Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Unknown's Plot Twists Too Much

Plus, I Am Number Four is so-so, and Big Mommas is dire stuff.

by | February 17, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a mystery man (Unknown, starring Liam Neeson and January Jones), a teenage alien (I Am Number Four, starring Alex Pettyfer and Timothy Olyphant), and a cross-dressing fed (Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son, starring Martin Lawrence and Brandon T. Jackson). What do the critics have to say?



Lately, Liam Neeson has a thing for European intrigue. He journeyed to Paris to rescue his daughter in 2009’s Taken, and now he heads to Berlin for Unknown, a twisty thriller that critics say undermines its strong premise with implausible plotting. Neeson stars as a man who falls into a coma after a car accident; when he awakens, he discovers his wife (January Jones) doesn’t recognize him, and he’s being targeted by shadowy forces. The pundits say Neeson and an expert supporting cast help keep Unknown watchable, but ultimately, the unlikely story and excessive action set pieces keep it from truly soaring.

I Am Number Four


Another week, another tale of a teenager with supernatural powers. In I Am Number Four, our hero is neither a vampire nor a wizard, but an alien — which matters little to critics, who say the movie has some decent action scenes, but little in the way of memorable characters or original plotting. Alex Pettyfer stars as a teenage alien with extraordinary powers who wants to settle down and enjoy high school life in a sleepy Ohio town; unfortunately, some evil aliens have already killed three of his associates. The pundits say Four rips off just about every other film of its ilk, from Twilight to Harry Potter, without adding much to the formula, though there are a few exciting moments here and there.

Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son


Some cinematic stories are so sprawling or emotionally overwhelming that it takes a trilogy to tell them — think Lord of the Rings or the Apu trilogy. But the Big Momma movies? If the first two installments didn’t exactly set the critical world afire, the pundits are especially unamused by Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son, calling it a particularly slim assemblage of crass gags that furthers the franchise’s one-joke premise without, ahem, expanding upon it. Once again, Martin Lawrence plays an FBI agent who must go undercover in the most counterintuitive of disguises — this time in an all-girls school after his nephew witnesses a killing. The pundits say Big Mommas is tired stuff – clichéd, dull, and shrill, with little reason to exist. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a brief history of movies with dudes in drag.)

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

First Look SundanceTV Musical Podcast Interview Holidays based on movie X-Men BET Mary Tyler Moore Sci-Fi Freeform police drama Photos GoT Calendar Country Showtime Reality historical drama war Lionsgate docudrama Opinion Mystery PBS Super Bowl Emmys Bravo composers discovery Trailer E! TV Land DC Comics Sneak Peek vampires Watching Series TBS TIFF Lifetime PaleyFest Music Red Carpet CBS Universal Reality Competition Fall TV NBC Ghostbusters Biopics Cartoon Network Starz 24 frames Schedule Winners MTV sports AMC Cosplay crime drama crime IFC Nickelodeon dramedy Action Rock Awards Fantasy TNT Polls and Games Valentine's Day politics travel biography FX cooking BBC Marvel WGN Writers Guild of America Disney 2015 Year in Review aliens Star Wars Tomatazos A&E Video Games SDCC 2016 Masterpiece Infographic 007 USA crime thriller Nominations Summer Animation technology Comedy Central Pirates Teen Pop supernatural The CW 2017 Horror Logo Amazon Syfy Drama zombie Esquire TCM CMT Spring TV Thanksgiving Dark Horse Comics Grammys TCA Best and Worst Musicals science fiction Trivia period drama TLC Toys Winter TV Extras ABC Rom-Com LGBTQ GIFs boxoffice OWN Comic Book RT History TV MSNBC harry potter GLAAD CNN President thriller VICE Box Office sitcom Disney Channel Countdown The Arrangement adventure Kids & Family Oscars HBO CBS All Access BBC America FOX Premiere Dates Crackle singing competition comiccon TruTV Netflix American Society of Cinematographers Superheroes Set visit Character Guide Certified Fresh APB Star Trek Hulu Election cinemax FXX TCA 2017 Comedy cops Nat Geo Food Network Tumblr NYCC VH1 El Rey Rocky ITV ESPN Martial Arts Adult Swim Fox News Sundance DirecTV serial killer Marathons ABC Family History psycho social media diversity