Total Recall

8 Christmas Specials That Should Be Classics (But Aren't)

by | December 3, 2014 | Comments

Back in the days when there were fewer channels — and a lot more variety shows — TV was pretty much wall-to-wall Christmas specials in December, from singing and dancing and sketch comedy to animated kids and crickets and long-eared donkeys. Cut to the present day where, apart from a handful of specials centered around pop stars performing at the lighting of one Christmas tree or other, the major networks mostly spotlight the blessed foursome — Rudolph, Frosty, Charlie Brown, and the Grinch — while relegating the TV of yore to DVD or basic cable. Here’s a handful of gems from yesteryear that might make help your season bright:


This special made-for-TV movie event, produced for the United Nations, boasts a once-in-a-lifetime collection of talent, with Sterling Hayden, Peter Sellers, Ben Gazzara, Eva Marie Saint, Robert Shaw, James Shigeta, Peter Fonda, Pat Hingle, and Steve Lawrence in front of the camera, with Rod Serling writing and Joseph L. Mankiewicz (All About Eve) directing.

An odd twist on Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, this is the story of a pro-isolationist (played by Hayden) who learns from three ghosts on Christmas Eve that mankind must work together (via, cough, the United Nations) in order to stave off the destruction of civilization. Not the Christmas-iest of fare, perhaps, and the politics are rather on-the-nose (Serling was never at his subtlest when writing about issues), but it’s a compellingly odd bit of pop culture.

How you can see it: Unseen for decades after its December 1964 premiere and still unavailable on DVD, this special has recently resurfaced annually on Turner Classic Movies, with the next broadcast scheduled for December 18, 2014.


If you want evidence of the “Pac-Man Fever” that gripped the nation in the early 1980s, look no further than this Christmas special, a spin-off of the Saturday morning cartoon series about the munching yellow orb and his continuing adventures fighting off a quartet of cranky ghosts. This holiday extravaganza sees Santa Claus crash-landing in PacLand; St. Nick has no idea where he is, and the video game characters (including Mrs. Pac-Man — she must have ditched the “Ms.” along the way — and their offspring Baby-Pac) don’t know Santa, but our heroes nonetheless help the jolly old man repair his sleigh, thus, y’know, saving Christmas.

If you’ve already guessed that this shamelessly commercial piece of Reagan-era TV animation is mostly junk, well, you’ll get no argument here. But there’s something so shameless about it, and so committed to its ridiculous storyline, that makes Christmas Comes to PacLand the kind of car-accident viewing from which you just can’t turn your head. Put it on in the background of your holiday parties and watch the slack-jawed response from friends and family.

How you can see it: Warner Archive’s Pac-Man: The Complete Second Season DVD contains the special as an extra; you might also check the Cartoon Network or Boomerang’s listings, since someone with a sense of humor at those channels will occasionally pop it into the December schedule.


To watch the wholesome, harmonic music of the sprawling King Family from the 1960s is to know that you’re watching the culture that the counter-culture was countering. But I’d rather watch the King Cousins jazz-hand their way through a musical rendition of “Twas the Night Before Christmas” over another viewing of Woodstock any day. What started as the King Sisters, a popular singing act of the 1940s and 1950s, metastasized into the stage-filling King Family of spouses, children, cousins and in-laws by the mid-1960s, when they occupied the hour before Lawrence Welk on ABC.

The Kings’ holiday specials endure, especially this Christmas classic, which gave TV one of the most memorable variety moments ever: King Sister Alyce sings a plaintive “I’ll Be Home for Christmas” to her son Ric, who was serving in the army — only to have Ric surprise her onstage mid-song, joining his flustered and overjoyed mother for the remaining verses. For a country dealing with the deployment of so many of its young men to Vietnam, it was a heartfelt and resonant reunion.

How you can see it: It’s featured on the new two-disc set King Family Christmas: Classic Television Specials, Volume Two (Polly O. Entertainment), along with their Thanksgiving show, a Qiana-licious 1974 Christmas special, two Christmas episodes of their prime-time variety show, and a terrific PBS documentary about the Kings and their contributions to holiday TV.


Actually the 1957 Christmas episode of the The Frank Sinatra Show, this memorable duet has become a free-standing special in its own right in recent years. Long available on VHS only in scratchy black-and-white, the full-color version was released in 2003 after Tina Sinatra found a 35mm print of the episode in the family vaults.

There’s almost no plot tying this all together — Der Bingle drops in on his pal Frank for a holiday dinner (there’s a manservant perpetually in the background doing all the heavy lifting), and they do some singing, together and apart. They also walk outside at one point and find themselves in Dickens-era England, where they do some more singing. In an era where attempts at reviving the variety show can only be done with heavy doses of irony and winking (looking at you, Maya Rudolph), sometimes it’s just enough to spend half an hour with two of the greatest male vocalists of the 20th century as they ply their trade.

How you can see it: Happy Holidays just made its DVD debut as part of Bing Crosby: The Television Specials, Volume 2 – The Christmas Specials (UMe).


The late, great Jim Henson was responsible for scads of holiday programming over the years, from the charming John Denver and the Muppets: A Christmas Together (1979) to Emmet Otter’s Jug-Band Christmas (1977) — I’ve always thought of the latter as “A Child’s First Total Bummer,” but it has its partisans. Perhaps the hardest to track down is A Muppet Family Christmas, which marks one of the only occasions in which the casts of Sesame Street, The Muppet Show, and Fraggle Rock all share billing.

The convoluted storyline involves all the Muppets heading to the farm owned by Fozzie’s mom, who has planned to leave town for Christmas and has rented the place to Doc and his dog Sprocket. (The farm is, naturally, host to a number of Fraggle holes.) If you’re a fan of the boisterous humor and musical interludes for which the Muppets are famous, you’ll have a blast with this charming, if slightly overstuffed, special.

How you can see it: Currently out of print on DVD — and home video versions don’t always have all the songs, because of complicated rights issues — the special can be viewed on YouTube.


Ten years ago, TV audiences were assaulted with A Christmas Carol: The Musical, a cable movie that must have seemed like a good idea on paper, what with Kelsey Grammer as a singing and dancing (but still crabby) Scrooge, and musical comedy pros like Jane Krakowski, Jesse L. Martin, and Jason Alexander playing various ghosts. Unfortunately, the songs (by acclaimed tunesmiths Alan Menken and Lynn Ahrens) are aggressively unmemorable, and the whole thing is lit so brightly you would think it was Scrooge’s Swinging Christmas in Malibu.

There are other musical options available for fans of the Dickens novella: besides the delightful big-screen Scrooge (1970), starring Albert Finney, there’s also The Stingiest Man in Town, an original musical produced for The Alcoa Hour back in 1956. Basil Rathbone makes a memorably miserly Scrooge, with young Vic Damone playing the younger version of the character. More people are probably familiar with the animated Rankin-Bass remake from 1978, but the live-action original is worth tracking down.

How you can see it: Alas, no Tina Sinatra has come to this show’s rescue: while it originally aired in color, only a black-and-white kinescope version is known to exist, and it can be purchased on DVD from Video Artists International.


One of those Gen X holiday favorites — it even got referenced, reverentially, on a South Park Christmas episode — that used to air on network TV before being sent out to pasture on basic cable, this Rankin-Bass effort focuses on a small town whose citizens all get their letters to Santa returned to them after a letter to the local newspaper says that Saint Nick is a fraud. Can the local clock-maker (and his trusty mouse sidekick) build a giant bell-tower in time for December 24 to win back the favor of Father Christmas?

Of all the Christmas specials that got downgraded to second-tier status, this one’s a personal favorite, from the stellar voice cast — Broadway vets Joel Grey and Tammy Grimes, comedian George Gobel, veteran character actor John McGiver (The Manchurian Candidate) — to its passel of catchy songs (“Christmas Chimes Are Calling,” “Even a Miracle Needs a Hand,” “Give Your Heart a Try”). I never let a December pass without at least one viewing.

How you can see it: Available as a stand-alone Blu-ray and DVD, or sharing a DVD with another charming B-lister, Frosty’s Winter Wonderland (all from Warner Home Video), and also a perennial part of ABC Family’s “25 Days of Christmas.”


Yes, technically, this is the holiday episode from the first season of The Venture Bros., but since it wittily plays off so many conventions of the Christmas-special genre — right down to the spinning “SPECIAL” that used to herald every CBS special in the 1970s — it deserves to be more widely seen. The Venture Bros. itself was always a shrewd parody of vintage Hanna-Barbera adventures of the Jonny Quest ilk, and this episode effectively skewers TV’s holiday perennials.

Not that there aren’t some bonuses thrown in as well — this might be the first mainstream American TV show to include the Krampus (Santa’s monstrous sidekick who punishes evil children), not to mention an evil spy whose specialty is hiding in a crèche as “Tiny Joseph.” Even if you’ve never watched the series, you’ll be able to follow the off-the-wall characters and get the darkly absurd jokes.

How you can see it: “A Very Venture Christmas” is included in The Venture Bros. Season One DVD (Warner Home Video).

Alonso Duralde is the author of the quintessential holiday film guide Have Yourself a Movie Little Christmas. Follow him on Twitter at @aduralde.



Tag Cloud

Rock natural history Certified Fresh First Look sports Horror Disney Plus movie TIFF cars criterion SXSW Netflix Christmas movies obituary Trivia dceu talk show Disney Channel TV Land Summer Cannes YouTube Premium Sundance Now Heroines Ellie Kemper Superheroes Red Carpet RT History TCA Awards green book Pop Disney Shondaland cinemax Lucasfilm free movies BBC One Pirates GIFs Amazon Prime canceled christmas movies best teaser RT21 Martial Arts Set visit Video Games The Witch cartoon Infographic Comedy Ovation YouTube scary movies historical drama Crunchyroll VH1 crime New York Comic Con Grammys Pop TV disaster FX on Hulu dogs richard e. Grant spinoff Year in Review Election Universal Comics on TV spanish language spain DC Comics TCA Winter 2020 WarnerMedia travel spider-man Apple TV Plus Best and Worst Sneak Peek halloween children's TV DirecTV Star Wars MCU chucky war social media Ghostbusters BBC America latino Lifetime Christmas movies Stephen King Film Festival Bravo Comedy Central quibi NBC Sundance Spring TV 007 USA Network Walt Disney Pictures rotten movies we love spy thriller toy story Apple Schedule CBS universal monsters Calendar doctor who DGA Podcast Valentine's Day Superheroe Endgame AMC independent Christmas game of thrones documentaries Paramount CMT Showtime Premiere Dates Hulu what to watch FXX The Arrangement video on demand Extras Winners mockumentary YouTube Red Marvel Television 71st Emmy Awards Crackle adaptation Thanksgiving anthology VICE 2019 Mary Poppins Returns Family Holidays X-Men parents Freeform ratings Creative Arts Emmys Brie Larson political drama mutant Funimation OneApp cults Mary Tyler Moore E3 casting a nightmare on elm street Spike Drama twilight crime thriller cats witnail IFC asian-american zero dark thirty politics Interview History SDCC franchise versus singing competition 2020 comics Mary poppins reboot Adult Swim 2018 BAFTA sequel First Reviews ABC Family nbcuniversal mission: impossible 2017 romance Marathons Captain marvel NYCC DC Universe PlayStation FX Tomatazos PBS Film MTV Action cooking Music fast and furious Logo TV renewals diversity Elton John SundanceTV worst Nickelodeon revenge The Walking Dead screenings golden globes Winter TV Opinion Rocketman award winner Amazon police drama Biopics biography TruTV Cosplay canceled TV shows Travel Channel TCM Marvel Avengers comedies thriller Hear Us Out Mudbound E! strong female leads HBO Max Star Trek DC streaming service OWN die hard sag awards Discovery Channel comic Anna Paquin Binge Guide stoner Nat Geo Countdown Spectrum Originals Acorn TV space YA Toys TLC Netflix Animation supernatural Hallmark 2015 boxoffice ITV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Peacock cancelled TV series ESPN Black Mirror aliens Trailer Character Guide Teen TNT cancelled television Food Network Kids & Family streaming FOX IFC Films reviews MSNBC crossover Chernobyl Starz The CW Disney streaming service Fox News Sci-Fi Tumblr vampires Vudu documentary Reality Emmy Nominations ABC PaleyFest American Society of Cinematographers slashers Country hispanic unscripted BBC Pixar robots Cartoon Network renewed TV shows Fall TV blaxploitation indiana jones technology superhero See It Skip It Britbox binge zombie dramedy cancelled TV shows TBS Warner Bros. Sony Pictures period drama CNN true crime sitcom Sundance TV Chilling Adventures of Sabrina television festivals Quiz comiccon name the review Song of Ice and Fire Polls and Games A&E Classic Film Women's History Month CW Seed based on movie justice league Academy Awards Turner Classic Movies psycho Arrowverse cops dc Photos batman Trophy Talk VOD concert WGN breaking bad Disney+ Disney Plus Musical LGBT docudrama adventure TCA 2017 Holiday Marvel Studios Fantasy transformers Mindy Kaling HBO Go laika satire rotten joker Shudder Emmys ghosts HBO President films GoT TCA Columbia Pictures cancelled Television Academy Lifetime Awards Tour werewolf Rom-Com facebook Esquire Dark Horse Comics romantic comedy Television Critics Association medical drama The Purge Lionsgate Tubi animated hollywood blockbuster serial killer San Diego Comic-Con composers finale kids theme song science fiction A24 Amazon Prime Video 72 Emmy Awards 20th Century Fox LGBTQ stand-up comedy directors dark hist Tarantino GLAAD BET discovery Hallmark Christmas movies 24 frames Paramount Network El Rey news nature foreign TV emmy awards anime Baby Yoda jamie lee curtis psychological thriller book critics Pride Month Super Bowl series Syfy 45 child's play Rocky Masterpiece Amazon Studios zombies Pet Sematary Musicals 2016 Turner harry potter APB Writers Guild of America Box Office Black History Month dragons Oscars Epix CBS All Access elevated horror 4/20 Western screen actors guild Comic Book movies indie Mystery all-time classics miniseries Apple TV+ 21st Century Fox Awards south america BET Awards video tv talk Nominations game show Reality Competition USA National Geographic crime drama Watching Series stop motion