Critics Consensus

The Happytime Murders Won't Leave You in Stitches

Plus, Support the Girls is Certified Fresh, and guess A.X.L.'s Tomatometer.

by | August 23, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got  Melissa McCarthy sharing the screen with some very profane puppets (The Happytime Murders, co-starring Elizabeth Banks and Maya Rudolph) and a boy and his robot dog (A.X.L., starring Alex Neustaedter and Becky G). What are the critics saying?


The Happytime Murders (2018) 23%

Jim Henson made tons of timeless family-friendly fare with his Muppets, but — as evidenced by film projects like The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth — he never saw puppetry strictly as kids’ stuff. It’s fitting, then, that his son Brian has taken that experimental spirit and injected it into The Happytime Murders, an R-rated black comedy following a murder mystery that takes place in a world populated by humans and puppets. A blend of ostensibly cuddly characters and enthusiastically adult humor, this is the kind of movie that sounds too gonzo to be real — and it almost wasn’t, enduring a decade in development before facing a lawsuit from the studio behind Sesame Street. After all that, it saddens us to report that Happytime is getting murdered by critics; reviews describe a clumsy comedy that’s too busy being aggressively edgy to actually be funny, never mind put a fresh spin on a story whose rough outline should be familiar to anyone who’s seen Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Despite that Henson pedigree and a terrific human cast that includes Melissa McCarthy, Maya Rudolph, Elizabeth Banks, and Joel McHale, this looks like one to stream — if you see it at all.


A.X.L. (2018) 25%

Hollywood is definitely taking that whole “dog days of summer” thing seriously this year. Last week, audiences went back in time to imagine the first boy-and-his-dog friendship in Alpha; this week, we’re taking a peek into the future with A.X.L., in which a teenage boy (Alex Neustaedter) happens upon a canine-shaped cutting-edge military robot. Naturally, the contraption’s bureaucratic minders are eager to get their creation back on its leash, so to speak — a quest complicated by the fact that our young hero has already bonded with his new four-legged pal. So it’s Benji plus Short Circuit, but does it add up to a winner with the critics? Unfortunately, we don’t know yet, because A.X.L. doesn’t have any reviews yet. That’s rarely a positive sign this late in the week, but while we wait to see for sure how things shake out, how about a round of Guess the Tomatometer?


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

The CW CBS All Access Esquire festivals Martial Arts Fox News Best and Worst Star Wars Walt Disney Pictures mutant miniseries Box Office Writers Guild of America Superheroes vampires CNN Pirates science fiction Cartoon Network Super Bowl Lionsgate TIFF dc HBO 24 frames biography Ovation cooking VICE TCM zombie finale New York Comic Con National Geographic Fantasy Columbia Pictures YouTube Red 2019 ratings Emmys RT History Marathons spy thriller unscripted medical drama USA Black Mirror Sony Pictures Britbox VH1 A&E Paramount Network Marvel cops SDCC dramedy DirecTV Song of Ice and Fire thriller Calendar award winner IFC period drama comiccon Hulu Paramount Red Carpet Thanksgiving serial killer Acorn TV Reality Competition Podcast FOX crime drama CBS Winners Disney docudrama OWN Quiz DC Universe Shudder CMT Adult Swim green book doctor who historical drama TNT BBC Grammys DC streaming service Musicals Election Nominations robots Bravo Action 20th Century Fox boxoffice Showtime Superheroe Cosplay Comics on TV GoT PaleyFest streaming YA Reality BET Infographic SundanceTV Apple Disney Channel television Epix crossover Winter TV composers ITV Logo Lifetime Amazon Comedy Central Opinion PBS 45 Starz Countdown LGBTQ jamie lee curtis transformers Sneak Peek First Look war Character Guide TCA 2017 Mary poppins BBC America golden globes San Diego Comic-Con Horror political drama Watching Series TLC TruTV Kids & Family Crackle crime thriller Animation Food Network cinemax Freeform zombies IFC Films what to watch Tomatazos social media justice league DC Comics Universal Rocky American Society of Cinematographers APB GLAAD Spring TV FX Awards Tour 2018 Interview Netflix Comic Book Star Trek Set visit Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Awards Certified Fresh Nickelodeon El Rey cats Photos technology discovery Valentine's Day Ellie Kemper comic 21st Century Fox Musical Lucasfilm ABC Music Trophy Talk Nat Geo Fall TV Teen 2015 Sundance Rock sitcom Biopics Christmas politics Shondaland Extras TCA sports Rom-Com travel Trivia Holidays ABC Family Summer Western aliens singing competition Country YouTube Premium See It Skip It Creative Arts Emmys Pop MTV WGN Year in Review 2017 Masterpiece talk show crime Spike Drama AMC blaxploitation Polls and Games based on movie President hist supernatural Mystery FXX Sci-Fi psycho binge GIFs NYCC Schedule X-Men CW Seed Warner Bros. History TV Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Pixar Comedy ESPN NBC Premiere Dates harry potter SXSW Ghostbusters Mindy Kaling anime romance spider-man Video Games diversity Dark Horse Comics police drama Tumblr 2016 Mary Poppins Returns E! cults 007 dceu facebook The Arrangement Oscars Toys Sundance Now E3 adventure Syfy USA Network MSNBC Trailer TBS TV Land Mary Tyler Moore