When Is A DVD Worth $400? A Look At Criterion Collectibles

by | April 27, 2007 | Comments

When is a DVD worth $400? To DVD enthusiasts, it’s when said disc is a rare Criterion white-ring issue of Pier Pasolini‘s 1975 film "Salo," which can go for upwards of a few Benjamin Franklins in today’s collectors’ market.

You see, Criterion — that bastion of cinematic preservation bringing classic films, foreign titles, and director’s cuts to North American armchair cinephiles — has released over 300 titles in its 23-year reign as every movie fiend’s best friend. That oeuvre is composed nearly entirely of critical classics ("The Rock" and "Armageddon" notwithstanding) that usually sell for between $30 and $40 — until, that is, distribution rights to a film expire. Once a disc goes OOP (Out Of Print), its Criterion value shoots skyward.

Currently at least 18 Criterion titles have gone out of print; if one is so lucky as to own the Criterion issues of , say, "RoboCop," "This Is Spinal Tap," "Rebecca," or John Woo’s "The Killer," that DVD can be worth over $100 alone. (And if anyone has a Criterion copy of Perry Henzell’s "The Harder They Come," our own Tim Ryan may fork over a fortnight’s pay to get his hands on it.)

That isn’t to say these titles aren’t available in standard issues — you can find a non-Criterion (read: barebones) version of Pasolini’s "Salo" on EBay for the cost of $5.95. But as many cinema lovers know, when Criterion issues a DVD, it gives a film the royal treatment: movies presented in their original aspect ratios, in discs packed with in-depth special features and bonus materials.

Adding covetousness to the allure of OOP discs is the designation of the "white ring." Signifying a particular film’s limited Criterion release, a Criterion DVD bearing a frosted white center can boost a rare issue’s value into the realm of extreme cost. The white ring means hard-to-find. The white ring means expensive (that is, if you can find it for sale and verify its legitimacy). The mere mention of the white ring is enough to make any true DVD collector drool with desire, like a Pavlovian dog with a home video fetish.

Thus is born the $400 DVD. Arguably the most expensive disc these days is the Criterion issue of "Salo" (also known as "Salo, or the 120 Days of Sodom"), Pasolini’s 1975 film adapted from the Marquis de Sade’s satirical story of wealthy libertines holed up in a castle to defile and debauch a group of adolescent children. Pasolini transferred the story to a 1944 Fascist setting, but the graphic nature of the film’s numerous rape, sex and torture scenes led to widespread banning in multiple countries.

Released by Criterion in 1998, the DVD was only available a short time before licensing conflicts intervened and the edition was pulled. The desirable Criterion white ring edition of "Salo" is rumored to go for as much as $500 at times; one current EBay listing offers it for the Buy It Now price of $399.95.

However, the folks over at Criterion have announced that they’ve regained the rights and intend to re-release "Salo" sometime in 2007 (and in HD!), so you’d better hurry up and unload that cache of white ring "Salo" DVDs fast. (Incidentally, Criterion’s On Five blog is a great read for a behind-the-scenes look at the company’s goings-on, including their process for choosing cover art for Jules Dassin’s "Night And The City" and "Thieves’ Highway.")

Oh, and if anyone’s in the market for the entire Criterion Collection to date — 320 titles in all — get ready to fork over a cool $7,000 for the lot of ’em. (Hey, at least shipping is free!)

[Thanks to our great Forum members for bringing such interesting topics to mind!]

Tag Cloud

indiana jones Calendar Musicals Summer ITV Schedule book adaptation Fox Searchlight TV renewals renewed TV shows Video Games boxing zero dark thirty Election A24 Best Actor rt labs critics edition comic Universal Pictures scorecard Chernobyl Hallmark TV movies canceled japanese Comedy Central LGBT lord of the rings Pop name the review IFC Black History Month Tubi spider-man HBO Go 73rd Emmy Awards Apple TV+ Sundance Now dexter Anna Paquin Fall TV 4/20 Creative Arts Emmys Neflix Paramount Network Avengers christmas movies Amazon Prime blockbusters Fargo Rocketman Tomatazos TV One BAFTA Discovery Channel supernatural scary movies Mary Tyler Moore Lionsgate critic resources Disney vampires Television Critics Association Netflix Christmas movies war Acorn TV social media robots thriller Film Comic Book 2019 Nickelodeon pirates of the caribbean Red Carpet documentaries Kids & Family comiccon Stephen King basketball Broadway Heroines spanish golden globes Ovation independent dc superhero toy story AMC Plus Spike historical drama tv talk Best Actress Adult Swim YouTube Red comedies USA 45 Quiz black comedy Pride Month Star Wars mcc popular Character Guide SXSW 2022 what to watch versus comic book movies Christmas nature ESPN stop motion ViacomCBS Mary poppins AMC Premiere Dates concert streaming asian-american TLC Emmy Nominations diversity spy thriller History Winter TV Toys hollywood Grammys anime Pixar stand-up comedy romance video indie Spectrum Originals free movies Vudu screenings Sony Pictures The CW Writers Guild of America New York Comic Con Box Office GLAAD VOD art house SXSW sports Watching Series Syfy TV Land 72 Emmy Awards Turner Classic Movies Mary Poppins Returns cancelled biography Biopics BET Awards aliens hist Awards Tour cooking Epix franchise Sundance cartoon Chilling Adventures of Sabrina rotten movies we love Disney Channel Animation all-time RT21 godzilla Fantasy parents TCA 2017 sag awards werewolf spinoff Interview 24 frames singing competition Elton John animated Comedy SDCC Binge Guide Amazon Studios theme song CBS Trivia Warner Bros. ABC Family hispanic Baby Yoda 007 Captain marvel The Arrangement best olympics trailers BBC spanish language Black Mirror Brie Larson Sci-Fi APB Drama Best and Worst teaser zombies Turner debate james bond Trailer telelvision comic books Women's History Month justice league spider-verse serial killer Crackle adenture GIFs 79th Golden Globes Awards Classic Film new zealand new york 2016 festivals Exclusive Video japan Marathons adaptation king arthur television Freeform TCA The Academy TCM richard e. Grant TIFF know your critic quibi Oscar revenge comic book movie IFC Films 99% Lifetime Christmas movies joker news PaleyFest OneApp children's TV saw Arrowverse movie E! Oscars X-Men Marvel Television scene in color NBC 21st Century Fox rt labs criterion Alien Mystery YouTube Premium Britbox National Geographic aapi BBC America 1990s dramedy American Society of Cinematographers marvel comics fast and furious HBO Max Sundance TV Polls and Games RT History sequel transformers CBS All Access Teen TNT Reality Competition Tags: Comedy obi wan Lifetime natural history mob new star wars movies reboot Lucasfilm venice worst HFPA Emmys Best Picture films women Holiday breaking bad hispanic heritage month Starz Sneak Peek dogs Amazon cancelled television italian blockbuster Pop TV Year in Review miniseries MTV LGBTQ 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Bravo Winners The Witch Ellie Kemper NBA TCA Awards cults kaiju NYCC royal family Pet Sematary french The Walt Disney Company composers streaming movies Pacific Islander superman halloween tv Funimation nbcuniversal mutant Musical legend BBC One FXX Marvel Studios Cosplay Logo green book Set visit crime drama Amazon Prime Video DGA political drama obituary Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt TBS toronto Travel Channel San Diego Comic-Con true crime casting heist movie adventure hidden camera South by Southwest Film Festival dark 2018 dceu mission: impossible sequels Television Academy marvel cinematic universe 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies series 20th Century Fox ratings cops Super Bowl FX cars romantic comedy Tumblr Rom-Com cancelled TV shows international Trophy Talk comics Legendary rt archives CNN nfl finale chucky award winner Reality Country period drama politics feel good Comics on TV Spring TV Martial Arts First Reviews anthology Photos Fox News batman Image Comics football high school Pirates Best Director scary Awards Nominations king kong Cartoon Network sopranos VH1 screen actors guild harry potter Apple TV Plus festival game of thrones E3 Horror target facebook disaster DC Universe USA Network laika Certified Fresh cinemax 94th Oscars Apple Infographic game show cancelled TV series emmy awards classics razzies dreamworks YouTube live event directors Family live action El Rey science fiction posters 90s discovery critics The Purge Tarantino Disney+ Disney Plus Shondaland blaxploitation Disney streaming service crossover Prime Video young adult Crunchyroll Extras biopic OWN crime TV movies archives genre worst movies streamig trophy monster movies DC Comics spain zombie Cannes Mindy Kaling satire Paramount Plus Podcast cats remakes Nat Geo MSNBC australia video on demand jurassic park child's play President a nightmare on elm street DC streaming service Mudbound PlayStation BET 2020 dragons Walt Disney Pictures Dark Horse Comics black leaderboard wonder woman Rocky Action A&E elevated horror kids suspense ID 93rd Oscars docudrama Food Network Countdown universal monsters strong female leads medical drama mockumentary unscripted book Instagram Live halloween IMDb TV PBS ABC YA ghosts Thanksgiving Rock Hollywood Foreign Press Association binge slasher prank Superheroes psycho Academy Awards latino VICE Esquire Song of Ice and Fire witnail Wes Anderson fresh Tokyo Olympics WGN south america kong boxoffice Netflix based on movie docuseries Western police drama space DirecTV FX on Hulu First Look Universal Comic-Con@Home 2021 Superheroe Valentine's Day Ghostbusters Opinion die hard Endgame Showtime crime thriller travel gangster ABC Signature WarnerMedia Disney Plus 2015 deadpool sitcom Star Trek SundanceTV FOX Marvel MCU reviews vs. doctor who GoT The Walking Dead slashers CW Seed jamie lee curtis twilight stoner Hear Us Out 2021 talk show golden globe awards HBO canceled TV shows documentary technology action-comedy foreign Music Peacock CMT 2017 Holidays TruTV Hulu Shudder Film Festival rotten Columbia Pictures See It Skip It psychological thriller rom-coms Masterpiece Paramount TCA Winter 2020 MGM