The Sinner Star Bill Pullman Promises Even the Book’s Readers Won’t Guess What’s Coming in the Finale

Crime drama’s master sleuth talks changes from the book, psychological breakthroughs, and that magnificent beard.

by | September 14, 2017 | Comments

Even if you’ve read author Petra Hammesfahr’s novel The Sinner, don’t think you know how the USA Network crime drama will end, star Bill Pullman (Independence Day) advised ahead of the event series’ finale.

Pullman plays Det. Harry Ambrose, murder suspect Cora Tannetti’s biggest ally. Cora (Jessica Biel) is more than just a suspect, however; a crowded beach full of people saw her kill a man in broad daylight. Ambrose put it together that she has been re-enacting a previous scenario that was perhaps a case of self-defense. The season finale of The Sinner airing next Wednesday will reveal the truth, and perhaps the fate of Ambrose’s marriage, which he can’t solve quite as easily.

The Sinner has been a bit of a sleeper hit this summer. It’s earned a 94% Tomatometer score with 31 reviews since it premiered August 2 and has been Certified Fresh.

Pullman spoke with Rotten Tomatoes during a stopover in Martha’s Vineyard on the way to the Toronto International Film Festival for the premiere of Battle of the Sexes, and the actor has more movies in the works for 2018.

Fred Topel for Rotten Tomatoes: Has The Sinner been a real sleeper hit of the summer for you?

Bill Pullman: My expectations and hope were that it would find a certain audience. Then people might watch it afterwards or whatever, but it’s done much better than I thought. My representatives were saying, “Well, it premiered very well, but we’re used to declining numbers or they might plateau.” Everybody was managing expectations and I thought, “They’re probably optimistic — even so I have to be prepared.” But, it has climbed every week. I could tell by the television agent at ICM how excited he was to call me the day after each screening. I could see all those numbers meant a lot to him.

RT: Have you been aware of the good reviews too?

Pullman: You know, I try to duck out of reading those until it’s all over. I do go back and read some when it’s old news. People have been telling me there are some supporters out there for it.

RT: You’ve had a beard in your last few roles. Is this your new look?

Pullman: I just shaved it! I had to say goodbye to the beard because I’m doing two parts and neither of them have a beard. I’m playing Nelson Rockefeller in Cheney, and he never had a beard. Then I’m doing a sequel to The Equalizer, and I didn’t have a beard in the first one.

RT: Why was it the right look for Ambrose in The Sinner?

Pullman: A couple of years ago, this Norwegian theater director had the idea that I should come to Norway and do Othello. I had a beard for that. When I came back, we were doing the sequel to Independence Day and when Roland Emmerich saw pictures of me in my wardrobe with this beard, because I hadn’t shaved it off yet, he said, “I like the beard. We’ll keep it for Whitmore.” Every movie it seemed like everybody said, “Let’s keep the beard. I like the beard.” I was ready for anything with [The Sinner creator] Derek Simonds and Tony Campos who was directing. They saw pictures of me with the beard and said, “You know, this really works for Ambrose.” It was a good run with the beard for two years, about five movies.

RT: If people have read the book, does the finale still have some surprises in store for them?

Pullman: Yes, there are still things they get to be surprised by. The weight and value of things are different too. There are things that can take a long time in the book that don’t so much in our story and vice versa. For one thing, the Ambrose character is not nearly as developed in the book as he is in the show. What he goes through in the last phase is more invented by Derek.

RT: Ambrose was right about the psychological repetition of the stab wounds. Has he gotten too close with Cora by the end?

Pullman: I think it’s the peculiarity of the human mind they’re trying to account for. It’s also a metaphor to repetition patterns that people get into, in ways they don’t recognize consciously. In both characters, in Ambrose and her, what patterns of behavior are we unconscious of? What caused it or what feeds it? Either unconsciously or semi-consciously, I think Ambrose is half aware. It’s more of a fugue state for her, almost pulling back the curtain on a lot of things for her. He’s at least more aware of behavior, at least dimly aware.

RT: Is there a resolution to his marriage?

Pullman: Yeah. I don’t think it’s something you’ll be prepared for. He can’t really sustain it without going through a lot more, at this point in the story. He’s not capable of it. He does everything he can to sustain it but it really is harder than he thought. In a way, his relationship [with Cora] becomes more intimate. There’s a lot more levels of intimacy, not sexuality, but intimacy that he probably hasn’t had for a while with anybody.

RT: Was it heartbreaking to film the scene where he’s watering his trees?

Pullman: It was so strange that we had the good fortune that it rained that day. There was a point where the first AD, the director, and Derek said, “Are we going to commit to rain? What if it stops raining and we have to keep shooting coverage?” I wasn’t even thinking about [the rain] too much except for the fact that everybody was coming up to me going, “Are you OK?” because I was so soaked. I didn’t want to be [distracted] with keeping warm or drying off or anything. Just keep going. I think the rain added this level of urgency to it all.

RT: Who do you play in Battle of the Sexes?

Pullman: I get to play Jack Kramer, who is the obstacle to Billie Jean King. He was a true-life guy who was quite a charismatic guy, good tennis player. He’s very important to American tennis. He led the strike at Wimbledon in ’73, when they allowed players to negotiate their own salaries individually for the first time and that made professional tennis playing possible so people could have careers and raise families. But the bridge too far was to get along with Billie Jean King. He believes that women are not as capable as men in playing tennis and that they’re not as resilient. They don’t have the strength and the speed. That makes him a male chauvinist pig, so I’m a good kind of antagonist.

RT: Actors always say you can’t judge your character, but when someone in real life had views like that does it still apply?

Pullman: When they first talked to me about it, I said, “You know, I don’t want to be the guy that’s just stuck in his own age, as a female empowerment movie where we all have the brilliance of our own modern day perspective and everybody else looks like they’re regressive personalities or something.” They were very interested in making it nuanced. I think honestly saying, “This guy is not an overbearing male chauvinist. He was part of a culture that believed this. That doesn’t mean he’s 100-percent bad guy.” All the characters are kind of compromised, but they’re still very human and you don’t ever disengage or give up on them as people.

RT: Do you play tennis in the movie?

Pullman: No, I don’t have to play tennis in the movie. I’ve done other things where I’ve had to play tennis.

RT: For those who don’t know the historical connection, how was Nelson Rockefeller involved with Dick Cheney?

Pullman: I don’t know if you’re familiar with that whole idea of the Rockefeller Republicans. In the ’60s and early ’70s, the Republican party had a wing that was pro-environment and interested in setting up the EPA, which they did; pro– education and setting up a huge state system, which was largely Republican driven; then they started the NEA for the arts. At a certain point, there was a faction in the party that wanted to go hard right and scorched earth, no compromises with the other party. You’ll see in the movie how it turns out.

RT: Does your character fill the same role in The Equalizer 2?

Pullman: I didn’t know where my character was going. I’m not sure if it’s even resolved. Maybe there’ll be a third one and it’ll go in yet another direction.

The Sinner finale airs Wednesday, September 20 at 10 p.m. on USA.

[youtube_video url=

Tag Cloud

ABC Family historical drama Pop TV Marvel Sundance TV TV movies Image Comics Country nature Masterpiece VH1 dark anthology spanish language Lifetime Christmas movies Certified Fresh die hard sag awards rom-coms cartoon best A24 Extras Musicals aapi fast and furious nbcuniversal YouTube Red black comic books cars Mary poppins docudrama SundanceTV Pop name the review Ghostbusters psychological thriller olympics PlayStation Quiz E3 1990s TCA 2017 Tokyo Olympics APB stop motion Starz talk show Cosplay canceled Food Network ghosts BAFTA Mystery Spring TV Netflix Christmas movies james bond Holidays anime obituary San Diego Comic-Con Opinion CNN discovery Dark Horse Comics toronto Super Bowl TV 2020 BBC One MCU Marvel Studios cooking Star Trek Television Critics Association singing competition harry potter Comic Book war cancelled politics Set visit 71st Emmy Awards Awards Premiere Dates 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Peacock Fantasy australia Classic Film adenture godzilla The CW cancelled TV series boxing CBS All Access japan Lionsgate dogs VOD Election TNT Apple TV+ rotten movies we love Horror heist movie golden globe awards The Purge Sci-Fi canceled TV shows Rocketman Spike Oscars streaming movies Paramount universal monsters DirecTV legend Tumblr Kids & Family Calendar criterion space toy story TIFF streaming Box Office Bravo king kong transformers Disney Plus Apple TV Plus GLAAD spider-man elevated horror technology OneApp First Reviews doctor who Fall TV History LGBTQ Year in Review know your critic documentaries new star wars movies venice Red Carpet 4/20 Film Festival DC Universe Hallmark Christmas movies Travel Channel indie HBO Go period drama GoT monster movies Rock FXX FOX Christmas Baby Yoda political drama IFC cancelled television Sony Pictures Trivia OWN justice league Vudu Epix Ellie Kemper Podcast MSNBC hist The Arrangement Sundance Now Trophy Talk blaxploitation 2018 witnail Mary Poppins Returns cats Disney Channel TCA Winter 2020 Mary Tyler Moore stand-up comedy archives series blockbuster The Walking Dead Acorn TV high school animated Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Family blockbusters hispanic Hulu classics Turner Classic Movies YouTube Black History Month NYCC DGA Warner Bros. Television Academy 2019 Reality Competition boxoffice Syfy Amazon Prime Video Academy Awards all-time game of thrones Paramount Plus Nat Geo twilight green book kids Shudder Turner Action natural history PaleyFest quibi basketball FX Awards Tour supernatural prank directors vampires Legendary Funimation emmy awards DC Comics teaser Reality theme song USA Network LGBT live action The Walt Disney Company Sneak Peek dceu deadpool PBS a nightmare on elm street movie RT History 99% USA Esquire Spectrum Originals Superheroe versus concert news BBC America Marvel Television American Society of Cinematographers parents Heroines TCM Broadway new zealand Stephen King DC streaming service pirates of the caribbean Film Endgame sequels TV Land Summer 2017 screen actors guild Lifetime based on movie book adaptation razzies binge Animation SXSW mission: impossible 45 crime drama Creative Arts Emmys AMC dramedy joker 93rd Oscars marvel cinematic universe latino serial killer game show National Geographic Tarantino popular psycho sitcom trailers fresh WarnerMedia Columbia Pictures Captain marvel hidden camera TLC composers golden globes jurassic park Disney streaming service Universal christmas movies Crunchyroll nfl FX on Hulu independent Valentine's Day video on demand children's TV new york Women's History Month police drama Exclusive Video Emmy Nominations Infographic Pixar Trailer Crackle Rocky robots Chernobyl wonder woman zombies Amazon Prime IFC Films Hear Us Out strong female leads Pacific Islander BET crossover Britbox casting 2021 Mindy Kaling asian-american Music Comedy Central TBS Tubi Musical breaking bad Logo Western ViacomCBS scene in color TV renewals comiccon slashers Black Mirror franchise cinemax facebook WGN movies television spinoff TV One E! ABC sequel halloween tv CBS miniseries Pride Month foreign kong Apple cops A&E BET Awards batman thriller Cartoon Network romance Teen Disney Cannes YouTube Premium festivals disaster reviews Adult Swim Anna Paquin CW Seed Martial Arts Wes Anderson ESPN Binge Guide See It Skip It book YA comedies docuseries suspense dc worst Interview TCA Awards First Look social media Nickelodeon Best and Worst Lucasfilm adventure satire Netflix ABC Signature 90s reboot Star Wars 20th Century Fox comic international true crime CMT Song of Ice and Fire Tomatazos child's play Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Walt Disney Pictures Pirates Biopics crime ITV VICE films Showtime GIFs Grammys SDCC critics 007 revenge aliens 72 Emmy Awards NBC Comics on TV 21st Century Fox ID werewolf Schedule Winter TV hollywood indiana jones video worst movies Rom-Com rotten sports Thanksgiving NBA medical drama italian crime thriller saw ratings BBC New York Comic Con chucky award winner Emmys women travel south america scary movies finale Superheroes zero dark thirty Paramount Network lord of the rings Amazon Studios spy thriller festival 2015 Elton John free movies Fox News dragons Winners stoner Alien El Rey Brie Larson adaptation diversity TCA Discovery Channel french TruTV President scorecard mockumentary MTV superman romantic comedy 2016 The Academy Video Games Drama The Witch comics screenings Writers Guild of America renewed TV shows RT21 Toys japanese Pet Sematary Avengers Photos king arthur zombie what to watch Comic-Con@Home 2021 Disney+ Disney Plus Ovation unscripted Holiday Freeform cancelled TV shows cults science fiction Hallmark HBO Max Countdown 24 frames tv talk telelvision kaiju Amazon Watching Series biography Marathons rt archives Mudbound jamie lee curtis mutant Comedy X-Men documentary Arrowverse HBO football halloween superhero Shondaland richard e. Grant spanish laika Nominations Polls and Games Character Guide remakes target spain Fox Searchlight Sundance