Critics Consensus

Critical Consensus: Mighty Thrills, Spartan Plot In "300"; "Gift" Doesn't Keep On Giving

by | March 8, 2007 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got 300 mighty Spartans ("300," starring Gerard Butler) and a reluctant do-gooder ("The Ultimate Gift," starring Abigail Breslin). What do the critics have to say?

Fangirls and fanboys, the wait is over. "300," Zack Snyder’s CG adaptation of Frank Miller‘s cult graphic novel sensation is here. And while critics say it’s a feast for the eyes, many note it’s slightly less a delight for the brain. "300" tells the tale of the ancient Battle of Thermopylae, in which 300 Spartans fought a star-crossed battle against the heavily fortified Persian army. Subtlety is not the order of the day here, nor is slavish attention to historical detail, but the pundits say the movie is visually sumptuous, a spectacle of ultraviolence and visceral thrills. However, others say "300" takes itself seriously to the point of self parody, and lacks compelling characters and cohesive plotting. "300" is currently at 60 percent on the Tomatometer.

Because "Anticipate Defeat!" was less rousing.

"The Ultimate Gift" is a movie about learning the true meaning of wealth, and stepping outside one’s self centered existence. These are good lessons to learn, but critics say the movie, while likeable, is too sappy to fully register. "The Ultimate Gift" tells the story of a trust fund kid who stands to inherit the fortune of his recently deceased grandfather — but only after he completes a series of tasks, which include living on the streets, doing manual labor, and being nice to people. Critics say "The Ultimate Gift" is sweet, heartfelt, and well-meaning — but also schmaltzy and dramatically inert. At 35 percent on the Tomatometer, this may not be the "Ultimate" viewing experience.

"’Silverado’ was 20 years ago. You can change clothes now."

Also opening this week in limited release: the South Korean import "The Host," a monster movie/satire/family drama, is at 94 percent; "Maxed Out," a doc that takes on the credit card industry, is at 85 percent; "Beyond the Gates," a drama about a teacher caught up in the Rwandan genocide starring John Hurt and Hugh Dancy, is at 71 percent; "The Namesake," a drama about a family caught between two cultural worlds starring Kal Penn and Jacinda Barrett, is at 70 percent; and "Exterminating Angels," a French drama about voyeurism and taboos, is at 52 pecent.

"KBBL’s going to give me something stupid!"

Recent Historical Epics:
65% — Apocalypto (2006)
39% — Kingdom of Heaven (2005)
16% — Alexander (2004)
55% — Troy (2004)
78% — Gladiator (2000)

Tag Cloud

007 Oscar dramedy Podcast anime telelvision high school docudrama harry potter Comics on TV international ghosts The Academy cancelled Adult Swim Fargo south america TV Land cooking black History summer TV preview elevated horror finale crossover Tubi Marathons docuseries Teen MSNBC Best Picture animated streaming movies Rock American Society of Cinematographers Crackle diversity ABC Signature Apple TV Plus batman biopic free movies Creative Arts Emmys Mudbound justice league Marvel Studios romance blockbuster Musicals scene in color series Disney Plus 21st Century Fox worst movies documentary aapi Crunchyroll Pride Month Turner toy story Women's History Month ITV Holiday critic resources rt archives dreamworks die hard Classic Film doctor who Family RT History documentaries sag awards MTV FXX vs. 2020 scene in color film series Writers Guild of America 2021 Focus Features South by Southwest Film Festival Valentine's Day New York Comic Con Hollywood Foreign Press Association Paramount rt labs critics edition CW Seed BBC America social media australia hispanic heritage month dceu CBS All Access Spike Paramount Pictures YA cinemax directors ESPN spanish language Image Comics Pop TCA Winter 2020 Mary Poppins Returns HBO Emmy Nominations Election 93rd Oscars satire Travel Channel Apple TV+ trophy Music Calendar olympics OneApp award winner joker Lifetime Christmas movies revenge Netflix Christmas movies TV One President live action foreign TCA 2017 casting Amazon Prime Video NBA Sneak Peek mcc comic book movies NYCC Character Guide Film Festival video on demand CNN Mary Tyler Moore Exclusive Video travel Extras natural history Comic Book spain LGBTQ spanish Black History Month debate Avengers Biopics superhero versus Chernobyl Nickelodeon Stephen King Tarantino rotten Trophy Talk universal monsters Animation The Walt Disney Company OWN IFC Films razzies The Walking Dead 90s laika cars USA Reality Christmas dexter interviews Pacific Islander Starz posters 20th Century Fox Tags: Comedy Discovery Channel screenings Universal miniseries TCA Awards cats Acorn TV vampires Red Carpet USA Network Opinion composers japan Wes Anderson The CW Fantasy reviews Film chucky streamig Logo HFPA italian green book fresh National Geographic game show Peacock obituary Shondaland classics Countdown DC Universe indiana jones cancelled television See It Skip It sequels Comedy Central scorecard book adaptation news television FX on Hulu TLC venice A&E zero dark thirty football 71st Emmy Awards 73rd Emmy Awards APB E3 ratings Certified Fresh Spectrum Originals Cartoon Network Star Trek Superheroe Masterpiece legend Year in Review Western Food Network VOD MGM Pet Sematary Arrowverse gangster cops rom-coms stand-up comedy Instagram Live all-time 2019 festivals AMC parents Cosplay PaleyFest art house deadpool Epix 24 frames dogs fast and furious Amazon Rom-Com nature science fiction Indigenous zombies sopranos teaser Binge Guide period drama Song of Ice and Fire Fox News suspense leaderboard canceled TV shows rt labs FX Lionsgate YouTube true crime Superheroes trailers TBS Pixar witnail 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards toronto Oscars disaster richard e. Grant E! YouTube Premium Toys summer preview Nominations medical drama kong halloween tv 2017 Mindy Kaling TIFF basketball Native IFC tv talk 2016 Spring TV dragons Broadway Hallmark Christmas movies scary Sci-Fi Paramount Plus politics 45 cults 2015 Ellie Kemper rotten movies we love binge Endgame halloween VH1 Super Bowl adenture Watching Series streaming best hist hollywood Winners women BET new zealand BET Awards TV movies Vudu Pop TV worst Esquire RT21 Disney Mystery sitcom Apple TCA series reboot comic book movie ViacomCBS discovery Bravo The Arrangement Fox Searchlight pirates of the caribbean Ovation aliens criterion independent golden globes Sony Pictures HBO Go screen actors guild slasher archives canceled DGA christmas movies The Purge Polls and Games heist movie CMT Best and Worst Lucasfilm GLAAD blockbusters Television Critics Association Netflix twilight Holidays mockumentary jamie lee curtis TCM remakes spider-verse Action child's play Kids & Family Geeked Week Elton John PBS saw Alien thriller popular Sundance Now Star Wars Cannes FOX Country based on movie serial killer comiccon Disney Channel Best Actress target scene in color police drama king kong historical drama psycho Neflix Box Office Horror new york new star wars movies Reality Competition what to watch 1990s book james bond Paramount Network Best Director 94th Oscars cancelled TV series festival Nat Geo transformers Disney streaming service obi wan romantic comedy Amazon Prime TV zombie sports IMDb TV broadcast marvel cinematic universe Disney+ Disney Plus mob Winter TV quibi royal family Interview monster movies crime thriller robots comedies WarnerMedia Mary poppins franchise stop motion anthology renewed TV shows GoT Warner Bros. Comic-Con@Home 2021 Lifetime scary movies Baby Yoda films NBC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt live event theme song Brie Larson adventure First Reviews Syfy sequel kaiju boxoffice action-comedy facebook name the review SundanceTV golden globe awards black comedy Freeform YouTube Red Anna Paquin Star Wars Celebration Britbox CBS Hear Us Out Black Mirror scene in color Columbia Pictures Trailer mutant nbcuniversal asian-american Universal Pictures know your critic movies BBC indie hidden camera crime TV renewals war Captain marvel lord of the rings Martial Arts Awards supernatural TruTV crime drama 99% comic Hallmark Musical slashers Prime Video Awards Tour Sony Television Academy 4/20 movie Best Actor marvel comics dc AMC Plus Sundance young adult biography The Witch concert technology critics Infographic Quiz children's TV psychological thriller 2018 LGBT X-Men comics Walt Disney Pictures kids Grammys Tomatazos El Rey Heroines Pirates spinoff unscripted Rocketman a nightmare on elm street feel good werewolf A24 hispanic game of thrones Dark Horse Comics Set visit spy thriller dark Thanksgiving Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ABC strong female leads blaxploitation DC streaming service king arthur genre Video Games 79th Golden Globes Awards cartoon MCU Trivia godzilla Rocky Hulu First Look nfl Marvel TNT mission: impossible video talk show wonder woman Legendary Photos adaptation breaking bad cancelled TV shows boxing San Diego Comic-Con latino Tokyo Olympics ABC Family Shudder PlayStation Turner Classic Movies BBC One Marvel Television Ghostbusters Schedule space DC Comics Academy Awards GIFs BAFTA jurassic park singing competition SXSW 2022 HBO Max SDCC 72 Emmy Awards DirecTV prank summer TV VICE Tumblr french comic books Drama political drama Comedy superman Summer stoner SXSW Emmys WGN Fall TV Funimation Showtime Amazon Studios japanese emmy awards Sundance TV Premiere Dates spider-man target ID