Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Despite Laughs, Extract Isn't Quite Potent Enough

Plus, All About Steve is floundering, while Gamer has yet to receive a review.

by | September 3, 2009 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a wacky workplace (Extract, starring Jason Bateman and Ben Affleck), crazy love (All About Steve, starring Sandra Bullock and Bradley Cooper), and video game violence (Gamer, starring Gerard Butler and Ludacris). What do the critics have to say?



Mike Judge is one of contemporary cinema’s finest chroniclers of the working life — and what a madhouse it can be. His first feature, Office Space, was a riotous exercise in workplace absurdity, but critics say his latest, Extract, isn’t quite as funny — or as insightful. Jason Bateman stars as the owner of a flavoring factory with plenty on his mind: his wife’s affections are waning, one of his employees has suffered a cringe-worthy injury, and his best pay gives him questionable advice, usually while under the influence. The pundits say Extract has some very funny moments and several fine performances, but overall, the film feels slighter and more uneven than Judge’s previous work.


All About Steve

Sandra Bullock’s pure likability has elevated plenty of so-so romantic comedies, but she can’t always overcome the deficiencies of a terrible script. Case in point: All About Steve, which critics describe as one of the worst in the actress’ solid career. Bullock stars as a woman who falls head-over-heals for a TV cameraman (Bradley Cooper) after a single blind date and proceeds to follow him around the country. The pundits say All About Steve is an oddly creepy, sour film, featuring a heroine so desperate and peculiar that audiences may be more likely to pity than root for her. (Also, be sure to check out our rundown of the Best Stalker Movies in this week’s Total Recall.)



It appears the folks behind Gamer are afraid that it’s the cinematic equivalent to the N-Gage, since it wasn’t screened for critics prior to release. Gerard Butler stars as the main character in a futuristic MMORPG, but with a twist: he’s a living, breathing human being, and he’s being controlled by a teen gamer. Kids, turn off that Atari Jaguar and guess that Tomatometer!

Also opening this week in limited release:

  • Liverpool, a minimalist drama about a lonely Argentine man, is at 100 percent.
  • Unmade Beds, about two hipster immigrants in London looking for love, is at 86 percent.

  • Amreeka, a dramedy about a Palestinian woman making a new life in a small American town, is at 80 percent.

  • American Casino, a documentary that explores the causes and effects of the current economic crisis, is at 54 percent.

  • Tickling Leo, about a family’s dark secret from World War II, is at 33 percent.

Tag Cloud

toronto slashers Marvel Television adaptation anime BAFTA adventure renewed TV shows Spike dark animated Film Universal TV Land free movies cinemax Rocketman cops LGBTQ latino National Geographic movies CMT SundanceTV psychological thriller black Tubi hollywood NBC Comic Book The Witch Nat Geo supernatural Toys Marathons The Purge OneApp GIFs Reality Year in Review Action Cartoon Network PlayStation stoner Countdown TruTV Tarantino Starz spain Musicals Awards Tour toy story book Election 2018 Rocky jamie lee curtis Summer BBC One HBO Max Creative Arts Emmys comedies Apple TV Plus FOX Mary Tyler Moore Mystery Superheroes spinoff Turner nbcuniversal Mindy Kaling indie Apple TV+ Hulu Crunchyroll vampires TLC biography war halloween tv serial killer Shondaland Animation binge The Academy twilight a nightmare on elm street TV renewals green book Avengers ABC Quiz TCA Winter 2020 YA Endgame elevated horror Trophy Talk Mudbound Trailer Vudu archives Sundance TV HBO Film Festival cancelled TV series social media The CW HBO Go Grammys worst movies Binge Guide Holidays dceu batman American Society of Cinematographers critics talk show child's play Fox News Spectrum Originals Crackle Turner Classic Movies crime Showtime Baby Yoda concert true crime VOD die hard Biopics ITV Winter TV spider-man Brie Larson historical drama Funimation The Walking Dead TCA Awards sequel aliens sag awards CBS All Access Tomatazos Travel Channel Family japanese 2019 canceled 24 frames Calendar transformers WGN DC Comics Acorn TV DC streaming service Musical Television Academy parents joker stop motion indiana jones CNN Women's History Month Interview Fall TV Freeform Britbox AMC discovery BBC America Paramount series Mary Poppins Returns crime thriller Watching Series MSNBC Winners Captain marvel Kids & Family TIFF disaster YouTube Premium 007 Anna Paquin DC Universe hist obituary Marvel cancelled television 2016 SXSW foreign Spring TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cosplay Fantasy docudrama dc game of thrones Epix CBS sequels politics Video Games Hear Us Out Netflix WarnerMedia Adult Swim television TNT MTV theme song Valentine's Day 2015 cults Disney Plus sports MCU directors movie scary movies Cannes Stephen King halloween Premiere Dates Black History Month Sneak Peek History 2017 crime drama medical drama Hallmark PaleyFest BET video on demand scorecard doctor who FXX independent video Marvel Studios Thanksgiving Writers Guild of America Sundance comic spanish See It Skip It cats Hallmark Christmas movies TCA First Look Food Network 4/20 ghosts reboot period drama police drama richard e. Grant Sundance Now Extras Music teaser award winner cancelled TV IFC Films children's TV NYCC mutant universal monsters Logo game show Peacock miniseries Opinion Certified Fresh Fox Searchlight casting OWN cooking natural history ID breaking bad south america Academy Awards Masterpiece laika crossover nfl Star Trek Lionsgate comiccon political drama fast and furious FX Ovation ratings Nickelodeon strong female leads Chernobyl TCM football versus El Rey festival E! Amazon Studios screenings worst Sony Pictures emmy awards australia VICE romance E3 streaming Lifetime Christmas movies comic books FX on Hulu mission: impossible canceled TV shows finale USA Network Disney streaming service USA GoT blockbuster YouTube Red italian superhero chucky sitcom rotten movies we love Emmys hispanic facebook Disney Channel Super Bowl Paramount Network Christmas documentaries Television Critics Association technology Columbia Pictures BET Awards Character Guide Tumblr Comics on TV Star Wars nature thriller First Reviews documentary Ellie Kemper Lucasfilm Discovery Channel french zombies unscripted diversity justice league Emmy Nominations zero dark thirty Holiday 71st Emmy Awards Western IFC venice Dark Horse Comics rotten Best and Worst Disney spanish language Trivia spy thriller San Diego Comic-Con Heroines Bravo composers Pirates VH1 Rom-Com Photos dogs Lifetime quibi psycho romantic comedy dramedy science fiction news Set visit Black Mirror Song of Ice and Fire Horror best Pet Sematary Esquire CW Seed cartoon A24 festivals Superheroe Walt Disney Pictures TBS blaxploitation 72 Emmy Awards Oscars A&E ABC Family APB Pop zombie singing competition BBC Elton John Rock dragons werewolf Apple Drama harry potter Polls and Games Warner Bros. Pride Month Comedy Mary poppins X-Men Disney+ Disney Plus 20th Century Fox Comedy Central kids Syfy mockumentary Infographic Amazon Prime Pop TV 45 comics GLAAD SDCC tv talk Country DirecTV satire Netflix Christmas movies remakes Awards witnail robots Teen name the review RT History YouTube boxoffice Ghostbusters anthology DGA Box Office films criterion cars franchise revenge christmas movies RT21 screen actors guild stand-up comedy 21st Century Fox LGBT Red Carpet Sci-Fi Reality Competition Nominations Arrowverse Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pixar classics reviews President all-time Podcast PBS asian-american ESPN Martial Arts cancelled TV shows The Arrangement 2020 travel Schedule TCA 2017 New York Comic Con Amazon based on movie what to watch golden globes Classic Film space Shudder Amazon Prime Video