Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: The Woman in Black is a Solid Ghost Story

Plus, Chronicle is Certified Fresh, and Big Miracle is a strong whale tale.

by | February 3, 2012 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a ghost story (The Woman in Black, starring Daniel Radcliffe and Ciarán Hinds), teenage superheroes (Chronicle, starring Dane DeHaan and Alex Russell), and a whale rescue (Big Miracle, starring John Krasinski and Drew Barrymore). What do the critics have to say?

The Woman in Black


Daniel Radcliffe tackles his first major post-Harry Potter role in The Woman in Black, and critics say this spooky, atmospheric ghost story conjures up some terrific old-fashioned thrills. Radcliffe stars as Arthur Kipps, a young lawyer who journeys to a small town to settle the estate of a recently-deceased, reclusive widow. However, the locals are reluctant to discuss the matter, and for good reason — a spectral presence casts a dark shadow over the community. The pundits say The Woman in Black sometimes relies too heavily on jump scares, but mostly it does the resurrected Hammer Films imprint proud by harkening back to the company’s Gothic glory days, and Radcliffe is rock-solid in the lead role. (Check out Radcliffe’s Five Favorite Films here.)



A found-footage mockumentary about teenagers with superpowers, Chronicle is also terrifically acted and endlessly imaginative, critics say. Andrew (Dane DeHaan) is a kid who’s being bullied at home and at school when he starts videotaping his daily activities. His footage gets exponentially more interesting when he and two of his friends develop telekinetic powers after visiting a mysterious gulch. The pundits say the Certified Fresh Chronicle is an action-packed sci-fi yarn that doesn’t skimp on character development, and the result is an exciting, emotionally resonant feature debut for director Josh Trank. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we run down some of cinema’s most unconventional superheroes.)

Big Miracle


Big Miracle is a mix of romance, realpolitik, and animal rescue that critics say makes for a surprisingly satisfying blend, thanks to excellent performances and an intelligent script. John Krasinski and Drew Barrymore star as a small town news reporter and a Greenpeace volunteer who campaign to save a trio of gray whales trapped by ice at the Arctic Circle; their efforts attract global attention and governmental response, and romance soon follows. The pundits say Big Miracle is smarter and more complex than its synopsis suggests, and if its plotting is occasionally uneven, the film earns its feel-good climax.

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Splinters, a documentary about indigenous surfing in Papua New Guinea, is at 83 percent.

  • The Innkeepers, a horror film about ghost hunters searching for spirits in a haunted hotel, is Certified Fresh at 76 percent.

  • Kill List, a thriller about a mentally damaged hitman who undertakes a particularly disturbing assignment, is Certified Fresh at 76 percent.

  • Windfall, a documentary about the impact of a wind farm on an economically depressed small town, is at 58 percent.

  • W.E., starring Abbie Cornish and James D’Arcy in Madonna‘s biopic of American Duchess of Windsor Wallis Simpson, is at 18 percent.

And finally, mad props to Brian C for coming the closest to guessing One for the Money‘s three percent Tomatometer.

Tag Cloud

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rock golden globe awards Food Network MSNBC stand-up comedy Epix free movies zero dark thirty TV One SundanceTV versus science fiction TCA psychological thriller international high school technology based on movie Nickelodeon blaxploitation a nightmare on elm street Disney streaming service Rocky blockbuster CBS All Access book adaptation dceu hist marvel comics breaking bad travel Black History Month disaster VOD rt labs Interview 90s remakes 72 Emmy Awards Focus Features BAFTA Turner 21st Century Fox The Purge australia DirecTV independent Amazon Box Office doctor who aliens FOX Awards Tour series dc cancelled TV series SXSW 2022 festivals popular 79th Golden Globes Awards Wes Anderson critic resources Set visit satire Winners A&E Black Mirror posters video on demand indie Trivia dark Hallmark Christmas movies art house Freeform Paramount Pictures Exclusive Video mission: impossible Tumblr Amazon Prime Video Lucasfilm toronto scorecard Spring TV nature worst movies television The Arrangement Sundance cancelled comic books Broadway Mystery The Walking Dead crime drama Binge Guide Countdown Sneak Peek singing competition Film Festival rom-coms festival italian spinoff Mindy Kaling Stephen King Comic-Con@Home 2021 Apple TV Plus mob Crunchyroll Peacock diversity ghosts nfl Holiday venice Vudu superhero Holidays DC streaming service BET Awards all-time gangster criterion ABC Signature concert sequel AMC anthology royal family quibi toy story 2016 BBC America Funimation lord of the rings Year in Review Sundance Now Marvel 2019 mcc Trailer slasher spanish language 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards adenture summer TV dreamworks Dark Horse Comics Syfy Mary poppins Television Critics Association Ellie Kemper sag awards supernatural basketball Britbox Emmys Schedule SXSW boxoffice Shudder OWN Cannes 2021 SDCC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina APB comic biopic theme song child's play adaptation sitcom binge revenge Disney+ Disney Plus spy thriller OneApp leaderboard rt archives HFPA Tarantino genre CMT Fantasy cinemax king kong new zealand true crime know your critic children's TV TIFF YA Superheroes kaiju king arthur 2018 biography Superheroe slashers fresh Elton John Pacific Islander casting cults Comedy Marvel Studios sequels james bond IMDb TV History Podcast streaming movies new star wars movies Best Actress political drama Teen Mary Tyler Moore dexter godzilla YouTube Premium Writers Guild of America halloween hispanic heritage month crime thriller Masterpiece Marathons Legendary Comedy Central Sci-Fi renewed TV shows Reality monster movies Valentine's Day Netflix finale Calendar Travel Channel Disney Channel wonder woman WGN Nat Geo Shondaland TV renewals Apple TV+ talk show women vampires USA Network Video Games Arrowverse worst TruTV Thanksgiving Discovery Channel docuseries historical drama comics Disney Plus kids hispanic TV movies Crackle black Marvel Television dragons Pop HBO Max CBS Reality Competition Spike Song of Ice and Fire WarnerMedia 71st Emmy Awards Pixar The Walt Disney Company elevated horror The CW Best Actor foreign 93rd Oscars TV Land Walt Disney Pictures Animation chucky live event Chernobyl serial killer legend werewolf prank Lifetime screen actors guild Fox Searchlight Photos Music Anna Paquin DGA Heroines suspense zombies TNT Paramount Network razzies robots saw documentary Image Comics Prime Video feel good politics Watching Series trailers Lifetime Christmas movies cats Best Picture japan cars TCA 2017 book screenings kong batman cancelled TV shows LGBT TLC Mary Poppins Returns Star Trek classics witnail CNN debate CW Seed films Film period drama Oscars critics romance Musical 007 Character Guide green book game show Classic Film unscripted BBC Quiz South by Southwest Film Festival fast and furious movies Super Bowl harry potter Hulu FXX young adult Hallmark RT History Turner Classic Movies Musicals Action IFC Films Alien war 20th Century Fox joker VH1 Comic Book miniseries emmy awards TCM streamig 2020 composers teaser Pride Month boxing Trophy Talk Awards Hear Us Out First Reviews Adult Swim justice league Summer Fall TV Certified Fresh Paramount reboot Infographic Family Disney pirates of the caribbean Best Director Amazon Studios Western FX on Hulu IFC space Avengers First Look mutant parents japanese NBC Tokyo Olympics cops animated anime dogs jamie lee curtis thriller E! American Society of Cinematographers Horror Sundance TV The Academy documentaries Mudbound scary die hard rt labs critics edition Biopics new york rotten docudrama Esquire LGBTQ ViacomCBS New York Comic Con Fargo vs. aapi Acorn TV Columbia Pictures superman Tubi 94th Oscars Election Hollywood Foreign Press Association Television Academy cartoon PaleyFest Tags: Comedy spider-man TCA Winter 2020 NBA President TCA Awards Ovation Martial Arts ITV blockbusters mockumentary Starz summer preview HBO Logo Premiere Dates ESPN rotten movies we love asian-american Ghostbusters Bravo TV name the review olympics golden globes Pirates Captain marvel marvel cinematic universe tv talk streaming ratings Universal ABC Family Fox News heist movie A24 DC Comics award winner psycho spider-verse BET Christmas spanish 2015 ID YouTube Red reviews Toys AMC Plus BBC One canceled TV shows See It Skip It obi wan Rom-Com Nominations 45 Tomatazos scene in color facebook Neflix MGM Emmy Nominations Instagram Live Pop TV Spectrum Originals 24 frames crime spain stop motion Universal Pictures social media archives twilight cooking Apple comiccon french Comics on TV Netflix Christmas movies Polls and Games Academy Awards YouTube strong female leads natural history Best and Worst ABC action-comedy HBO Go Baby Yoda jurassic park scary movies Cartoon Network Star Wars Brie Larson DC Universe indiana jones directors stoner VICE deadpool police drama hidden camera canceled Red Carpet zombie San Diego Comic-Con Paramount Plus PlayStation comic book movie crossover Cosplay E3 Showtime black comedy nbcuniversal hollywood football news Warner Bros. Kids & Family Winter TV El Rey comedies Pet Sematary what to watch dramedy GoT Rocketman The Witch 2017 GIFs Grammys GLAAD X-Men sopranos game of thrones Drama obituary richard e. Grant summer TV preview MTV target FX telelvision universal monsters broadcast MCU trophy Extras Oscar RT21 discovery adventure transformers romantic comedy Lionsgate halloween tv TBS best 1990s Women's History Month 4/20 73rd Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Country christmas movies latino Creative Arts Emmys NYCC National Geographic laika south america USA movie sports Endgame PBS Opinion cancelled television comic book movies 99% franchise live action Sony Pictures medical drama video