Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Hancock Isn't Signature Smith

Plus, Kit Kittredge: An American Girl is Certified Fresh.

by | July 1, 2008 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got moody superheroes (Hancock, starring Will Smith and Charlize Theron), and cub reporters (Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, starring Abigail Breslin and Julia Ormond). What do the critics have to say?

It seems like a can’t-miss prospect: a moody, conflicted superhero, unloved by the public despite his best efforts, played by Will Smith, aka Mr. Independence Day. However, great ideas are a dime a dozen, and critics say Hancock never fully takes flight. An attempt at a subversive take on caped crusader mythos, Smith has super-strength and a drinking problem; however, he learns to show a softer side after saving the life of a public relations expert. The pundits say Smith is solid as always, but the film quickly abandons its clever premise in favor of typical action sequences. Additionally, its shifts in tone — from wry comedy to sentiment — don’t quite cohere. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, Hancock is not one of Smith’s signature films.


With the Fourth of July on the horizon, it seems like an apt time to celebrate the can-do, go-get-’em American spirit. With that in mind, critics say you could do a lot worse than Kit Kittredge: An American Girl, an old-school, family-friendly charmer. Abigail Breslin stars as the title character, a sharp, kind, inquisitive pre-teen whose journalistic aspirations come in handy: she attempts to solve a mystery and, in the process, save her family’s house and exonerate some falsely-accused fellow citizens. The pundits say Kit is a gentle, heartfelt tale that’s both a delivery system for wholesome messages and a surprisingly moving drama. At 79 percent on the Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh Kit Kittredge has Girl power to spare.

“From now on, we trust no one but the Newsies.”

Also opening this week in limited release:

The surreal black comedy Kabluey, starring Lisa Kudrow and Scott Prendergast (who also directs), is at 100 percent.

The French thriller Tell No One, starring Kristin Scott Thomas and Francois Cluzet, is at 93 percent.

Gonzo: the Life and Work of Dr. Hunter S. Thompson, Alex Gibney‘s documentary portrait of the iconic gonzo journalist, is at 86 percent.

The Wackness, the coming-of-age story of a drug dealer in mid-1990s New York, starring Ben Kingsley, Famke Janssen, and Josh Peck, is at 70 percent.

Diminished Capacity, a bittersweet comedy about a newspaperman recovering from a concussion starring Matthew Broderick and Virginia Madsen, is at 17 percent.

“You weren’t a millionaire until you were 40? I was eight!”

Recent Will Smith Movies:
69% — I am Legend (2007)
66% — The Pursuit of Happyness (2006)
69% — Hitch (2005)
34% — Shark Tale (2004)
58% — I, Robot (2004)

Tag Cloud

debate Disney Plus Spring TV international war cancelled TV shows Best and Worst social media Arrowverse political drama Reality kaiju DGA streaming movies Cartoon Network 71st Emmy Awards Sneak Peek cancelled witnail YouTube Universal elevated horror tv talk basketball Animation HFPA Trailer Disney Ovation Sony Pictures series emmy awards adventure sequel The Witch New York Comic Con Winners CBS 2015 Endgame See It Skip It superman Apple The CW Spectrum Originals Emmys The Academy Election Broadway monster movies Nominations Food Network gangster Tomatazos ITV Travel Channel critics Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Schedule finale Rocky YouTube Red mob Emmy Nominations DirecTV Character Guide PlayStation Star Wars Tokyo Olympics PBS CNN cooking Hear Us Out obituary Elton John films 4/20 scorecard Epix Mary poppins Instagram Live unscripted game show CMT casting Disney streaming service psychological thriller miniseries reviews Super Bowl Superheroe Neflix superhero chucky 73rd Emmy Awards Bravo 2021 Mindy Kaling green book psycho animated Film Columbia Pictures transformers Fox News new star wars movies Kids & Family Premiere Dates ABC Sundance Now video on demand Peacock name the review A&E french Shudder biography Wes Anderson Hulu cops live event comic Certified Fresh quibi kong Dark Horse Comics IFC Films E3 breaking bad NBC facebook Alien Sci-Fi Pop 2020 romantic comedy 2019 Shondaland Rock free movies spanish language nbcuniversal crime Turner Pet Sematary game of thrones 93rd Oscars dramedy news science fiction Valentine's Day Paramount Plus Horror TV movies golden globes BAFTA spider-man Calendar FX thriller Red Carpet what to watch VOD Amazon Prime Video MSNBC suspense Chernobyl 90s cancelled television X-Men king arthur Apple TV+ Lucasfilm scary movies RT History anthology HBO movies Film Festival Fall TV Apple TV Plus halloween tv TV renewals cartoon canceled TV shows ViacomCBS Marvel Television FOX TruTV IFC telelvision parents Sundance mutant slashers based on movie History natural history Marvel YouTube Premium Ellie Kemper BBC America romance award winner LGBT docuseries Year in Review Mystery TCA Winter 2020 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards target Comics on TV dragons japan Mary Tyler Moore dceu Hallmark Christmas movies Spike Classic Film scary FX on Hulu Image Comics movie feel good medical drama worst 1990s Heroines historical drama Cannes AMC teaser Netflix Christmas movies Oscars japanese marvel cinematic universe USA 72 Emmy Awards HBO Go screen actors guild composers 24 frames young adult mockumentary rt labs Paramount Network Drama Starz 21st Century Fox Infographic VH1 Photos best BET Awards NBA DC Universe GoT archives Family popular dogs zero dark thirty Mudbound First Look Watching Series Pixar comiccon MCU Podcast GIFs Country ESPN Cosplay Set visit prank spider-verse cars anime critic resources Showtime President TLC cats indiana jones WarnerMedia blockbusters know your critic richard e. Grant child's play Comedy Central a nightmare on elm street Amazon Prime Tumblr Music comics hollywood kids Western NYCC worst movies deadpool trailers comic book movies Legendary sopranos werewolf sitcom Box Office Baby Yoda Netflix theme song heist movie documentary Amazon Studios Disney+ Disney Plus Ghostbusters sequels Stephen King PaleyFest 45 crime drama Discovery Channel hispanic GLAAD disaster Funimation ABC Family vampires rt labs critics edition live action leaderboard CW Seed hist Women's History Month saw Comic Book Action APB razzies Binge Guide black comedy VICE Hallmark aapi Pirates Disney Channel Turner Classic Movies police drama posters Logo SundanceTV rotten rt archives strong female leads docudrama Lionsgate Rom-Com National Geographic nfl cancelled TV series universal monsters The Walking Dead joker Awards Tour true crime art house criterion Sundance TV Academy Awards TV Land Masterpiece Opinion Captain marvel Holidays pirates of the caribbean LGBTQ wonder woman Britbox sports comic books Martial Arts hidden camera rotten movies we love comedies Crunchyroll fresh TCA Awards documentaries nature adenture spanish Superheroes The Walt Disney Company Television Critics Association Lifetime action-comedy twilight blaxploitation ghosts Nickelodeon 007 comic book movie Comedy boxoffice spain TV One CBS All Access Grammys television foreign mcc Interview TCM james bond blockbuster Acorn TV robots rom-coms Awards lord of the rings video godzilla genre TIFF AMC Plus dc space royal family Fantasy BBC One stand-up comedy Avengers toy story 2017 reboot BBC adaptation Warner Bros. harry potter USA Network Esquire new zealand italian El Rey streaming TV dexter cinemax ABC Signature toronto Biopics festivals Black Mirror travel vs. stop motion fast and furious E! boxing 99% doctor who TBS Trivia black Polls and Games 2018 crossover Rocketman king kong The Arrangement Walt Disney Pictures directors 20th Century Fox Fargo Comic-Con@Home 2021 venice Creative Arts Emmys book adaptation classics Trophy Talk women marvel comics Black History Month halloween zombie south america Winter TV spinoff Summer Christmas Marathons Video Games Toys First Reviews Adult Swim Teen Crackle new york HBO Max DC Comics YA zombies Prime Video OWN A24 satire singing competition aliens Mary Poppins Returns BET Tags: Comedy spy thriller Marvel Studios Nat Geo Star Trek 79th Golden Globes Awards ratings batman Tarantino latino Tubi 2016 TCA indie biopic talk show scene in color RT21 franchise all-time children's TV FXX serial killer cults Thanksgiving supernatural trophy laika revenge San Diego Comic-Con slasher Chilling Adventures of Sabrina binge Pride Month jurassic park book Reality Competition concert IMDb TV Musicals jamie lee curtis Fox Searchlight football versus Writers Guild of America Pacific Islander Amazon Lifetime Christmas movies American Society of Cinematographers Brie Larson mission: impossible dark Television Academy Countdown Pop TV Extras Holiday screenings stoner australia dreamworks TCA 2017 TNT Musical justice league DC streaming service christmas movies olympics Hollywood Foreign Press Association The Purge asian-american Freeform SDCC hispanic heritage month Syfy festival Quiz discovery die hard independent MTV Universal Pictures diversity Exclusive Video technology crime thriller Anna Paquin high school golden globe awards period drama WGN remakes SXSW politics OneApp canceled ID renewed TV shows legend sag awards Song of Ice and Fire Vudu Paramount