Zen Boogeyman: How John Wick Became an Instant Cult Classic

With David Leitch's Atomic Blonde hitting theaters, Nathan Rabin explores the power behind Leitch and Chad Stahelski's Keanu Reeves-powered surprise hit actioner.

by | July 25, 2017 | Comments

(Photo by David Lee/Summit Entertainment)

As a filmmaker, you can destroy entire cities with relative impunity and gleefully obliterate whole civilizations with malicious delight without losing an audience’s sympathy. But movies must tread lightly when animals are involved, because there are few things more likely to enrage audiences than the unnecessary death of an animal, particularly a dog. Dogs are borderline sacred in American society, and our treatment of onscreen mutts reflects that.

Thankfully, the 2014 instant cult classic John Wick, directed by former stuntmen Chad Stahelski and David Leitch, has the most necessary and meaningful death of a cinematic canine since Old Yeller, and one nearly as mourned. The dog is the key to John Wick’s magic. Without it, the movie is merely an extraordinarily well-made, skillfully directed and performed action neo-noir starring Keanu Reeves. That’s not a bad place to start, but the dog’s death elevates John Wick to the level of lurid pop tragedy. It transforms a movie for action-film buffs into a movie for anyone likely to be deeply affected by the death of an adorable dog. That is to say, everyone.

I usually find the revenge genre morally abhorrent and emotionally empty, but when vengeance is exacted on behalf of a four-legged charmer instead of a person, it changes everything. In that case, the very universe itself howls for justice, and in John Wick, the title character is the instrument of its fury.

The film opens with the death (by natural causes) of John Wick’s wife (Bridget Moynahan), a woman good and decent enough to inspire her adoring husband to abandon his life of violence and criminality, even though he is to killing people what Meryl Streep is to acting: the gold standard by which all others are judged. A lesser film would have dragged out the wife’s death, but John Wick deals with her as quickly, smoothly, and efficiently as it does everything else.

(Photo by David Lee/Summit Entertainment)

He’s no mere killer for hire. He’s more like a contemporary folk hero.

Before her light is permanently extinguished, though, she arranges to have a puppy named Daisy shipped to her husband’s home to help him deal with his impending grief. John doesn’t get to spend a whole lot of time with the dog, but he doesn’t need to. Daisy immediately makes an indelible impression and worms her way into the hearts and minds of everyone in the audience. Seldom has a badass action movie been so defined by the adorableness of one of its principals. With the exception of the Death Wish series, of course.

John Wick himself is a familiar action-movie archetype: a man of violence who has figured out a way to leave his past behind and enjoy the simple pleasures of an honest, law-abiding existence. Then one day, Iosef Tarasov (Alfie Allen), the degenerate son of Russian mob kingpin Viggo Tarasov (Michael Nyqvist), attempts to buy John’s 1969 Ford Mustang Mach 1 from him at a gas station. Wick politely declines the offer, but Iosef is used to having his way, so he and his men follow John home, where they murder his dog and steal his car. This makes John Wick angry. And you wouldn’t like John Wick when he’s angry. Because first he gets angry, and then he starts murdering people. And once he starts, he doesn’t stop until his thirst for vengeance has been sated.

Wick now has something to live for, and more importantly, something to kill for. From that point on, Viggo and John are on a collision course only one of them will survive, if anyone survives at all. In one of the film’s few bits of exposition, Viggo explains that John’s nickname was “The Boogeyman,” but even that undersells his badassery, because, as Viggo clarifies, John Wick is not the boogeyman so much as he’s the one you send to kill the boogeyman. He’s no mere killer for hire. He’s more like a contemporary folk hero.

In Viggo, John Wick boasts a villain worthy of its anti-hero. Nyqvist plays the mob boss as an inveterate philosopher who regards his life and death with a wry sense of world-weary resignation. His respect for Wick borders on awe, and he seems to know, deep down, that it is his existential destiny to be killed by him. He seems resigned to his fate.

But something deeper also seems to be at work. There’s a sense that Viggo wishes John Wick were his son, and he’s come to terms with his death — and the death of his own son — as an appropriate price to pay to the universe for the unforgivable, unpardonable crime of killing Wick’s dog and stealing his car. To put it in Network terms, when snot-nosed Iosef and his boys killed Wick’s dog, they meddled with the primal forces of nature, and Wick quite simply is not having it.

(Photo by David Lee/Summit Entertainment)

The genius of John Wick lies in its tough-guy minimalism.

Derek Kolstad’s crackerjack screenplay is as notable for all of the things that aren’t said as it is for the few things that are. It boldly and brazenly eschews exposition — the elaborate backstories and speeches and arbitrary love interest and all of the other crap that makes action movies so forgettable and interchangeable — so that it can focus monomaniacally on all the things that make action movies awesome.

The film allows John Wick to remain a mystery throughout and surrounds him with characters who are every bit as enigmatic and tantalizingly unknowable as him. We learn, for example, almost nothing about the underworld figures played by the likes of heavyweights Willem Dafoe and Ian McShane, but the way they treat each other says more about them and the dark, ominous, honor-bound world they inhabit than reams of dialogue ever could. Because John Wick leaves so much unsaid, we don’t have any choice but to fill in the blanks.

These weary survivors flesh out the film’s vision of a criminal world that functions as an alternate universe that exists within our own world, complete with an elaborate code of ethics that, like everything else in the film, is never explicitly spelled out. This shadow world has gods and demons and legends of their own, and John Wick qualifies as all three. He’s a righteous angel of vengeance.

The genius of John Wick — and I do not use that word lightly — lies in its tough-guy minimalism, in the way it strips the revenge melodrama down to its raw, potent core. That minimalism extends to the dialogue. The more Keanu Reeves says here, the less badass he seems. Thankfully he says almost nothing, so when he does speak it’s more forceful. Likewise, we don’t need to hear about what a force of nature John Wick is because it’s apparent in every punch, every kick, and every bad guy murdered; the film is admirably committed to showing rather than telling.

Just about the only time John Wick says more than is absolutely necessary is when he’s captured by Viggo and explains the urgency and necessity of his particular path. He describes what Daisy meant to him, how she gave him his first taste of hope in ages, only to have that hope extinguished by a bullet. In John Wick, the criminal world is no place for tourists: either you’re in the life 100 percent or you’re out completely.

John murders a small nation’s worth of glowering Russians over the course of the movie, so he’s not exactly tip-toeing shyly back into his old ways. Yet it isn’t until John is captured by Viggo and roped to a chair, when he tells him and his armed thugs, “People keep asking if I’m back and I haven’t really had an answer. But now, yeah, I’M THINKING I’M BACK!” that his bloody comeback becomes official.

(Photo by David Lee/Summit Entertainment)

There’s a Zen calm to John Wick that comes as much from the actor as the script.

Reeves delivers those instantly iconic lines with ragged breath and visceral, overpowering rage. Like Philip Seymour Hoffman in Mission Impossible 3, he’s a deadly threat to everyone around him even when bound and captured by his enemies.

But there’s a Zen calm to John Wick that comes as much from the actor as the script. Reeves possesses a sweetness and vulnerability that, in the past, has worked against his efforts to come across as tough and imposing. But that likability, as well as his androgynous good looks, makes it easy to buy the title character as a man who will never recover from the personal losses he’s suffered, no matter how many Russians he murders. Just as importantly, at this stage in his career, Reeves has the presence and physical chops to pull off playing this virtuoso of bloodshed, this Mozart of righteous mass murder. Style-wise, John Wick is a marvel of clean, unadorned efficiency. The film’s alternately black-grey and lurid neon color scheme and visceral brutality suggest Only God Forgives if Nicolas Winding-Refn’s film was intent on entertaining audiences rather than repulsing them.

The world of John Wick is full of mystery and empty spaces, so while the film is perfect in its own right, its universe begs to be expanded with sequels and a TV spin-off and graphic novels and comic books and novelizations. Accordingly, the sequel did even better with critics and audiences than the original film, and it seems like there’s an awful lot that can still be done with the character, as evidenced by plans for a John Wick TV series.

But why stop there? If any blood-splattered action movie franchise invited an officially licensed line of dog toys and bulletproof puppy vests, it’s this one. Hell, if Billy Jack got four movies, then John Wick deserves at least eight.

John Wick transformed Keanu Reeves (who had a little bit of success in action via the popular Matrix films) from a wannabe badass to the real thing. John Wick is the hero we need, and a hero for our times, even if we have done little, if anything, to deserve him.

Original Certification: Fresh
Tomatometer: 85 percent
Re-Certification: Fresh

Nathan Rabin is a freelance writer, columnist, the first head writer of The A.V. Club and the author of four books, most recently Weird Al: The Book (with “Weird Al” Yankovic) and You Don’t Know Me But You Don’t Like Me.

Follow Nathan on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

suspense Watching Series Lifetime Acorn TV Academy Awards Dark Horse Comics NBC The Walt Disney Company TCM RT21 composers romantic comedy spider-man USA Network zombies GoT Star Trek Election police drama sports TCA Mary Tyler Moore Opinion Fox News films chucky canceled The Witch Family Podcast Pacific Islander golden globe awards hollywood GIFs children's TV jurassic park blockbuster spanish Pirates psychological thriller serial killer Starz dogs adventure ghosts VICE renewed TV shows Fox Searchlight DC Universe crossover supernatural Rock Crunchyroll Alien Disney Plus Apple TV+ all-time A24 Image Comics Star Wars vampires romance Pop Nickelodeon Binge Guide stop motion Animation what to watch aliens Classic Film parents NBA james bond First Reviews Film Festival japanese Hear Us Out Summer toy story sag awards japan Tumblr period drama spy thriller Awards Tour Best and Worst streaming movies adenture worst Comic Book indiana jones OWN Exclusive Video Broadway Winners werewolf APB universal monsters BBC One SDCC criterion Interview 2018 Reality Competition award winner lord of the rings SundanceTV sitcom kaiju Black History Month Netflix Disney book Captain marvel Super Bowl Teen Country Spike comic Extras ABC Signature Film deadpool Pride Month football Lifetime Christmas movies australia halloween tv IFC Films foreign rt archives Certified Fresh quibi monster movies Brie Larson latino die hard Comedy spinoff elevated horror video on demand PaleyFest RT History 2019 Esquire prank Tarantino Spectrum Originals canceled TV shows American Society of Cinematographers TruTV Arrowverse HBO Syfy comedies toronto Television Critics Association Cartoon Network Trailer stand-up comedy Thanksgiving game of thrones Creative Arts Emmys nbcuniversal 93rd Oscars directors FX DC Comics Apple TV Plus Tubi wonder woman TV Land Horror Freeform Funimation 1990s Comic-Con@Home 2021 black crime drama french political drama Paramount Plus documentaries 72 Emmy Awards scene in color Stephen King Heroines screen actors guild FXX TV movies WarnerMedia Quiz YA Disney Channel Cannes NYCC best X-Men E! Baby Yoda ratings Sci-Fi target Christmas witnail Netflix Christmas movies diversity adaptation singing competition YouTube Red See It Skip It Character Guide technology CBS All Access razzies satire Set visit travel Marvel Television christmas movies Mindy Kaling Countdown Shondaland dramedy rotten joker Valentine's Day golden globes ABC Trivia tv talk fast and furious Sundance TV Pixar TCA Awards facebook docudrama Sundance First Look Cosplay Reality boxoffice venice CBS Grammys National Geographic Marathons LGBTQ Writers Guild of America Sony Pictures Legendary psycho Superheroes San Diego Comic-Con based on movie Action television VOD Fall TV HBO Max binge worst movies Winter TV medical drama Paramount Network cancelled 4/20 politics The Academy FX on Hulu MCU disaster harry potter south america trailers USA cults documentary TBS Hulu unscripted halloween war Song of Ice and Fire GLAAD Warner Bros. 21st Century Fox Ovation Avengers comics nature docuseries obituary theme song crime thriller Tokyo Olympics high school 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards BAFTA Ellie Kemper ITV Nominations zombie TIFF Photos Vudu MSNBC ViacomCBS Infographic Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt MTV Trophy Talk 71st Emmy Awards BBC America cats Shudder Ghostbusters versus rotten movies we love Mary poppins casting Masterpiece transformers Rocketman twilight spain cinemax heist movie The CW superman legend 007 Comedy Central new zealand HBO Go Nat Geo cancelled television streaming Black Mirror cancelled TV series mockumentary TNT BBC Box Office hidden camera Crackle 20th Century Fox Food Network Oscars Musical sequel Superheroe Women's History Month breaking bad Elton John telelvision zero dark thirty international superhero PlayStation news DC streaming service slashers Emmy Nominations Anna Paquin Sundance Now ESPN game show Amazon sequels dragons new star wars movies CNN dc 99% 2016 Disney streaming service robots The Arrangement CW Seed TCA 2017 Pet Sematary dark Rocky IFC Amazon Prime Video discovery cops Universal anime YouTube emmy awards 2021 space Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Travel Channel godzilla Marvel Studios richard e. Grant blaxploitation women AMC 90s Kids & Family scorecard olympics mission: impossible kong spanish language strong female leads Chernobyl saw Calendar historical drama king kong Mudbound Lionsgate Pop TV biography Tomatazos LGBT Premiere Dates stoner Disney+ Disney Plus Music cartoon Britbox YouTube Premium festivals Epix hispanic green book Emmys TV One pirates of the caribbean DirecTV Fantasy Apple justice league basketball Endgame Marvel A&E History CMT live action festival Holiday blockbusters VH1 Turner Classic Movies natural history Amazon Prime 24 frames TLC E3 Spring TV BET Awards doctor who fresh Year in Review The Walking Dead kids SXSW Sneak Peek Martial Arts marvel cinematic universe cooking Schedule PBS asian-american teaser President critics BET Drama nfl mutant classics rom-coms dceu TV TV renewals italian DGA 2020 Awards independent scary movies Walt Disney Pictures ABC Family TCA Winter 2020 boxing science fiction Amazon Studios New York Comic Con movie animated know your critic Columbia Pictures aapi Red Carpet Mary Poppins Returns El Rey movies Musicals laika indie Comics on TV cars series new york Holidays Wes Anderson comic books Biopics Mystery remakes book adaptation Adult Swim comiccon Hallmark screenings batman revenge Polls and Games a nightmare on elm street Peacock 2015 Lucasfilm Showtime video thriller name the review finale cancelled TV shows FOX popular ID WGN Toys miniseries Western Television Academy Hallmark Christmas movies crime reboot Video Games The Purge Rom-Com OneApp social media talk show free movies Discovery Channel jamie lee curtis 45 true crime 2017 Turner Paramount Bravo Logo reviews anthology child's play hist concert franchise archives