Total Recall

10 Found Footage Films

In this week's Total Recall, we present a list of found footage movies from a variety of genres, inspired by Earth to Echo.

by | July 2, 2014 | Comments

Found Footage

It took a surprisingly long time for it to happen, but with this weekend’s Earth to Echo, found footage comes home to roost in the family film genre — and in honor of this adorably Amblinesque blend of 1980s all-ages fun and 21st-century technique, we decided to take a look at some of the more well-reviewed examples of a filmmaking style that’s definitely taken its share of critical lumps over the years. Naturally, there’s plenty of horror in here, but just like a group of kids heading off into the woods to debunk an urban legend, you might find a few surprises too. Power up that handheld camera, because it’s time for Total Recall!


The Bay

77%

A found footage horror movie from the guy who gave us Rain Man and The Natural? It sounds like a disaster, but in Barry Levinson’s The Bay, the only disaster is what we’re doing to our water supply — specifically in Chesapeake Bay, where the refusal of one town’s mayor to heed researchers’ warnings of lethal toxicity lead to a horrific outbreak of a mutant breed of tongue-eating louse. Freaky stuff, and well-handled by Levinson, who rebounded from a string of wretched stinkers like Envy and Man of the Year by using the inherent raw immediacy implied by found footage in pursuit of a timely (and obviously deeply felt) message. “Levinson’s film proves something pretty unequivocally,” argued Jason Gorber for Twitch. “Any conceit, any style, be it found footage or shakycam or haunted house or whatever, can be great in the hands of a good filmmaker.”

The Blair Witch Project

86%

No surprises here — The Blair Witch Project spawned the current found-footage craze, and there’s no way we were leaving it off this list, even if it has become a sort of whipping boy for the many inferior knockoffs inspired by its runaway success. And although, looking back, it really only has a few truly potent scares, it strings them out so patiently — and uses its then-novel narrative gimmick so well — that it’s easy to understand how Blair Witch scared the dickens out of so many filmgoers, particularly during the days of its early release, when it was still rumored to be culled from actual footage left behind by the Witch’s real-life victims. “The Blair Witch Project is the scariest movie I’ve ever seen,” decreed Lloyd Rose for the Washington Post. “Not the goriest, the grossest, the weirdest, the eeriest, the sickest, the creepiest or the slimiest… Just flat out the scariest.”

Chronicle

85%

Before 2012, the superhero and found-footage genres might not have seemed like the most natural of companions — but as Chronicle demonstrated, under the right circumstances, they can go together as deliciously as peanut butter and chocolate. Following the adventures of troubled teen Andrew (Dane DeHaan), his cousin Matt (Alex Russell), and their school acquaintance Steve (Michael B. Jordan) after they discover an unknown object that leaves them with telekinetic powers, the Josh Trank-directed drama imagines the giddy thrill that might come from developing adolescent superhuman abilities — as well as the struggle to come to terms with the responsibility all those cool new gifts entail. Of course, that’s a struggle familiar to anyone who’s ever read early Spider-Man, but Max Landis’ screenplay delves a bit deeper into the darkness — and the cast imbues his characters with easily relatable anguish. “It’s a testament to Trank’s capable direction that the movie feels so grounded in reality,” wrote USA Today’s Claudia Puig. “There is no sense of the magical in the goings-on, even though what the boys are doing defies logic and gravity.”

Cloverfield

78%

Hyped with a fairly brilliant “viral” ad campaign that made it seem like producer J.J. Abrams was brewing up some truly next-level cinema, Cloverfield couldn’t help but disappoint a little when it stomped into theaters in 2008 and filmgoers realized it was really just a monster movie with a(n occasionally nauseating) found-footage twist. Still, taken on its own terms, this is a better-than-average entry in this week’s subgenre, boasting some energetic work from director Matt Reeves and a solid script from Drew Goddard. Basically, if you’re going to watch one movie about a monster running amok in New York City while handicam-toting twentysomethings try to make sense of the destruction, this is the one to choose. “There’s nothing to Cloverfield, really, but stripped-down chaos shot in a faux-verite Blair Witch Project fashion,” shrugged the Chicago Tribune’s Michael Phillips, who then admitted, “But I have to say, I was with it.”

End of Watch

85%

Most critics — and more than a few filmgoers — would agree that the found-footage gimmick has been more than played out since rising to prominence with The Blair Witch Project in the late 1990s. Still, it’s a powerful tool when used in the right way, as demonstrated by writer/director David Ayer’s End of Watch, which follows a cop/film student (Jake Gyllenhaal) and his partner (Michael Pena) on patrol in the mean streets of South Central Los Angeles. While Ayer’s use of the found footage technique proved divisive among critics, End of Watch earned a healthy $51 million at the box office, picked up a pair of Independent Spirit Award nominations, and enjoyed the respect of scribes such as Amy Biancolli of the San Francisco Chronicle, who wrote, “The best scenes are filmed inside the cruiser, dashboard shots that face inward instead of out, catching Gyllenhaal and Peña in moments so playful and true they make all other buddy cops look bogus by comparison.”

Europa Report

81%

Having apparently never seen the end of 2010: The Year We Make Contact, a group of astronauts (played by Daniel Wu, Anamaria Marinca, Christian Camargo, Karolina Wydra, Sharlto Copley and Michael Nyqvist) board a deep space flight to Jupiter’s moon Europa, intent on probing the surface to try and find forms of life. The result is director Sebastián Cordero’s Europa Report, sort of a more intelligent cousin to the disastrous Apollo 18; rather than cheap scares and ill-conceived characters, Report tries to wring real human drama out of a dangerous situation that slowly goes from hopeful to horrifying — and, to many critics’ immense satisfaction, also grounds its story in intelligent dialogue that at least sounds like the kind of stuff scientists might say. “Finally,” crowed Joe Neumaier of the New York Daily News. “A found-footage thriller that merits, and expands on, this irrationally popular format.”

Lake Mungo

96%

An eminently creepy low-budget ghost story barbed with scary videotapes, cell phone footage, and mockumentary interviews, Lake Mungo took the spirit of unsettling real-life documentaries like Capturing the Friedmans and used it as the chilling springboard for a grueling question: how do families carry on after the death of a loved one? In most cases, one hopes the answer includes fewer moments of blood-curdling horror than Mungo, but that undercurrent of real-world sadness helps anchor the fear with genuine poignancy. Calling it “a sophisticated, adult tale that blends complex, compelling emotions with reflexive commentary on film as a ‘medium’ of memory, manipulation and magic,” Little White Lies’ Anton Bitel deemed it “a classic supernatural enigma, once seen never forgotten.”

Paranormal Activity

83%

For a lot of found footage horror movies, the device is used largely as a narrative and/or editing gimmick in order to obfuscate details and amp up jump scares. But with 2009’s Paranormal Activity, director Oren Peli rocked it Blair Witch style, using the characters’ handheld cameras to slowly ratchet up an overall feeling of dread that finally yields to a payoff rendered all the more haunting by its refusal to rely on gore or over-the-top special effects. Your mileage may vary with the growing list of Paranormal spinoffs and sequels, but the original is as simple as it is effective. “It illustrates one of my favorite points, that silence and waiting can be more entertaining than frantic fast-cutting and berserk f/x,” wrote an appreciative Roger Ebert. “For extended periods here, nothing at all is happening, and believe me, you won’t be bored.”

[Rec]

90%

You’ve no doubt noticed that quite a few of the movies on our list have fallen under the horror umbrella, but precious few are as lethally effective as [Rec], the 2007 sensation helmed by Spanish writer-directors Jaume Balagueró and Paco Plaza. Plunging viewers into the nightmarish hellscape of an apartment complex that might be ground zero for a quickly spreading virus that turns its hosts into homicidal savages, it proved that no matter how played out found footage might have seemed even then, it could still be used as an effective delivery mechanism for sparse, economic horror. The inevitable sequels fell victim to the laws of diminishing returns, but the original remains a classic of the genre; as Jason Morgan put it for Filmcritic.com, “Not since John Carpenter’s one-shot intro to Halloween has POV horror been this good.”

Trollhunter

82%

Found footage is so pervasive these days that it’s spread all the way to Norway, where director André Øvredal used it for his international cult hit Trollhunter. One of those movies whose plot is rather brilliantly summed up in its title, it follows the occasionally scary, often hilarious adventures of a group of college students whose pursuit of a suspected bear poacher takes a surprising turn when they discover that he’s actually after a much, much bigger quarry. With uniformly strong performances and more of a cinematic aesthetic than your average found-footage film, Trollhunter elicited applause from the majority of critics, including the Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney, who called it “An enjoyably off-kilter hybrid of The Blair Witch Project and Where the Wild Things Are.” There’s a presumably bigger-budget Hollywood remake in the works, but you don’t need to wait for that; the original is streaming via Netflix right now.

Take a look through the rest of our Total Recall archives. And don’t forget to check out Earth to Echo.

Tag Cloud

comic HFPA FX on Hulu cancelled target hispanic jurassic park DC Comics Mystery kids blockbuster australia LGBTQ LGBT toy story Avengers TCM crime die hard rt labs critics edition 007 Apple TV Plus Paramount Pictures Music award winner 21st Century Fox New York Comic Con MGM 2020 Amazon Studios Best and Worst Mary Poppins Returns ABC Signature Britbox SundanceTV Pride Month space discovery hist Tomatazos Trailer NBC Tags: Comedy Countdown spy thriller Star Wars TBS TV One Paramount Hollywood Foreign Press Association WGN indie USA Network GLAAD Pirates Bravo canceled Showtime unscripted book adaptation foreign Oscars Cannes mutant Elton John National Geographic Biopics Syfy streaming TV movies live action TCA Awards Women's History Month comic books Crunchyroll hispanic heritage month dexter Universal Pictures aapi SXSW Disney streaming service dreamworks nfl President politics cooking Vudu news prank new star wars movies Set visit Acorn TV chucky Year in Review VICE rt archives 2016 anime rt labs Character Guide Best Picture Marvel Fantasy films Amazon Prime Video Box Office spinoff ghosts The Arrangement what to watch thriller singing competition Disney+ Disney Plus japan Alien RT History cinemax Star Wars Celebration Focus Features italian Dark Horse Comics child's play know your critic BBC America Lucasfilm TCA 2017 women Certified Fresh batman social media game of thrones comiccon technology 90s versus Pixar talk show Martial Arts 2018 harry potter ABC Family doctor who teaser scary book Apple FX Sundance TV Winter TV classics crime thriller MSNBC archives docuseries TV renewals game show crossover miniseries Hallmark Christmas movies BBC One Paramount Plus Tokyo Olympics YouTube Red fresh romance mcc HBO Go Pet Sematary dc live event Food Network Mary poppins halloween halloween tv Stephen King documentaries scene in color series Indigenous comic book movie NBA Marvel Studios christmas movies VH1 Spring TV Creative Arts Emmys 99% Red Carpet cults Sundance Now disaster HBO rotten Mindy Kaling nbcuniversal The Purge IMDb TV Paramount Network boxoffice Adult Swim zombie Best Director Super Bowl Calendar VOD Binge Guide Tarantino Crackle football sopranos FOX toronto justice league indiana jones psychological thriller emmy awards festivals golden globe awards Grammys Lionsgate 45 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina See It Skip It werewolf Toys History Emmys GoT ID Classic Film Geeked Week American Society of Cinematographers Disney Plus Horror slashers Photos historical drama psycho leaderboard Video Games Infographic mob a nightmare on elm street war Warner Bros. period drama ESPN zombies Amazon Prime television blockbusters free movies obi wan franchise NYCC Winners Reality Competition Mudbound Netflix Rocky based on movie adenture Masterpiece suspense TNT broadcast mockumentary Oscar all-time best Television Critics Association name the review 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Discovery Channel saw AMC Superheroe sitcom king arthur posters robots Trophy Talk action-comedy Sundance BAFTA crime drama rotten movies we love natural history Nickelodeon Universal movies critic resources Rock Brie Larson biopic adaptation ABC medical drama olympics breaking bad kaiju CW Seed HBO Max golden globes rom-coms movie Television Academy Black Mirror basketball monster movies diversity cancelled TV shows IFC Films 20th Century Fox CNN Fargo Quiz The Witch kong Song of Ice and Fire green book Endgame parents mission: impossible quibi Freeform scene in color film series Comedy Central TV Land Ellie Kemper DGA Film A24 popular japanese 2019 Neflix CBS All Access godzilla Christmas summer preview Black History Month Comics on TV El Rey Sci-Fi Sony superhero documentary Arrowverse remakes joker Starz Columbia Pictures YouTube Premium Pacific Islander Turner Classic Movies Opinion pirates of the caribbean biography Film Festival Spike video on demand Prime Video TIFF DC Universe adventure Shudder streaming movies summer TV preview Tumblr Image Comics Turner travel Legendary 71st Emmy Awards Thanksgiving superman The CW Native romantic comedy CMT SXSW 2022 finale Schedule animated satire San Diego Comic-Con Logo james bond cancelled television science fiction DC streaming service IFC comic book movies Amazon Cartoon Network revenge venice Family jamie lee curtis facebook trailers transformers Baby Yoda First Look Star Trek Valentine's Day 24 frames Marvel Television Kids & Family trophy south america ratings sag awards sports scary movies Summer USA BET series anthology slasher police drama 2017 1990s PBS Sneak Peek Pop TV deadpool zero dark thirty Rom-Com First Reviews 79th Golden Globes Awards spider-verse tv talk children's TV french 2015 Marathons OneApp Lifetime scorecard asian-american hidden camera serial killer vampires true crime Polls and Games dceu criterion 94th Oscars royal family Watching Series A&E Emmy Nominations BET Awards The Academy Holiday debate Awards Tour E! OWN Comedy Musical Mary Tyler Moore X-Men YouTube spanish strong female leads Extras latino screen actors guild richard e. Grant DirecTV Spectrum Originals nature MTV summer TV Nominations razzies genre Walt Disney Pictures Peacock Broadway Rocketman spanish language cancelled TV series PlayStation 2021 vs. cars YA aliens Fox News TCA comics Fox Searchlight Hallmark international Funimation Netflix Christmas movies Disney Channel feel good directors Teen wonder woman new zealand worst movies APB Travel Channel Reality TruTV streamig Western South by Southwest Film Festival sequel Election obituary supernatural universal monsters Academy Awards interviews Shondaland spider-man worst TV Hear Us Out black comedy Cosplay laika twilight AMC Plus cats Nat Geo political drama CBS SDCC TCA Winter 2020 Captain marvel Writers Guild of America Trivia Drama gangster BBC Exclusive Video docudrama PaleyFest marvel comics GIFs Comic Book composers Disney 72 Emmy Awards 93rd Oscars Chernobyl stop motion WarnerMedia Superheroes Action stoner blaxploitation renewed TV shows spain heist movie legend The Walt Disney Company dark witnail Heroines Best Actor Holidays Tubi Premiere Dates concert Musicals fast and furious scene in color ViacomCBS Anna Paquin boxing stand-up comedy telelvision young adult theme song lord of the rings marvel cinematic universe canceled TV shows Comic-Con@Home 2021 Wes Anderson king kong The Walking Dead Lifetime Christmas movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt E3 Ovation screenings Podcast RT21 Instagram Live MCU Fall TV sequels FXX elevated horror Country art house 73rd Emmy Awards Sony Pictures Esquire Hulu critics reboot Apple TV+ comedies casting Epix reviews dogs hollywood ITV TLC independent Awards video dragons high school 4/20 black Interview Ghostbusters cops binge target scene in color new york Best Actress cartoon dramedy Pop Animation festival