TORONTO: "The Wind That Shakes the Barley" Review

by | September 7, 2006 | Comments

The leftfield winner of the Palme D’Or at Cannes, "The Wind That Shakes the Barley" tells the story of a group of Irish Republican Army members during the heady moments when Ireland was on the cusp of independence from Britain. But while there is much to admire here, the film, screening at the Toronto International Film Festival, lacks the visceral impact to really work as a whole.

The story begins with Damien (Cillian Murphy, excellent as always) preparing to go to medical school in London when a friend is killed by the British for mouthing off. He decides to stay and join his brother Teddy (Pádraic Delaney) and a group of friends in an armed rebellion. The occupying forces hold the Irish in utter contempt (Roger Allam, the fascist TV commentator in "V For Vendetta" and effectively nasty here as a British official, refers to the Emerald Isle as a "priest-infested backwater").

Director Ken Loach has an excellent eye for period detail, and the film has a wonderful sense of the bonds (and fissures) within the community. Damien’s romance with the politically sympathetic Sinead (Orla Fitzgerald) is poignant and uncertain. "Wind" also bristles with the vagaries of about the political and social situation. An attempt to start an independent court devolves into an ideological shouting match in its first session, and the fledgling soldiers must deal with the repercussions of going into battle with family and friends; in some cases, their actions are as ignoble as those they claim to be against. And the breathtaking green vistas, the battleground for this guerilla war, are beautiful and ominous in equal measure.

And yet, in the end, there’s something missing from "Wind" that keeps it from resonating as it should. Once a peace treaty is signed between Ireland and Britain, the film becomes far less involving. Characters become mouthpieces for lengthy political dissertations rather than people with resonant convictions, and much of the historical background is handled by having someone burst into a room with important news. There’s something deflating about witnessing a film establish such a strong tone only to get bogged down into what ends up seeming like a contentious meeting of the planning board.

"The Wind That Shakes the Barley" is not a bad film, but had it maintained the elegiac tone of its early scenes, it could have been more than just a history lesson.

"The Wind That Shakes The Barley" is currently at 60 percent on the Tomatmeter; some critics have praised the film’s atmosphere and performances, while others say it lacks the human touch of Loach’s best work.

Tag Cloud

FXX police drama period drama OWN series DC Comics Election Holidays Sundance Now teaser comiccon HBO Go toy story Apple TV+ book finale YouTube Drama BBC Paramount Network DC Universe Disney APB Baby Yoda Superheroe TBS rotten romance 2020 ghosts dramedy supernatural elevated horror cooking award winner WGN VH1 TNT sports Chernobyl Crackle joker Trailer Teen unscripted medical drama children's TV dark Marathons science fiction ABC Family slashers animated Set visit Film Festival Winners TLC MTV talk show YouTube Premium Tarantino Awards movies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Music E! comics Musicals YA Cartoon Network adventure diversity Biopics Peacock docudrama natural history Sony Pictures CBS All Access cancelled TV shows composers Film Disney Plus spanish language comic WarnerMedia MCU what to watch twilight NYCC space crossover Oscars blockbuster canceled mission: impossible game show game of thrones mutant Pop PaleyFest Trivia video BBC One universal monsters MSNBC romantic comedy Western Amazon Prime Schedule 20th Century Fox spider-man Fantasy franchise Stephen King cartoon ESPN emmy awards Ellie Kemper Hallmark Apple technology fast and furious binge Valentine's Day Year in Review facebook Columbia Pictures SDCC PBS Lifetime TCA 2017 TCA Winter 2020 renewed TV shows best social media Fox News thriller Hallmark Christmas movies Logo IFC festivals Lionsgate Funimation American Society of Cinematographers DGA OneApp Paramount Sundance Esquire Adult Swim cancelled television Best and Worst 2016 TV sequel Lucasfilm Hulu Discovery Channel news Country TV Land war Winter TV Superheroes Captain marvel stand-up comedy witnail kids Travel Channel foreign indiana jones Kids & Family TCA The Purge 2019 Trophy Talk criterion Ghostbusters IFC Films Brie Larson Sci-Fi spinoff cars Rock Bravo RT21 Podcast cops Amazon Prime Video 45 Marvel Studios dragons TruTV Amazon Tumblr FX on Hulu television LGBT BET Awards strong female leads NBC RT History Interview casting versus halloween hist Britbox Classic Film anime classics dceu VOD Shudder Comedy Sundance TV X-Men San Diego Comic-Con theme song Amazon Studios A24 2018 Mary Poppins Returns Women's History Month AMC miniseries spain TIFF rotten movies we love Arrowverse Starz worst sequels Black Mirror sitcom Anna Paquin psycho Nickelodeon Reality obituary zombie Opinion Black History Month Mudbound Mary Tyler Moore crime drama Hear Us Out Showtime hollywood Television Academy Horror Character Guide transformers nature The Witch Reality Competition richard e. Grant TCM Crunchyroll 007 DC streaming service name the review satire asian-american zombies sag awards Comic Book travel Star Trek werewolf National Geographic Disney Channel Mindy Kaling E3 The Arrangement Avengers laika Cosplay Star Wars comedies Rocketman video on demand robots Creative Arts Emmys President hispanic mockumentary directors south america Emmy Nominations golden globes History green book nbcuniversal 2015 SundanceTV Food Network Apple TV Plus Polls and Games chucky A&E based on movie GoT political drama quibi Photos Freeform scary movies 71st Emmy Awards Spring TV revenge harry potter Masterpiece Comedy Central Academy Awards 24 frames Emmys Animation TCA Awards Tomatazos First Look stop motion christmas movies dogs Extras Action BBC America Nat Geo blaxploitation 4/20 Binge Guide El Rey psychological thriller HBO BET documentaries GIFs Acorn TV Mystery FOX cancelled Mary poppins USA Network discovery Nominations dc Family films spy thriller Syfy LGBTQ serial killer VICE child's play boxoffice canceled TV shows Certified Fresh historical drama Walt Disney Pictures Marvel Television zero dark thirty Rom-Com Cannes Marvel disaster BAFTA movie New York Comic Con Thanksgiving Ovation Spike politics The Walking Dead The CW 72 Emmy Awards Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt GLAAD cats ITV anthology Fall TV critics USA HBO Max crime thriller Pixar Shondaland Countdown Toys Holiday Red Carpet Writers Guild of America FX CMT biography screenings CBS TV renewals jamie lee curtis batman Super Bowl Dark Horse Comics Vudu die hard Pop TV Pet Sematary Awards Tour Turner crime all-time CNN Rocky singing competition SXSW documentary 2017 latino free movies Epix indie CW Seed First Reviews Summer Universal See It Skip It reboot stoner breaking bad tv talk Comics on TV independent parents Calendar superhero Endgame Netflix Christmas movies justice league Video Games Warner Bros. true crime Disney+ Disney Plus ratings 21st Century Fox Disney streaming service concert reviews Lifetime Christmas movies vampires ABC doctor who Musical Pirates Turner Classic Movies Martial Arts Infographic Spectrum Originals Elton John Quiz streaming YouTube Red Television Critics Association cults Pride Month Box Office Sneak Peek aliens Netflix Christmas Song of Ice and Fire Grammys PlayStation Watching Series Heroines a nightmare on elm street DirecTV adaptation screen actors guild Premiere Dates cinemax cancelled TV series Tubi