (or threat?) the series has offered since it began: that dark days are headed to the medieval-esque fictional kingdom of Westeros. Upon its premiere, it was hailed as a strong, faithful adaptation of George R. R. Martin’s book and was successful enough to earn a second season renewal just two days after its debut. (Everything could have been different, however; series creators David Benioff and D.B. Weiss famously scrapped the first pilot.)


The Walking Dead 80%


Rank: 6
Network: AMC
Premiere date: October 31, 2010
Stars: Andrew Lincoln, Norman Reedus, Steven Yeun, Jon Bernthal

The opening episode of AMC’s zombie apocalypse series was the network’s highest-rated premiere ever, and the tense installment that opened the show was both stunningly gorgeous and incredibly terrifying, locking in an audience that would stick around to make it one of the biggest shows on television — a true feat in an era of increasingly fractured viewership.


The Sopranos 92%


Rank: 5
Network: HBO
Premiere date: January 10, 1999
Stars: James Gandolfini, Edie Falco, Lorraine Bracco

David Chase’s series about mob boss Tony Soprano, the original cable antihero, and his extended family is largely credited with ushering in a second golden age of television. The most acclaimed scene from the pilot, where Tony is feeding ducks in his pool and has a panic attack when they leave, encapsulates Tony’s existential dread, which the series would go on to portray so well.


The Handmaid's Tale 83%


Rank: 4
Network: Hulu
Premiere date: April 26, 2017
Stars: Elisabeth Moss, Samira Wiley, Yvonne Strahovski, Ann Dowd

When Margaret Atwood’s dystopian novel was released in 1985, it seemed like a far-off fiction. But the story, about an authoritarian theocratic dictatorship that has taken over the United States and subjugated women to less-than-human roles in society, felt much closer to reality for certain audiences when it premiered in politically turbulent 2017. That timeliness, combined with the stunning direction of experienced cinematographer Reed Morano (for which she won an Emmy) and star Elisabeth Moss’ chilling performance turned the series into a hallmark program of the post-Obama era.


Breaking Bad 96%


Rank: 3
Network: AMC
Premiere date: January 20, 2008
Stars: Bryan Cranston, Aaron Paul, Betsy Brandt, Anna Gunn

The Breaking Bad pilot introduces one of the defining antiheroes of Peak TV: Walter White, a suburban chemistry teacher making ends meet by moonlighting at the car wash until the day he’s diagnosed with inoperable lung cancer and told he has two years to live. The pilot shows the exact moment Walt begins his descent from hero to villain: when he recruits his former student Jesse Pinkman to help him make crystal meth (and the money he’ll need for his family when he’s gone).


Mad Men 94%


Rank: 2
Network: AMC
Premiere date: July 19, 2007
Stars: John Hamm, Elisabeth Moss, Christina Hendricks, John Slattery

Matthew Weiner spent years researching the 1950s and ’60s for his iconic series, and the pilot — which he first wrote in 2000 and shelved until after he finished working on The Sopranos — bears the fruit of that meticulous work. It introduces the world of ’60s ad agency Sterling Cooper and its hard-drinking, strikingly handsome, womanizing ad exec Don Draper along with the distinct visual style and tone that would define the series.


Lost 85%


Rank: 1
Network: ABC
Premiere date: September 22, 2004
Stars: Matthew Fox, Evangeline Lily, Josh Holloway, Jorge Garcia

The pilot of Lost is two hours long, which might seem a little like cheating, but it’s actually the perfect distillation of what the series would turn out to be: scary, mesmerizing, and sometimes very, very confusing. Our hero Jack wakes up after his plane crash-lands — then immediately snaps into action and tries to use his skills as a doctor to save as many of his fellow passengers as possible. They’re all trapped on a tropical island, and — oh yeah, there’s a polar bear. Wait, what? That’s something we would continue saying well into the series’ six-season run.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

leaderboard directors king kong obi wan Best and Worst 2016 breaking bad screen actors guild summer TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Broadway Countdown Black Mirror Interview high school Chernobyl Winter TV 2015 1990s 2017 2018 superhero Amazon Prime natural history cartoon target scene in color sitcom biopic Neflix japan MCU Walt Disney Pictures TV Film Festival worst movies technology CMT Amazon teaser spain GIFs mob FXX spy thriller SDCC adenture Tokyo Olympics halloween tv 79th Golden Globes Awards period drama Funimation stoner Action Universal Pictures TLC A24 sequel animated wonder woman MTV live event comics Nominations true crime PlayStation Black History Month TV One posters Reality laika political drama Paramount Pictures scene in color film series ratings First Look Comic-Con@Home 2021 Mary Poppins Returns Star Trek A&E Song of Ice and Fire aliens boxoffice TCA Awards Ovation Mindy Kaling satire Tumblr boxing joker Character Guide art house YouTube HBO Max E! Sci-Fi Sundance TV The Walt Disney Company casting war Infographic Disney+ Disney Plus rotten mcc Drama comedies christmas movies 72 Emmy Awards dexter witnail TCA 2017 Set visit screenings Calendar Oscar RT21 Adult Swim E3 Amazon Prime Video sports biography Creative Arts Emmys ESPN dark hidden camera IMDb TV Wes Anderson dramedy Cosplay Shudder parents Film 93rd Oscars Warner Bros. festivals crime Rock SXSW Sony Pictures Fall TV doctor who a nightmare on elm street feel good Masterpiece TCA Winter 2020 Tubi Exclusive Video superman rt archives cats Chilling Adventures of Sabrina award winner halloween 2019 Legendary FOX new star wars movies GoT rotten movies we love critics Biopics Alien Pop TV romance Pirates dceu Christmas cancelled TV shows Valentine's Day aapi Marvel Television talk show kaiju zero dark thirty comic book movie south america summer TV preview australia OneApp Pet Sematary french diversity scary Rocky docuseries Turner Classic Movies hist Opinion comic book movies rom-coms miniseries chucky MSNBC Lucasfilm anthology IFC stop motion Endgame Freeform psycho IFC Films streaming movies archives Certified Fresh TIFF godzilla Television Academy WarnerMedia spider-verse serial killer remakes game of thrones ABC Family VOD toronto cancelled television television medical drama Paramount Box Office Musicals obituary The Arrangement VH1 2021 blaxploitation basketball Fargo marvel comics streamig Turner marvel cinematic universe Netflix Christmas movies Comedy child's play NYCC Winners binge GLAAD science fiction historical drama Brie Larson young adult green book Awards Tour richard e. Grant Red Carpet pirates of the caribbean crossover dragons cinemax adventure book adaptation series razzies Year in Review BBC One History National Geographic scary movies ghosts Polls and Games LGBT zombie quibi ViacomCBS Watching Series Hallmark canceled TV shows critic resources mission: impossible black comedy Britbox popular hollywood dreamworks CBS BET Awards Captain marvel international batman TV renewals football Focus Features Hear Us Out Superheroes reviews kids TCA zombies Holidays sequels NBC Native AMC Plus Musical El Rey VICE 007 Summer spanish language YouTube Red adaptation cars Writers Guild of America Academy Awards Best Actor HFPA Peacock Lifetime slashers 73rd Emmy Awards police drama ABC Signature asian-american franchise WGN jurassic park Showtime Food Network Sneak Peek rt labs critics edition Disney Plus Dark Horse Comics fresh Superheroe Animation TCM crime thriller The Witch Super Bowl cancelled know your critic best Mary Tyler Moore comic books ITV facebook mutant telelvision PaleyFest Trophy Talk Cannes Marvel Studios Country Comics on TV Logo Best Director Rom-Com Tomatazos Rocketman emmy awards 45 Best Actress Reality Competition Image Comics disaster Spectrum Originals Star Wars Vudu spinoff rt labs Esquire SundanceTV Best Picture BET genre TV movies transformers based on movie twilight Cartoon Network documentaries Pacific Islander Crunchyroll what to watch ID Comedy Central Spring TV Pride Month DC Comics Syfy Paramount Plus 99% Tarantino Hulu james bond Prime Video TNT scorecard thriller The Purge Marvel Shondaland book king arthur Lifetime Christmas movies video documentary Kids & Family cults Indigenous dc TruTV Mudbound comiccon X-Men kong comic news lord of the rings Family AMC Television Critics Association hispanic finale harry potter travel Fantasy OWN live action spider-man Women's History Month President Nat Geo olympics Trailer canceled South by Southwest Film Festival MGM Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt golden globes 24 frames space CNN HBO Go Columbia Pictures 21st Century Fox suspense Arrowverse APB Fox News Election cops TV Land summer preview Holiday DGA The Walking Dead Video Games indiana jones docudrama japanese Pop Fox Searchlight San Diego Comic-Con Lionsgate Hollywood Foreign Press Association crime drama social media DC Universe Sundance Now Classic Film game show BAFTA Epix Crackle Spike fast and furious New York Comic Con heist movie criterion Baby Yoda indie monster movies HBO Disney streaming service royal family Martial Arts politics Travel Channel Instagram Live die hard Emmys stand-up comedy Oscars FX italian 20th Century Fox spanish black FX on Hulu PBS Trivia psychological thriller ABC LGBTQ blockbusters renewed TV shows Horror YA Western The Academy Ghostbusters movie SXSW 2022 Starz dogs theme song 2020 golden globe awards Sundance vampires Star Wars Celebration revenge First Reviews Comic Book Mary poppins Podcast target Elton John unscripted video on demand robots CW Seed 94th Oscars hispanic heritage month name the review universal monsters elevated horror scene in color Premiere Dates Awards nfl latino Avengers new york Toys cancelled TV series foreign Quiz Tags: Comedy sopranos Anna Paquin justice league versus Heroines Geeked Week anime Hallmark Christmas movies Grammys reboot all-time tv talk new zealand Apple Acorn TV 4/20 broadcast composers supernatural nbcuniversal Extras Binge Guide Emmy Nominations action-comedy Stephen King Music RT History Nickelodeon The CW gangster children's TV USA Sony CBS All Access YouTube Premium sag awards prank nature Disney Channel Universal Disney venice women NBA blockbuster saw Apple TV+ Paramount Network deadpool classics Netflix werewolf 71st Emmy Awards Thanksgiving DC streaming service concert romantic comedy USA Network scene in color series DirecTV discovery Ellie Kemper strong female leads independent vs. interviews toy story Apple TV Plus cooking Marathons festival free movies Pixar Bravo mockumentary Amazon Studios BBC America jamie lee curtis films Schedule legend Mystery TBS Teen debate trailers movies trophy BBC Photos slasher streaming singing competition American Society of Cinematographers worst See It Skip It Discovery Channel 90s