The Simpsons Decade

Lookwell: How Conan O'Brien, Robert Smigel, and Adam West Predicted Modern Comedy in One Failed Pilot

In this week's column, Nathan Rabin explores an absurd cop drama spoof from 1991 that was way ahead of its time.

by | April 19, 2016 | Comments



When Abe Vigoda died recently at the age of 94, the public mourned a beloved character actor and television fixture whose career lasted much longer than anyone had a right to expect. But they were also mourning a man who long ago turned himself into an absurdist, oddball joke, a walking punchline who didn’t necessarily have to do anything funny to win laughter. Vigoda’s hangdog presence alone seemed to reduce many to guffaws.

Actually, it isn’t entirely accurate to say that Vigoda turned himself into a joke. It’d be more accurate to say that Conan O’Brien turned him into a surprisingly popular running gag by featuring him as part of his show’s crazy repertory cast of outrageous and surreal characters, a coterie that also included the Masturbating Bear and Mr. T.


Lookwell feels at once a product of television’s past and an early glimpse into its future.

It never felt like O’Brien was exploiting Vigoda for cheap laughs, though. He was using him for comedic purposes, alright, but it always felt like he was laughing with Vigoda rather than laughing at him. O’Brien was celebrating the weird show business survivors from our fuzzy, half-remembered past and our weird emotional connection to them, and it helped that they were in on the joke.

In the early 1990s, a pre-fame O’Brien and regular collaborator Robert Smigel similarly took Adam West, another figure from the cheesier recesses of pop culture past, and made his exquisitely cornball cult of personality the core of their ill-fated but widely beloved 1991 pilot Lookwell. It only aired once, and it never got picked up or made it to series, but this strange riff on 1970s cop shows somehow proved more influential and talked about than a lot of shows that make it into syndication. Today, Lookwell feels at once a product of television’s past and an early glimpse into its future.

The cornerstones of edgy television comedies to come are all here. In a world of multi-camera sitcoms fortified with the unholy, inhuman braying of laugh tracks and/or a live studio audience, Lookwell boldly opted for the single camera, laugh track-free sensibility of the interchangeable cop shows of the 1970s that were its inspiration. At a time when police dramas and comedies alike understandably leaned towards protagonists who were nice, likable, relatable, and sane, Lookwell instead gave us a deluded anti-hero who was unmistakably scheming, amoral, deranged, and damn near impossible to relate to.

Like Get A Life’s iconic head sociopath Chris Peterson, Ty Lookwell, the character Adam West brilliantly inhabits, isn’t just ingratiatingly daffy in time-tested comedy form. He’s a lunatic, a confident man who seems to inhabit his own bizarre universe, a universe that doesn’t look like ours and plays by entirely different rules.

Lookwell also isn’t just a man who gets all of his ideas from television. No, he’s damn near television personified. He’s television’s Ford- and Carter-era cheesiness rendered flesh. But where Peterson is forever stuck on the other side of the tube, passively taking in television’s rich cornucopia of inanity and insanity, Lookwell has made it inside the television. He has ascended to a higher level of craziness.


Not only is Lookwell not in on the joke, he inhabits a television world where jokes don’t exist, just clues and crimes and roles he feels he’s perfect for.

After a gloriously pitch-perfect opening credit sequence, West’s Lookwell begins the pilot dispensing wisdom to a fellow actor in an audition for a Happy Days reboot. With his leather jacket and comically oversized black pompadour, he could not look more out of place, a preposterously cartoonish caricature of a 1950s greaser plopped down in early 1990s Los Angeles. When a fellow actor inquires whether he’s Ty Lookwell, he responds affirmatively, then coolly implores, “But until this audition is over, I prefer to be addressed as Buzz McCool.” Not only is he not in on the joke, he inhabits a television world where jokes don’t exist, just clues and crimes and roles he feels he’s perfect for.

In a way, Lookwell anticipates The Brady Bunch movies in dropping the living embodiment of 1970s cheese into the real world of the 1990s, then deriving big laughs out of the incongruous juxtaposition between the two. The show and the film’s anachronistic fashion style and aggressively non-ironic sensibility rub right up against a contemporary world that can’t help but see them as clueless, crazy relics of a bygone era.

But Lookwell splits the difference by sporting the look and feel of a 1970s cop show like Mannix or Ironside, right down to a score that’s half dirty, borderline porno funk and half police-and-military martial pomp. It sounds at once swank and gritty, and it’s one of those killer details that makes the show’s satire wonderfully specific.

Lookwell divides his time between impossible auditions, acting lessons where he uses Bannigan as an unlikely tool to understand the complexities of Shakespeare, and horning his way into police investigations under the curious logic that three years of pretending to be a detective has given him unique insight into the criminal mind.


Lookwell derives much of its subversive, trash-culture kick from the sense that Adam West is, on some level, playing a version of himself.

Long ago, Lookwell was given an honorary badge (along with seemingly every other middle-aged white man who played a cop on television in the 1970s) and decided that this meaningless publicity stunt made him a real detective. When the real cops patiently try to discourage him from poking his nose into their investigation of a luxury car theft ring, Lookwell responds with a quietly indignant, “I don’t think you understand. I used to play a detective.” In Lookwell, celebrity is more than a state of mind; it’s a form of insanity that keeps its titular protagonist from ever having to confront the reality that he’s a terrible actor and an even worse crimefighter, and that the people he thinks he’s assisting really just want him to go away.

Lookwell derives much of its subversive, trash-culture kick from the sense that Adam West is, on some level, playing a version of himself, and that Ty Lookwell is essentially West with a different signature show and no self-consciousness or self-awareness whatsoever. The pilot is equally scathing yet loving in its deconstruction of the detective drama and in its spoof of acting divorced from anything other than the actor’s enormous, blinding ego. In this context, the wonderfully phony nature of West’s performance, with its strange, almost William Shatner-like emphases and purring, conspiratorial tone, is perfect.

Smigel and O’Brien didn’t need a good actor for Lookwell. Hell, a good actor would have ruined the whole project. They needed someone who could act as terribly, as distinctively, and as hilariously as only Adam West can. Good acting often comes down to listening, to engaging with other actors, to being generous and open in the moment. West’s performance as Ty Lookwell, in sharp contrast, is an exercise in self-indulgence. Lookwell behaves as if he is the only person in the world who exists. He sees life as an endless monologue delivered primarily to himself, and for his own benefit.

If much of Lookwell feels screamingly contemporary, even prescient, it’s also redolent of the past. The pilot’s impeccably straight-faced deadpan tone and loving recreation of the style and sensibility of what it’s spoofing calls to mind the 1980s television comedy Police Squad!, the cult classic created by the Zucker Brothers that famously only lasted six episodes but went on to inspire three hit Naked Gun films.


It’s similarly ahead of the curve in its loving, ironic embrace of 1970s kitsch.

By the third Naked Gun movie, a mugging and over-the-top Leslie Nielsen stopped just short of dressing up in clown make-up and punctuating his jokes with a honking bicycle horn, but on Police Squad, as in Airplane!, he played things absolutely straight and was much funnier. That’s the deadpan tone Lookwell effortlessly nails.

It’s similarly ahead of the curve in its loving, ironic embrace of 1970s kitsch. It understands that the key is nailing the details, whether it’s a ridiculously pompadoured Lookwell auditioning for the role of “Buzz McCool,” or the manly freeze frame on West looking determined as the show’s title comes onscreen for the first time .

But Lookwell is also a throwback to West’s heyday. Long before Lookwell cast West as a man unable to delineate between the make-pretend of his acting career and the reality of his actual life, he became an instant camp icon in Batman, a show that never stopped winking at its audience to let them know it was all just a big joke everyone was in on, including the kids in the audience. Thanks in no small part to West’s angrily, defiantly non-naturalistic, super-stylized performance, Batman elevated comic book shenanigans to the level of pop-art. It made goofy, Roy Lichtensteinesque pop culture riffing wildly popular, at least for a little while, and inflamed the imaginations of pop culture-damaged kids like myself in the process.

Despite airing only once, Lookwell helped transform West from a campy has-been to a camp icon who is a walking punchline first, a joke second, and an actor a distant third. Indeed, Family Guy decided that there was no point in casting West as an Adam West-like figure when they could just cast him as himself and imagine that in some weird alternate universe, he ended up the mayor of a Rhode Island town. There’s something sadly apt about imagining West as the mayor of Cheap Pop Culture Reference City (which is my nickname for Family Guy’s Quahog), since he himself reigns supreme with folks like Abe Vigoda, William Shatner, Mr. T, and Mike Tyson as a ubiquitous pop-culture reference.

The enduring genius of Lookwell is that it used West’s weird, singular iconic baggage as the cornerstone for a smart, dense, and fully thought-out vision that filtered an unabashed love for 1970s macho sleaze through the smart-ass irony and sarcasm of the early 1990s, rather than just coasting on the public’s nostalgia for the 1960s Batman and the beloved actor who played him. 

It remains to be seen whether a premise this odd or unique would have sustained an entire season, let alone a lengthy run. Yet in its justifiably brilliant pilot, young turks O’Brien and Smigel (both of whom we’ll be hearing a lot more from over the course of this series) proved that it didn’t even take an hour of television to create a lasting comic legacy.

Up Next: The Simpsons.

Nathan Rabin on Twitter: @NathanRabin

Tag Cloud

Year in Review Family boxing Hallmark Christmas movies Nickelodeon scary Pacific Islander zombies richard e. Grant women Marathons new york SXSW 2022 miniseries Fargo docudrama Drama festival mcc comic comiccon critics DC Comics rotten emmy awards wonder woman versus Columbia Pictures Awards Tour spanish language BAFTA 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards 2020 Mary poppins Oscars jamie lee curtis thriller hollywood Arrowverse Disney hispanic heritage month Chilling Adventures of Sabrina marvel cinematic universe Amazon History kids cancelled television prank Set visit saw FX on Hulu crime Broadway Musicals Animation Polls and Games tv talk Lucasfilm GIFs sports robots comics Rock Tumblr dark Quiz Western dreamworks 72 Emmy Awards First Reviews mission: impossible mutant Disney streaming service children's TV Podcast NBA Oscar Best Actress Mindy Kaling PlayStation sitcom blaxploitation RT21 24 frames natural history IFC sequels book adaptation 90s Food Network Wes Anderson jurassic park parents Nat Geo BBC America nature Epix Superheroes SundanceTV discovery CBS All Access latino Premiere Dates transformers A24 politics Alien worst Mudbound ghosts social media Country doctor who Tokyo Olympics movies LGBT Star Wars FOX popular obi wan dramedy Apple die hard President Calendar binge Paramount Plus what to watch dceu Freeform The Walking Dead CW Seed Fantasy comedies archives docuseries nfl Countdown remakes MSNBC 93rd Oscars international halloween critic resources godzilla cooking aapi Logo know your critic Extras Writers Guild of America blockbusters FX TCA Awards Legendary 71st Emmy Awards Sundance TV trophy Nominations summer TV preview Superheroe Ghostbusters Hollywood Foreign Press Association WarnerMedia CBS Opinion scene in color live action stop motion 2021 Hallmark art house The Walt Disney Company spider-man Sony golden globe awards Lifetime Cartoon Network TIFF marvel comics VH1 HBO Max Endgame 79th Golden Globes Awards sag awards Sony Pictures breaking bad criterion japan dexter Election crime drama Certified Fresh Pop Vudu Sundance Now dc Infographic rom-coms Shondaland Netflix Christmas movies Box Office Neflix CNN Television Academy Syfy medical drama Baby Yoda E3 SDCC The Academy Summer Thanksgiving Pixar japanese 1990s rt labs critics edition video TBS Emmys ID Disney Plus screenings finale Apple TV+ Universal ABC Signature ViacomCBS TV movies cats singing competition Women's History Month 73rd Emmy Awards 4/20 Red Carpet TV anime 007 MGM MTV Black History Month Funimation toy story Best Director TNT series batman psycho Turner Best Actor BET Awards vs. Apple TV Plus cancelled TV series gangster Biopics DirecTV Trivia stoner animated Fall TV superman rt labs adaptation dragons genre justice league ratings Comedy Acorn TV anthology Academy Awards harry potter trailers documentary biography Hear Us Out cinemax unscripted Song of Ice and Fire psychological thriller feel good best Heroines Valentine's Day italian game of thrones Tubi HBO Go ABC CMT X-Men pirates of the caribbean USA 2018 asian-american PaleyFest Winter TV Rocky Teen theme song ITV indie worst movies all-time mockumentary Lionsgate Holiday elevated horror Awards BBC screen actors guild Rom-Com Hulu FXX Sneak Peek Spring TV spy thriller Britbox NBC BET BBC One TLC dogs Geeked Week SXSW movie Marvel Studios action-comedy stand-up comedy Cosplay serial killer Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt RT History The CW cults cancelled Peacock Musical Spike reboot composers First Look TV renewals Paramount black comedy lord of the rings 20th Century Fox LGBTQ teaser renewed TV shows hispanic festivals IFC Films Horror HBO ESPN Crunchyroll foreign concert TruTV Marvel Trophy Talk news Lifetime Christmas movies cars new zealand See It Skip It Elton John directors spinoff New York Comic Con 2019 Mary Tyler Moore Focus Features Warner Bros. Esquire GLAAD scene in color film series 2015 laika Winners independent YouTube Premium video on demand Sci-Fi Chernobyl Rocketman IMDb TV hist boxoffice Marvel Television crime thriller christmas movies Holidays twilight TV One AMC Plus VICE royal family Grammys mob Mary Poppins Returns Black Mirror Reality AMC diversity sopranos green book historical drama summer TV quibi OWN venice cops 21st Century Fox Discovery Channel Pet Sematary casting Stephen King joker debate vampires high school revenge Walt Disney Pictures target Film Festival Fox Searchlight 45 Shudder a nightmare on elm street 2016 broadcast universal monsters obituary supernatural Character Guide disaster king kong free movies rotten movies we love talk show franchise sequel classics spider-verse 2017 strong female leads Turner Classic Movies South by Southwest Film Festival Pirates Watching Series Comic Book book TCM chucky black Creative Arts Emmys Paramount Network GoT Disney+ Disney Plus slasher basketball Starz period drama streaming movies streamig YouTube streaming werewolf Trailer halloween tv kaiju YA El Rey cartoon Amazon Studios Travel Channel Comedy Central television Spectrum Originals Dark Horse Comics razzies Photos zombie telelvision TCA heist movie kong ABC Family Star Trek australia Reality Competition zero dark thirty Fox News Martial Arts USA Network Tags: Comedy Ellie Kemper james bond documentaries science fiction WGN young adult Indigenous fast and furious Universal Pictures NYCC technology hidden camera 94th Oscars TCA 2017 OneApp Disney Channel Cannes witnail travel PBS Netflix fresh Instagram Live superhero E! award winner cancelled TV shows DC Universe Amazon Prime Video Film south america comic books Tarantino facebook Super Bowl 99% San Diego Comic-Con Showtime game show Emmy Nominations target scene in color Masterpiece french rt archives APB Prime Video Native The Witch interviews HFPA live event YouTube Red space war Pride Month Pop TV based on movie king arthur scary movies child's play romance Amazon Prime Sundance Classic Film Comic-Con@Home 2021 legend Interview Image Comics toronto DGA spain Avengers monster movies spanish Star Wars Celebration Best and Worst The Arrangement indiana jones MCU VOD Schedule Anna Paquin slashers A&E Comics on TV canceled nbcuniversal crossover Brie Larson scene in color series scorecard Mystery National Geographic Ovation Paramount Pictures adventure Tomatazos The Purge suspense Captain marvel name the review satire Bravo Best Picture reviews Christmas TV Land American Society of Cinematographers true crime leaderboard Music adenture Toys films comic book movie DC streaming service canceled TV shows biopic golden globes Television Critics Association new star wars movies political drama Crackle aliens Kids & Family deadpool Adult Swim football TCA Winter 2020 olympics comic book movies summer preview Binge Guide Exclusive Video posters blockbuster Video Games Action police drama romantic comedy