Toronto Film Fest: The Good, The Bad, and The Better So Far

A short roundup of some of the fest's flicks.

by | September 11, 2007 | Comments

Well, it certainly hasn’t been a dull festival. Tons of films big (Michael Clayton) and small (Juno) have screened to kudos, and on the whole there haven’t been very many outright disappointments (notwithstanding George Romero‘s Diary of the Dead and a few others).

It’s now a week into the Toronto Film Festival, and we definitely have our favorites. They include, in no particular order: the Ian Curtis biopic Control, the quirky teen comedy Juno, Lars and the Real Girl starring Ryan Gosling, and Julie Taymor‘s ambitious Beatles-infused Across the Universe. Many other entries are good as well (No Country for Old Men, Michael Clayton, Lust, Caution, Disengagement). A few in particular are unconventionally enjoyable (Sukiyaki Western Django, Nothing is Private).


Across the Universe

I just came from a press screening of Brian DePalma‘s Redacted, anticipation of which stemmed from its second-place showing last week at the Venice Film Festival (where Ang Lee‘s Lust, Caution took the Golden Lion prize). With an unconventional format that combines a French-narrated faux-documentary, a deployed soldier’s home videos, local Arab television reports and fictional video-hosting websites, Redacted tells the (based-on-a-true) story of a group of U.S. Army soldiers involved in the rape and murder of an Iraqi girl. DePalma’s film is at least rife with meaning, though there are so many divisive issues concerning Iraq in Redacted that it’s hard to know where to start. Are U.S. peace-keeping procedures dangerously confusing to Iraqis? Does mutual misunderstanding often lead to tragic civilian casualties? Do the media keep the rest of us adequately informed about a war that is happening on the other side of the world? Redacted is likely to split critics (one journalist warned me off, calling it straight-up “bad,” while a smattering of applause erupted at the end of my screening).

Plenty of other films have gotten mixed receptions as well. Julie Taymor notoriously battled with studio execs over her Across the Universe, which combines a 1960s-1970s love story with historical events, all set to a near non-stop soundtrack of Beatles songs. Sound good to you, fellas? Unsurprisingly, Across the Universe seems to leave many male reviewers cold, while women (and predisposed lovers of musicals) enjoy it much more. The film is out in limited release this week. Full review to come!

Speaking of high profile cinematic gambles, I’m headed out to the late night screening of Todd HaynesI’m Not There. Cate Blanchett nabbed Venice honors for her portrayal of Bob Dylan; six more actors take on different aspects of the legendary musician’s life and persona, including Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, and Richard Gere. More on that very shortly.

Tag Cloud

Lifetime Marathons political drama indiana jones Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt ESPN worst Arrowverse TNT Fox News YouTube Red Country parents Turner elevated horror scary movies USA Network New York Comic Con Star Trek Pirates nature Television Academy Horror 71st Emmy Awards Schedule Premiere Dates First Reviews RT History Tarantino Cartoon Network Pop Martial Arts franchise BET discovery war The Walking Dead Comedy DGA sequels child's play binge hispanic laika crime Dark Horse Comics Rocky Pop TV YouTube Pet Sematary First Look Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Apple TV+ Comedy Central Sneak Peek Pixar FX Tubi Countdown BAFTA Britbox Black History Month Women's History Month TCA Stephen King critics Podcast DC Universe zero dark thirty Columbia Pictures Lucasfilm Universal Superheroes Ellie Kemper latino films Film 72 Emmy Awards IFC Films VH1 Grammys Lionsgate Binge Guide WGN Hear Us Out Cannes DC streaming service unscripted richard e. Grant dramedy spy thriller medical drama romance 007 asian-american talk show The Purge Winners satire VICE Amazon Studios Emmy Nominations Holiday superhero APB TV renewals jamie lee curtis Sci-Fi Superheroe Captain marvel San Diego Comic-Con docudrama psycho Best and Worst 21st Century Fox cults 24 frames Disney Plus dark The Witch game show TCA 2017 police drama golden globes Television Critics Association video on demand CW Seed universal monsters DC Comics festivals ABC hist kids El Rey Western Paramount social media SDCC cancelled cartoon psychological thriller theme song politics spinoff Spectrum Originals Animation period drama Apple TV Plus romantic comedy boxoffice Disney ghosts Tumblr diversity adventure National Geographic Warner Bros. space zombie children's TV Calendar reviews facebook Comics on TV HBO Max Heroines blaxploitation 2017 Esquire screenings toy story Sony Pictures versus History cancelled TV shows emmy awards 2018 Quiz Avengers spain Rock stand-up comedy X-Men anthology Watching Series reboot Hulu Crunchyroll stoner Syfy nbcuniversal spider-man indie TBS sag awards Marvel Television news adaptation TIFF Reality Competition award winner cancelled television TCM quibi all-time mutant Awards Tour technology disaster biography miniseries Fantasy OneApp Masterpiece ratings OWN Bravo harry potter spanish language finale cops NYCC WarnerMedia Netflix TV what to watch tv talk serial killer movies fast and furious comic streaming cars FX on Hulu GLAAD YA HBO thriller Anna Paquin Set visit 2020 Rocketman Marvel Studios twilight blockbuster 2019 joker NBC CMT dc supernatural Mary Poppins Returns Tomatazos teaser Opinion Travel Channel Pride Month Song of Ice and Fire Chernobyl travel SXSW ITV Holidays CBS ABC Family Polls and Games comiccon Endgame See It Skip It Paramount Network Extras A&E cooking 45 Trailer game of thrones HBO Go Teen doctor who Mudbound Epix Apple Mindy Kaling green book Box Office PaleyFest GoT President anime Photos singing competition Baby Yoda Academy Awards television Disney+ Disney Plus Funimation Musicals criterion stop motion Christmas historical drama sequel TCA Awards Rom-Com witnail mockumentary E! Freeform Logo transformers Food Network free movies 20th Century Fox series Classic Film TCA Winter 2020 Mary poppins Amazon revenge foreign Awards VOD MTV Amazon Prime Video Family die hard book CNN Crackle Brie Larson Musical video robots American Society of Cinematographers PlayStation sitcom Lifetime Christmas movies TruTV BBC One Drama cancelled TV series justice league natural history Music based on movie Elton John cats Sundance FOX Valentine's Day Kids & Family a nightmare on elm street 4/20 crossover FXX Ghostbusters TV Land Star Wars YouTube Premium LGBTQ Netflix Christmas movies slashers TLC Comic Book true crime Toys animated Red Carpet Spike Infographic Amazon Prime Hallmark Christmas movies The CW vampires aliens Emmys Year in Review BBC America breaking bad zombies Film Festival Adult Swim comedies christmas movies chucky Oscars Nickelodeon Summer Shondaland Vudu dragons Turner Classic Movies USA LGBT canceled TV shows DirecTV best Shudder concert crime drama independent A24 Election rotten cinemax documentaries dogs AMC Black Mirror Character Guide obituary strong female leads Nat Geo comics MSNBC documentary Discovery Channel Trivia rotten movies we love Reality directors CBS All Access Acorn TV canceled The Arrangement dceu Mystery BET Awards werewolf Disney streaming service BBC composers Biopics 2016 Sundance Now Interview Trophy Talk GIFs halloween crime thriller Starz Walt Disney Pictures renewed TV shows Marvel Showtime Thanksgiving south america IFC Ovation screen actors guild name the review mission: impossible batman 2015 sports movie Cosplay PBS MCU Certified Fresh Sundance TV casting SundanceTV Disney Channel Winter TV E3 Mary Tyler Moore classics Creative Arts Emmys Video Games RT21 Nominations Fall TV Writers Guild of America Spring TV hollywood Hallmark science fiction Super Bowl Action Peacock