Critics Consensus

Critics Consensus: 10,000 B.C. is Primitive; Bank Gets the Job Done

Also: College Trip is on a Road to nowhere.

by | March 6, 2008 | Comments

This week
at the movies, we’ve got prehistoric passion (10,000 B.C., starring
Steven Strait and
Camilla Belle), travel travails (College Road Trip,
starring Martin Lawrence and
Raven-Symone), and
hard-boiled heists (The Bank Job, starring
Jason Statham). What do the
critics have to say?

If you’re
looking for subtlety,
Roland Emmerich is not your man. That’s not to say he’s a
bad filmmaker; he’s made some quality big-budget, high-concept yarns (Independence
springs to mind) that deliver thrills aplenty. Unfortunately, critics say
his latest,

10,000 B.C.
, is mired in the stone age. B.C. stars

Steven Strait and
Camilla Belle
as a pair of hunting-and-gathering honeys; when
Belle gets kidnapped, Strait and members of their tribe journey into the unknown
to save her — and run across saber-toothed tigers, wooly mammoths, and other
civilizations. The pundits say 10,000 B.C. doesn’t lack for compelling
visuals, but it’s weak on plot and characterization and filled with
unintentional comedy. At 12 percent on the Tomatometer, 10,000 B.C. is a
Mesolithic mess. It’s also the worst-reviewed film of Emmerich’s career.

“Jiminy Jilickers! Just missed the Red Bull Flugtag!”

College Road Trip,
Martin Lawrence joins
Ice Cube and
Robin Williams in the pantheon
of once-edgy performers toplining poorly-reviewed family road trip comedies.
Lawrence stars as the overbearing father of
Melanie (
Raven-Symone), whose plan for a just-the-girls trip to look at schools
is undermined by her dad’s insistence on going along for the ride; subsequently,
laffs are had and lessons are learned, at least in theory. The pundits say Road
features over-the-top gags and a remarkable shortage of comic
imagination. At zero percent on the Tomatometer, this is the worst-reviewed film
of Lawrence’s career, edging out the five percent
Big Momma’s House 2

Maiden voyage of the Battleship Pigtemkin.

touring the martial arts circuit in movies like
The Transporter
Jason Statham returns to his grimy thriller roots with

The Bank Job
Based on the real-life 1971 robbery of security deposit boxes, he stars as a
petty thug in over his head as the job spirals out of control. It’s a throwback
to the heist movies of yore, and according to the critics (to quote
The French
‘s tagline) the time is right for an out-and-out thriller like this.
Director Roger Donaldson never lets the pace flag, forging a movie that’s
dramatic, funny, and plain entertaining. At 73 percent on the Tomatometer, The Bank Job is looking like a solid investment. (And
check out our Total Recall feature on heist movies


“Who knew Louise Brooks could bend like that?”

opening this week in limited release:

Testing out the rumor that Stratocasters taste like fried banana.

Roland Emmerich Films:
46% — The Day After Tomorrow (2004)
62% — The Patriot (2000)
25% — Godzilla (1998)
62% —

43% — Stargate (1994)

Tag Cloud

Infographic robots Apple sequel TV DC Universe Fox News Awards Tour Marvel dragons Music The Purge Arrowverse Winners renewed TV shows The Arrangement independent cars VH1 doctor who Paramount Network Comedy Central Nat Geo docudrama SDCC Black Mirror dceu animated 2016 spider-man Dark Horse Comics Western A&E Musical hispanic The CW Columbia Pictures Shudder Sci-Fi Mary poppins Warner Bros. Television Academy LGBTQ 2015 Lucasfilm Adult Swim Freeform Election christmas movies Tumblr based on movie Reality Syfy romance war Holiday Action latino zombies Watching Series Cosplay Pride Month Apple TV Plus Mary Tyler Moore Drama First Look The Witch GIFs Schedule WarnerMedia Disney+ Disney Plus psycho 2018 crime GoT spain facebook award winner Opinion Elton John green book Classic Film Red Carpet YouTube Premium spinoff versus Musicals TBS 2020 PBS screenings justice league blockbuster Certified Fresh cats adventure Pop Epix Lifetime Valentine's Day Spectrum Originals Christmas BET National Geographic Podcast strong female leads Britbox Peacock Calendar Women's History Month FXX south america The Walking Dead TV renewals discovery Rocky CMT X-Men Mindy Kaling YouTube mutant Superheroes Summer Winter TV game of thrones LGBT Crackle disaster USA Network E3 RT21 20th Century Fox WGN E! crime thriller nature Mary Poppins Returns Ghostbusters 2017 TCA 2017 TNT Disney Plus Fall TV cancelled MSNBC indie Reality Competition sitcom AMC witnail Cartoon Network natural history police drama Oscars blaxploitation book unscripted spanish language Trophy Talk Anna Paquin Star Trek APB serial killer sports Hallmark 45 transformers 007 diversity werewolf Emmy Nominations Song of Ice and Fire travel cancelled TV shows biography Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC Disney Channel Brie Larson theme song series CBS All Access VICE New York Comic Con composers MTV Set visit Spike anthology what to watch teaser true crime Sony Pictures President Marathons Video Games Pet Sematary Stephen King boxoffice finale politics breaking bad crime drama movies HBO quibi Trailer dramedy children's TV Thanksgiving cartoon TruTV CNN San Diego Comic-Con Year in Review Logo CW Seed Turner Classic Movies Nominations aliens Countdown Marvel Studios Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper DC Comics free movies casting Horror Cannes Writers Guild of America Lifetime Christmas movies Turner Emmys festivals GLAAD medical drama TLC 21st Century Fox kids Amazon Mudbound social media IFC Extras jamie lee curtis Acorn TV Awards See It Skip It Interview Toys Captain marvel OWN HBO Max Rocketman Paramount NBC canceled spy thriller 71st Emmy Awards streaming Crunchyroll American Society of Cinematographers Marvel Television dc Mystery Amazon Prime Holidays Family science fiction miniseries First Reviews Hulu Esquire Premiere Dates Superheroe stand-up comedy cooking TIFF romantic comedy Film Festival Fantasy Lionsgate comiccon Disney streaming service Rom-Com ratings Ovation BBC Disney Tomatazos cults zombie cinemax Amazon Prime Video Best and Worst ESPN Star Wars El Rey Netflix Quiz technology supernatural A24 FX YA television ABC Family MCU Film Binge Guide psychological thriller Grammys mockumentary Rock Showtime canceled TV shows richard e. Grant elevated horror DGA hist PaleyFest Comic Book Animation historical drama SundanceTV toy story 2019 Starz IFC Films TCM halloween Pirates Universal Kids & Family Sundance ITV space Country Comedy cops Comics on TV YouTube Red Heroines Super Bowl FOX slashers batman Trivia Sneak Peek BBC America Photos Spring TV Vudu DirecTV Character Guide period drama Chernobyl Walt Disney Pictures DC streaming service golden globes cancelled TV series Food Network Box Office USA Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Hallmark Christmas movies Biopics zero dark thirty SXSW Sundance Now Polls and Games Teen Bravo comics comic Martial Arts revenge RT History cancelled television singing competition vampires Masterpiece ghosts adaptation TV Land binge joker Shondaland thriller video Creative Arts Emmys foreign TCA talk show rotten movies we love game show crossover Tarantino political drama tv talk CBS Apple TV+ Pixar 24 frames Netflix Christmas movies anime harry potter NYCC History