Watching Series: The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug

We Revisit The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings Movies

by and | December 14, 2014 | Comments

In anticipation of the upcoming release of Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies, we here at RT decided to take a look back at the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the first two films of the Hobbittrilogy. Our latest installment covers The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, which editors Tim Ryan and Ryan Fujitani rewatched for some fresh perspective.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug


The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug

Ryan: The two biggest issues I had with An Unexpected Journey were the jarring visual effects and the propulsive-yet-somehow-mundane narrative arc, which mostly consisted of the heroic ensemble scurrying from one perilous threat only to wind up in another. Fortunately, The Desolation of Smaug found a way to make the former much more palatable and, thanks to some thrilling action set pieces, the latter more compelling, even if the plot followed a similar structure. The Hobbit still feels like a lesser franchise compared to LotR, of course, but even as Smaug juggled a few competing story threads that felt decidedly like rest stops en route to an epic conclusion, it also more fully realized the nascent threat of Sauron, which helped raise the stakes. I have a few minor quibbles with the film, but overall I found it a much more enjoyable watch than An Unexpected Journey, and I’d like to get your general thoughts on Smaug before I delve into the nitty-gritty.



Tim: Judged against The Lord of the Rings trilogy, the Hobbit films (the first two, anyway) can’t help but feel less substantial. But what’s wrong with that? If you scale back your expectations, An Unexpected Journey and (especially) The Desolation of Smaug are perfectly serviceable — and frequently outstanding — moviemaking on a grand-scale. The characters aren’t as vivid and the battles between good and evil aren’t as weighty, but as pure spectacle, Smaug mostly delivers. Martin Freeman and Richard Armitage make for fine leads, and Ian McKellen brings gravitas by just showing up. The forest infested by giant spiders shows that Peter Jackson hasn’t lost his affinity for the creepy crawlies, and even though the barrel escape/orc battle may defy the laws of physics (and logic), it’s really exciting. The set design remains impeccable — the M.C. Escher-like twists of the elf lair, the creeky wooden man-made island town of Esgaroth, and the the tight stairs and vast rock sculptures that line the Lonely Mountain are vivid and picturesque. And the scene in which Bilbo enters Smaug’s vast treasure chamber emanates a sense of I’ve-got-a-bad-feeling-about-this dread that echoes the space slug scene in The Empire Strikes Back. Sure, it’s probably at least 20 minutes too long (I have a sneaking suspicion that when it’s all said and done, the three Hobbit movies could be trimmed into one killer three-hour feature). But stretched-to-the-limit Peter Jackson is still more imaginative that just about any other blockbuster director out there.

Ryan: I remember some folks grumbling about the barrel scene when Smaug first came out, and I get that the physics are a little wonky, but like you, I thought it was pretty exciting. The action is visceral, inventive and easy to follow, if a tad cartoony, and the Mirkwood elves come off looking absolutely badass. But as long as we’re talking about that scene, I do feel the need to mention the level of violence in the film: there are a lot of decapitations and point-blank arrows to the face. I didn’t really have a problem with it, and in my opinion the orcs make for much more exciting action scenes than CGI trolls, CGI goblins, or CGI spiders, but I can’t deny I was surprised by the sheer brutality of it, however bloodless it might have been.



You also make a great point about the production design and Peter Jackson’s craftsmanship in general. I still think a Guillermo del Toro version of The Hobbit would have been really interesting, but there’s an explicit familiarity in what we’ve seen so far in Journey and Smaug that feels like a warm blanket — a slightly timeworn blanket with a few rough patches here and there, but a warm one nonetheless — and it makes it difficult to imagine anyone else in the director’s chair.

Having said all this, there were still a couple of things that bothered me about Smaug, which, to be clear, I thought was a far superior film to An Unexpected Journey. I could have done without the elf-dwarf romance between Tauriel and Kili, although I liked Evangeline Lilly; it felt completely unnecessary to me. The rest of the dwarves, save for Thorin and maybe Balin (the old, “voice of reason” dwarf), remain largely indistinguishable from each other. And there really isn’t anything substantive about the story, which essentially amounts to “a bunch of dwarves walk home… but there’s a dragon there!” I can see why Peter Jackson felt the need to shoehorn in the rise of Sauron. Honestly, I was much more intrigued by the history between the dwarves and the elves — briefly referenced in the film — and it seems we may get some of that in The Battle of the Five Armies, so I’m looking forward to the franchise ending with a bang.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug

Tag Cloud

boxoffice medical drama vampires discovery binge Apple TV Plus transformers Extras San Diego Comic-Con Comic Book TV renewals Lifetime Superheroe Lionsgate Columbia Pictures Premiere Dates Comedy Central CW Seed TruTV CMT book tv talk technology Sci-Fi USA Britbox Spike Quiz singing competition ESPN game show Turner Classic Movies Warner Bros. Binge Guide Peacock cartoon natural history sports New York Comic Con DC Universe movie The Purge Rom-Com E! The CW serial killer Dark Horse Comics RT History Paramount Network series DC streaming service TIFF CNN canceled TV shows Thanksgiving Amazon Prime Nominations Anna Paquin HBO children's TV Teen Photos Discovery Channel X-Men Election See It Skip It talk show Spectrum Originals breaking bad GLAAD award winner slashers YouTube Premium Podcast Christmas The Witch Rock game of thrones Opinion Superheroes hispanic Trivia mockumentary Sundance TV Marvel Television Emmy Nominations Pixar YouTube MCU Nat Geo harry potter docudrama richard e. Grant independent 24 frames SundanceTV MSNBC Heroines Television Academy Mindy Kaling dramedy First Reviews FOX Crunchyroll Western robots diversity TCA Winter 2020 DGA quibi dceu Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt justice league GIFs TLC Amazon historical drama Reality Competition theme song Cannes Esquire Family Martial Arts mutant Baby Yoda golden globes comiccon Syfy Black Mirror Cartoon Network Winners Awards Best and Worst Musicals Disney Plus Star Trek psycho Musical latino Sony Pictures TV Land Creative Arts Emmys police drama composers Trailer Music TCA 2017 Marvel TNT Stephen King VICE south america Crackle Reality sequel cancelled television Tubi nature ABC crime thriller Comics on TV Walt Disney Pictures TBS Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Food Network TCM finale Shondaland IFC Films sag awards christmas movies Summer 2015 Academy Awards Captain marvel social media kids Pop blaxploitation dc President WGN Brie Larson Film Festival 2020 stand-up comedy documentary revenge crime Spring TV crossover Shudder Ghostbusters Calendar Black History Month 71st Emmy Awards A&E Certified Fresh name the review Ovation USA Network Amazon Studios Infographic cooking dragons doctor who Endgame Pirates comic festivals History Vudu Animation Mystery movies 2016 A24 werewolf FX blockbuster Year in Review canceled Netflix animated period drama Lucasfilm anime Marathons facebook Rocky Super Bowl politics 2018 AMC thriller comics YouTube Red BBC what to watch DirecTV Set visit green book Valentine's Day travel HBO Max Elton John Fall TV GoT free movies unscripted political drama 2017 Bravo DC Comics YA versus cancelled romance aliens Character Guide strong female leads APB screenings Watching Series Mary Poppins Returns Kids & Family CBS PBS Countdown Disney+ Disney Plus directors zombies Box Office adventure BET NYCC video SXSW cults Showtime IFC anthology Fantasy Oscars The Walking Dead Nickelodeon Trophy Talk Song of Ice and Fire true crime Tarantino Netflix Christmas movies Sundance Now Lifetime Christmas movies reboot Red Carpet Turner FXX rotten movies we love Comedy Hulu television 21st Century Fox Disney Channel Schedule PaleyFest Universal Apple TV+ sitcom cars Marvel Studios NBC zero dark thirty Freeform Rocketman ABC Family cats E3 Tomatazos cinemax Ellie Kemper Sundance 20th Century Fox Country disaster LGBTQ crime drama witnail Star Wars Paramount supernatural Pet Sematary Women's History Month RT21 2019 American Society of Cinematographers Hallmark Christmas movies ghosts joker First Look WarnerMedia SDCC OneApp spy thriller Disney Grammys ITV hist Mary Tyler Moore Apple Biopics Masterpiece Awards Tour Action Epix streaming spain El Rey space adaptation science fiction foreign biography Logo Fox News Interview Disney streaming service screen actors guild toy story spanish language Horror Film elevated horror Writers Guild of America cancelled TV series dogs cops Emmys OWN Arrowverse LGBT halloween BBC America Starz cancelled TV shows TV based on movie 45 Polls and Games MTV Avengers Amazon Prime Video ratings batman Cosplay Holiday zombie Holidays renewed TV shows Sneak Peek jamie lee curtis TCA indie Adult Swim Winter TV Acorn TV spinoff Video Games miniseries teaser war spider-man The Arrangement CBS All Access Mary poppins psychological thriller Pride Month 007 Drama Mudbound Toys Tumblr Chernobyl Hallmark Classic Film VH1 casting romantic comedy National Geographic