Five Favorite Films

The Lighthouse Director Robert Eggers' Five Favorite Films

The rising director spills the beans on Tarkovsky, the occult, Mary Poppins as a witch, and the thread between his work and Bergman's: fart jokes.

by | October 28, 2019 | Comments

Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images for BFI

(Photo by Gareth Cattermole/Getty Images for BFI)

Partnered with the likes of Hereditary, Green Room, It Comes At Night, and The Killing of A Sacred Deer, Robert Eggers’ directorial debut The Witch helped create that unmistakable brand of A24 horror. The Witch hit those “elevated horror” notes: An original, slow-burn plot that expects film literacy and attention from viewer, which typically flies in the face of the average horror watcher expecting jump scares and constant loud noises.

Eggers’ second movie, The Lighthouse, is set on a wind-battered and isolated New England island at the turn of the 20th century, practically a jump into modern times compared to The Witch‘s 1630 setting. Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe star as two “wickies” assigned to maintain the remote lighthouse, setting the stage for a blackly comic ascent into madness involving farts and angry monologues, questionable plates of food, menacing birds, and a light at the top of the stairs that one man refuses to let the other look at. It’s like Step Brothers if it were written by Algernon Blackwood.

After a successful second-week expansion that saw the movie crack the top 10 box office without a wide release, we talked to Eggers to congratulate him on another Certified Fresh effort, and to get his Five Favorite Films.


Fanny and Alexander (1982) 100%

I’d like to say that the television version that’s longer is better than the version that was in movie theaters. Bergman’s my favorite filmmaker, if I had to choose. It’s very much a culmination of most of the themes and motifs of his career that appears as a physical personification in the very beginning of the film, similar kinds of ghosts that Bergman explored in the past. He has his love for the theater and puppetry and there’s moments of hope and joy, but it also just reminds you that humans have certain demons that they can’t ever escape. It’s really rich and it touches on so many things about what it is to be human that it’s really quite remarkable. And as with every Bergman movie, there’s not a moment of bad performance to be found.

But I think that the first episode, if you were to watch the TV version, is just Christmas with a family. A long episode of getting to know a family at Christmas. And I was talking with [Home Alone director] Chris Columbus about Christmas in movies and he was explaining how it’s just a time of heightened emotions for everyone. So that’s a really clever way to learn about this family and all of their dynamics super deeply, by beginning at Christmas. And the first time you watch it, you’re kind of like, “Where is the story? What is this? This is just Christmas.” And then the next episode, the plot begins but you’ve gotten to know this family incredibly closely and so then you’re just so invested with them through the rest of the film.

Also, like The Lighthouse, it has some fart jokes.

Mary Poppins (1964) 96%

Another movie that takes place in the Edwardian era, but in the country where Edward was actually reigning. It was an important movie for me as a kid and it continued to be something that I revisited again because it’s just good. Good storytelling, quite beautiful. You’ve got to love the matte paintings of the London rooftops. You’ve got to love a movie where a witch is your nanny. Obviously, no challenge to Dick van Dyke’s Australian Cockney accent, but his performance in that movie is really incredible. He is such a good physical comedian and when they’re in the chalk painting — which is also just lovely, the live action mix and the animation — he often has the same dance choreography as Julie Andrews. And he interprets it incredibly differently. It’s not that he can’t do them, it’s that he’s interpreting them in a different way, for humor, with his body type and so cleverly.

It’s a movie where kids have power. They understand some things that their Edwardian dad doesn’t. And we use a Mary Poppins-esque weathervane shot in The Lighthouse. And then also, as much as it is a very, very satisfying narrative, the movie’s not without mystery. What is Mary Poppins’ backstory? What is her relationship with Bert? She creeps me out. Like when her reflection in the mirror keeps singing after her. The way she’s a little bit austere with the children and then the next minute she’s super cuddly, it is a little creepy. And then it just isn’t her, but when the kids get lost in East London, and there’s the dogs barking, and the old beggar woman who’s like, “Come here, children” or whatever. That was incredibly terrifying as a child.

Andrei Rublev (1969) 95%

I feel like talking about Mary Poppins all day. Okay. Andrei Rublev, spelled ‘Rublev’ but pronounced ‘Rublov’. It’s because we don’t use the Cyrillic alphabet. I really do love Tarkovsky’s Mirror as well. But the last act, or the last movement of Andrei Rublev is probably just the best thing in cinema history. That bell casting sequence is just so powerful. In some ways, it’s kind of the same thing that Fanny and Alexander does where you’re not even sure who Andrei Rublev is for quite a while the first time you watch the movie, and this is the episode that makes sense together and works together [in a film that doesn’t have] this super linear, aggressive plot. And then the last movement is very linear, that is incredibly cathartic once you’ve been marinated in this world. It really knocks you out. But in general, the movie is so well-staged and beautiful and stunning and inspiring. It’s completely mind-blowing.

Nosferatu (1922) 97%

I’ve seen the Herzog one a good many times too, but the Murnau film… Murnau is neck to neck with Bergman as my favorite director. He’s responsible for some of the best images in cinema of all time, from Nosferatu to Faust to Sunset. His work was so influential that filmmakers generations later can be referencing Murnau without knowing it. But Nosferatu is an interesting movie. It was produced by Albin Grau, an occultist who started an independent film studio to make occult-themed movies. Nosferatu was his first endeavor. And he hired the screenwriter, and he hired Murnau, and he was the production designer and did a lot of concept art. Very much part of the authorship of this film. And Max Schreck, as much as he is a folk vampire and a reinterpretation of Stoker’s literary gothic vampire, he’s also influenced by Albin Grau’s early 20th-century occultist views on vampirism. But in many ways — there’s horror movies before it, obviously — Nosferatu invents horror movies. The editing of the parallel story together in some ways invents cinema.

Shadows of Our Forgotten Ancestors (1964) 100%

I don’t always love Parajanov’s roaming camera in this movie, but he settled down from Color of Pomegranates onwards. Parajanov’s love for the folk culture is quite infectious. The way that he loves everything on screen, I relate. And the winter mummers are so mysterious. He makes this Hutsul culture come alive and it’s so exotic. Now I know a lot about Carpathian culture and Slavic folklore so the movie doesn’t have a lot of mystery to me anymore. But the first time I saw these images that I couldn’t understand, I was completely conquered because he so clearly understood them [and] they were infused with some kind of meaning that just felt essential to me.

The Lighthouse is currently playing in select theaters.


Tag Cloud

Emmys Showtime TruTV American Society of Cinematographers Crunchyroll Marvel high school strong female leads jurassic park Mudbound blockbusters FX Ghostbusters Quiz crime drama robots Tumblr Pop Pet Sematary 2015 Nickelodeon Countdown History A24 black comedy renewed TV shows psychological thriller A&E rt archives halloween Interview GIFs rom-coms zombies target The Walt Disney Company politics black cops Captain marvel Binge Guide Martial Arts MCU TCA Winter 2020 Nat Geo blockbuster spider-verse Paramount Plus french political drama The Walking Dead superman dragons godzilla BAFTA FXX CBS crime Lifetime trailers Disney Channel tv talk SXSW YouTube Premium video The Arrangement Marvel Television E! cats Amazon Studios Baby Yoda TCA USA Network NYCC dc comiccon Hallmark Christmas movies breaking bad telelvision WGN The Witch critic resources PBS Heroines First Reviews Lionsgate mission: impossible canceled TV shows 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Musicals Freeform Year in Review scary movies DC streaming service sopranos CBS All Access canceled zombie documentary RT21 TLC Amazon Prime Video mcc Pirates Apple TV+ Video Games Classic Film screen actors guild Film NBA game of thrones Rocketman Masterpiece Toys supernatural kaiju Universal halloween tv Disney free movies child's play Television Critics Association TV renewals spain singing competition Tomatazos directors Holidays comics TCM serial killer facebook international Esquire GLAAD 72 Emmy Awards reviews Sci-Fi National Geographic 2017 docudrama SDCC Marvel Studios TBS medical drama cars video on demand President best IFC Films doctor who Mary Poppins Returns The CW dceu lord of the rings animated Apple know your critic 71st Emmy Awards Western LGBTQ feel good Turner Classic Movies marvel comics asian-american Disney+ Disney Plus kids E3 Animation indiana jones ABC BET cancelled golden globe awards Star Wars new zealand live event royal family comic books Writers Guild of America marvel cinematic universe comic book movie Stephen King Black Mirror FX on Hulu Super Bowl satire stand-up comedy harry potter women sequels scene in color The Purge Elton John cancelled television cartoon Syfy book Ovation Columbia Pictures popular period drama christmas movies dramedy saw YouTube Red war Britbox justice league parents BBC America VOD San Diego Comic-Con SundanceTV genre hist Lifetime Christmas movies vampires comedies spinoff Crackle streaming Comic-Con@Home 2021 disaster Tarantino Family aliens australia hollywood 2020 CNN werewolf Fantasy ABC Family aapi TCA Awards Red Carpet stop motion TIFF teaser Epix OneApp universal monsters witnail toronto TV Shudder adenture Travel Channel Dark Horse Comics art house Sneak Peek Summer die hard Song of Ice and Fire mob Oscars Comics on TV Fall TV social media new star wars movies scary biopic psycho 24 frames Hulu New York Comic Con heist movie all-time Trailer Sundance Now mockumentary Apple TV Plus 2018 green book 2019 Biopics rt labs spider-man Drama Valentine's Day anthology hispanic heritage month Mary Tyler Moore miniseries suspense natural history Pacific Islander Arrowverse emmy awards theme song Pride Month news Star Trek king kong DC Universe nbcuniversal Extras comic venice dexter ABC Signature cinemax elevated horror Pixar Holiday Country laika latino Fox Searchlight obituary Anna Paquin chucky talk show worst biography kong what to watch GoT thriller unscripted police drama gangster Comic Book monster movies twilight Superheroes remakes archives Reality Paramount Network OWN Infographic Tokyo Olympics a nightmare on elm street Black History Month ESPN golden globes Academy Awards Netflix Christmas movies Starz Hear Us Out BBC basketball Cosplay Brie Larson Ellie Kemper Music Amazon Mystery Polls and Games VH1 YouTube true crime Awards BET Awards batman sag awards Turner Trivia DC Comics rotten movies we love 99% Cannes YA sequel Vudu Winners Chilling Adventures of Sabrina name the review IFC Awards Tour screenings reboot HBO Go Premiere Dates Spectrum Originals Grammys ViacomCBS Paramount AMC Plus festival japanese quibi binge Mindy Kaling crime thriller ratings james bond WarnerMedia foreign independent ID movies football hidden camera RT History Women's History Month 90s Action blaxploitation HBO slashers new york cults action-comedy boxing Bravo vs. Disney streaming service wonder woman 21st Century Fox Funimation Netflix Nominations zero dark thirty MSNBC dark Christmas crossover Warner Bros. Kids & Family Logo LGBT adventure APB 2016 Lucasfilm Wes Anderson dogs transformers festivals Chernobyl rt labs critics edition TV Land Pop TV Neflix game show Spring TV concert franchise posters The Academy jamie lee curtis young adult TV movies AMC criterion dreamworks streaming movies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Photos Reality Competition Marathons Sundance award winner toy story spanish Amazon Prime TV One Acorn TV nfl Hallmark CMT live action fast and furious VICE versus Calendar Legendary X-Men revenge FOX Walt Disney Pictures movie classics Musical Trophy Talk See It Skip It Film Festival Discovery Channel diversity Fox News cancelled TV shows Television Academy CW Seed DirecTV DGA Sony Pictures Broadway 007 Comedy spanish language Podcast Alien Certified Fresh Disney Plus Instagram Live superhero rotten films USA boxoffice Avengers fresh cancelled TV series deadpool worst movies book adaptation romance Rock japan joker Food Network Emmy Nominations debate indie MTV Spike comic book movies PaleyFest Exclusive Video romantic comedy documentaries south america scorecard Endgame PlayStation Universal Pictures mutant TNT 20th Century Fox Adult Swim Mary poppins nature television 45 4/20 sitcom historical drama ghosts king arthur Cartoon Network TCA 2017 Character Guide Peacock sports space Superheroe BBC One spy thriller Watching Series Image Comics slasher olympics Creative Arts Emmys 93rd Oscars Tubi Set visit Rom-Com finale Teen richard e. Grant Comedy Central prank Thanksgiving ITV Sundance TV cooking legend science fiction Best and Worst discovery Horror series technology 1990s Shondaland critics anime pirates of the caribbean 2021 stoner Winter TV 73rd Emmy Awards children's TV travel Election HBO Max docuseries based on movie Rocky First Look NBC adaptation casting IMDb TV Schedule razzies italian El Rey Box Office composers hispanic Opinion