Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: "Ratatouille" is Tasty, "Die Hard" is Solid, "Sicko" is Socko, "Evening" Falls

by | June 28, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies we have hungry, hungry rats ("Ratatouille," starring Patton Oswalt and Brad Garrett), a world-weary hero (Bruce Willis in "Live Free or Die Hard"), a provocateur extraordinaire ("Sicko," the new doc from Michael Moore), and a rare midsummer tearjerker ("Evening," starring Meryl Streep and Claire Danes). What do the critics have to say?

After a slight stumble with "Cars," "Ratatouille" marks a semi-return to form for Pixar. This animated flick stars Remy (voiced by Patton Oswalt), a rat whose aspirations to become a chef land him in a struggling restaurant’s kitchen, where he befriends a hapless garbage boy (Lou Romano). While critics are floored by the stunning leap in animation quality that Pixar seems to make with each movie, they’re equally impressed by "Ratatouille"’s fast pacing, memorable characters, and overall good humor. And like director Brad Bird‘s previous film, "The Incredibles," "Ratatouille" juggles themes of identity and individualism without being heavy-handed. "At 90 percent Tomatometer, the Certified Fresh "Ratatouille" is a movie to savor. (Check out RT’s interview with Patton Oswalt.)

"You like me…you really like me!"

Despite the title, the setting for the latest "Die Hard" isn’t New Hampshire; it’s Washington, D.C., where a group of super-hackers (led by Timothy Olyphant) are plotting to attack America’s computer infrastructure and bring the nation to its knees. McClane teams with a cyber geek to stop them; rousing pyrotechnics ensue. Critics say that while the plot is beyond preposterous, it’s of little matter with stunts and action this exhilarating and intense. And they also note that Bruno settles nicely into his iconic role. At 77 percent on the Tomatometer, "Live Free" is not only Certified Fresh, it’s the second-best-reviewed "Die Hard" after the original. (Check out RT’s interview with Bruce Willis here.)

Just another day at the office for McClane.

Wherever Michael Moore goes, cameras, and controversy, follow. That’s certainly the case for "Sicko"; Moore’s latest doc, which compares and contrasts our privatized health care with other health care systems abroad, has gotten him in hot water with the Bush administration over a potentially embargo-violating Cuban medical trip. But Moore is finding much love among critics, who call it a mature, humanistic film. They praise Moore’s decision to spend much of the time off-screen, allowing the events to convince and anger on their own merits. At 89 percent Tomatometer, "Sicko" is Certified Fresh and just what the doctor ordered. (Check out RT’s interview with Michael Moore.)

"Anyone know where I can get some freedom fries?"

Like so many other ambitious, richly layered novels adapted into films, "Evening" is what some critics call impossible to translate faithfully to the big screen. Assembling a dazzling cast, "Evening" stars Vanessa Redgrave as terminally ill mother who recounts to her children an affair she had as a young woman (played by Claire Danes). Critics call it a melodramatic artsy film, one that tries to go for emotional uplift, but with plot devices and character arcs that are too obvious to be genuinely affecting. At 32 percent Tomatometer, "Evening" falls and tumbles.

A few actors trying to make a quick getaway.

Also opening this week in limited release: "Ghosts of Cité Soleil," a harrowing portrait of the titular Haitian slum, is at 81 percent; "Over the GW," an autobiographical look into rehab, is at 80 percent; "In Between Days," a coming of age story with a Korean twist, is at 77 percent; and "Vitus," a drama about a young musical prodigy, is at 69 percent.

Recent Pixar Movies
76% — "Cars"
97% — "The Incredibles"
98% — "Finding Nemo"
95% — "Monster’s Inc."
100% — "Toy Story 2"

Tag Cloud

Photos dc children's TV Lifetime Avengers Geeked Week GIFs Comedy critic resources PlayStation Netflix Christmas movies richard e. Grant indiana jones gangster films award winner scary movies sports Black History Month docudrama Paramount scene in color IMDb TV Interview mob dexter Best Picture 007 emmy awards rotten movies we love feel good Tomatazos Amazon Prime Video Star Wars Tokyo Olympics robots broadcast pirates of the caribbean kong Binge Guide popular AMC Western politics japan international Amazon Prime 2015 golden globes New York Comic Con NBC golden globe awards asian-american Exclusive Video Election TCM OneApp Holidays ghosts 2020 72 Emmy Awards war Winners Superheroes nfl MTV Sundance chucky Best Director The Witch reviews versus video Pop Bravo Grammys women USA Network FOX HBO Go deadpool Podcast Winter TV WGN AMC Plus Neflix universal monsters based on movie GoT batman BET latino Classic Film a nightmare on elm street foreign Brie Larson Opinion First Reviews YA TLC Trivia blockbusters Lionsgate Universal Disney streaming service CBS Black Mirror Crunchyroll Box Office harry potter anime Pop TV TIFF Fantasy Disney live event TV hispanic Cartoon Network cancelled television 73rd Emmy Awards cartoon TCA Winter 2020 Oscar toy story Star Trek classics E! American Society of Cinematographers Pirates History festivals hidden camera Anna Paquin science fiction Film DC streaming service Best Actress criterion 2016 MSNBC die hard comic book movie godzilla Superheroe Sundance TV anthology nature Hear Us Out See It Skip It 2018 Comics on TV Teen Trophy Talk psychological thriller comedies best comic books The Walt Disney Company summer preview Baby Yoda 21st Century Fox Pacific Islander TV One green book Arrowverse series comic book movies Ellie Kemper Shondaland cops IFC Films Captain marvel BBC America singing competition true crime Musical Lucasfilm Pet Sematary Stephen King Lifetime Christmas movies Best and Worst Britbox discovery Travel Channel space Mary Tyler Moore crime drama renewed TV shows zero dark thirty twilight BET Awards dramedy game show Star Wars Celebration DC Comics Pride Month boxoffice supernatural spider-verse 94th Oscars jamie lee curtis Martial Arts prank south america BBC Image Comics ID directors diversity japanese A24 fresh Song of Ice and Fire E3 GLAAD 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards debate BBC One psycho Oscars DirecTV Instagram Live legend james bond christmas movies medical drama venice genre comiccon Holiday Reality 45 scary HBO Max obituary tv talk 2017 Apple news australia Family Spectrum Originals National Geographic Hollywood Foreign Press Association book Hallmark Christmas movies TV movies Amazon Studios rotten 2021 Turner Classic Movies vs. cancelled screenings Year in Review CMT IFC kids hollywood ViacomCBS mcc Marathons Sundance Now Nat Geo Countdown miniseries Native Marvel Studios Cosplay Fox News trophy halloween tv DGA archives Rocky Peacock Endgame zombie Emmy Nominations justice league 93rd Oscars lord of the rings parents Crackle Television Critics Association cancelled TV shows The Walking Dead TCA animated biopic technology reboot 99% theme song Toys adventure Legendary toronto Nickelodeon Women's History Month 2019 Quiz YouTube french target Sneak Peek know your critic Drama saw disaster FXX ratings Chernobyl stand-up comedy black ITV concert dreamworks finale HBO Starz monster movies Biopics The Arrangement king kong USA YouTube Premium joker canceled spider-man Adult Swim Marvel Television Prime Video Syfy Best Actor Spring TV Funimation action-comedy Horror obi wan unscripted high school sag awards rt archives HFPA LGBT dceu witnail Disney Plus Creative Arts Emmys revenge leaderboard SXSW transformers royal family Dark Horse Comics Broadway target scene in color Thanksgiving romantic comedy marvel comics Trailer movie SXSW 2022 Mary Poppins Returns Kids & Family worst romance Sci-Fi indie italian thriller sopranos Discovery Channel Fox Searchlight aapi period drama Certified Fresh dark Cannes Writers Guild of America CW Seed Walt Disney Pictures 24 frames Epix crime Film Festival cults FX television mockumentary Mystery SDCC movies casting trailers Marvel scene in color film series all-time San Diego Comic-Con PaleyFest hispanic heritage month binge Red Carpet Apple TV+ Super Bowl Premiere Dates new star wars movies Musicals NBA blaxploitation Hallmark halloween festival free movies YouTube Red laika king arthur Rom-Com summer TV preview Food Network Showtime vampires Fall TV Alien slasher streamig spain cinemax blockbuster Universal Pictures name the review APB olympics rt labs critics edition 71st Emmy Awards Set visit The Purge Freeform interviews comic football franchise scorecard FX on Hulu ABC Signature South by Southwest Film Festival Animation stop motion 1990s Calendar marvel cinematic universe The CW suspense zombies A&E critics satire elevated horror MGM DC Universe talk show RT21 Watching Series Indigenous Awards Tour 90s Christmas cats art house posters crime thriller Ovation Esquire Awards superhero Wes Anderson natural history Comedy Central Paramount Pictures Comic-Con@Home 2021 President Hulu documentaries Fargo wonder woman Video Games BAFTA biography sequels nbcuniversal OWN SundanceTV dogs streaming movies Sony child's play TCA 2017 Acorn TV MCU new zealand boxing WarnerMedia cars Comic Book Disney Channel Tumblr Extras TV renewals The Academy razzies scene in color series Mudbound Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Chilling Adventures of Sabrina police drama breaking bad VICE black comedy live action Netflix rom-coms telelvision slashers 79th Golden Globes Awards TBS Nominations Columbia Pictures game of thrones strong female leads Heroines heist movie Tarantino 4/20 Focus Features TCA Awards Paramount Plus basketball TV Land Character Guide independent Apple TV Plus adaptation superman kaiju ABC what to watch streaming jurassic park dragons remakes spinoff Infographic video on demand Spike Disney+ Disney Plus CNN TNT Warner Bros. Masterpiece spy thriller Shudder Polls and Games Summer adenture historical drama spanish Action Ghostbusters Valentine's Day book adaptation CBS All Access new york teaser Turner cancelled TV series Reality Competition Vudu 20th Century Fox Elton John sitcom hist cooking VOD crossover screen actors guild canceled TV shows LGBTQ Sony Pictures Music stoner rt labs Paramount Network NYCC social media facebook mutant serial killer ESPN Mindy Kaling Emmys Pixar doctor who documentary Rocketman spanish language Rock VH1 X-Men quibi political drama Mary poppins aliens Country Amazon young adult travel docuseries RT History summer TV Tags: Comedy Schedule Tubi Academy Awards sequel fast and furious El Rey Television Academy Logo worst movies composers werewolf First Look comics ABC Family mission: impossible PBS TruTV