Hear Us Out

20 Years Later, Scooby-Doo Is Still a Clever, Subversive Take on the Mystery Inc. Gang

Film critic Rendy Jones waxes nostalgic about the well-executed balance between satire and faithful homage and the all-around campy fun of the long-running cartoon's first live-action adaptation.

by | June 17, 2022 | Comments

Out of the many long-running franchises in animation history, no show received as many iterations as Scooby-Doo. Since 1969, the iconic Hanna-Barbera series has been reincarnated more times than Doctor Who has regenerated. There was a Scooby-Doo that was prolific for each generation: Gen-Xers grew up with the first run of the series, Scooby-Doo, Where Are You!, and Millennials had A Pup Named Scooby-Doo and Scooby-Doo On Zombie Island. Lucky for me, Gen-Z got one of the most iconic iterations to date: Scooby-Doo, the 2002 live-action film adaptation. But Scooby-Doo wasn’t just a cultural reset smash hit that Gen-Z puts on a pedestal to this very day; it changed the trajectory of the franchise forever.

With the movie celebrating its 20th anniversary this week (feel old yet?), it’s a perfect time to unmask that 31% Tomatometer score and make the case as to why the Raja Gosnell-directed and James Gunn-written classic is a clever and subversive take on the franchise’s history.

It Deconstructs the Archetypes and Has Fun Doing It

Poster image for Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Anyone could have done a procedural copy-and-paste job to adapt Scooby-Doo for the big screen, but James Gunn attempted to deconstruct the series’ formula while staying true to it. His approach was meant to be in the same vein as Shrek, who was the hotshot cool kid in the classroom at the time. While it doesn’t hit the same mark Shrek did from a satirical standpoint, Gunn’s script was a valiant attempt at commenting on the archetypes of the characters and the mysteries they’ve experienced. It was Gunn’s first venture into the realm he’s known best for today: a found family ensemble with good chemistry who also can’t stand each other.

It’s an enticing if not refreshing concept to disband the gang for most of the movie. The overall exhaustion of the gang’s status quo — Velma is always undervalued for her work, Fred is a showboat, Daphne is constantly kidnapped — warrants the break-up in the opening. The story establishes that they’ve been working together for many years, and the bubbling internal dysfunction between the mystery gang reaches its breaking point. It’s quickly paced, but you feel the weight of it all.

Linda Cardellini and Freddie Prinze Jr. as Velma and Fred in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Working individually on Spooky Island two years later, the new mystery allows them to slowly rekindle their relationships, and the gang learns what it’s like to be a team again. Gunn’s script explores different avenues and shifts the functionality of the team’s dynamic. While he didn’t get clearance to make Velma or Fred outrightly gay as he intended, he did get to make their relationship a strong one. One of the best examples is when Velma comments on how Daphne and Fred always split up together when they try investigating for clues and she’s left on her own. In a surprising twist, Fred lets Velma tag along with him and they work together throughout. It’s not commentary for the sake of being meta but for bettering the relationship of a group that has been on the rocks.

Arguably, the best played-for-laughs aspect is Daphne’s arc, which back then was meant to be hilarious but today is empowering. During the team’s breakup, she spent her time training in martial arts so she can defend herself from being kidnapped, which often happened in the series. The climactic fight between her and Zarkos is well executed, and the script is never in your face about her gender like so many modern superhero films are; it lets her actions speak for themselves.

Its Sense of Humor Is Goofy, but It’s Timeless

Mathew Lillard as Shaggy and Neil Fanning as the voice of Scooby-Doo in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Scooby-Doo remains true to formula without throwing in modern references. Gunn’s script largely avoids pop culture shout-outs to give the movie a timeless factor, unlike movies like Alvin and the Chipmunks, Sonic the Hedgehog, or even 2020’s Scoob!, all of which frontload their humor with pop culture references. Granted, Scooby-Doo did overdo it in the fart joke department, but outdated references expire fast, and fart jokes are forever.

It Was a Potent Shot of Early 2000s Nostalgia

Having stated the above, though, Scooby-Doo is also a compelling time capsule of its era. The tropical resort setting is straight out of MTV, complete with a cameo from Sugar Ray, and the Mystery Inc. gang’s modernized looks fit in seamlessly, despite calling back to their classic outfits.

The cameo appearances aren’t unreasonably gratuitous, either; they provide a glimpse into the show’s identity, or they serve as legitimate plot details. Daphne, for example, realizes people are being possessed when she notices Mark McGrath’s eyes glow a demonic green as he sings to her. It’s subtle but effective, a combination that a lot of movies today have difficulty achieving.

It Boasts a Perfectly Cast Killer Ensemble

Sarah Michelle Gellar, Linda Cardellini, Matthew Lillard, and Freddie Prinze Jr. as the Mystery, Inc. gang in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

Casting director Mary Vernieu deserves a Nobel Prize for assembling an ensemble of great actors who fit into their respective roles so perfectly. This was the first live-action adaptation of the series, and she knocked it out of the park with Avengers-level precision. Soon-to-be-married duo Freddy Prinze Jr. and Sarah Michelle Gellar (their wedding was just a few months after Scooby-Doo opened) were top-notch as Fred and Daphne; Gellar’s independent spunkiness and Prinze’s confident, self-centered attitude brought more life than the characters had in previous iterations. Linda Cardellini’s absolutely nailed Velma with her nasally, deadpan delivery. And then there was Matthew Lillard.

What can one say about Matthew Lillard’s performance as Shaggy? Despite the film’s negative reviews, Lillard’s performance was universally praised, and he’s now the primary actor who portrays the character in all Scooby-Doo-related media to this very day. It was the role he was born to play, and he is now one with Shaggy.

Matthew Lillard as Shaggy in Scooby-Doo (2002)

(Photo by ©Warner Bros.)

All joking aside, though the narrative places all the characters at odds with one another, you can see the genuine chemistry between the cast, the shared camaraderie within the Mystery Inc. gang that matched the spirit of the source material. Sure, Scooby-Doo himself might suffer from CGI that looks dated even by 2002 standards (seriously, compare this to the other big family blockbuster of the time, Stuart Little 2), but the energy Lillard shares with that dog is more realistic than a lot of the schlock we see even today.

We’re not saying Scooby-Doo is some gold standard of family entertainment, but it understands its source material and knows how to play off of it, which is more than a lot of other live-action adaptations can say. The casting is pitch-perfect, the balance between being faithful and satirical is fresh, and it’s just classic campy fun. It was a modernized Scooby-Doo without emphasizing how modernized it was, which, in today’s cinema landscape, is more welcome than ever.

Scooby-Doo was released in theaters on June 14, 2002.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

toronto Apple TV Plus Focus Features Paramount Pictures 2020 spider-verse 71st Emmy Awards stand-up comedy WGN Comic Book ITV live event game of thrones batman Musical MSNBC MGM japanese gangster hispanic Apple TV+ black comedy what to watch Amazon Character Guide Shudder cinemax witnail comic book movie new york Biopics a nightmare on elm street kids Television Critics Association Fall TV crime thriller based on movie Nominations comics Best Actor Universal Tokyo Olympics Polls and Games Sony Pictures high school universal monsters Best Picture movies films posters San Diego Comic-Con rotten movies we love Mary Poppins Returns cooking harry potter trailers President cancelled TV shows superhero comiccon ghosts BET ABC Family Podcast Avengers facebook Oscars Family Instagram Live docuseries period drama action-comedy cults Cosplay Best Director Video Games Disney+ Disney Plus First Look summer TV social media anime TIFF broadcast ABC documentaries halloween hidden camera festival Musicals interviews blaxploitation 2018 CBS All Access YouTube finale doctor who lord of the rings Marathons aliens renewed TV shows rt archives godzilla fresh kaiju remakes cancelled TV series Turner Classic Movies DC Universe Prime Video nbcuniversal cancelled television venice blockbuster jurassic park TCA 2017 comedies scary Tags: Comedy 24 frames Television Academy black hist Amazon Prime Video Legendary Peacock monster movies scene in color streaming movies stop motion king arthur award winner psycho Ghostbusters Fargo Travel Channel Martial Arts Chilling Adventures of Sabrina BBC America TV renewals joker Women's History Month italian 20th Century Fox MCU Pixar directors Reality casting Thanksgiving crossover reboot classics Endgame 2017 FX on Hulu trophy Reality Competition Britbox heist movie rt labs critics edition spy thriller pirates of the caribbean discovery HFPA Infographic Walt Disney Pictures E3 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Comics on TV boxing AMC Plus green book Paramount cars Kids & Family FXX theme song war Comedy ID serial killer series Animation Grammys comic book movies Lucasfilm Baby Yoda Horror strong female leads aapi Academy Awards live action disaster LGBTQ razzies Pop Heroines TruTV Disney indiana jones VOD DGA Superheroe Marvel Television crime drama Marvel 007 YouTube Red concert Pop TV marvel comics new zealand transformers historical drama Fox News politics Disney streaming service breaking bad Amazon Studios scary movies Elton John nature TV One USA Super Bowl news TNT SDCC composers El Rey Winter TV BAFTA History Universal Pictures Native BBC One Toys legend quibi worst spinoff Holiday ViacomCBS Creative Arts Emmys adaptation Broadway TLC Tubi spain docudrama video on demand telelvision children's TV child's play dexter spanish Lifetime Christmas movies Schedule hollywood saw 93rd Oscars Alien ESPN LGBT dc dramedy independent Marvel Studios Mary poppins TCM unscripted OneApp Chernobyl Star Trek mutant TBS popular streamig Rock 2021 superman summer preview Esquire james bond 99% Writers Guild of America political drama The CW toy story target young adult Turner jamie lee curtis The Walking Dead emmy awards Nat Geo kong scene in color film series zombie Dark Horse Comics anthology Music Indigenous X-Men TV Land marvel cinematic universe Bravo Discovery Channel book adaptation PlayStation miniseries sequels free movies Mystery Star Wars Celebration Pet Sematary CMT Comedy Central animated Columbia Pictures 94th Oscars zero dark thirty talk show scorecard spanish language Fox Searchlight Brie Larson Superheroes WarnerMedia Classic Film Interview HBO mcc sag awards Fantasy Sundance Now SXSW National Geographic Paramount Plus NBC Photos indie Captain marvel romance 45 versus OWN japan AMC hispanic heritage month The Purge adenture CNN Warner Bros. GIFs Netflix Christmas movies Certified Fresh 73rd Emmy Awards french Election crime supernatural 4/20 worst movies canceled robots Starz A24 Quiz movie deadpool Spring TV king kong Adult Swim 72 Emmy Awards Emmy Nominations Action comic books women IFC Red Carpet Awards Tour DirecTV Anna Paquin vs. streaming Disney Channel true crime sopranos Spectrum Originals slashers Image Comics Oscar FX science fiction sequel boxoffice MTV wonder woman debate Trophy Talk Hollywood Foreign Press Association Hallmark Christmas movies dogs GoT television scene in color series thriller screen actors guild Crackle Song of Ice and Fire revenge 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Emmys cartoon cops stoner Tomatazos critic resources IMDb TV biopic 2016 all-time RT21 Opinion The Walt Disney Company halloween tv laika Vudu Film Acorn TV The Witch Spike genre Showtime DC Comics Set visit Best and Worst Shondaland HBO Go Summer police drama Syfy Pirates criterion summer TV preview Mudbound christmas movies Best Actress biography Ellie Kemper CBS Christmas technology basketball olympics TCA Awards canceled TV shows Sundance 2015 PBS YA south america die hard Nickelodeon know your critic satire best franchise game show Sundance TV festivals Lionsgate TCA werewolf australia Crunchyroll A&E richard e. Grant USA Network Binge Guide mob Masterpiece TCA Winter 2020 Hallmark Awards VICE Winners Cartoon Network fast and furious SXSW 2022 obi wan rom-coms Stephen King CW Seed BBC mockumentary archives medical drama Country Hulu E! nfl justice league Star Wars VH1 reviews Paramount Network slasher NBA NYCC Tarantino 1990s twilight feel good sitcom RT History Sci-Fi Mindy Kaling Tumblr adventure First Reviews Trivia binge Countdown FOX international zombies South by Southwest Film Festival Trailer screenings tv talk Holidays Pride Month Wes Anderson rotten ratings Box Office football romantic comedy IFC Films Neflix PaleyFest HBO Max Epix new star wars movies target scene in color singing competition obituary comic Comic-Con@Home 2021 Extras mission: impossible Calendar Watching Series Rocky Amazon Prime Valentine's Day See It Skip It Film Festival cancelled ABC Signature critics Pacific Islander teaser Food Network Ovation book Geeked Week golden globes Teen blockbusters Disney Plus Sony latino Freeform asian-american 2019 diversity APB space rt labs art house chucky golden globe awards DC streaming service Western Logo Netflix Arrowverse Mary Tyler Moore Cannes name the review TV GLAAD The Arrangement dragons dreamworks Black Mirror natural history cats Rom-Com documentary vampires Premiere Dates leaderboard Year in Review Apple Lifetime Sneak Peek prank elevated horror TV movies SundanceTV Funimation sports video foreign 79th Golden Globes Awards BET Awards Drama spider-man 90s dark parents American Society of Cinematographers dceu YouTube Premium travel psychological thriller New York Comic Con Exclusive Video suspense 21st Century Fox royal family Hear Us Out Black History Month The Academy Rocketman