Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hancock Isn't Signature Smith

Plus, Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is Certified Fresh.

by | July 1, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got moody superheroes (Hancock, starring Will Smith and Charlize Theron), and cub reporters (Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, starring Abigail Breslin and Julia Ormond). What do the critics have to say?

It seems like a can’t-miss prospect: a moody, conflicted superhero, unloved by the public despite his best efforts, played by Will Smith, aka Mr. Independence Day. However, great ideas are a dime a dozen, and critics say Hancock never fully takes flight. An attempt at a subversive take on caped crusader mythos, Smith has super-strength and a drinking problem; however, he learns to show a softer side after saving the life of a public relations expert. The pundits say Smith is solid as always, but the film quickly abandons its clever premise in favor of typical action sequences. Additionally, its shifts in tone — from wry comedy to sentiment — don’t quite cohere. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, Hancock is not one of Smith’s signature films.


With the Fourth of July on the horizon, it seems like an apt time to celebrate the can-do, go-get-’em American spirit. With that in mind, critics say you could do a lot worse than Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, an old-school, family-friendly charmer. Abigail Breslin stars as the title character, a sharp, kind, inquisitive pre-teen whose journalistic aspirations come in handy: she attempts to solve a mystery and, in the process, save her family’s house and exonerate some falsely-accused fellow citizens. The pundits say Kit is a gentle, heartfelt tale that’s both a delivery system for wholesome messages and a surprisingly moving drama. At 79 percent on the Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh Kit Kittredge has Girl power to spare.

“From now on, we trust no one but the Newsies.”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The surreal black comedy Kabluey, starring Lisa Kudrow and Scott Prendergast (who also directs), is at 100 percent.

The French thriller Tell No One, starring Kristin Scott Thomas and Francois Cluzet, is at 93 percent.

Gonzo: the Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, Alex Gibney‘s documentary portrait of the iconic gonzo journalist, is at 86 percent.

The Wackness, the coming-of-age story of a drug dealer in mid-1990s New York, starring Ben Kingsley, Famke Janssen, and Josh Peck, is at 70 percent.

Diminished Capacity, a bittersweet comedy about a newspaperman recovering from a concussion starring Matthew Broderick and Virginia Madsen, is at 17 percent.

“You weren’t a millionaire until you were 40? I was eight!”

Recent Will Smith Movies:
69% — I am Legend (2007)
66% — The Pursuit of Happyness (2006)
69% — Hitch (2005)
34% — Shark Tale (2004)
58% — I, Robot (2004)

Tag Cloud

ABC Signature obituary golden globes canceled TV shows teaser Tubi Nominations Hear Us Out directors witnail Grammys die hard binge rotten movies we love superman Baby Yoda comedies OWN RT History indie pirates of the caribbean hidden camera natural history PaleyFest versus Disney Plus GLAAD Winter TV scary movies Turner Classic Movies TV Land TCA Awards Fall TV FOX adaptation Drama Musical classics Pop TV spider-man 45 Mystery AMC indiana jones Broadway Black Mirror trailers blaxploitation Esquire WGN Chilling Adventures of Sabrina mission: impossible popular remakes LGBT The Witch Video Games Lifetime Music Elton John social media quibi japanese child's play Stephen King jurassic park Amazon Prime Comedy Central Apple TV Plus cops golden globe awards Acorn TV king kong TruTV History MTV 21st Century Fox Podcast Spectrum Originals 99% Photos festival Quiz worst Oscars X-Men space sports Mary poppins halloween tv Awards Tour war rt archives Brie Larson Food Network Superheroes travel Opinion sequels Amazon Prime Video Tarantino reviews Paramount kids mutant spanish language criterion blockbusters Star Trek Marathons Horror Countdown Pirates Sony Pictures Trailer Mudbound video New York Comic Con VICE docudrama BBC One Election dc politics Hallmark science fiction cults TCM historical drama diversity Showtime Film Festival Television Critics Association Shondaland dceu women hollywood television political drama foreign El Rey batman talk show FX on Hulu Warner Bros. Amazon National Geographic Comics on TV 2020 concert cancelled TV shows kong festivals DC Universe cancelled TV series Comedy Rom-Com TBS Disney streaming service TV 2017 Disney deadpool dark composers Disney Channel biography boxing 2021 toronto slashers WarnerMedia crossover news animated Fox Searchlight documentary theme song italian YouTube children's TV nature Apple TV+ Valentine's Day 007 E3 Interview Women's History Month hispanic 2019 VOD The Walking Dead 2018 ABC Teen BAFTA screenings A&E 72 Emmy Awards First Reviews Thanksgiving Exclusive Video superhero Martial Arts Vudu APB TCA Winter 2020 what to watch films OneApp green book book series twilight Cartoon Network USA Network cinemax TIFF VH1 Sneak Peek Arrowverse facebook Super Bowl cancelled Sundance Now ghosts Rock comiccon mockumentary DC Comics Sundance Toys GoT Crackle serial killer technology discovery Ellie Kemper 20th Century Fox Western supernatural worst movies doctor who TV One game of thrones Logo The Walt Disney Company Musicals name the review Captain marvel elevated horror Columbia Pictures parents fresh emmy awards movies Walt Disney Pictures sag awards CBS game show ESPN Year in Review 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards strong female leads cartoon Paramount Network Television Academy finale Tumblr BBC America Film Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled television Rocketman SundanceTV Holiday Avengers halloween Chernobyl dogs Crunchyroll ratings 2016 San Diego Comic-Con Nat Geo chucky 71st Emmy Awards spinoff rom-coms Red Carpet Pop disaster The Academy rotten unscripted Creative Arts Emmys Awards justice league GIFs Reality revenge fast and furious First Look PlayStation Peacock laika asian-american Paramount Plus monster movies CBS All Access Amazon Studios razzies werewolf latino critics psychological thriller cooking President Universal Emmy Nominations Watching Series TNT godzilla Summer Epix TLC Nickelodeon Calendar blockbuster Britbox transformers richard e. Grant ABC Family Dark Horse Comics Black History Month Reality Competition TV renewals dragons all-time best Holidays based on movie Schedule TCA independent FX kaiju joker comics Family Freeform Infographic canceled spain CMT DC streaming service Starz true crime black 2015 Ovation Tomatazos documentaries sequel crime thriller Writers Guild of America jamie lee curtis french Trivia Anna Paquin nfl Sci-Fi Travel Channel IFC streaming Pride Month BET NYCC miniseries free movies The Purge telelvision Comic Book Legendary Fox News zombies Cannes HBO Go spy thriller The Arrangement Mindy Kaling medical drama Discovery Channel IFC Films Mary Tyler Moore Syfy Apple romance scorecard ID ITV toy story Hulu Polls and Games psycho American Society of Cinematographers MCU Marvel Premiere Dates E! Pet Sematary Certified Fresh anime australia police drama Set visit renewed TV shows stop motion A24 MSNBC comic books Fantasy vampires sitcom cats HBO 24 frames CW Seed harry potter See It Skip It screen actors guild Marvel Television Lucasfilm stand-up comedy USA Character Guide stoner RT21 award winner romantic comedy Rocky dramedy LGBTQ casting Alien Funimation TCA 2017 PBS docuseries Bravo Spring TV comic a nightmare on elm street BBC movie YouTube Premium boxoffice singing competition HBO Max DGA Box Office reboot YouTube Red football Trophy Talk Binge Guide tv talk south america Winners Spike video on demand Cosplay Country DirecTV Hallmark Christmas movies 4/20 anthology thriller franchise period drama Sundance TV ViacomCBS cars Biopics Mary Poppins Returns venice Pixar Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt crime zombie Classic Film The CW spanish adventure james bond christmas movies Academy Awards Kids & Family archives aliens satire nbcuniversal Endgame Best and Worst Ghostbusters Lionsgate Heroines BET Awards Shudder Turner Extras Christmas FXX Action Disney+ Disney Plus YA Masterpiece Emmys Netflix Christmas movies robots Adult Swim Animation crime drama SXSW NBC CNN prank breaking bad universal monsters zero dark thirty hist Song of Ice and Fire Superheroe SDCC Star Wars Marvel Studios Netflix