Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Despite Laughs, Extract Isn't Quite Potent Enough

Plus, All About Steve is floundering, while Gamer has yet to receive a review.

by | September 3, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a wacky workplace (Extract, starring Jason Bateman and Ben Affleck), crazy love (All About Steve, starring Sandra Bullock and Bradley Cooper), and video game violence (Gamer, starring Gerard Butler and Ludacris). What do the critics have to say?



Mike Judge is one of contemporary cinema’s finest chroniclers of the working life — and what a madhouse it can be. His first feature, Office Space, was a riotous exercise in workplace absurdity, but critics say his latest, Extract, isn’t quite as funny — or as insightful. Jason Bateman stars as the owner of a flavoring factory with plenty on his mind: his wife’s affections are waning, one of his employees has suffered a cringe-worthy injury, and his best pay gives him questionable advice, usually while under the influence. The pundits say Extract has some very funny moments and several fine performances, but overall, the film feels slighter and more uneven than Judge’s previous work.


All About Steve

Sandra Bullock’s pure likability has elevated plenty of so-so romantic comedies, but she can’t always overcome the deficiencies of a terrible script. Case in point: All About Steve, which critics describe as one of the worst in the actress’ solid career. Bullock stars as a woman who falls head-over-heals for a TV cameraman (Bradley Cooper) after a single blind date and proceeds to follow him around the country. The pundits say All About Steve is an oddly creepy, sour film, featuring a heroine so desperate and peculiar that audiences may be more likely to pity than root for her. (Also, be sure to check out our rundown of the Best Stalker Movies in this week’s Total Recall.)



It appears the folks behind Gamer are afraid that it’s the cinematic equivalent to the N-Gage, since it wasn’t screened for critics prior to release. Gerard Butler stars as the main character in a futuristic MMORPG, but with a twist: he’s a living, breathing human being, and he’s being controlled by a teen gamer. Kids, turn off that Atari Jaguar and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Liverpool, a minimalist drama about a lonely Argentine man, is at 100 percent.
  • Unmade Beds, about two hipster immigrants in London looking for love, is at 86 percent.

  • Amreeka, a dramedy about a Palestinian woman making a new life in a small American town, is at 80 percent.

  • American Casino, a documentary that explores the causes and effects of the current economic crisis, is at 54 percent.

  • Tickling Leo, about a family’s dark secret from World War II, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

Elton John Baby Yoda robots sequel singing competition YouTube Turner tv talk transformers The Witch Marvel cats Superheroes TLC politics USA DC Universe National Geographic Chilling Adventures of Sabrina movie Comedy Central social media kids disaster Tarantino ratings renewed TV shows versus anthology GLAAD anime Fall TV President ESPN ghosts book screen actors guild Pop 24 frames crime thriller FXX jamie lee curtis IFC New York Comic Con Sneak Peek Comic Book San Diego Comic-Con Avengers sag awards TV Election ABC Family Mary poppins Music Classic Film universal monsters vampires Disney Channel crime foreign cancelled children's TV composers based on movie YA mockumentary 2020 nature halloween Funimation Spectrum Originals Musical cancelled television CBS theme song Trivia Nickelodeon Showtime TruTV Mudbound DC Comics game of thrones revenge Nominations Best and Worst Nat Geo adventure scary movies Freeform Character Guide Lionsgate El Rey reboot DirecTV Hallmark Christmas movies PBS canceled Paramount biography Shondaland OneApp Captain marvel Tubi Rocky Quiz Red Carpet NYCC Box Office Fantasy Reality Competition 21st Century Fox Amazon Prime Video Starz Endgame Pride Month Watching Series talk show Polls and Games historical drama Rom-Com cancelled TV shows Epix Black History Month spider-man OWN Winter TV Animation Sony Pictures war cartoon binge dogs cinemax WGN USA Network Thanksgiving Black Mirror Opinion Lifetime History south america blockbuster Adult Swim APB Rocketman Reality Martial Arts documentary Trailer GoT cars HBO Universal Grammys NBC Year in Review werewolf Musicals WarnerMedia Podcast Trophy Talk Photos dragons Star Trek DC streaming service stand-up comedy Fox News christmas movies comiccon Rock A24 Mary Poppins Returns The Arrangement Marathons Chernobyl teaser A&E facebook Anna Paquin Dark Horse Comics First Look Television Academy video Netflix Christmas movies Song of Ice and Fire Turner Classic Movies strong female leads comics richard e. Grant animated GIFs canceled TV shows Film Certified Fresh TBS casting Arrowverse serial killer adaptation space Masterpiece Lifetime Christmas movies Mindy Kaling Pop TV blaxploitation toy story spinoff zombie CMT CBS All Access Awards Tour series E3 Pixar Marvel Television Ellie Kemper Marvel Studios TCM Country RT History DGA award winner Drama boxoffice Binge Guide indie independent Awards doctor who Columbia Pictures Disney+ Disney Plus LGBT CNN Walt Disney Pictures Logo BET supernatural CW Seed slashers MCU 45 Discovery Channel Ghostbusters mutant Paramount Network Hulu dc Biopics Esquire Amazon Prime unscripted witnail romantic comedy Comedy hist FX MTV Calendar Horror reviews Oscars BBC directors Pet Sematary spanish language breaking bad zero dark thirty Holidays SundanceTV golden globes Creative Arts Emmys Lucasfilm cops Food Network docudrama Acorn TV Apple TV Plus Amazon Sundance Now sports what to watch Netflix Britbox First Reviews Superheroe Women's History Month streaming PaleyFest YouTube Premium Crackle Film Festival E! miniseries TV renewals natural history Disney streaming service cooking diversity 2017 Family finale Syfy Action Disney Stephen King spy thriller 2016 The CW YouTube Red medical drama travel Super Bowl Video Games Sundance TV Ovation The Purge Hallmark police drama ITV Comics on TV Valentine's Day LGBTQ Countdown SDCC crossover Extras period drama Tomatazos Sci-Fi FOX Pirates dceu joker 71st Emmy Awards free movies FX on Hulu VICE Warner Bros. thriller aliens Teen IFC Films quibi TCA Winter 2020 screenings political drama Bravo BBC America Premiere Dates psychological thriller dramedy franchise science fiction justice league Schedule Peacock TIFF HBO Max elevated horror Holiday 2015 Brie Larson romance Cartoon Network psycho Cosplay TNT Emmys technology Tumblr MSNBC AMC festivals latino Mary Tyler Moore Mystery Cannes Vudu discovery true crime Spike American Society of Cinematographers Infographic Apple hispanic spain Disney Plus See It Skip It 2019 Shudder sitcom Apple TV+ zombies game show ABC TV Land 2018 The Walking Dead batman Amazon Studios comic Christmas crime drama Heroines cults 007 TCA Winners green book harry potter Emmy Nominations Interview Spring TV name the review Kids & Family Travel Channel Summer Western Sundance TCA 2017 X-Men 20th Century Fox Set visit Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Toys VH1 television Crunchyroll rotten movies we love Star Wars Writers Guild of America Academy Awards SXSW movies RT21 cancelled TV series