Watching Series: The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

We Revisit The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings Movies

by , and | December 11, 2014 | Comments

In anticipation of the upcoming release of Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies, we here at RT decided to take a look back at the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the first two films of the Hobbittrilogy. Our latest installment covers The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, which editors Tim Ryan and Ryan Fujitani rewatched for some fresh perspective.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug


The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers

Tim: I remember liking The Two Towers better than The Fellowship of the Ring when I saw it in the theater. It certainly contains more striking imagery, from the craggy Ents to the imposing Mûmakil (which, like the AT-ATs in The Empire Strikes Back, are inefficient as battle weaponry but still look completely awesome). However, upon watching the extended edition, I wasn’t as involved. Unlike Fellowship, which supplemented the theatrical cut with plenty of seemingly essential side notes, I thought the special edition of the Two Towers longer, not more illuminating.

Ryan: Yep, Two Towers was my favorite of the three LOTR films for several reasons: I, too, love the Ents (my favorite characters from the series, in fact), Eomer and the riders of Rohan are badass, the destruction of Isengard and the climactic battle at Helm’s Deep are epic, and we get some of Gollum’s meatiest scenes, among other things. Unfortunately, this latest rewatch drastically changed my assessment of the movie. I don’t know if it was because it was the extended cut, or if I simply never noticed these issues before, but I found The Two Towers wholly unfocused, forced to split its time between several storylines that almost never converge. This was a big problem for me, and my love for the movie diminished quite a bit upon this viewing.

 

 

Tim: Still, credit where it’s due: that climatic battle sequence is breathtaking in its visceral power, and Gollum has to be considered one of the definitive movie characters of the 2000s. Therein lies another issue with the Two Towers, however: Andy Serkis is such a gifted physical actor, and Gollum is such a vivid creation, that he ends up overshadowing the human actors by a pretty wide margin.

Luke: I’m not gonna lie: I fell asleep in this movie. I don’t know if it was the pizza, er lembas bread, but I was out stone cold midway through. Thing is, like you guys, this was my favorite theatrically, but the extended edition throws the narrative wildly out of balance. I liked the Two Towers theatrically because it split its time judiciously between the Frodo-Sam-Gollum journey (the best thing, for me) and the machinations at Rohan leading up to Helm’s Deep, but in the long version it seemed Gollum disappeared for huge stretches in favor of more — so very much more — standing around and talking by interchangeable stock types anticipating battle. I think by about the four-millionth exhortation of “We ride!” — followed by another meeting — I was done. Pared back to the treachery of Gollum and his game of wits with the hobbits, though, there’s a good movie in here.

 

 

Ryan: I hate to admit it, but I also nodded off around the time Aragorn was pretending to like Eowyn’s battlefield broth (a completely unnecessary scene I’m glad was left on the cutting room floor), and at one point, there were, by my count, four narrative threads being juggled: the preparations at Rohan, Pippin and Merry with the Ents, Frodo and Sam, and the love story between Aragorn and Arwen. Thankfully — and wisely — the theatrical cut pared down the latter of those quite a bit, but with extended stretches devoted to the other three (lending to the long absence of Gollum from the screen, as noted by Luke), the longer cut just dragged on and on. For my money’s worth, the theatrical cut of this film is just right; my affection remains strong, if slightly abated, thanks to Helm’s Deep and the Ents.

Tim: You know, when a tree fell on my car last year, I was initially convinced it was a random accident. Now I know it wasn’t: I was the target of a plot devised at one of those Ent Moots.

Ryan: And they’d been planning it for centuries.

Luke: Speaking of Ents, Ryan we must make mention of one of our favorite moments in all the trilogy, I think. You know what I’m talking about?

Ryan: You can only be speaking of the copious amounts of ganj… err, Longbottom Leaf being smoked.

Luke: Well that was rather stirring, of course, but you must remember the cheer that went up when one of the Ents used the surging floodwaters of Isengard to quench his flaming hair of leaves.

Ryan: Oh, that! Such a small moment, yet so brilliantly comic. I thought to myself, “Yup, that’s what I would have done, too.”

Luke: [Laughs] I salute the genius at Weta who did that.

Tag Cloud

elevated horror Election YouTube Premium Freeform GIFs The CW TCM Martial Arts Creative Arts Emmys discovery Britbox zombie RT21 CBS crossover 24 frames Extras ESPN anthology thriller Shudder Columbia Pictures Summer what to watch Cosplay Nickelodeon Cartoon Network Certified Fresh 2016 Masterpiece blaxploitation USA Video Games Amazon Prime Paramount Network streaming Grammys Country SundanceTV Mary Tyler Moore HBO American Society of Cinematographers GLAAD medical drama comiccon talk show teaser romance adaptation IFC SDCC Ghostbusters BBC America 2015 Tumblr Showtime Quiz Mary Poppins Returns sports TruTV PBS Photos El Rey Musicals DC Comics festivals Bravo richard e. Grant Star Wars cooking IFC Films serial killer transformers Western RT History Oscars USA Network San Diego Comic-Con based on movie Esquire Reality Competition The Arrangement spider-man Best and Worst Crackle Brie Larson Sundance Now zombies Anna Paquin SXSW DC streaming service DC Universe television Mindy Kaling Women's History Month Ellie Kemper Countdown E! ratings anime cats See It Skip It Paramount Awards Red Carpet Pixar TLC President period drama 45 Apple LGBTQ Toys Universal psycho Biopics social media Pop First Look Comedy Central Tomatazos Sony Pictures true crime BBC Super Bowl dc VICE CNN 21st Century Fox facebook Disney Channel Trailer Mary poppins Fall TV Comics on TV unscripted Spectrum Originals vampires docudrama mockumentary Adult Swim Kids & Family E3 Comedy YouTube Red Epix Amazon Rocky TV Premiere Dates MSNBC crime ABC Family science fiction TCA 2017 20th Century Fox dragons A&E Pirates Lifetime adventure psychological thriller Sundance Syfy natural history Horror Netflix Shondaland 2018 Spike Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt FXX war Watching Series Marvel National Geographic dceu cults Rom-Com robots Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Schedule golden globes Writers Guild of America travel technology Acorn TV Rock doctor who Drama historical drama Mudbound jamie lee curtis singing competition Animation 2019 Comic Book TV Land Sci-Fi Warner Bros. spy thriller MCU Polls and Games Music Walt Disney Pictures supernatural CBS All Access Infographic witnail mutant Black Mirror cinemax VH1 boxoffice 007 NBC Hulu Podcast Thanksgiving Emmys Holidays DGA YA Calendar harry potter Pet Sematary sequel GoT Starz TIFF green book Spring TV political drama Fox News TNT PaleyFest NYCC cops aliens casting award winner MTV ABC X-Men ITV theme song biography CW Seed Ovation Musical Lionsgate Lucasfilm Winter TV FX Teen Set visit miniseries APB Nominations CMT Superheroe Mystery History Winners finale diversity Captain marvel DirecTV Song of Ice and Fire Christmas binge Character Guide BET Interview OWN Sneak Peek Trophy Talk Awards Tour Stephen King TBS WGN New York Comic Con TCA dramedy justice league Fantasy Disney Opinion police drama politics Food Network Dark Horse Comics Trivia composers comic Nat Geo sitcom Year in Review FOX Star Trek zero dark thirty crime drama Superheroes nature Valentine's Day Reality hist crime thriller Box Office Marathons AMC Action Logo 2017