Tomatometer Watch: How Good is Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince?

Early reviews peg the sixth installment as one of the series' best.

by | July 10, 2009 | Comments


The Harry Potter franchise gets its sixth film adaptation next week, and early buzz on the wizarding saga is… fantastically fresh! As Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) and Co. experience the first tremors of teenage love — and all the hormonal shifts that come with puberty, (Hog)warts and all — the battle between good and evil is also heating up. Can Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince and returning helmer David Yates withstand the series’ growing pains? By the looks of things, Half-Blood Prince not only might maintain the franchise’s track record of Certified Freshness, it may also conjure up the best reviews of the entire series. As a wizard might say, “Merlin’s Beard!”

As critics continue to chime in with reviews of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, a quick glance at the early Tomatometer not only shows that initial reactions are overwhelmingly positive, but also that they indicate that Certified Fresh status might be right around the corner. (A film needs a minimum of 40 reviews counted, at least five of them by Top Critics, for Certified Fresh consideration.) Half-Blood Prince would land in very good company; all five of its movie predecessors have earned the Certified Fresh distinction:

Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (2001), 78%

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (2002), 82%

Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (2004), 89%

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005), 88%

Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (2007), 77%

But what exactly are the critics saying about Half-Blood Prince? Read on for a survey of Tomatometer reviews so far.


IT’S GORGEOUS: Thanks to director David Yates, director of photography Bruno Delbonnel (Amelie), and composer Nicholas Hooper (who also worked with director Yates on Order of the Phoenix), Half-Blood Prince has a technically gorgeous look and feel.

Among the always outstanding production values and top-drawer visual effects, special note should be made of series newcomer Bruno Delbonnel’s exceptionally atmospheric cinematography and Nicholas Hooper’s emotionally churning score, which contains only the slightest trace of John Williams’ original themes.” — Todd McCarthy, Variety

Not only has [Yates] made the film look gorgeous, but he has a much surer grip on the special effects, deploying them in the service of big set pieces that actually flow with the rhythms of the story, as well as a better understanding of what his younger cast can do.” — Alistair Harkness, Scotsman


THE HARRY POTTER KIDS ARE GROWING UP: Teenage life brings not only heightened dangers for Harry, but much darker themes, following J.K. Rowling’s increasingly mature books. Death, loss, longing, and love — along with plenty of make-out sessions, thanks to the hormones raging at Hogwarts — making this an appropriately more adult, if still PG-rated, affair.

Half-Blood Prince feels like the most grown-up Potter film yet when it comes to the menace of the bad guys. They’re everywhere, and they’re casually evil. While the death of Cedric Diggory in Goblet of Fire was a stunner, Half-Blood Prince carries a constant presence of malice, and it feels like any kid could be killed at any moment.” — Devin Faraci, CHUD


ON THE ACTION, OR LACK THEREOF: Writer Steve Kloves has excised at will from Rowling’s source material, omitting at least one major showdown from his script. The result: fewer set pieces, although critics note that the few that are included are thrilling.

There are surprisingly few action sequences … But those there are – a chase in the corn between Harry and the Death Eaters, the scene in a forbidding cave where Harry and Dumbledore seek to unravel Voldemort’s secrets – crackle with a chilling sense of threat.” — Sarah Crompton, Telegraph UK


RUNTIME, SHMUNTIME: At two hours and 33 minutes long, Half-Blood Prince is a real bladder tester. But with so few set pieces, can plot development and movie magic keep things clipping along?

Despite its 153-minute running time, Yates’s film proceeds at a cracking pace.” — Nick Curtis, Evening Standard

By the time we get back to the actual plot, almost two hours have passed, and by then, you might have completely given up on caring who the titular “half-blood prince” is. That makes it the first time in the series you really start feeling the movie’s length before the two-hour mark due to the amount of needless filler.” — Edward Douglas, Coming Soon


THE CAST: DOES SOMEBODY SMELL OSCAR? Harry Potter‘s central trio of young actors have developed serious chops throughout the series, and seem to only get better as they age. Critics also love Half-Blood Prince‘s supporting cast of returning and new players, including some of the British Isles’ best thespians. One new addition in particular has some critics already predicting Oscar buzz.

“If this were any movie but part six of a series, I’d say [Jim] Broadbent does ‘Best Supporting Actor’ level work here. It’s a master class in how to make the most of every moment onscreen without ever once overpowering the film around him.” – Drew McWeeny,


IS HALF-BLOOD PRINCE ONE OF THE BEST HARRY POTTER FILMS YET? Director Yates is also at the helm for the final two Harry Potter films, The Deathly Hallows Pt. 1 and 2, and has set up Half-Blood Prince as an effective precursor to the coming conclusion of the series. That many critics count Half-Blood Prince among the series’ best bodes well for its final film chapters.

A comfortable second in IGN’s opinion, the depth and scale of the drama raising it above the level of the one-dimensional early films, and the sensitivity with which these heavy themes are handled a marked improvement on the more callous Order of the Phoenix. It doesn’t reach the magical heights of Alfonso Cuaron’s truly spellbinding Prisoner of Azkaban, but Yates is fast approaching that territory, which bodes well for his helming of the final instalments.” — Chris Tilly, IGN UK

We can already sense the two-part seventh and final saga on the horizon, and the whole less-frenzied affair is tonally and emotionally suggestive of a post-battle re-grouping before a final cinematic assault.” — Wally Hammond, Time Out

Read more early reviews of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, which debuts worldwide on July 15. To revisit all five previous Harry Potter films in advance of Half-Blood Prince, watch along with our Editor in Chief, Matt Atchity, as he Deconstructs Harry, one film a day.

Tag Cloud

a nightmare on elm street Summer Britbox rotten movies we love mission: impossible sequel children's TV vampires cars anime Countdown Chilling Adventures of Sabrina reboot Mary poppins BBC One The Purge Creative Arts Emmys SDCC anthology SXSW Universal docudrama Star Wars spider-man Disney Channel batman Rock supernatural The Witch 2016 Tomatazos laika CBS Awards Biopics period drama breaking bad Sundance TV universal monsters dragons NYCC 2020 El Rey all-time Rocky mockumentary BBC MTV versus Fox News criterion Mystery Women's History Month classics Amazon Prime Video blaxploitation Film Festival directors transformers Sony Pictures richard e. Grant Marvel strong female leads singing competition Television Critics Association south america dceu franchise crime romantic comedy Extras christmas movies romance VOD Pop TV Musical Marathons Stephen King disaster Showtime Avengers RT History parents IFC Films twilight Bravo cancelled TV series Binge Guide ABC Family Apple TV Plus true crime Discovery Channel Red Carpet nature GLAAD cancelled television slashers ratings cancelled TV shows National Geographic scary movies Amazon Prime psychological thriller Apple Family revenge Infographic stop motion jamie lee curtis Shudder Acorn TV thriller Cannes quibi Film GIFs History nbcuniversal Writers Guild of America stand-up comedy Lucasfilm asian-american satire comics Holidays ABC CBS All Access spain talk show game of thrones Mudbound sports crime thriller Rocketman halloween Western HBO Go travel Awards Tour Disney OneApp Song of Ice and Fire VH1 Masterpiece teaser Opinion President Netflix FX on Hulu Winter TV festivals BAFTA Turner Classic Movies Schedule Turner YouTube Premium A&E natural history WarnerMedia Photos fast and furious Comics on TV Superheroes political drama Heroines TCA Winter 2020 miniseries Super Bowl YA NBC war police drama award winner Best and Worst Hear Us Out 2015 New York Comic Con social media Trivia TCA Quiz Oscars 71st Emmy Awards witnail Christmas BET Pride Month Interview San Diego Comic-Con binge 24 frames Pop cults Arrowverse Music TV Land Trophy Talk HBO LGBTQ documentaries justice league medical drama biography adaptation composers Amazon what to watch sitcom zombie Certified Fresh TruTV critics BBC America spinoff Freeform Classic Film joker renewed TV shows 2019 Comedy Central MSNBC comic sequels Lionsgate unscripted Reality documentary Box Office free movies TCM DC Comics Amazon Studios mutant Character Guide LGBT The Walking Dead Marvel Television Crunchyroll Vudu Grammys book RT21 Fantasy GoT diversity E! space spy thriller Lifetime Christmas movies BET Awards video FX OWN Esquire Premiere Dates Brie Larson DC Universe psycho spanish language Ovation Hallmark Christmas movies Winners Nickelodeon 45 Action aliens chucky boxoffice Holiday First Reviews kids Adult Swim DC streaming service First Look CNN Food Network A24 Sundance Now golden globes zombies hispanic theme song DirecTV robots casting USA YouTube Red 007 independent films YouTube Television Academy Pet Sematary Baby Yoda child's play Set visit dc latino Hallmark toy story Dark Horse Comics Mindy Kaling VICE Musicals 2018 screenings dogs Pirates cats APB TCA 2017 reviews Academy Awards SundanceTV Travel Channel MCU Mary Tyler Moore See It Skip It cancelled Logo TV renewals superhero politics blockbuster X-Men worst 2017 CMT Election TV PBS harry potter 4/20 Apple TV+ finale tv talk serial killer Reality Competition best discovery cooking adventure The CW TLC Walt Disney Pictures Sci-Fi IFC canceled Tarantino Tubi PaleyFest Podcast Pixar Captain marvel green book Marvel Studios Fall TV TNT comedies Rom-Com 20th Century Fox CW Seed TBS Epix Tumblr Comedy TIFF Elton John Starz Spring TV Star Trek Hulu Lifetime game show rotten Valentine's Day animated American Society of Cinematographers HBO Max Disney+ Disney Plus hist USA Network Sneak Peek E3 Peacock movie Ellie Kemper Spike Cosplay name the review Emmys Paramount Network Nat Geo Cartoon Network The Arrangement video on demand crossover streaming Animation Drama Watching Series Martial Arts Syfy Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt sag awards Netflix Christmas movies Polls and Games cops AMC Country screen actors guild science fiction Columbia Pictures indie Chernobyl foreign Black History Month cinemax Shondaland FOX Video Games concert obituary 21st Century Fox comiccon Mary Poppins Returns Endgame die hard Anna Paquin PlayStation Paramount Disney streaming service 72 Emmy Awards Nominations ghosts hollywood Spectrum Originals based on movie Horror Thanksgiving Superheroe WGN crime drama Crackle news TCA Awards Comic Book stoner zero dark thirty dramedy Calendar doctor who ITV technology ESPN Warner Bros. indiana jones FXX Black Mirror Emmy Nominations Trailer facebook Ghostbusters canceled TV shows Disney Plus elevated horror DGA television Toys dark Funimation werewolf emmy awards Kids & Family Sundance Year in Review cartoon Teen series historical drama movies