Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: Alice Looks Great, Lacks Wonder

Plus, Brooklyn's Finest isn't quite arresting.

by | March 5, 2010 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a trip down the rabbit hole (Alice in Wonderland, starring Johnny Depp and Mia Wasilkowska) and a ride-along with the boys in blue (Brooklyn’s Finest, starring Richard Gere and Don Cheadle). What do the critics have to say?


Alice in Wonderland

At first glace, a Tim Burton adaptation of Alice in Wonderland seems perfectly serendipitous: Hollywood’s most playfully macabre filmmaker would be the obvious choice to reinterpret Lewis Carroll’s darkly whimsical tale. However, critics say the result is curiouser – a film of remarkable visual invention that lacks strong plotting or a sense of wonder. Mia Wasilkowska stars as the titular heroine who heads down the rabbit hole, where she encounters such eccentrics as the goofy-but-somewhat-sinister Mad Hatter (Johnny Depp) and the tyrannical Red Queen (Helena Bonham Carter). The pundits say Burton’s taste for phantasmagoric images is intact, but he loses track of the narrative, and the film misses the book’s good humor and sense of wide-eyed awe. (Check out this week’s Total Recall, in which we count down Burton’s best-reviewed films, as well as our feature on composer Danny Elfman’s Five Favorite Films.)


Brooklyn’s Finest

With Training Day, Antoine Fuqua brought fresh, gritty energy to the cop drama. Now he’s back on the mean streets with Brooklyn’s Finest and critics say this one is far less — ahem — arresting. Finest follows three cops (Richard Gere, Don Cheadle, and Ethan Hawke) who, over the course of a particularly hectic week, find their personal and professional lives at wit’s end; will they sacrifice their ethics in the line of duty? The pundits say the movie features fine performances in the service of a shopworn script that borrows liberally from dozens of law enforcement flicks without bringing much new to the table.

Also opening this week in limited release:

Tag Cloud

latino spy thriller witnail Quiz 2015 adventure cults dramedy AMC Shondaland Action See It Skip It sequel Grammys Syfy Women's History Month Interview spinoff crime thriller GLAAD Disney Musical Vudu Comics on TV Bravo RT History quibi FXX Mystery singing competition Sony Pictures Awards Dark Horse Comics HBO cinemax Arrowverse TCA 2017 Family historical drama GIFs Disney Channel Election Freeform Tumblr WarnerMedia 24 frames DGA anthology natural history Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt political drama game of thrones Amazon Paramount Heroines richard e. Grant series Winners OWN Sundance Now game show 2017 Trailer cars ABC Apple ratings cooking dc Fall TV DC streaming service Toys Anna Paquin X-Men teaser Year in Review National Geographic Best and Worst docudrama CBS All Access BET El Rey Film Festival transformers hist zombie GoT disaster psycho Amazon Prime Video Fantasy sitcom TNT medical drama Musicals Netflix video Spike Rock E3 USA Network comiccon VH1 PaleyFest TV Summer harry potter Pet Sematary biography 21st Century Fox Comedy adaptation APB Trophy Talk FOX Hulu TBS Valentine's Day MTV ESPN Martial Arts casting Starz Character Guide BBC Red Carpet YouTube Red Walt Disney Pictures hispanic Britbox MSNBC The Witch Black Mirror Superheroe space Pop Country Nominations First Reviews DC Comics Amazon Prime Cosplay aliens award winner robots Nat Geo Reality Competition sports Lucasfilm Film blaxploitation Lifetime Esquire Teen cats Horror Rocketman TruTV Shudder Food Network PBS facebook technology LGBTQ romance Countdown Fox News Watching Series based on movie Biopics finale RT21 YA San Diego Comic-Con Logo Thanksgiving dragons YouTube Premium Certified Fresh zero dark thirty Peacock First Look Sci-Fi TLC television Calendar Star Trek Captain marvel USA Mary Tyler Moore TIFF book Tomatazos Pixar doctor who Adult Swim ABC Family Box Office WGN E! Television Academy CBS Masterpiece thriller psychological thriller LGBT Star Wars Acorn TV CNN spanish language Cartoon Network Epix Song of Ice and Fire Video Games Elton John animated Spring TV DC Universe comic ITV crime Disney streaming service kids Mindy Kaling spider-man Kids & Family Superheroes Chernobyl 20th Century Fox diversity elevated horror CMT Opinion Creative Arts Emmys Comedy Central 2019 serial killer Mudbound vampires Spectrum Originals Binge Guide The Arrangement IFC Trivia unscripted green book supernatural Paramount Network Brie Larson Animation Music Marathons Tarantino miniseries Drama streaming American Society of Cinematographers true crime travel SXSW politics Super Bowl Warner Bros. Winter TV Photos Premiere Dates Infographic mutant MCU boxoffice tv talk TCM war Marvel revenge A&E FX Podcast crime drama strong female leads foreign Extras jamie lee curtis Emmys The CW Reality what to watch Writers Guild of America Showtime anime dceu Rocky Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BBC America golden globes Set visit 007 Oscars 71st Emmy Awards spain TV Land Columbia Pictures zombies Mary poppins children's TV History NBC Sneak Peek Pirates Mary Poppins Returns binge Universal Sundance HBO Max IFC Films science fiction social media Stephen King Christmas cops Pride Month Crackle mockumentary CW Seed stand-up comedy festivals Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper Cannes nature Comic Book Lionsgate President Polls and Games VICE Schedule theme song Holidays DirecTV Emmy Nominations SDCC ghosts toy story SundanceTV Rom-Com period drama police drama 2018 Western discovery composers 2016 Awards Tour Ghostbusters movies TCA 45 talk show justice league crossover Ovation NYCC south america New York Comic Con