Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Watch Watchmen, But Caveat Emptor

The big-screen adaptation of Alan Moore's work is visually stunning but very, very long.

by | March 5, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got Watchmen, the long-awaited adaptation of Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel directed by Zack Snyder and starring Billy Crudup and Carla Gugino. What do the critics have to say?



After years of speculation, negotiations, lawsuits, and geek anticipation, Alan Moore’s classic graphic novel Watchmen is finally hitting the big screen. So, is it worth watching? The answer, say critics, is a qualified yes. The film is set in a dystopian 1985, in which Richard Nixon is still president and the future looks bleak. A group of retired superheroes is forced back into action when one of their colleagues is murdered and suspicions of an anti-hero conspiracy arise. A number of critics find Watchmen to be excessively reverent to Moore’s book, as well as overlong and dark bordering on dour. However, others say this ambitious, sprawling superhero epic is emotionally weighty and visually stunning. (Check out Watchmen Headquarters for all of RT’s Watchmen-related news and features.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Fados, a documentary about the haunting Portuguese musical genre, is at 100 percent.
  • The Oscar-nominated 12, a Russian spin on 12 Angry Men, is at 88 percent.
  • Explicit Ills , starring Rosario Dawson and Paul Dano and featuring four interconnected stories involving low-income Philly residents, is at 82 percent.
  • Tokyo!, an omnibus film that focuses on Japan’s largest city and features a segment from Michel Gondry, is at 71 percent.
  • Phoebe in Wonderland, starring Elle Fanning and Bill Pullman in a drama about a family coping with a child with Tourette’s Syndrome, is at 46 percent.
  • Sherman’s Way, a quirky indie road comedy in which an Ivy Leaguer and a washed-up ex-jock hit the highway, is at 22 percent.

Tag Cloud

franchise First Reviews DC Comics Marathons NYCC Crackle Tarantino Rock cooking cinemax historical drama what to watch spanish language mockumentary 20th Century Fox Marvel Studios richard e. Grant FOX crime thriller spinoff strong female leads twilight Disney Channel Hallmark TCA Winter 2020 Interview MSNBC christmas movies war Sci-Fi Musicals slashers joker A24 Masterpiece werewolf Quiz harry potter Comic Book The Walking Dead adventure scorecard Family parents Calendar festivals Spike BBC America dragons video Country Esquire police drama child's play Trivia Holidays movie facebook APB GLAAD batman hollywood Television Academy USA Network screenings cancelled TV series TCA 2017 TV Land Black Mirror cancelled TV shows toronto Horror Election dark zombies Sundance Now Premiere Dates latino Universal Martial Arts Paramount video on demand Marvel Television diversity singing competition discovery Classic Film Hulu SundanceTV sitcom Chernobyl Awards Tour Emmys kids tv talk worst spider-man Biopics CMT biography Mary poppins sequel 2016 dramedy TNT SDCC natural history TV renewals Fox News Starz Valentine's Day Lucasfilm SXSW book Christmas robots stand-up comedy GoT Discovery Channel Lifetime Christmas movies GIFs documentary First Look indie screen actors guild IFC Films breaking bad Paramount Network Apple renewed TV shows doctor who TV Nickelodeon crime drama hist blockbuster E! Walt Disney Pictures fast and furious space IFC comedies Writers Guild of America award winner crossover Schedule Mindy Kaling Trophy Talk psychological thriller versus Ellie Kemper television YouTube composers Logo spy thriller indiana jones A&E Extras 45 CBS Year in Review critics DC streaming service Vudu Acorn TV BET Awards WGN criterion TLC Netflix Mudbound Awards Pop sag awards Disney Plus ITV Disney Syfy Countdown aliens cults ghosts hispanic The Purge San Diego Comic-Con AMC stop motion best medical drama Superheroes Tomatazos FX on Hulu Photos Shudder Action asian-american miniseries scary movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Travel Channel Comedy Central name the review BBC elevated horror unscripted comics History VICE Binge Guide Amazon Disney+ Disney Plus psycho LGBTQ DGA cancelled Music Shondaland HBO New York Comic Con CNN Nat Geo directors American Society of Cinematographers Superheroe Certified Fresh DirecTV casting independent Oscars witnail classics halloween Comedy green book Reality streaming Summer Holiday foreign Film 4/20 Turner Song of Ice and Fire Star Wars documentaries Freeform Cannes films Trailer Cartoon Network game of thrones chucky Animation Character Guide transformers Podcast TIFF Rocketman El Rey Star Trek universal monsters justice league Amazon Prime Video movies 2019 The Arrangement Set visit finale crime Best and Worst Infographic satire PaleyFest Warner Bros. Elton John Tubi cops Toys Endgame based on movie PBS Television Critics Association cancelled television news OneApp RT History venice Nominations Rom-Com Marvel rotten movies we love supernatural Showtime festival Cosplay spain Opinion Comics on TV Black History Month Polls and Games DC Universe Drama science fiction Tumblr Disney streaming service Sundance TV Watching Series Ovation romance mission: impossible 2018 sports 21st Century Fox Mary Poppins Returns 72 Emmy Awards Netflix Christmas movies VH1 political drama Sony Pictures Sneak Peek PlayStation south america Rocky TCM thriller Film Festival E3 Pixar docudrama comiccon Anna Paquin Arrowverse YA Heroines period drama Super Bowl OWN FX laika RT21 jamie lee curtis Crunchyroll Pet Sematary 2015 vampires reviews Creative Arts Emmys Spring TV The CW YouTube Red BAFTA comic NBC revenge serial killer canceled romantic comedy ABC Family Adult Swim Turner Classic Movies See It Skip It travel Peacock Western Apple TV+ dc concert Sundance The Witch Winners Reality Competition worst movies animated Dark Horse Comics social media Pop TV nature obituary 007 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt emmy awards free movies Baby Yoda Amazon Studios sequels Amazon Prime cars ratings Captain marvel Kids & Family Box Office stoner true crime TCA cartoon Brie Larson Grammys theme song Avengers Women's History Month Britbox Bravo dogs CBS All Access die hard Stephen King disaster 2020 Winter TV X-Men BET LGBT ABC Epix anime rotten zero dark thirty binge all-time nfl a nightmare on elm street Food Network technology WarnerMedia TruTV USA BBC One VOD President teaser CW Seed canceled TV shows 71st Emmy Awards HBO Go Spectrum Originals MCU TBS Ghostbusters golden globes TCA Awards dceu politics Pride Month 2017 mutant superhero Hallmark Christmas movies zombie Lifetime cats HBO Max Mystery Teen Funimation anthology talk show Red Carpet Lionsgate MTV Musical Thanksgiving YouTube Premium nbcuniversal Pirates Academy Awards National Geographic children's TV quibi boxoffice game show Hear Us Out Fall TV adaptation Emmy Nominations FXX remakes Video Games football Fantasy Mary Tyler Moore ESPN Apple TV Plus Columbia Pictures reboot blaxploitation 24 frames series toy story