When Is A DVD Worth $400? A Look At Criterion Collectibles

by | April 27, 2007 | Comments

When is a DVD worth $400? To DVD enthusiasts, it’s when said disc is a rare Criterion white-ring issue of Pier Pasolini‘s 1975 film "Salo," which can go for upwards of a few Benjamin Franklins in today’s collectors’ market.

You see, Criterion — that bastion of cinematic preservation bringing classic films, foreign titles, and director’s cuts to North American armchair cinephiles — has released over 300 titles in its 23-year reign as every movie fiend’s best friend. That oeuvre is composed nearly entirely of critical classics ("The Rock" and "Armageddon" notwithstanding) that usually sell for between $30 and $40 — until, that is, distribution rights to a film expire. Once a disc goes OOP (Out Of Print), its Criterion value shoots skyward.

Currently at least 18 Criterion titles have gone out of print; if one is so lucky as to own the Criterion issues of , say, "RoboCop," "This Is Spinal Tap," "Rebecca," or John Woo’s "The Killer," that DVD can be worth over $100 alone. (And if anyone has a Criterion copy of Perry Henzell’s "The Harder They Come," our own Tim Ryan may fork over a fortnight’s pay to get his hands on it.)

That isn’t to say these titles aren’t available in standard issues — you can find a non-Criterion (read: barebones) version of Pasolini’s "Salo" on EBay for the cost of $5.95. But as many cinema lovers know, when Criterion issues a DVD, it gives a film the royal treatment: movies presented in their original aspect ratios, in discs packed with in-depth special features and bonus materials.

Adding covetousness to the allure of OOP discs is the designation of the "white ring." Signifying a particular film’s limited Criterion release, a Criterion DVD bearing a frosted white center can boost a rare issue’s value into the realm of extreme cost. The white ring means hard-to-find. The white ring means expensive (that is, if you can find it for sale and verify its legitimacy). The mere mention of the white ring is enough to make any true DVD collector drool with desire, like a Pavlovian dog with a home video fetish.

Thus is born the $400 DVD. Arguably the most expensive disc these days is the Criterion issue of "Salo" (also known as "Salo, or the 120 Days of Sodom"), Pasolini’s 1975 film adapted from the Marquis de Sade’s satirical story of wealthy libertines holed up in a castle to defile and debauch a group of adolescent children. Pasolini transferred the story to a 1944 Fascist setting, but the graphic nature of the film’s numerous rape, sex and torture scenes led to widespread banning in multiple countries.

Released by Criterion in 1998, the DVD was only available a short time before licensing conflicts intervened and the edition was pulled. The desirable Criterion white ring edition of "Salo" is rumored to go for as much as $500 at times; one current EBay listing offers it for the Buy It Now price of $399.95.

However, the folks over at Criterion have announced that they’ve regained the rights and intend to re-release "Salo" sometime in 2007 (and in HD!), so you’d better hurry up and unload that cache of white ring "Salo" DVDs fast. (Incidentally, Criterion’s On Five blog is a great read for a behind-the-scenes look at the company’s goings-on, including their process for choosing cover art for Jules Dassin’s "Night And The City" and "Thieves’ Highway.")

Oh, and if anyone’s in the market for the entire Criterion Collection to date — 320 titles in all — get ready to fork over a cool $7,000 for the lot of ’em. (Hey, at least shipping is free!)

[Thanks to our great Forum members for bringing such interesting topics to mind!]

Tag Cloud

Watching Series Hallmark Christmas movies harry potter Oscars Peacock VOD vampires Spectrum Originals video TNT Mary poppins DGA Emmy Nominations DC streaming service cars cops Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Studios Star Wars child's play discovery Sundance TV satire mockumentary name the review Summer Pop TV psychological thriller worst spinoff Year in Review A24 24 frames Turner Classic Movies game of thrones OWN 45 films Spike Sundance miniseries Trailer Pirates Nominations documentary nbcuniversal asian-american Sci-Fi sequel 2017 GLAAD YouTube Red Esquire concert comedies sag awards Captain marvel composers Vudu ghosts BAFTA 2018 thriller Starz spider-man PaleyFest NYCC spy thriller screenings E3 2020 BBC America Funimation Tubi psycho ABC Family news anthology Rocketman IFC Films cancelled TV shows YouTube Kids & Family Mary Poppins Returns Sundance Now boxoffice Reality Competition BET El Rey zero dark thirty Musicals police drama Mindy Kaling cults TCA 2017 Avengers AMC casting universal monsters die hard Comedy TLC Awards Tour criterion Lucasfilm unscripted Pet Sematary foreign Star Trek Comic Book Reality tv talk Paramount Nickelodeon Travel Channel USA Network kids The CW christmas movies Television Critics Association Set visit Baby Yoda Animation joker MSNBC dragons Fox News Grammys Awards Amazon Prime E! cooking Mudbound TCA comics free movies Action rotten movies we love Super Bowl Winners CBS zombies medical drama Marvel Studios Pride Month Food Network 72 Emmy Awards Amazon Prime Video biography Holiday RT History NBC FX talk show Christmas robots television Netflix Best and Worst Podcast blockbuster reboot Pixar Shondaland PlayStation Music FOX DC Comics Infographic Election Crackle fast and furious nature spanish language SDCC game show Emmys Amazon Adult Swim aliens 2019 Stephen King series Holidays BET Awards Fantasy Anna Paquin Shudder Writers Guild of America Lionsgate The Purge Arrowverse Tarantino Marvel Television National Geographic TV anime Trivia A&E Ovation Marvel dark American Society of Cinematographers critics golden globes YA Winter TV HBO Go political drama directors period drama Black Mirror Britbox crime 21st Century Fox San Diego Comic-Con Fall TV LGBTQ dceu parents chucky halloween CMT mission: impossible MTV Logo Musical Cannes witnail The Arrangement war dc Red Carpet DC Universe Columbia Pictures TCA Winter 2020 cartoon singing competition VH1 Biopics 71st Emmy Awards hispanic Endgame adaptation Hear Us Out Film Freeform Showtime all-time Lifetime Christmas movies Hulu historical drama Apple TV+ cancelled TV series batman festivals serial killer VICE Interview Lifetime book based on movie Disney sitcom YouTube Premium Television Academy blaxploitation Song of Ice and Fire slashers Apple cats movies Superheroes superhero crime thriller Binge Guide supernatural Rom-Com social media dramedy ESPN Hallmark emmy awards rotten independent APB Mary Tyler Moore X-Men Video Games award winner Heroines green book Quiz werewolf hist Women's History Month crossover Walt Disney Pictures FXX Elton John Acorn TV Paramount Network disaster finale movie CBS All Access Marathons mutant canceled TV shows stop motion true crime Opinion Tumblr children's TV Bravo quibi Disney Channel Mystery stoner sports Family First Look elevated horror 2016 Sneak Peek Epix Cosplay CNN Netflix Christmas movies transformers Martial Arts Countdown Comics on TV latino science fiction SundanceTV PBS Sony Pictures adventure Apple TV Plus comic natural history docudrama renewed TV shows Toys Superheroe Disney streaming service Trophy Talk Tomatazos FX on Hulu Ellie Kemper Masterpiece TruTV spain First Reviews The Witch canceled Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Academy Awards HBO Warner Bros. zombie TBS revenge USA comiccon strong female leads reviews travel breaking bad Classic Film Polls and Games crime drama Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Rocky GoT binge cancelled Disney Plus Film Festival ratings screen actors guild Country Calendar versus TV Land CW Seed theme song Character Guide richard e. Grant TV renewals Rock Box Office twilight TCA Awards Spring TV New York Comic Con IFC BBC Thanksgiving President politics Dark Horse Comics The Walking Dead ITV WarnerMedia Pop Ghostbusters franchise romantic comedy Nat Geo indie DirecTV Extras See It Skip It dogs video on demand Western Certified Fresh diversity Syfy justice league SXSW cancelled television what to watch obituary documentaries MCU Crunchyroll toy story RT21 Photos stand-up comedy streaming TCM indiana jones Chernobyl technology romance laika teaser HBO Max Turner GIFs Teen facebook 20th Century Fox ABC space Cartoon Network Schedule Universal scary movies History Brie Larson animated Drama Horror Discovery Channel BBC One OneApp 4/20 WGN classics 007 doctor who Black History Month best hollywood Comedy Central Disney+ Disney Plus cinemax jamie lee curtis south america TIFF LGBT Premiere Dates 2015 a nightmare on elm street Valentine's Day