Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Jack and Jill Fetches Bad Reviews

Plus, Immortals looks great but suffers from thin plotting, and J. Edgarnever quite gets at the heart of the man.

by | November 10, 2011 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got twin turmoil (Jack and Jill, starring Adam Sandler and Katie Holmes), mythical mayhem (Immortals, starring Henry Cavill and Mickey Rourke), and a multifaceted fed (J. Edgar, starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Armie Hammer). What do the critics have to say?

Jack and Jill


Adam Sandler’s got a winning formula — lowbrow yuks plus sentimentality equals box office gold — but critics say Jack and Jill may test the patience of even the most loyal of Sandman acolytes, as its jokes are even more juvenile than usual. Sandler stars as Jack, a successful ad executive whose obnoxious twin sister Jill (also played by Sandler) moves to town; hilarity ensues. The pundits say Jack and Jill‘s gags are remarkably crass, and its relentless mocking of Jill is surprisingly mean-spirited, though Al Pacino scores some big laughs parodying himself. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we present a list of actors playing opposite themselves.)



Director Tarsem Singh certainly has a knack for eye-popping images, but critics say the problem with Immortals is that its attention to blood-soaked visual detail always trumps character development and storytelling. Henry Cavill stars as Theseus, a humble stonemason who vows revenge against the tyrannical King Hyperion (Mickey Rourke) after the death of his mother, and soon our hero rounds up a posse to stop the tyrant and restore peace to the land. The pundits say Immortals looks great, but its silly dialogue and narrative shortcomings keep it from being an immersive sword and sandal thrill ride. (Check out co-star Freida Pinto’s Five Favorite Films.)

J. Edgar


J. Edgar purports to explore the professional and personal life of influential (many would say too influential) FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover, but critics say Clint Eastwood‘s admittedly handsome biopic is ultimately too vague a portrait of its controversial subject, despite a committed performance from Leonardo DiCaprio. J. Edgar chronicles Hoover’s tenure at the bureau, as well as his oft-rumored but never substantiated love affair with Associate FBI Director Clyde Tolson. The pundits say the trouble with J. Edgar is that it’s a bit too cautious — it ticks off the events of Hoover’s life without exploring his motives and feelings, though DiCaprio is typically strong.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

Premiere Dates TCM Amazon Action Exclusive Video VICE BBC America TCA sitcom period drama Toys social media Disney Channel cooking Rocky Spring TV CNN FOX Comedy Central Emmys IFC Mystery VH1 adventure LGBTQ serial killer cinemax DirecTV Superheroes Food Network AMC ESPN singing competition Election 007 Netflix FX Polls and Games CMT Tumblr Universal Set visit Calendar Bravo Winter TV Marathons TV Land Certified Fresh Ghostbusters Tomatazos NYCC 2016 GIFs BBC CBS All Access politics Music Musicals Marvel SundanceTV vampires docudrama TIFF ITV PaleyFest Infographic Biopics crime drama NBC sports SDCC Opinion Martial Arts Red Carpet Disney Esquire Awards Hulu E! Comedy Sundance Rom-Com harry potter USA 24 frames Animation MTV History BET Adult Swim PBS FXX Year in Review Cartoon Network Holidays MSNBC Nat Geo discovery Schedule Oscars Crackle TruTV Masterpiece Valentine's Day Watching Series Photos diversity Country Rock The CW Showtime Trailer A&E Character Guide Freeform TCA 2017 Box Office Cosplay Podcast Reality Competition Best and Worst American Society of Cinematographers Kids & Family Pop Starz dramedy Summer ABC First Look Sci-Fi Logo Interview ABC Family Pirates Fox News Sneak Peek Extras Drama Nominations Trivia Reality Thanksgiving Syfy Winners TBS crime thriller Fantasy travel 2017 comiccon TNT President GoT HBO Horror CBS Lifetime WGN boxoffice El Rey Countdown Grammys Fall TV DC Comics Star Wars Writers Guild of America Lionsgate Nickelodeon OWN science fiction thriller 2015 GLAAD Video Games