A Day to Give Thanks (for Good Thanksgiving Movies!)

by | November 24, 2005 | Comments

The Newsday column gets to take a few days off during the big holidays, but I couldn’t let today go by without offering our friends a handful of Turkey-day treats. If you’re looking for a holiday-appropriate movie to watch with the family while all your turkey and stuffing is digesting, feel free to pick one (or more) of these Thanksgiving-centric flicks.

Home for the Holidays — Written by "Buckaroo Banzai" scribe WD Richter and directed by the multi-talented Jodie Foster, "Home for the Holidays" is absolutely stuffed with great actors. Sort of a less slapsticky and more realistic version of "Christmas Vacation," it’s about a stressed-out woman (Holly Hunter) who returns to the roost to enjoy(?) a manic Thanksgiving dinner with her entire extended family. Even if the movie stunk (which it so absolutely does not) it would be worth seeing for a cast that includes Anne Bancroft, Charles Durning, Robert Downey Jr., Dylan McDermott, Steve Guttenberg, Claire Danes, Austin Pendleton, David Strathairn, Cynthia Stevenson, and Amy Yasbeck. (Tell me that wouldn’t be a fun crew to eat turkey with.)

Pieces of April — This endearing 2003 indie from Peter Hedges ("About a Boy") stars Katie Holmes as an estranged daughter who invites her skeptical family for a Thanksgiving feast at her tiny little apartment. One half of the film sees April’s family struggling to make it in time for dinner, and the other half deals with poor frazzled April as she desperately tries to build an edible turkey dinner. In addition to some of Ms. Holmes’ very best work, "April" also features fantastic performances from Oliver Platt, Patricia Clarkson, Derek Luke, and Sean Hayes.

What’s Cooking? — From director Gurinder Chadha ("Bend It Like Beckham") comes this tale of four separate families, and the various preparations they make to have a solid Thanksgiving affair. Jewish, African-American, Vietnamese, and Latino families populate this holiday charmer, and the cast is another stellar ensemble: Dennis Haysbert, Alfre Woodard, Joan Chen, Mercedes Ruehl, Lainie Kazan, Maury Chaykin, Kyra Sedgwick, and Julianna Margulies keep the guest list colorful, and there’s plenty of wit, wisdom, and warmth (and even a few surprises) in this holiday treat.

Hannah and Her Sisters — Opening and closing with a pair of Thanksgiving dinners, the heavily-ensembled Woody Allen comedy is still considered one of the director’s very best films. Winner of three Oscars (for screenplay and the performances by Michael Caine and Dianne Wiest) and a nominee for four more, "Hannah and Her Sisters" is a razor-sharp and hilariously insightful story about one extended family and the non-stop stress the relatives cause one another. Also on board are Mia Farrow, Barbara Hershey, Carrie Fisher, Max von Sydow, Julie Kavner, Daniel Stern, Maureen O’Sullivan, Joanna Gleason, and Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Even the hardcore Woody-philes consider this one of his finest screenplays.

Planes, Trains & Automobiles — If it’s me you’re asking, PT&A is the #1 finest Thanksgiving movie ever made, mainly because it’s "about" nothing more than finding a way to make it home for the holidays. Steve Martin and the late, great John Candy star as a pair of astonishingly mismatched traveling partners who’ll stop at nothing to make it home in time for some turkey. (For my money, this is John Hughes‘ finest film, just barely ahead of the teenage trifecta of "Sixteen Candles," "The Breakfast Club," and "Ferris Bueller’s Day Off.") Featuring tons of laughs, lots of great sights along the way, and a sweet-natured finale that always makes my eyeballs a little moist, "Planes, Trains & Automobiles" is a comedy classic for any season … but it really does work best in November. (If you’re watching this one with the family, please be sure to cover the kiddies’ ears when Mr. Martin arrives, unhappily, at a car rental kiosk. Trust me.) Also keep eyes peeled for hilarious little cameos by Kevin Bacon, Martin Ferrero, Dylan Baker, Michael McKean, Edie McClurg, and Ben Stein.

So there’s my Turkey Day quintet. Sorry for leaving "Son in Law" off the list, but I was doing "best Thanksgiving" movies and not "least awful Pauly Shore movies." (Maybe we can do that one on Pauly’s birthday.) Anyway, on behalf of everyone here at Rotten Tomatoes, I’d like to wish all our readers, and their friends & relatives & acquaintances & pets & non-annoying co-workers, a very safe & happy holiday. And if I left out any of your favorite Thanksgiving movies (there really aren’t all that many!), feel free to leave ’em in the comments section. We’ll need five more for next year!

Tag Cloud

Fox News Best and Worst Podcast toy story Reality Competition TV Land films 45 FX Fall TV cancelled television cancelled disaster Pride Month comedies Discovery Channel ratings Disney streaming service New York Comic Con Black Mirror AMC fast and furious NBC Schedule Paramount See It Skip It travel unscripted 21st Century Fox TCA Awards Classic Film YA FXX Drama psychological thriller festivals Universal Tarantino Tubi ESPN Election Chernobyl anime Ovation Nat Geo space independent Sundance Now cops The Arrangement Binge Guide Biopics Cartoon Network Mary Tyler Moore Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Opinion History versus criterion movies National Geographic strong female leads Elton John Oscars MSNBC stop motion Star Trek PaleyFest concert LGBT DC Universe 2019 Freeform Marathons spider-man Winners Shudder natural history Walt Disney Pictures period drama Awards elevated horror cats Black History Month Video Games Lifetime MCU SXSW Brie Larson Shondaland GIFs TCA Winter 2020 Star Wars VH1 Martial Arts Pop Netflix Christmas movies stoner Captain marvel Baby Yoda Food Network Ghostbusters E! social media Extras comiccon satire animated Sneak Peek First Look crime canceled book children's TV Spring TV Adult Swim finale Lionsgate DC streaming service TNT Rock SundanceTV doctor who Cannes composers discovery classics south america crossover GoT 72 Emmy Awards 007 reviews Fantasy Mindy Kaling Winter TV Syfy directors Sci-Fi rotten harry potter Warner Bros. Certified Fresh mission: impossible free movies dogs Turner Classic Movies Peacock Apple TV+ hispanic nature werewolf E3 Showtime Television Academy casting television Apple TV Plus Animation CMT cooking Heroines zombie game of thrones batman A24 war IFC Cosplay breaking bad golden globes ABC Country Thanksgiving name the review robots sports slashers Rocky OWN jamie lee curtis based on movie PBS miniseries Trailer hist Arrowverse Epix cancelled TV shows documentaries tv talk 20th Century Fox Mystery richard e. Grant Super Bowl OneApp transformers dc BBC Quiz all-time Rocketman Western YouTube political drama Holiday Emmy Nominations Comics on TV El Rey kids CBS All Access series cartoon Ellie Kemper sag awards WarnerMedia IFC Films FOX Amazon indiana jones A&E TruTV Funimation serial killer VICE worst Turner Writers Guild of America Hallmark critics spy thriller USA dragons cinemax franchise Pirates Bravo Mudbound Box Office Paramount Network Acorn TV reboot San Diego Comic-Con First Reviews politics Marvel Amazon Studios police drama Disney Channel Vudu Calendar TCM scary movies Comedy Central parents Hulu HBO Go technology laika zero dark thirty Awards Tour LGBTQ dramedy spanish language Creative Arts Emmys romance Nickelodeon Superheroe video news revenge nbcuniversal Action vampires Nominations 4/20 The Walking Dead spinoff 2020 Endgame canceled TV shows dceu binge CW Seed teaser VOD Marvel Studios mockumentary Stephen King Marvel Television Apple sequel Comic Book Dark Horse Comics zombies Pop TV christmas movies romantic comedy streaming adaptation Netflix Academy Awards psycho cancelled TV series USA Network facebook twilight comics Crunchyroll green book chucky science fiction best Amazon Prime 24 frames TIFF halloween Lucasfilm Travel Channel latino Sundance TV YouTube Premium foreign APB Summer anthology DGA Reality Columbia Pictures indie Hallmark Christmas movies boxoffice Pet Sematary Music documentary Hear Us Out supernatural renewed TV shows Set visit CNN Anna Paquin thriller theme song diversity emmy awards video on demand asian-american Red Carpet aliens Spike Kids & Family Trophy Talk Interview Television Critics Association historical drama blaxploitation Premiere Dates NYCC 2017 child's play YouTube Red TV renewals TLC BBC One RT21 RT History adventure Grammys Song of Ice and Fire Esquire ITV President blockbuster quibi Polls and Games Disney+ Disney Plus Year in Review Valentine's Day ABC Family TCA 2017 talk show 71st Emmy Awards Britbox crime drama 2018 Women's History Month PlayStation joker 2016 movie BET BBC America dark singing competition Disney MTV Sony Pictures sitcom Mary poppins Toys 2015 witnail Rom-Com DC Comics Avengers American Society of Cinematographers game show The Purge obituary cars Mary Poppins Returns sequels docudrama TBS Tumblr screenings BET Awards FX on Hulu GLAAD HBO what to watch Watching Series CBS rotten movies we love Logo Trivia Teen Pixar mutant spain Starz DirecTV crime thriller award winner Emmys Horror Holidays die hard comic WGN cults biography HBO Max Superheroes stand-up comedy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy Family Amazon Prime Video justice league Lifetime Christmas movies Infographic Christmas Masterpiece Film Festival superhero Tomatazos BAFTA X-Men ghosts TCA screen actors guild Countdown SDCC Crackle Sundance hollywood TV a nightmare on elm street Character Guide Disney Plus The CW Spectrum Originals Musical The Witch Musicals Photos Film medical drama universal monsters true crime