Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Gold is a Fool's Paradise, Roscoe is Not Welcome

Also: Vince Vaughn hits bumps on his comedic road trip.

by | February 7, 2008 | Comments

This week
at the movies, we’ve got treasure hunters (Fool’s Gold, starring
Matthew McConaughey and
Kate Hudson), awkward reunions (Welcome Home Roscoe Jenkins,
starring Martin Lawrence and
Mo’Nique), and a stand-up road trips (Vince
Vaughn’s Wild West Comedy Show
). What do the critics have to say?

They say
all that glitters ain’t gold — and critics say

Fool’s Gold

gives off almost no shine whatsoever. The movie stars

Matthew McConaughey
Kate Hudson
as a divorced couple who reunite to hunt for sunken treasure; danger and wacky
antics ensue. The pundits say Fool’s Gold is aptly titled, with a
ludicrous plot, non-existent chemistry between the leads, wildly inconsistent
tonal shifts, and a sense of “been there, done that” throughout. At seven
percent on the Tomatometer, Fool’s Gold is the cinematic equivalent of
pyrite — or perhaps pumice. And it’s definitely a step down from the stars’
previous collaboration,

How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days
, at 42 percent.
(Check out RT’s examination of notable treasure hunt movies here.)

"The Allman Brothers are playing in Providence this week,
Philly next week, D.C. the week after that.."

Morrissey once said, we hate it when our friends become successful.

Welcome Home Roscoe Jenkins
is about a successful guy who’s hated by his family —
and though critics say it has its moments, it doesn’t totally cohere.

Martin Lawrence stars as the titular character, an obnoxious self-help guru who returns
home for his parents’ golden anniversary — and finds that his family is eager to
cut him down to size. The pundits say Roscoe Jenkins has its share of
flaws, not least of which is an over-reliance on weather-beaten slapstick. But
others note the movie features spirited work from a skilled supporting cast, and
some surprising humanity beneath the crass jokes. At 50 percent on the
Tomatomter, this one’s getting a lukewarm Welcome.

"Yep. Your house has scurvy."

Vince Vaughn’s
Wild West Comedy Show: 30 Days and 30 Nights — Hollywood to the Heartland
has a title
that makes Don’t Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in
the Hood
seem like a paragon of restraint. And critics say it’s indicative
of a documentary that doesn’t quite know when to quit. The movie follows the
amiable Vaughn and a group of up-and-coming comedians on a month-long, 6,000
mile tour across America. The pundits say when the film focuses on the stage
show, it’s a blast. However, they also say there are few too many diversions and
backstage banter on this trip. At 52 percent on the Tomatometer, this one’s a
little too much West and not enough Wild.

"Did you ever know that you’re my hero-o-o?"

opening this week in limited release:

"Paris Hilton was saluditorian?"

it’s time for props distribution:
livewire24 and
BladeoftheImmortal came the
closest to guessing The Eye‘s 19 percent Tomatometer, and
came the closest to guessing
Strange Wilderness
‘ zero percent

Kate Hudson Movies:
22% — You Me and Dupree (2006)
39% — The Skeleton Key (2005)
22% — Raising Helen (2004)
42% —
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days
11% — Alex and Emma (2003)

Martin Lawrence Movies:
15% — Wild Hogs (2007)
5% — Big Momma’s House 2 (2006)
48% — Open Season (2006)
13% — Rebound (2005)
13% — National Security (2003)

Tag Cloud

FXX police drama crime thriller X-Men Watching Series Awards TBS AMC CBS All Access Nat Geo Adult Swim Biopics Emmys DC Comics Nickelodeon Infographic Marathons supernatural thriller Schedule El Rey First Look RT History CBS Grammys travel harry potter YA MTV Mystery Trivia Character Guide Pop E3 Summer Cosplay Musicals Winners Drama 24 frames Opinion CNN Cartoon Network Winter TV Sci-Fi The Arrangement dramedy Box Office Fox News The CW Fall TV Syfy discovery cops Comic Book Showtime TNT A&E TLC Food Network Reality Lionsgate ABC zombie social media BET TIFF Calendar NBC Pirates Reality Competition VH1 Horror transformers Video Games Valentine's Day IFC political drama Musical Spring TV science fiction Amazon 2015 Crackle biography Comedy Central SundanceTV SDCC Netflix Certified Fresh Tumblr cooking Esquire singing competition Tomatazos aliens Extras DirecTV HBO E! Disney Channel ITV Podcast Comedy adventure APB Starz Best and Worst American Society of Cinematographers Country Mindy Kaling crime drama Oscars ABC Family Sneak Peek Rom-Com Universal Sundance Logo Kids & Family Disney Lifetime Martial Arts TCA LGBTQ cinemax TruTV TV Land Red Carpet Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt USA NYCC ESPN technology MSNBC GIFs period drama boxoffice historical drama politics serial killer TV President GoT Music Trailer diversity Polls and Games Countdown TCA 2017 Marvel psycho OWN Dark Horse Comics Holidays Freeform Hulu Interview 2017 war sports FX 007 Premiere Dates comiccon BBC America based on movie BBC TCM Thanksgiving Election Bravo Set visit Teen PaleyFest FOX sitcom vampires Animation CMT Photos crime GLAAD Toys Mary Tyler Moore Fantasy Ellie Kemper History Star Trek Rock Ghostbusters Rocky WGN docudrama Superheroes Super Bowl Masterpiece VICE composers Star Wars Action Year in Review Writers Guild of America 2016 PBS Nominations