Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Jack and Jill Fetches Bad Reviews

Plus, Immortals looks great but suffers from thin plotting, and J. Edgarnever quite gets at the heart of the man.

by | November 10, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got twin turmoil (Jack and Jill, starring Adam Sandler and Katie Holmes), mythical mayhem (Immortals, starring Henry Cavill and Mickey Rourke), and a multifaceted fed (J. Edgar, starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Armie Hammer). What do the critics have to say?

Jack and Jill


Adam Sandler’s got a winning formula — lowbrow yuks plus sentimentality equals box office gold — but critics say Jack and Jill may test the patience of even the most loyal of Sandman acolytes, as its jokes are even more juvenile than usual. Sandler stars as Jack, a successful ad executive whose obnoxious twin sister Jill (also played by Sandler) moves to town; hilarity ensues. The pundits say Jack and Jill‘s gags are remarkably crass, and its relentless mocking of Jill is surprisingly mean-spirited, though Al Pacino scores some big laughs parodying himself. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a list of actors playing opposite themselves.)



Director Tarsem Singh certainly has a knack for eye-popping images, but critics say the problem with Immortals is that its attention to blood-soaked visual detail always trumps character development and storytelling. Henry Cavill stars as Theseus, a humble stonemason who vows revenge against the tyrannical King Hyperion (Mickey Rourke) after the death of his mother, and soon our hero rounds up a posse to stop the tyrant and restore peace to the land. The pundits say Immortals looks great, but its silly dialogue and narrative shortcomings keep it from being an immersive sword and sandal thrill ride. (Check out co-star Freida Pinto’s Five Favorite Films.)

J. Edgar


J. Edgar purports to explore the professional and personal life of influential (many would say too influential) FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, but critics say Clint Eastwood‘s admittedly handsome biopic is ultimately too vague a portrait of its controversial subject, despite a committed performance from Leonardo DiCaprio. J. Edgar chronicles Hoover’s tenure at the bureau, as well as his oft-rumored but never substantiated love affair with Associate FBI Director Clyde Tolson. The pundits say the trouble with J. Edgar is that it’s a bit too cautious — it ticks off the events of Hoover’s life without exploring his motives and feelings, though DiCaprio is typically strong.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Horror 24 frames Best and Worst DC Comics Action A&E Box Office TIFF Reality Star Wars Rom-Com docudrama Dark Horse Comics YA PaleyFest Lifetime WGN Pirates E3 Logo Opinion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt 007 aliens transformers dramedy Polls and Games Video Games politics The Arrangement Year in Review crime thriller ABC Family crime TruTV IFC MSNBC Winners ESPN FXX ITV vampires VH1 Infographic FX Schedule GIFs technology Mystery E! Drama Reality Competition Disney X-Men The CW Super Bowl GoT OWN supernatural Calendar ABC Food Network social media TV Land Sneak Peek Cartoon Network political drama Grammys Showtime cooking Syfy Comedy Central Sundance Adult Swim AMC Fox News Music Nat Geo Interview Star Trek Musicals President Fall TV Emmys Mindy Kaling Rocky Premiere Dates Set visit TNT Teen serial killer Extras Awards Martial Arts BET Sci-Fi El Rey Lionsgate NBC LGBTQ Countdown TCA 2017 biography Bravo period drama CMT Trailer Mary Tyler Moore zombie 2015 crime drama boxoffice Tumblr BBC Election History Photos PBS Summer Certified Fresh historical drama Spring TV Ellie Kemper Toys BBC America Musical Watching Series composers TBS SundanceTV war cops Masterpiece NYCC Writers Guild of America FOX USA Comic Book sports Marvel Esquire Tomatazos comiccon Red Carpet thriller harry potter Disney Channel MTV TV Holidays GLAAD Kids & Family Amazon singing competition Country DirecTV Netflix diversity travel CNN Marathons Cosplay HBO science fiction Character Guide TCM adventure Animation Hulu SDCC Nominations American Society of Cinematographers Crackle Rock Freeform Starz First Look Valentine's Day Nickelodeon sitcom 2016 Universal 2017 psycho RT History APB VICE Thanksgiving Podcast cinemax Ghostbusters Biopics police drama Trivia TLC discovery Winter TV Superheroes Oscars TCA CBS based on movie Pop CBS All Access Fantasy Comedy