Critics Consensus

The Last Witch Hunter Doesn't Cast A Spell

Plus, Steve Jobs, The Knick, and Supergirl are all Certified Fresh.

by | October 22, 2015 | Comments

This week at the movies, we’ve got a slayer of the supernatural (The Last Witch Hunter, starring Vin Diesel and Elijah Wood); a tech icon (Steve Jobs, starring Michael Fassbender and Kate Winslet); contagious, outrageous musicians (Jem and the Holograms, starring Aubrey Peeples and Juliette Lewis); a desperate rock manager (Rock the Kasbah, starring Bill Murray and Bruce Willis); and a relentless spirit (Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension, starring Katie Featherston and Hallie Foote). What do the critics have to say?


The Last Witch Hunter (2015) 18%

First Abraham Lincoln killed vampires, then Hansel and Gretel pursued witches. Now, along comes another legendary figure — Vin Diesel — on a quest to rid the world of evil forces. Unfortunately, critics say The Last Witch Hunter is a seriously muddled fantasy adventure weighted down with dull exposition and mediocre action set-pieces. Diesel stars as Kaulder, an immortal witch hunter who seeks revenge after a close friend is killed. The pundits say The Last Witch Hunter is too dark and brooding to entertain as either a popcorn flick or as a campy lark.


Steve Jobs (2015) 85%

Screenwriter Aaron Sorkin is able to take seemingly unfilmable true stories — about the founding of Facebook, say, or the front office of the Oakland A’s — and turn them into the stuff of riveting drama. But critics say what really makes Steve Jobs something special is Michael Fassbender’s uncanny performance in the title role — he captures the tech mogul’s charisma as well as his less attractive attributes. Set around three of Jobs’ major product launches, the film also veers into the Apple head’s sometimes rocky interpersonal relations, and the pundits say that while Steve Jobs is occasionally stagey and overly talky, it’s magnificently crafted and wonderfully acted.


Jem and the Holograms (2015) 22%

Glamour! Glitter! Fashion! Fame! What more does a movie need? Well, critics say Jem and the Holograms could use more (and better) music; while the film has solid performances and flashes of energy, it too often feels like a Disney Channel showbiz drama. Based upon the popular 1980s cartoon show — but updated for the viral video era — Jem and the Holograms follows the titular band as it tries to become musical superstars. The pundits say the movie is bright and inoffensive, but also predictable and — at two hours — way too long.


Rock the Kasbah (2015) 7%

Directed by Barry Levinson,  starring Bill Murray, and featuring a bunch of big names in small roles, Rock the Kasbah has the kind of pedigree that most films would envy. Too bad, then, that, critics say the film is a serious miscalculation on many levels, from its inconsistent tone to its simplistic politics. Bill Murray stars as a down-on-his-luck music manager who finds himself stranded in Afghanistan after his only remaining act bails on a USO tour. While traveling through a small village, he discovers a young woman with a terrific voice, and decides to try to get her into a televised singing competition. The pundits say Rock the Kasbah is an off day for all concerned, though it might inspire viewers to check out its loose inspiration — the Certified Fresh 2009 documentary Afghan Star.


Paranormal Activity: The Ghost Dimension (2015) 14%

The first Paranormal Activity made oodles of cash and kicked off a craze of found footage horror films, but the franchise has been bumpy ever since. Critics say this latest incarnation — in which an eight-year-old is bedeviled by a malevolent spirit, necessitating the installation of security cameras — is mostly tired and predictable, with a few inventive wrinkles and a lot of rote jump scares.


What’s Hot on TV

The Knick: Season 2 (2015) 97%

The Knick delivers an addictive second season with stunning visuals, knockout performances, and disturbing moments adding up to a period drama that’s anything but dated.


Supergirl: Season 1 (2015) 92%

Melissa Benoist shines as Superman’s plucky little cousin in Supergirl, a family-friendly comic-book adaptation that ditches cynicism for heart.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Top Spin (2015) , a documentary about three young competitive ping pong players, is at 100 percent.
  • Heart of a Dog (2015) , Laurie Anderson‘s cinematic essay about the death of her beloved pooch, is at 95 percent.
  • Bone Tomahawk (2015) , starring Kurt Russell and Matthew Fox in a Western about a ragtag posse attempting to rescue its fellow townsfolk from cannibals, is t 84 percent.
  • Difret (2015) , a drama based on the true story of an Ethiopian teenager who killed the man who abducted her, is at 80 percent.
  • Suffragette (2015) , starring Carey Mulligan and Helena Bonham Carter in a historical drama about the fiery campaign for women’s voting rights in Great Britain, is at 79 percent.
  • Nasty Baby (2015) , starring Kristen Wiig in a dark comedy about a gay couple attempting to impregnate their close friend, is at 65 percent.
  • I Smile Back (2015) , starring Sarah Silverman and Josh Charles in a drama about a suburban mom in the throes of profound depression, is at 48 percent.
  • Tokyo Tribe (2015) , a gonzo Japanese hip-hop musical action film,  is at 48 percent.
  • Dan Franzen

    Having seen the new Paranormal Activity, I believe the 20% figure to be way too high. It’s a terrible rehash that, unfortunately, leaves the door open for yet another sequel (yes, I know this is purported to be the last one).

    • Jason Young

      Franchises like that care far more about ticket sales than critic scores. As long as 11th graders take their dates in hopes she’ll cozy up on you when the jump scare comes, they can keep cranking them out

      • Dan Franzen

        Even so, it’s not going be a high grosser. It didn’t cost much to make, I believe, so it’ll turn a profit (maybe?), but even fans of the found-footage subgenre will dislike it.

        • Jason Young

          We can only hope

  • Tenshi Ippikiookami

    if you don’t take into account steve jobs, which is getting wide, of the four new releases, the best rated right now is “Jem and the hologramas”…

  • Crockett

    I want to see a review of Bone Tomahawk here. Maybe next week?

Tag Cloud

cats dogs Adult Swim TBS fresh Podcast Turner Classic Movies Horror cars Holiday TNT Rock die hard OneApp obituary cartoon Elton John Shudder Nominations mutant Walt Disney Pictures crime drama E3 football Bravo Mindy Kaling directors Chilling Adventures of Sabrina GLAAD superhero boxoffice Sundance Now period drama universal monsters ESPN quibi Emmys VH1 The Academy stand-up comedy 93rd Oscars Ovation supernatural Pop biography comics Watching Series Rocky CNN Interview toronto Amazon Prime 2015 GIFs book Pacific Islander binge concert comedies TV One cancelled game show Fox News harry potter Holidays ABC Signature Family TCM Television Critics Association Western VOD kaiju crime Starz BBC One Martial Arts chucky nature films Ghostbusters Red Carpet video on demand trailers crossover fast and furious 20th Century Fox 24 frames finale singing competition A&E Arrowverse Sony Pictures DGA Grammys video theme song festival Fall TV A24 Black History Month new star wars movies foreign sitcom Image Comics robots LGBTQ RT History DC Comics Peacock lord of the rings USA franchise richard e. Grant mission: impossible jamie lee curtis hist SundanceTV BBC America Comedy Reality worst halloween tv diversity DirecTV BET Awards movie FOX doctor who Binge Guide ratings dark Comedy Central Awards james bond batman ABC Academy Awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards golden globes laika Trivia Trophy Talk justice league HBO LGBT DC Universe Shondaland Oscars nbcuniversal BBC Tumblr Nickelodeon movies Tarantino CBS rom-coms war streaming movies Vudu Captain marvel godzilla The Arrangement Hallmark based on movie australia social media twilight aapi book adaptation cancelled TV shows blockbuster new york ITV Legendary japanese Opinion Spring TV aliens Countdown Teen MSNBC 72 Emmy Awards zombie Awards Tour Esquire south america Amazon game of thrones technology cults comic books Cannes TV renewals Fox Searchlight Video Games news Winners Broadway Creative Arts Emmys Freeform Valentine's Day Hallmark Christmas movies strong female leads scene in color toy story Best and Worst 2019 Mystery Character Guide Action Disney streaming service Spectrum Originals high school Mary Tyler Moore Apple Crackle renewed TV shows women Star Wars Superheroe deadpool werewolf The CW animated Cartoon Network TCA American Society of Cinematographers Disney Channel docudrama satire Exclusive Video National Geographic USA Network disaster Lucasfilm Travel Channel Rocketman TCA Winter 2020 Epix king kong stop motion spain San Diego Comic-Con Mary poppins Country Women's History Month President indie discovery Crunchyroll Pride Month Polls and Games critics golden globe awards RT21 Premiere Dates Ellie Kemper Stephen King Acorn TV Columbia Pictures romantic comedy independent First Reviews Syfy sag awards cinemax Food Network CMT canceled TV shows witnail Photos Netflix Christmas movies NBC Box Office dragons adaptation CBS All Access jurassic park Comic Book Trailer popular First Look Amazon Studios Comics on TV Sneak Peek Showtime Animation Hulu teaser slashers spanish language Christmas breaking bad casting Disney Plus natural history 71st Emmy Awards serial killer rotten cancelled television Toys Musical docuseries heist movie archives X-Men ABC Family hidden camera FX on Hulu TV movies Rom-Com rt archives Baby Yoda YouTube Premium science fiction spinoff Sci-Fi adventure 2020 SDCC cancelled TV series Warner Bros. 99% sequel ViacomCBS Paramount Drama versus transformers hispanic Summer crime thriller TIFF international Apple TV+ police drama Election award winner dramedy cops parents Britbox Spike TCA Awards pirates of the caribbean Lionsgate 2018 Classic Film Film Festival TLC Marvel Studios 007 ghosts Nat Geo miniseries Turner reboot Set visit Funimation 2017 Schedule anime CW Seed Pirates Emmy Nominations Calendar E! MTV scorecard Brie Larson cooking reviews Hear Us Out Netflix AMC Marvel WGN History MCU Musicals Chernobyl Super Bowl Logo political drama Cosplay halloween razzies green book IFC Films marvel cinematic universe stoner live action The Walking Dead Alien IFC christmas movies historical drama joker latino DC streaming service Writers Guild of America Quiz nfl Thanksgiving medical drama hollywood canceled Fantasy Universal spy thriller 21st Century Fox SXSW comic screenings Certified Fresh name the review elevated horror Reality Competition free movies Apple TV Plus See It Skip It Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt The Walt Disney Company festivals politics Kids & Family Amazon Prime Video anthology BET Biopics black Lifetime Christmas movies 2016 WarnerMedia blockbusters New York Comic Con vampires Marvel Television documentary TCA 2017 El Rey best Infographic comiccon Tubi PaleyFest Tomatazos HBO Max spanish TV Dark Horse Comics Discovery Channel PlayStation Endgame OWN BAFTA 2021 child's play rotten movies we love indiana jones Extras Star Trek Year in Review HBO Go romance superman Pixar space thriller worst movies 45 prank unscripted Disney true crime know your critic PBS Mary Poppins Returns Black Mirror Disney+ Disney Plus Paramount Plus ID revenge children's TV The Witch zero dark thirty all-time dc YouTube TruTV 4/20 Anna Paquin FX Film Sundance asian-american Pet Sematary Paramount Network Television Academy tv talk Music new zealand psychological thriller television APB NYCC series a nightmare on elm street sports documentaries facebook blaxploitation composers travel boxing Pop TV emmy awards target classics GoT YouTube Red talk show saw TV Land Lifetime french Marathons Song of Ice and Fire Winter TV psycho scary movies zombies Superheroes kong Sundance TV Heroines what to watch remakes streaming criterion sequels spider-man telelvision italian dceu Avengers Masterpiece FXX mockumentary Mudbound screen actors guild YA monster movies The Purge VICE kids venice