Why 1999 Was The Ultimate Year for Teen Movies

10 Things I Hate About You turns 20 this year. So do American Pie, Cruel Intentions, and so many more.

by | March 31, 2019 | Comments

Touchstone courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Touchstone courtesy Everett Collection)

Filmmakers like Cameron Crowe, John Hughes, and Bob Clark may make us think the 1980s were the true renaissance of movies made for and about teens, but let’s not discount the 1990s – specifically one year in particular: 1999.

Depending on your definition of “teen movie,” there were up to 19 films in this genre released that year, according to Phillip Iscove, the television writer and co-host of the all-things-1999-movies podcast, Podcast Like It’s 1999. Even more important, Iscove says, is that teen rom-coms like 10 Things I Hate About You and She’s All That, black comedies like Jawbreaker and Cruel Intentions, and coming-of-age films like The Wood and American Pie still resonate with those who grew up in and around that era because “there’s a universality that they’re trying to hit.”

But why this year in particular? Surprisingly, it’s not just because one of them featured Heath Ledger singing in the high school bleachers.

The Clueless and Romeo + Juliet Effect

Paramount courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Paramount courtesy Everett Collection)

Before we dive into the year of 1999, let’s act like Alicia Silverstone’s Cher Horowitz from Clueless and totally pause at the mid-‘90s. Writer-director Amy Heckerling adapted that 1996 film from Jane Austen’s classic novel, Emma, replacing Regency-era British aristocracy with a posh Beverly Hills high school while star Silverstone kicked the dumb blonde trope out with last season’s fashions. A year before this, Baz Lurhmann’s flashy Romeo + Juliet set the Bard’s famous play about star-crossed teen lovers in a gritty, steamy beach city and made male lead Leonardo DiCaprio a teen heartthrob (his female counterpart, Claire Danes, was already known to younger audiences thanks to her cult TV show, My So-Called Life).

So it shouldn’t be a surprise that, by the time greenlights, casting, and production turnarounds were through, we’d land in 1999 with 10 Things I Hate About You, an adaptation of Shakespeare’s marital comedy The Taming of the Shrew about elaborate scheming to marry off one daughter in order to gain access to another; She’s All That, which is rooted in George Bernard Shaw’s Pygmalion, a play about teaching a lowly flower salesgirl how to pass in high society; and Cruel Intentions, which is based on Les Liaisons dangereuses, Pierre Choderlos de Laclos’s novel about bored socialites who break hearts for sport.

Clueless was proof-of-concept that there’s an audience [for modern adaptations of classic works] if it’s done well,” says Neil Landau, a screenwriter and professor at UCLA School of Theater, Film and Television. “Adults who greenlight movies love when it’s source material. It doesn’t feel as frivolous. I think the young people see them because of the canon and the things you study in high school.”

Plus, he says, these works were in the public domain and therefore cheap to get licensing rights.

Independents Studios + DVD Sales = Boffo Profits

Paramount courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Paramount courtesy Everett Collection)

It’s also important to remember what was going on in the industry itself at that time. She’s All That was distributed by Miramax when it still was the hip younger sibling brought in to spice up Disney. 10 Things I Hate About You was distributed by Touchstone Pictures, which is also part of Disney. American Pie was produced by Summit when it was still considered an independent studio. Then there’s MTV Films, which, Iscove reminds us, had an ambitious slate in 1999 that included Varsity Blues, Election, 200 Cigarettes, and The Wood – all movies for or about teens and young adults that were released in July or earlier of that year. He says, nowadays, companies like Annapurna Pictures (Everybody Wants Some!!) and A24 (The Bling RingEighth Grade) excel at distributing and producing these films, but it’s not all they do.

Part of this is because we’ve since changed how we look for these types of movies. Tim Gray, the senior vice president and awards editor at Variety, says his trade magazine wrote in 1998 that “DVD players were expected to hit 1.4 million in 1999.” He says that number may sound like small potatoes, but it was a strong indicator that the public was willing to commit to a new technology – especially since he says Variety also ran an advertisement around that time saying that “it would be a $13 billion industry within a decade.” Since teen movies were still cheap to make, Gray says that “indie companies were emboldened by that idea” of DVD viewership the way that video cassette players in the 1980s made Hollywood realize that there was still business to be had once a film left theaters.

Iscove argues that the desire for teens to see themselves on screen hasn’t changed – just how they find them may have evolved. We all know what “Netflix and chill” is code for, but think of the success of films like To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before and Alex Strangelove and realize that the kids may want to watch something on streaming channels too.

White Male Humor Still Dominated

Universal Pictures courtesy Everett Collection
(Photo by Universal Pictures courtesy Everett Collection)

The late ‘90s was still a time when white, male, heteronormative bro-culture dominated, especially since the (mostly male) development executives who were green-lighting these films had themselves been raised on now-questionable films like Porky’s and Risky Business. While there are exceptions – JawbreakerElection — this was an era where teen boys were straight, cis-gender, and supposed to treat sex like a conquest (see: Cruel Intentions and American Pie) and where teen girls were supposed to be OK with prettying themselves up and potentially dumbing themselves down in the name of popularity (see: 10 Things I Hate About You and She’s All That). Oftentimes, these kids were white, suburban, and entitled. When the idea of sexual assault is brought up, such as Julia Stiles’ Katarina’s reveal toward the end of 10 Things, it’s done in an almost blink-and-you’ll-miss-it way.

“It was the beginning of the ending of an era,” says UCLA’s Landau of this period when “virginity is a rite of passage for boys. For girls, it was filled with shame and stigma.” He says this only influenced mainstream views, as chances are girls and young women were going with boys in their age brackets to see these movies either in groups or on dates.

However, these norms have evolved considerably since 1999. Director Kay Cannon’s summer 2018 hit Blockers threw the double-standard that girls can’t own their own sexuality in our faces. Some of the biggest successes to come out of the recent South by Southwest film festival were Booksmart and Snatchers, which mock the finger-wagging trope of “good girls don’t do that.” As for films about boys and sex? Another hit from SXSW was Good Boys, which still has rauchy humor but – as the trailer reminds us – features boys from a much more innocent age.

We may never get another year as robust with movies that cater specifically to the teen audience as we did in 1999, and we may never again get teen movies quite like the ones we saw that year. But thanks to films like Blockers, like Eighth Grade, like The Spectacular NowDopeThe Edge of SeventeenSing Street, and Lady Bird, we can rest assured that the genre is in good hands, and the adolescents of today won’t lack for entertainment that speaks to them on a personal level too.

Check out our list of every 1999 teen movie ranked here. What were your favorites? Tell us in the comments!

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

BET Ghostbusters Lifetime vampires anthology space Acorn TV American Society of Cinematographers YouTube Premium Year in Review Martial Arts thriller GLAAD Heroines adventure supernatural Black Mirror DC Universe TCA 2017 political drama FX RT21 Brie Larson disaster Trophy Talk Star Trek Pet Sematary 007 TV Land historical drama boxoffice Awards Tour book binge Countdown Polls and Games E3 GIFs cars USA Network Christmas Comic Book TNT comiccon robots Red Carpet Fall TV MTV MSNBC Film Trailer Showtime Oscars Cosplay period drama Sundance Now Esquire Rock nature Captain marvel toy story Country politics zombie Trivia RT History facebook Musical Sundance comic Reality Competition Sony Pictures Best and Worst diversity theme song LGBTQ CMT ITV San Diego Comic-Con Box Office docudrama Adult Swim Freeform 2019 See It Skip It Spring TV Logo Emmys science fiction tv talk Nat Geo Lucasfilm Family Mudbound cinemax Shudder ABC LGBT cooking quibi 45 Tomatazos BBC America A&E sequel Columbia Pictures crime thriller WGN Shondaland singing competition Sneak Peek Anna Paquin witnail game show Calendar VICE Rocketman IFC Films Extras spy thriller spinoff festivals Creative Arts Emmys FOX finale 20th Century Fox Walt Disney Pictures crime adaptation Music cats true crime television miniseries award winner MCU jamie lee curtis Crackle ghosts Cannes Musicals Apple New York Comic Con Disney streaming service CNN FXX blaxploitation Tumblr talk show richard e. Grant YA mutant CBS All Access Animation dramedy psycho BBC harry potter SXSW Star Wars technology natural history travel Epix Biopics Pop Mary poppins OWN Mystery Comedy police drama Chernobyl Awards Disney Channel Premiere Dates Sci-Fi Lionsgate Amazon Prime Pirates Amazon Prime Video Winter TV mockumentary SundanceTV 2017 President Reality Food Network children's TV SDCC unscripted zero dark thirty Cartoon Network Warner Bros. revenge Photos Superheroe what to watch Comics on TV war movies NBC DC streaming service GoT Grammys Tarantino Writers Guild of America Comedy Central VH1 Dark Horse Comics Infographic X-Men DC Comics zombies Amazon green book sports transformers based on movie Pride Month CW Seed Interview medical drama Character Guide Opinion TV The Arrangement Fox News TruTV USA 24 frames IFC Rocky spider-man Holidays Toys TCM Starz El Rey AMC strong female leads teaser Mindy Kaling Set visit Spectrum Originals Podcast TBS Masterpiece dc crime drama Quiz Kids & Family Paramount Network Film Festival golden globes biography 2015 Marathons 2018 animated Certified Fresh National Geographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt social media romance streaming PBS Super Bowl The Witch TLC PaleyFest kids DirecTV Emmy Nominations Mary Tyler Moore cults Ellie Kemper ratings TIFF Britbox psychological thriller discovery Nominations Spike Binge Guide dceu Disney HBO Fantasy Syfy YouTube Red Pixar hist serial killer First Look dragons Action TCA 2016 Valentine's Day sitcom aliens Mary Poppins Returns Vudu Hulu Paramount APB CBS Schedule Thanksgiving DGA Marvel Watching Series Western Universal History Ovation Netflix Bravo NYCC E! justice league Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Drama ABC Family Summer doctor who crossover anime Nickelodeon 21st Century Fox elevated horror Women's History Month HBO Max Horror The CW composers series casting Video Games Elton John Winners Teen Superheroes Rom-Com cops Election ESPN Song of Ice and Fire Stephen King WarnerMedia