News

Westworld First Reviews: Season 3 Gives Series a Clunky Blade Runner Makeover

HBO's sci-fi horror tale sheds some of its previous story's gravitas in its return, offering audiences a high-tech popcorn-thriller instead.

by | March 6, 2020 | Comments

It’s been nearly two years since the second season of Westworld premiered to HBO and a lot has changed. When we last checked in with the series, which was created by Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan and inspired by Michael Crichton’s 1973 film of the same name, Dolores (Evan Rachel Wood) and Maeve (Thandie Newton), two robot characters who were initially programmed to bend at the whims of the park’s uber-rich clientele, had become fully sentient with violent results.

Blind with vengeful rage, Dolores went on a murderous rampage. Before ultimately escaping the confines of the Westworld theme park, the killer host pillaged The Forge, the supercomputer holding all of the guest data the Delos corporation had been secretly stealing.  She caused a flood, deleted a whole lot of those data pearls in the process, and installed her consciousness into the host replica of new Delos boss Charlotte Hale (Tessa Thompson) before heading into the Valley Beyond.


Photograph by John P. Johnson/HBO Thandie Newton HBO Westworld Season 3 - Episode 1

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

Things for former brothel owner Maeve went a different direction, entirely. After her glitch woke her up, the sentient host infiltrated the inner-workings of the park, enlisting Hector, Armistice and the rest of their outlaw gang, as well as Head of Narrative Design, Lee Sizemore,  to help in the search of her long lost daughter. Unfortunately for her, as she closed in on reuniting with the girl, Delores and Bernard (Jeffrey Wright) rained hell upon the park, leaving Maeve shot. As she bled out, she watched her daughter exit the park for greener digital pastures with Native American host Akecheta (Zahn McClarnon).

Discovering they were just pawns in a greater reality out-of-their reach is ultimately what drove each character’s journey after their awakening was complete. For Bernard, the right-hand to park-creator Dr. Robert Ford (Anthony Hopkins), his realization that he was a synthetic being this whole time — one who was created by Ford in the image of his former partner — was one of the show’s big reveals in its first season. This twist (and there were many) led Bernard to enable Dolores on her bloody journey all while attempting to pick up his own mental pieces, while he fell into an identity crisis, of sorts.


Photograph by John P. Johnson/HBO Tessa Thompson HBO Westworld Season 3 - Episode 1

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

The HBO series delved further the white hat vs. black hat morality play originally introduced in season 1. It also filled in the blanks regarding the political drama unfolding behind the scenes within Delos. Less-than-savory struggles lie behind the character motivations of Charlotte, Dr. Ford’s tenacious young replacement, and Delos investor William (Jimmi Simpson) who evolved into the Man in Black (Ed Harris), the coldhearted gunslinger hell-bent on burning the whole park to the ground.

The series, which puts the concepts of free will, corporate greed, and a towering god complex in a blender, gave viewers plenty of answers in the season 2 finale, only to lead us to many more questions once it all ended. Needless to say, ahead of its highly-anticipated return, which takes the story outside of the confines of the park and adds Aaron Paul (Breaking Bad) to the mix, expectations are running high. Does the new season live up to the hype? Here’s what the critics have to say:


SEASON 3 IS A SLICK-LOOKING CYBERPUNK REBOOT

Aaron Paul, Lena Waithe, Marshawn Lynch HBO Westworld Season 3 - Episode 1 (John P. Johnson/HBO)

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

Ironically, the best part of Westworld Season 3 might be those overwhelming visual tableaus: the spectacular shots of a copter floating over a metropolis, the romantic European vistas of Maeve’s WWII world, and even the intimate hell that Caleb is going through. Westworld doesn’t just try to show us a haunted vision of the future, but it immerses us in it. — Meghan O’Keefe, Decider

Time has passed since the end of season 2, and we find Dolores dealing with her new life in the outside world. In Los Angeles, everything looks like Tesla’s version of Blade Runner, with Cybertruck police cars carving up a clean, Japan-inspired city. — Jennifer Bisset, CNET

Ironically, the best part of Westworld Season 3 might be those overwhelming visual tableaus: the spectacular shots of a copter floating over a metropolis, the romantic European vistas of Maeve’s WWII world, and even the intimate hell that Caleb is going through. Westworld doesn’t just try to show us a haunted vision of the future, but it immerses us in it. — Meghan O’Keefe, Decider


THIS NEW COAT OF PAINT CAN’T COVER UP SOME CLUNKY STORYTELLING

Westworld wants to generate another existential conversation in Season 3, but even as the show swaps settings and introduces new faces, the details that make it come to life are perfunctory. — Brandon Katz, Observer

Action scenes are slick and easy-to-track, but they’re also detached, lacking the gleeful turns and grand lines that punctuated similar thrills from previous seasons. Backstory that used to be unveiled with a flourish is delivered sans showmanship, which can be refreshing when the new intel doesn’t warrant a whole to-do, but only contributes further to the new season’s straightforward execution. — Ben Travers, IndieWire

Perhaps the flatness of its new setting might have served, or might eventually serve in the season’s second half, as ironic counterpoint: The peculiarity of the robot uprising exists against a backdrop so flat and familiar as to make it all the more intriguing. But what tends to happen instead is that the flatness inflects every corner of the story and sucks away the vibrancy. — Daniel D’Addario, Variety

‘Westworld’ returns with the batteries charged in an energetic start.
Alberto Carlos, Espinof


DOLORES IS A VENGEFUL ROBOT WORTH ROOTING FOR

Photograph by John P. Johnson/HBO Evan Rachel Wood HBO Westworld Season 3 - Episode 1

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

Season 3 Dolores is a vast upgrade. She’s pissed off, but not blindly ruthless. She’s bent on giving humans what she thinks they deserve, but smart enough to know this world doesn’t operate like Westworld did. This is the kind of Dolores she should have been all along: a victim you feel empathy for with a cause worth fighting for — she’s seen the worst that humans can be and believes her kind is the next step in evolution. She’s not a one-note horseman of the robo-apocalypse. — Tim Surette, TV Guide

Dolores has often been a difficult character to track thanks to her regular identity crises, veering between damsel-in-distress and utterly unsympathetic villain, but in the third season, she finally seems to have hit a pleasant and steady middle-ground. We don’t fully know Dolores’ endgame, but we do know the ruthlessness with which she’ll pursue it and the remarkable capabilities she possesses to see it through. — Haleigh Fouch, Collider


AARON PAUL’S PERFORMANCE IS … FINE

Aaron Paul in Westworld season 3 (John P. Johnson/HBO)

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

Adding Paul as a new main character seems novel at first, but he quickly takes a backseat to everything else. — Chris Evangelista, SlashFilm

Aaron Paul walks sadly around a skyglass futuretropolis waiting for a popular smartphone app to assign him ATM robberies. — Darren Franich, EW


IT’S STILL COOL AND QUITE CONFUSING

Photograph by John P. Johnson/HBO Marshawn Lynch HBO Westworld Season 3 - Episode 1

(Photo by John P. Johnson/HBO)

There’s still plenty to be confused about. Westworld is 100% back on its bullshit and, depending on how much you like your TV to be a rug-yanking crash course in skepticism, still presents beautiful illusion after beautiful illusion for you to doubt. — Jacob Oller, Paste Magazine

All of the standard questions Westworld brings up in viewers remain: Is this person real or a host? Is this something happening now, or a flashback or flash forward? What exactly is reality, anyway? If something feels real, and affects someone like a real trauma, does that mean it’s real even if it takes place in a virtual playground? — Ron Hogan, Den of Geek

Expect the passions around “Westworld” to erupt once again when Season 3 arrives, confusion reigns and the series’ fans and detractors face off to defend their side. — Lorraine Ali, Los Angeles Times

Westworld season 3 premieres on Sunday, March 15 at 9 p.m. ET/PT on HBO.

Westworld: Season 3 (2020)
73%

#1
Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Westworld successfully reboots itself by broadening its scope while tightening its storytelling clarity -- although some may feel that the soul has been stripped from this machine in the process.

Tag Cloud

Comic-Con@Home 2021 Box Office superhero Horror spider-man finale BET Image Comics 2015 Tags: Comedy Broadway criterion AMC Plus Binge Guide Shondaland Tokyo Olympics critics razzies Character Guide Apple TV+ Tumblr doctor who RT21 Marvel The Purge Infographic summer TV scene in color film series teaser Focus Features Exclusive Video book Superheroe Year in Review Tubi APB Super Bowl halloween Acorn TV worst movies talk show MGM crime free movies The CW Mary Poppins Returns YouTube Premium GLAAD Rock vs. Sony Pictures Amazon Prime Star Wars Celebration king kong universal monsters Trivia scary movies Hallmark Christmas movies Watching Series DGA Walt Disney Pictures Television Critics Association mockumentary Baby Yoda Cosplay zombies science fiction Schedule VICE true crime Esquire Fall TV Animation Holidays Spectrum Originals TV Land scene in color SDCC comedies Fantasy Paramount Pictures cats spy thriller live event Instagram Live joker Oscar comic book movies obituary Dark Horse Comics strong female leads comic TruTV breaking bad BBC One jamie lee curtis laika SXSW 2022 Warner Bros. 20th Century Fox archives AMC romance Avengers TBS kong adenture Spring TV sequel The Walking Dead festivals Logo serial killer documentary emmy awards fresh Countdown mcc WGN japan Western Britbox dark TCA Awards Elton John natural history green book dexter 90s Best Actor know your critic discovery OneApp TV renewals NBC obi wan Crackle 73rd Emmy Awards comic books Quiz 4/20 leaderboard Adult Swim Certified Fresh docuseries child's play MTV First Look 45 aliens RT History PlayStation ViacomCBS canceled TV shows new zealand live action Lucasfilm comiccon Hollywood Foreign Press Association rotten lord of the rings politics richard e. Grant docudrama binge godzilla dragons asian-american crime drama TV remakes latino Native Masterpiece ghosts Geeked Week Sci-Fi movie batman stop motion The Witch Classic Film streaming movies Musical adaptation game of thrones golden globes Summer IMDb TV Ovation comics Hulu Interview Stephen King TIFF Endgame biopic kaiju cancelled TV shows jurassic park HBO animated Biopics australia Tarantino CBS All Access cults mission: impossible hispanic Film Festival nature The Academy A&E nbcuniversal Nat Geo tv talk historical drama YouTube Photos TV movies National Geographic streamig Neflix halloween tv movies ITV Musicals PBS debate FX films football 24 frames DC Comics Netflix Crunchyroll FOX Sundance ABC Signature Fox Searchlight summer TV preview romantic comedy Travel Channel Marvel Studios spanish language DirecTV Lifetime Christmas movies thriller SundanceTV Pop FX on Hulu Alien rt labs critics edition Extras Women's History Month Universal Television Academy reviews CNN rotten movies we love 2019 HBO Go quibi series Paramount Plus Toys MCU cancelled stoner Universal Pictures prank IFC Films Netflix Christmas movies elevated horror facebook twilight Black History Month Indigenous based on movie video political drama concert dogs mutant 93rd Oscars IFC action-comedy Sony San Diego Comic-Con golden globe awards Awards Tour high school Best Actress 79th Golden Globes Awards Cannes TCA Winter 2020 suspense Disney TNT dramedy critic resources screen actors guild cartoon black comedy marvel cinematic universe Showtime blockbuster werewolf video on demand Anna Paquin Holiday fast and furious Rom-Com Star Trek USA 99% Syfy popular saw stand-up comedy sopranos interviews franchise Wes Anderson award winner olympics Song of Ice and Fire Kids & Family satire sports Fargo new york worst cooking scene in color series 21st Century Fox venice cancelled television james bond blaxploitation justice league royal family Mary Tyler Moore Sneak Peek ABC Family legend casting war 007 Apple TV Plus cops Ellie Kemper 2017 comic book movie Mary poppins parents japanese Red Carpet south america spain Paramount Shudder vampires indiana jones theme song 72 Emmy Awards Country The Arrangement TCA Family Action new star wars movies feel good A24 Nickelodeon rt archives crossover what to watch TCM boxing target scene in color X-Men Arrowverse french 71st Emmy Awards Pride Month Star Wars technology BET Awards Opinion Disney+ Disney Plus travel Nominations space LGBT Rocky police drama nfl YA Lifetime cancelled TV series ratings USA Network Bravo Best and Worst screenings Cartoon Network Paramount Network chucky Pacific Islander trailers The Walt Disney Company Tomatazos Legendary Sundance TV VOD Captain marvel TV One book adaptation El Rey VH1 1990s gangster Creative Arts Emmys 2016 Teen genre disaster young adult Prime Video broadcast Election international superman E3 Disney Plus Comics on TV Freeform MSNBC GoT mob foreign Ghostbusters social media 2021 zero dark thirty NYCC Reality Competition Fox News aapi reboot rt labs diversity canceled ID king arthur Emmys First Reviews CMT CW Seed WarnerMedia kids game show Martial Arts Mindy Kaling Peacock Winners 2020 GIFs scorecard Winter TV deadpool renewed TV shows PaleyFest Amazon Prime Video Turner Classic Movies Grammys Hallmark monster movies all-time Heroines revenge adventure Mystery directors transformers cinemax children's TV 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Apple History NBA harry potter Vudu Pop TV dreamworks Video Games posters composers Reality psychological thriller Best Director Podcast Food Network documentaries Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Pirates cars hispanic heritage month toronto dceu anime Writers Guild of America miniseries Comedy Central Epix Comic Book Set visit Rocketman Disney Channel indie BAFTA South by Southwest Film Festival women boxoffice basketball blockbusters psycho Awards television FXX anthology medical drama Comedy HFPA Starz die hard See It Skip It TLC slashers Chernobyl Christmas Amazon CBS Sundance Now slasher sitcom 94th Oscars Drama Funimation sequels spinoff Pet Sematary Trophy Talk dc versus heist movie BBC America Oscars Hear Us Out toy story Pixar Academy Awards Black Mirror Emmy Nominations Music hist LGBTQ robots telelvision spider-verse art house HBO Max Polls and Games Trailer rom-coms American Society of Cinematographers E! zombie marvel comics DC Universe hollywood Spike trophy unscripted best Marathons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt black Columbia Pictures pirates of the caribbean YouTube Red classics TCA 2017 BBC Premiere Dates singing competition streaming ESPN name the review SXSW Thanksgiving festival news italian independent Superheroes Amazon Studios supernatural target Mudbound crime thriller Brie Larson Film Lionsgate ABC Disney streaming service wonder woman DC streaming service Marvel Television summer preview OWN Best Picture Turner Valentine's Day Calendar a nightmare on elm street sag awards period drama President witnail 2018 hidden camera biography Discovery Channel spanish scary New York Comic Con christmas movies