Alita: Battle Angel Early Reviews: Mind-Blowing Effects Meet A Mind-Numbing Script

See what critics are saying about the long-in-the-making manga adaptation from James Cameron and Robert Rodriguez.

by | February 1, 2019 | Comments

After years in the making, James Cameron’s pet project – the dystopian manga adaptation Alita: Battle Angel – is finally on its way to theaters, albeit with Robert Rodriguez in the director’s seat. Is it worth the wait? The first wave of reviews are leaning negatively, but the gist is pretty clear that, once again, Cameron and Co. are delivering big, eye-candy spectacle with a script that doesn’t do the visuals justice. Whether the effects and action and even the breakout performance-capture performance by Rosa Salazar are worth a ticket anyway varies from critic to critic, and may also differ from moviegoer to moviegoer.

Here’s what the critics are saying about Alita: Battle Angel:

Is this another must-see James Cameron spectacular?

Alita: Battle Angel is the old school blockbuster the world has needed for some time now.” – Mike Reyes, CinemaBlend

Alita: Battle Angel is the first great live-action manga adaptation.” – Karen Han, Polygon

Alita: Battle Angel is a mesmerizing feat of filmmaking — and stunning in 3D.” – Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

Alita: Battle Angel is a solid, visually stunning blockbuster that doesn’t pretend to be something it’s not.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

“Like the titular character, the film is a visually impressive technical marvel that lacks substance under its glossy shell.” – Matt Maytum, Total Film

“Calling this movie junk does a disservice to the authenticity of trash.” – Dennis Franich, Entertainment Weekly

Does Rosa Salazar give a star-making performance?

Alita: Battle Angel
(Photo by © 2018 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation)

“Salazar is the breakout of Alita: Battle Angel, portraying her character’s optimistic naïveté and lust for life with an enthusiasm that rarely grates.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

“Salazar brilliantly navigates the character’s emotional journey.” – Beth Elderkin,

“Tremendous…her ability to make the viewer believe in Alita in turn helps us believe in the world of Alita: Battle Angel all the easier.” – Mike Reyes, CinemaBlend

“To Salazar’s credit there’s something likable and determined about Alita, but the CGI puts an emotional forcefield around her.” – Matt Maytum, Total Film

“It’s possible Salazar gives a good performance, and I hope to see it someday. Her sensitive line readings clash madly with Alita’s digitally juked bot face.” – Dennis Franich, Entertainment Weekly

What about those big eyes, though?

“No, they did not need to be that big. But yes, I still love them.” – Karen Han, Polygon

“The impressive thing about the CGI is that the viewer soon gets used to these saucer-sized peepers.” – Nicholas Barber, The Wrap

“I found I had completely forgotten about them by the second scene she’s in.” – Emily Yoshida, Vulture/New York Magazine

“Alita’s eternally uncanny eyes are actually a great analogue for the film itself: a heightened visual gimmick that better delivers the film’s outsized emotions.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

“Her smoothed features and dewy, supersized peepers may be a direct nod to manga character design, but they make her look more like an android imagined by Margaret ‘Big Eyes’ Keane.” – Guy Lodge, Variety

How are the rest of the visual effects?

Alita: Battle Angel is a special effects marvel that raises the 3D bar.” – Julian Roman, MovieWeb

“With Jackson’s Weta Digital handling animation and visual effects, the first act is a sumptuous sensory experience shot in warm colors and radiant, super-crisp 3D. Many of the film’s 1,500 CGI shots are magnificent.” – Stephen Dalton, The Hollywood Reporter

“The detail put into Alita: Battle Angel‘s world-building is a feast for the eyes.” – Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

“The motorball sequences, in particular, are whooshing Big Mac cinema of the most jittery, adolescent order.” – Guy Lodge, Variety

“[They] might look cool now but won’t hold up.” – Beth Elderkin,

But the script ruins it?

Alita: Battle Angel
(Photo by © 2018 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation)

“Its umpteen story threads and endless mythology-meets-tech-porn jargon finally pound the interest out of you.” – Philip De Semlyen, Time Out

“There are so many plates spinning in Alita: Battle Angel, but all are vital to truly building the world we could potentially return to.” – Mike Reyes, CinemaBlend

“Too much of the movie is spent having characters over-explain things to people.” – Beth Elderkin,

“That the story isn’t particularly interesting is occasionally a drag, but, again, that’s not the point here.” – Karen Han, Polygon 

Did we really need a love story here?

“The cyborg romance is sappy and uneven…the valleys to the action peaks.”- Julian Roman, MovieWeb

“A dreary slab of boilerplate young-adult soap opera…Johnson is a charisma vacuum of white-bread boy-band blandness.” – Stephen Dalton, The Hollywood Reporter

“Why does Alita need a love interest? He just slows her down.” – Anne Cohen, Refinery29

Is there some good action at least?

“The action, which arrives loudly and often, is so coherent, and that makes it consistently thrilling.” – Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

“Rodriguez seems to be one of the only directors working who has figured out how to coherently stage a blockbuster action sequence.” – Karen Han, Polygon

“Dazzling and dizzying, the fight sequences in Alita: Battle Angel capture the dynamism of watching an anime without feeling so cartoonish that there are no stakes.” – Hoai-Tran Bui, Slashfilm

“A scene where the unarmed Alita single-handedly takes on a bar room full of thugs recalls Joss Whedon’s far superior sci-fi Serenity, which way back in 2005 executed a similar scene with far greater panache.” – Chris Hunneysett, Daily Mirror

Should we see it in 3-D?

Alita: Battle Angel
(Photo by © 2018 Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation)

“The movie’s action is phenomenal, especially in 3D.” – Samantha Nelson, The Verge

“No doubt best experienced in the highest quality format possible…if moviegoers have to choose only one 2019 release to see in IMAX 3D, Alita: Battle Angel is it.” – Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

“Visually Alita: Battle Angel is an experience well-worth that extra 3D cash.” – Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

Will we leave wanting more?

“[It] paves the way for potentially more compelling tales to come…hopefully, it’s successful enough to warrant a sequel.” –  Molly Freeman, ScreenRant

“If there’s any justice in the world, this won’t be the last time we’ll see the battle angel herself taking the big screen by storm; because Alita kicks all of the ass.” – Mike Reyes, CinemaBlend

“For the first time in a long time, I’m happy to stay on this wild, visually dazzling ride for a few more stops.” – Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

“This is a crashing bore, which doesn’t need a sequel, and certainly not a reboot.” – Chris Hunneysett, Daily Mirror

Alita: Battle Angel is in theaters everywhere February 14, 2019.

Adjusted Score: 75.882%
Critics Consensus: Alita: Battle Angel's story struggles to keep up with its special effects, but fans of futuristic sci-fi action may still find themselves more than sufficiently entertained.
Synopsis: From visionary filmmakers James Cameron (AVATAR) and Robert Rodriguez (SIN CITY), comes ALITA: BATTLE ANGEL, an epic adventure of hope... [More]
Directed By: Robert Rodriguez

Tag Cloud

Year in Review sitcom Apple TV+ witnail historical drama blaxploitation President sports comiccon Sundance Now Set visit revenge VH1 game of thrones medical drama Best and Worst Black Mirror 2019 DC Universe Action space based on movie RT History true crime Film Festival political drama HBO Mudbound dc Dark Horse Comics A&E cults television LGBT thriller sequel ESPN Crackle Marvel Christmas dceu Bravo Disney Channel binge canceled FX justice league cancelled toy story Nickelodeon kids IFC Films canceled TV shows Teen Horror Animation Lucasfilm zero dark thirty USA Stephen King doctor who tv talk mockumentary Mystery CMT Comic Book serial killer transformers Musicals Shudder E3 Chernobyl Starz quibi Premiere Dates Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Spike romance Amazon Prime Video FXX Binge Guide adventure vampires Amazon CNN spinoff Superheroe facebook richard e. Grant See It Skip It RT21 Acorn TV MSNBC stand-up comedy diversity series New York Comic Con Summer IFC ABC Family Ellie Kemper GoT Martial Arts The Arrangement MTV disaster halloween zombies GLAAD dragons Netflix nature Amazon Prime biography 21st Century Fox BBC America WGN Trivia strong female leads 20th Century Fox cooking Television Academy Lionsgate zombie supernatural jamie lee curtis Paramount Network Biopics YA The CW theme song Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Mary poppins Emmys Syfy discovery VICE hist Grammys latino Character Guide Elton John Trailer Food Network video golden globes cats Freeform CBS All Access Mary Poppins Returns police drama Vudu ratings DC Comics casting Photos Cosplay psycho TV renewals technology Fox News Calendar award winner TV Disney Plus Comedy Sony Pictures Awards Tour American Society of Cinematographers Trophy Talk elevated horror SundanceTV 71st Emmy Awards natural history BET OWN Film Quiz finale Reality Competition festivals Apple Esquire Heroines LGBTQ Rom-Com FOX Song of Ice and Fire cops Universal Election Infographic TruTV Certified Fresh Cartoon Network 007 Masterpiece TV Land composers docudrama Comics on TV Anna Paquin science fiction Pirates mutant Nat Geo 45 Sci-Fi CW Seed teaser Mary Tyler Moore YouTube Red Carpet X-Men Tomatazos adaptation slashers singing competition The Purge BBC Valentine's Day Nominations 2015 Women's History Month Ghostbusters Spring TV ghosts TCA 2017 SDCC Super Bowl south america animated spider-man cancelled television Box Office Britbox green book Paramount Cannes National Geographic Rocketman TCM TBS Logo cancelled TV shows Star Trek Western period drama History anime Star Wars Disney streaming service DGA Rocky Sundance TIFF anthology El Rey MCU AMC 2016 crime drama Brie Larson Winners Spectrum Originals hispanic Thanksgiving CBS PBS Pet Sematary movies talk show YouTube Red miniseries Extras ABC Columbia Pictures Winter TV Pride Month Tumblr social media Superheroes Video Games Pop The Witch spanish language Polls and Games aliens TNT Captain marvel crime thriller Hulu politics crime E! boxoffice children's TV Awards unscripted Warner Bros. cinemax robots Walt Disney Pictures HBO Max Shondaland Schedule SXSW Creative Arts Emmys TLC Lifetime Interview Family NYCC 24 frames Showtime DirecTV breaking bad Music Podcast Tarantino YouTube Premium crossover The Walking Dead psychological thriller Ovation Reality GIFs Holidays Mindy Kaling USA Network 2017 PaleyFest Peacock cars Sneak Peek WarnerMedia renewed TV shows DC streaming service travel Arrowverse Kids & Family Drama San Diego Comic-Con Pixar Comedy Central Country Watching Series Writers Guild of America war what to watch Countdown Marathons cancelled TV series Rock NBC foreign Epix joker Oscars TCA 2018 streaming dramedy ITV Fantasy Disney Musical Toys spain batman Fall TV comic game show free movies Adult Swim First Look book APB First Reviews Opinion spy thriller Emmy Nominations harry potter