Watching Series: The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

We Revisit The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings Movies

by , and | December 10, 2014 | Comments

In anticipation of the upcoming release of Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit: The Battle of the Five Armies, we here at RT decided to take a look back at the Lord of the Rings trilogy and the first two films of the Hobbittrilogy. Our latest installment covers The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, which editors Tim Ryan and Ryan Fujitani rewatched for some fresh perspective.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug


The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring

Luke: Okay, in the interest of full disclosure — because there’s always that one person — I’m going to get this out of the way right now: I was one of the three people on the planet not especially awed by these movies when I first saw them in theaters. As someone who grew up loving Tolkien’s trilogy, I felt Peter Jackson did as competent a job as could be expected — the movies looked the part and covered the story’s key action beats — but due to their time constraints, or perhaps their tone, the sense of immersion I got from the books, that magic of getting lost in the rich worlds of lore, just wasn’t there for me. So I’ve always been curious to see these extended editions, to see if that wonder might be restored — or whether, you know, I was just missing something altogether. As we begin Fellowship I’m struck by how huge this backstory is in the prologue — and how much, curiously, it covers in short form the events that will be expanded for The Hobbit. Tim?

Tim: What’s kept me from revisiting the Lord of the Rings movies since I first saw them in the theater is not only their staggering length, but also the fact that I know only the barest outlines of Tolkien’s mythology beyond what I’ve picked up from friends who are LOTR fans and from a casual listen to various Led Zeppelin deep cuts (in fact, I’m gonna listen to “The Battle of Evermore” as I pound this out). But I have to say that I’d forgotten how effective the opening sequence is in Fellowship of the Ring. I think the problem with a lot of sci-fi/fantasy tales is that they mistake complexity for depth, and Peter Jackson does a great job of avoiding this trap. The opening sequence is visually terrific, but more importantly, it does a great job of providing a basic explanation of the world we’re about to immerse ourselves in. It’s as if Peter Jackson is saying, “Here’s the deal. Here’s what’s at stake. Here’s why you should devote 12 hours of your life to this story.”

And then we get the Shire, and what a wonderful way to establish the milieu of this epic. The Shire is teeming with life, and it’s a place that looks enough like our world to draw us in, and otherworldly enough to make it seem magical (in lesser hands, the Lord of the Rings films could have looked like a New Age nightmare). And I know these movies are wall-to-wall with state-of-the-art special effects, but the first visual trick that blew my mind was how they were able to make Gandalf tower over Bilbo Baggins.



Ryan: Same here. Even when I watched the bonus features and witnessed the trickery they employed to achieve the effect, I found myself no less dumbfounded by it. It’s really incredible and a testament to the time and effort Jackson put into the film. The visual aspect of this movie, from the gorgeous landscapes to the spiffy effects, is one of the best things about it.

Having said that, I have to confess that I, like Luke, was not head-over-heels for this movie when I first saw it in theaters, but that’s mostly because, unlike many of my friends, I’d never read the books, so I wasn’t heading into it with an entire childhood of expectations just waiting to be fulfilled. Also, it was a late showing and I was exhausted, so I fell asleep about two hours into it.

Of course, I’ve rewatched Fellowship several times since then, and let me be clear: I think this is a great movie. In fact, watching the extended version reinforced that even more for me, because while I expected the added material to bog down the storytelling, I was pleasantly surprised when I found that it didn’t. Even in its longer form, the film felt satisfying to me.

Luke: Yeah, as we were watching this one, I felt that all of the additional and extended scenes were in harmony with the narrative structure. The biggest compliment I can pay this edition is that I didn’t notice the changes, at least in an obvious way. I still think the movie has a sense of “checking off the boxes” about it, but coming back to it after all this time I can appreciate the craftsmanship — and the apparent love and care that went into it. I mean, just the fact that so much of this — with its interminable portentous speeches and glassy, widescreen eyes — could play as camp, but doesn’t, is a testament to the even keel Jackson keeps the movie on. As Tim says, it could have played as a New age nightmare (I’m politely ignoring all the pan pipes on the soundtrack typing that), and I think it’s Jackson’s horror training that gives these movies some of their ballast.

Speaking of the director’s horror pedigree, some of the stuff in Fellowship is done really well. The Nazgûl (conjuring a little of Ralph Bakshi’s rotoscopic menace, which Jackson saw at a formative age) are great indicators of what’s to come, and if the cave troll still seems a bit weightless and cartoon-like, then that Balrog gets two clawed thumbs up from me — if only for looking like it thundered straight off the cover of a Dio album.



Tim: Ian McKellen is such a terrific presence that he lends all the necessary gravitas to Gandalf. Ian Holm, as Bilbo, and Elijah Wood, as Frodo, look enough alike that they could be related. Christopher Lee exudes typical menace as Saruman, and John Rhys-Davies provides Falstaffian heartiness as Gimli. Still, the actor who made the biggest impression on me this time out was Sean Bean as the tormented Boromir. He doesn’t have a ton to do, but Bean’s expressive face conveys the degree to which the ring is a sought-after commodity, and what havoc it can wreak on weaker souls. (I also have to mention that when Bilbo’s face goes all Mr. Hyde when he looks at the ring… man, I forgot what a shock that was).

Ryan: Complete agreement on Boromir (as well as the freaky Bilbo moment). If I were allowed just one nitpick with the film (and really, with the series as a whole), I’d have to go with the sometimes overwhelmingly simplistic “good vs. evil” theme prevalent throughout. There are only a few characters in the series who demonstrate any significant inner conflict, and — Surprise! — they’re the most interesting ones to watch. I get that Tolkien basically defined a lot of these fantasy archetypes for generations to come, but for better or worse, a lot of these characters are, essentially, just archetypes, and they never waver.

As a viewer, I never once questioned whether Aragorn or Legolas or Gimli would ever betray Frodo the same way that Boromir, to an extent, kept me guessing he might. I never once questioned whether Saruman was going to come around eventually and honor some unspoken wizard code; he was always going to be bad news here. This is why Boromir was so interesting, and why, as we’ll see in The Two Towers, Gollum is possibly the best character in the series. In the end, Fellowship is a success because it works anyway and effectively sets up the various storylines we’ll see come to fruition later.

Luke: I’m with you here. Gollum is the best character in the movies, as he was in the books (and for me, that goes for The Hobbit, too). It’s his complexity that makes him fascinating because, as you point out, Ryan, the world of Middle-earth is often black-and-white (though in fairness, it was something of an analogy for WWII.) Tolkien doesn’t know what to do with his female characters, either (“as was the style at the time,” ahem), which is an element that Jackson and his co-writers Philippa Boyens and Fran Walsh try and address — to varying degrees of success, as we’ll see. (Though any movie that gives Liv Tyler elf ears in service of a bigger arc is fine by me.) I also think it’s worth noting, in the Jekyll-and-Hyde stakes, Cate Blanchett’s spooky tranformation from peaceful Lady of the Lake to ring-crazed specter. Blanchett’s a big asset to the performances, alongside McKellen, who I agree was born to play Gandalf. Anyway, I think this movie’s really set the quest on solid footing thus far. I’m optimistic for a reappraisal.

The Fellowship of the Ring | The Two Towers The Return of the King

An Unexpected Journey | The Desolation of Smaug

Tag Cloud

green book Film Festival critics IFC Sundance TV GIFs tv talk talk show films unscripted Best and Worst Shondaland medical drama Christmas Marvel Television spider-man stand-up comedy DC Universe Acorn TV directors justice league Binge Guide The Witch PBS sag awards TCA Winter 2020 Fantasy USA Network BAFTA Peacock 72 Emmy Awards Tumblr Winners classics festivals Logo dogs Valentine's Day Lifetime Countdown MCU Sony Pictures Music TBS Awards SDCC Set visit Sundance Now FX on Hulu Nat Geo Drama police drama teaser laika dragons political drama Hulu Avengers rotten criterion Martial Arts HBO Go Nickelodeon Ellie Kemper cooking A&E Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters Film Spring TV Comics on TV crossover American Society of Cinematographers Winter TV Mystery slashers true crime breaking bad serial killer Lucasfilm AMC a nightmare on elm street Women's History Month Pop TV joker ABC Family GoT Anna Paquin Chernobyl renewed TV shows Heroines canceled Extras Fox News Comedy Central Comic Book Emmys scary movies comedies Photos mutant TLC sports President ratings Hear Us Out versus Baby Yoda Disney Kids & Family Academy Awards 2018 Mudbound Apple TV Plus Chilling Adventures of Sabrina ghosts singing competition movie based on movie spy thriller A24 CBS All Access LGBTQ HBO Max Freeform dceu First Reviews Holiday Funimation Warner Bros. Calendar Pop blaxploitation Trailer HBO quibi Vudu Action Esquire See It Skip It chucky Television Academy Syfy adaptation jamie lee curtis mission: impossible Rocky Crunchyroll TV Cannes concert IFC Films stoner witnail Apple adventure Summer Video Games Hallmark Amazon Prime Video Columbia Pictures 2019 space VOD 71st Emmy Awards anime screen actors guild cancelled TV shows crime thriller Brie Larson series news christmas movies New York Comic Con Family TCA Awards Reality BBC One LGBT TV renewals richard e. Grant Pixar binge Shudder 007 DC streaming service Comedy foreign Toys 2016 APB die hard crime disaster all-time romance romantic comedy zombie dramedy strong female leads revenge what to watch fast and furious elevated horror psychological thriller TCA 2017 Elton John nbcuniversal Crackle Captain marvel obituary technology Walt Disney Pictures documentary Song of Ice and Fire Fall TV cops child's play Holidays CNN Pet Sematary rotten movies we love zombies independent Red Carpet Sci-Fi comics Thanksgiving children's TV Character Guide Opinion latino Tubi Black History Month Epix hispanic kids Disney Plus robots harry potter BET Awards cancelled Cosplay Tomatazos Mary Poppins Returns diversity screenings Disney Channel satire Creative Arts Emmys golden globes comic Classic Film Year in Review YouTube spanish language YouTube Red WarnerMedia TCA The Walking Dead Turner Classic Movies El Rey Hallmark Christmas movies Spectrum Originals Mindy Kaling anthology OneApp Country worst YA television Marvel Studios finale transformers Musicals Pirates Disney+ Disney Plus Star Wars Interview 24 frames Amazon Starz CW Seed Reality Competition DirecTV X-Men Food Network Ovation award winner Trophy Talk GLAAD First Look name the review PaleyFest Cartoon Network Television Critics Association 20th Century Fox social media 45 dark Polls and Games Schedule WGN 4/20 Paramount cars supernatural halloween Certified Fresh Election casting indie cartoon YouTube Premium batman TCM TV Land theme song Marathons south america best Animation Star Trek war spinoff Netflix Christmas movies Rom-Com 2017 RT History 2020 hist Endgame MTV Horror E3 toy story Apple TV+ Musical History SundanceTV Superheroe ITV Amazon Prime Super Bowl biography sequels The CW Grammys Podcast DGA miniseries E! NBC BBC America USA RT21 Paramount Network docudrama canceled TV shows cancelled TV series Universal Tarantino Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Trivia reviews PlayStation mockumentary stop motion aliens indiana jones Adult Swim Spike Showtime ESPN universal monsters video on demand Box Office BBC Nominations streaming 21st Century Fox vampires TNT Awards Tour boxoffice Masterpiece Amazon Studios travel thriller superhero VICE documentaries Travel Channel TIFF Discovery Channel The Purge cancelled television parents CMT ABC crime drama 2015 FOX psycho Quiz VH1 Marvel FX free movies Rock werewolf politics Mary Tyler Moore Lifetime Christmas movies Oscars Turner animated Arrowverse video emmy awards spain Rocketman period drama Emmy Nominations BET cats historical drama Sneak Peek Pride Month Black Mirror zero dark thirty Watching Series Western SXSW Superheroes Dark Horse Comics book National Geographic OWN Teen The Arrangement sequel San Diego Comic-Con facebook blockbuster MSNBC dc nature Bravo Sundance sitcom Biopics hollywood twilight Premiere Dates asian-american Lionsgate CBS franchise Mary poppins NYCC comiccon cinemax movies Disney streaming service Infographic TruTV science fiction Britbox DC Comics Netflix reboot doctor who game show composers natural history FXX game of thrones Stephen King cults discovery