The Shape of Water Buzz: Critics Declare It's One of Guillermo del Toro's Best

Early reviews and social media posts hail it as the director's strongest work since Pan's Labyrinth.

by | August 31, 2017 | Comments

The Shape of Water
(Photo by Fox Searchlight Pictures)

Guillermo del Toro has a new movie on the way, which on its own is very exciting. Plus, the trailer makes it look amazing, sort of like a cross between Hellboy and Pan’s Labyrinth. Well, it’s time to raise your anticipation even further, becauese The Shape of Water just premiered at the Venice Film Festival, and the response from critics is overwhelmingly positive.

The Shape of Water stars Sally Hawkins, Octavia Spencer, and frequent del Toro collaborator Doug Jones in a Cold War-set fairy tale of sorts, about a lonely woman who forms an unlikely new bond when she and a co-worker discover a secret experiment in the top secret lab where they work. Del Toro has been up and down with critical favor throughout his career, but more than half of his features as a director are Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes, and his average review score is 77.8%. Currently, The Shape of Water has a unanimously favorable 100% score right out of the gate, and we can assume it will remain one of his higher-rated efforts.

Here’s what critics are saying in reviews and on social media:

A ravishing 60s-set romance, sweet, sad and sexy.
Xan Brooks, The Guardian

A ravishing, eccentric auteur’s imagining, spilling artistry, empathy and sensuality from every open pore, it also offers more straight-up movie for your money than just about any Hollywood studio offering this year…incontestably del Toro’s most rewarding, richly realized movie since Pan’s Labyrinth.
Guy Lodge, Variety

A visually and emotionally ravishing fantasy that should find a welcome embrace from audiences starved for imaginative escape…del Toro’s most satisfying work since Pan’s Labyrinth.
David Rooney, The Hollywood Reporter

Sweet and scary movie magic. [Del Toro’s] best film since Pan’s Labyrinth. It perhaps even equals it.
Jessica Kiang, The Playlist

For first half-hour or so, I thought The Shape of Water might be an all-timer. It’s not, but by far Gullermo del Toro’s best since Pan’s Labyrinth. Richard Jenkins is particularly fantastic.
Paul O’Callaghan, Sight and Sound

I expected lots from The Shape of Water, but not for it to be, among other things, a musical. Surprising and delightful.
Jill Lawless, Associated Press

There are elements of Beauty and the Beast, E.T., Amelie and The Creature from the Black Lagoon at play…something here for lovers of all kinds of movies — even silents and musicals.
Alonso Duralde, The Wrap

An immense achievement…this is del Toro’s Beauty and the Beast with the delicate time period touches and social awareness of Far from Heaven.
Brian Formo, Collider

Guillermo del Toro channels all the streams that make him unique into The Shape Of Water, pouring his heart, soul and considerable craft into an exquisite creature fable.
Fionnuala Halligan, Screen International

Not only is The Shape of Water one of del Toro’s most stunningly successful works, it’s also a powerful vision of a creative master feeling totally, joyously free.
Ben Croll, IndieWire

Loved The Shape of Water…visually sumptuous monster movie/love story. Commanding and moving.
Chris Vognar, Dallas Morning News

Like the best bath you’ve ever had, it sends tingles coursing through every part of you that other films don’t reach.
Robbie Collin, Daily Telegraph

The Shape of Water opens in theaters on December 8.

Tag Cloud

Endgame Paramount cancelled television Rocky Classic Film green book sag awards crime thriller biography Lucasfilm documentaries comedies Shudder dark teaser Nat Geo BET Awards Trophy Talk LGBT sequel TCM composers richard e. Grant Disney Channel indiana jones Mary Poppins Returns TCA Winter 2020 First Reviews children's TV Amazon Prime Fall TV Podcast asian-american Grammys Mary Tyler Moore Anna Paquin Walt Disney Pictures Marvel Television Disney Plus Freeform dramedy golden globes 45 toy story franchise Academy Awards politics social media Watching Series Disney YouTube Premium crime drama discovery Tubi Comics on TV 4/20 aliens TV comiccon Sundance Showtime Hulu CBS TBS historical drama Drama DC streaming service ESPN critics FX on Hulu serial killer Epix Best and Worst Character Guide award winner National Geographic Hear Us Out Vudu VH1 Oscars romance Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Tour streaming 007 Rom-Com VICE war unscripted Winter TV Masterpiece canceled TV shows Apple TV Plus FX Video Games adventure transformers DirecTV 2015 Hallmark singing competition RT History American Society of Cinematographers Country GoT Holidays Tumblr Marvel TNT History Ghostbusters game of thrones Sony Pictures Fantasy diversity what to watch Disney+ Disney Plus TIFF breaking bad vampires DGA Amazon SundanceTV films Crunchyroll halloween spider-man universal monsters Comedy Central Reality Competition The Walking Dead revenge Creative Arts Emmys foreign casting sitcom BET documentary Starz Cosplay TruTV GLAAD criterion TV renewals Mary poppins based on movie Peacock political drama Turner cinemax Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt E3 AMC Rock Disney streaming service Stephen King all-time elevated horror 24 frames Marvel Studios Interview Travel Channel CW Seed parents Food Network Tarantino WarnerMedia Extras versus boxoffice Heroines Apple TV+ latino Comic Book child's play video dceu zombies 2016 Pet Sematary miniseries DC Universe USA Apple crossover cartoon El Rey blockbuster Crackle movies X-Men quibi Box Office TCA Summer nature Women's History Month HBO Max Countdown MTV Polls and Games blaxploitation die hard Schedule A&E Family MSNBC Ellie Kemper kids NBC Ovation Chernobyl Teen Super Bowl cooking sports spain spanish language Pop TV Spring TV book video on demand Reality Kids & Family E! BBC One reboot ITV stand-up comedy YouTube christmas movies disaster witnail Bravo The Purge Western PlayStation Pop police drama Netflix Lifetime Spectrum Originals psycho theme song talk show ABC Family IFC Opinion Captain marvel cats free movies twilight HBO Go Emmys BAFTA television natural history OneApp ghosts Cannes Warner Bros. true crime FOX Christmas HBO 2019 comics 21st Century Fox CBS All Access Lifetime Christmas movies Pride Month Animation screen actors guild TV Land stoner comic reviews Amazon Prime Video mutant 2020 FXX psychological thriller Infographic Tomatazos scary movies Superheroe Television Academy finale joker Sci-Fi 2018 directors The Arrangement spy thriller PaleyFest zombie period drama tv talk renewed TV shows Esquire medical drama Film Festival Holiday YouTube Red SDCC Nickelodeon Black History Month First Look Turner Classic Movies Sundance Now chucky south america science fiction 2017 Paramount Network binge doctor who Star Wars mockumentary Trivia TLC Amazon Studios news Song of Ice and Fire USA Network hispanic San Diego Comic-Con animated Musical spinoff justice league Netflix Christmas movies SXSW See It Skip It PBS concert Calendar dragons Photos Arrowverse harry potter series rotten movies we love Sneak Peek Adult Swim romantic comedy Martial Arts Trailer CMT slashers President Britbox cancelled TV shows Marathons space Hallmark Christmas movies cults Shondaland adaptation zero dark thirty DC Comics Brie Larson Superheroes The Witch WGN Star Trek Avengers hist Baby Yoda dogs facebook Acorn TV Music robots Mudbound technology anthology Dark Horse Comics Film Election RT21 Pirates Action Logo The CW Nominations Toys Syfy travel strong female leads Elton John Certified Fresh Spike A24 Black Mirror LGBTQ YA Year in Review screenings Biopics Set visit Musicals thriller MCU Quiz cops werewolf game show APB Mindy Kaling cancelled Thanksgiving Discovery Channel ABC Mystery docudrama batman IFC Films ratings best a nightmare on elm street New York Comic Con Awards crime 20th Century Fox 71st Emmy Awards Red Carpet Fox News supernatural VOD Rocketman Winners NYCC Lionsgate Binge Guide Columbia Pictures jamie lee curtis Comedy Cartoon Network mission: impossible Universal cancelled TV series CNN indie independent canceled BBC America Funimation Sundance TV Premiere Dates name the review TCA 2017 Horror anime Pixar cars dc OWN movie festivals BBC satire GIFs Emmy Nominations Writers Guild of America Valentine's Day