Critics Consensus

The Happytime Murders Won't Leave You in Stitches

Plus, Support the Girls is Certified Fresh, and guess A.X.L.'s Tomatometer.

by | August 23, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got  Melissa McCarthy sharing the screen with some very profane puppets (The Happytime Murders, co-starring Elizabeth Banks and Maya Rudolph) and a boy and his robot dog (A.X.L., starring Alex Neustaedter and Becky G). What are the critics saying?


The Happytime Murders (2018) 24%

Jim Henson made tons of timeless family-friendly fare with his Muppets, but — as evidenced by film projects like The Dark Crystal and Labyrinth — he never saw puppetry strictly as kids’ stuff. It’s fitting, then, that his son Brian has taken that experimental spirit and injected it into The Happytime Murders, an R-rated black comedy following a murder mystery that takes place in a world populated by humans and puppets. A blend of ostensibly cuddly characters and enthusiastically adult humor, this is the kind of movie that sounds too gonzo to be real — and it almost wasn’t, enduring a decade in development before facing a lawsuit from the studio behind Sesame Street. After all that, it saddens us to report that Happytime is getting murdered by critics; reviews describe a clumsy comedy that’s too busy being aggressively edgy to actually be funny, never mind put a fresh spin on a story whose rough outline should be familiar to anyone who’s seen Who Framed Roger Rabbit. Despite that Henson pedigree and a terrific human cast that includes Melissa McCarthy, Maya Rudolph, Elizabeth Banks, and Joel McHale, this looks like one to stream — if you see it at all.


A.X.L. (2018) 27%

Hollywood is definitely taking that whole “dog days of summer” thing seriously this year. Last week, audiences went back in time to imagine the first boy-and-his-dog friendship in Alpha; this week, we’re taking a peek into the future with A.X.L., in which a teenage boy (Alex Neustaedter) happens upon a canine-shaped cutting-edge military robot. Naturally, the contraption’s bureaucratic minders are eager to get their creation back on its leash, so to speak — a quest complicated by the fact that our young hero has already bonded with his new four-legged pal. So it’s Benji plus Short Circuit, but does it add up to a winner with the critics? Unfortunately, we don’t know yet, because A.X.L. doesn’t have any reviews yet. That’s rarely a positive sign this late in the week, but while we wait to see for sure how things shake out, how about a round of Guess the Tomatometer?


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

Tag Cloud

politics Disney FXX docudrama Holiday SundanceTV game show Mary poppins discovery 24 frames laika Mudbound Fox Searchlight spanish language Logo FOX Stephen King The CW harry potter Summer Hallmark Christmas movies comics Sci-Fi Extras critics Comic Book Premiere Dates TCA 2017 spinoff Superheroes Heroines RT21 YA 007 name the review Paramount Network Reality Competition halloween Marvel Studios video Apple TV+ Action dc Horror Funimation Netflix Christmas movies japanese El Rey archives First Reviews DC streaming service 4/20 all-time Polls and Games Amazon Studios Drama GLAAD Columbia Pictures TCA Awards spider-man Podcast romance worst movies films Year in Review universal monsters werewolf Ovation The Academy National Geographic Pride Month 2015 Endgame CNN Lifetime series Teen boxoffice TCA classics VICE Mary Poppins Returns Character Guide Esquire 72 Emmy Awards Comedy australia Watching Series Sundance 20th Century Fox slashers SXSW Fantasy superhero Biopics chucky Hear Us Out cars what to watch italian children's TV singing competition Oscars ABC Universal remakes TCM Adult Swim Binge Guide Sony Pictures Rocketman Epix Emmys Mindy Kaling CW Seed franchise Film Nat Geo Trivia independent Turner Classic Movies cooking Pop TV DGA Baby Yoda NYCC composers quibi venice ITV Calendar Bravo supernatural toy story adventure dramedy comic green book psychological thriller cancelled American Society of Cinematographers Comics on TV Apple TV Plus Kids & Family television mutant halloween tv Star Wars Hulu Cartoon Network Awards movies The Arrangement Thanksgiving jamie lee curtis serial killer USA die hard Ellie Kemper spanish YouTube Premium Syfy Grammys a nightmare on elm street documentaries latino Pop Best and Worst Song of Ice and Fire renewed TV shows facebook Schedule nature satire CMT hist Discovery Channel Certified Fresh science fiction worst LGBT psycho canceled TV shows romantic comedy Rock DC Comics comedies nfl ghosts Country CBS ABC Family TNT X-Men Christmas Family Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Elton John concert Emmy Nominations Women's History Month Pixar canceled disaster GoT reboot TruTV Disney Channel Starz documentary stop motion IFC Films Spectrum Originals doctor who unscripted New York Comic Con Video Games Opinion game of thrones Creative Arts Emmys YouTube Red VH1 History Academy Awards james bond spain Lifetime Christmas movies Holidays TBS political drama The Witch kids indie crossover Marvel Television finale ESPN cops adaptation WarnerMedia Black Mirror Warner Bros. Photos Trailer crime thriller Spring TV news Classic Film 21st Century Fox PBS theme song screen actors guild Anna Paquin sag awards Brie Larson comiccon WGN Star Trek MSNBC diversity Countdown A24 hollywood Lucasfilm Animation Comedy Central Hallmark Netflix Sundance TV period drama Avengers Spike Food Network parents stoner richard e. Grant mission: impossible Tumblr rt archives Western Musical Nominations Tubi A&E Disney Plus Trophy Talk screenings fresh streaming YouTube Cosplay south america BET Tarantino Amazon natural history 2018 deadpool Mystery casting 2019 TV renewals President cancelled TV series free movies Writers Guild of America cancelled TV shows HBO The Purge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Shondaland AMC obituary APB CBS All Access rotten movies we love ratings Crunchyroll FX 2020 sitcom zombie Rom-Com cats Arrowverse DirecTV book LGBTQ sequels tv talk blockbuster BAFTA TV anthology Pirates historical drama First Look strong female leads HBO Max Turner Superheroe Toys Paramount transformers Chernobyl Winter TV MTV scary movies elevated horror The Walking Dead Winners Alien social media Vudu Box Office animated golden globes sports VOD foreign Interview Fox News NBC comic books Reality OneApp ID crime witnail football Freeform dark justice league cartoon Valentine's Day FX on Hulu Super Bowl Film Festival 71st Emmy Awards hispanic Crackle PlayStation rotten E! Shudder RT History anime Pet Sematary Set visit toronto award winner emmy awards dogs nbcuniversal TCA Winter 2020 Dark Horse Comics dragons TV Land child's play Red Carpet zero dark thirty war cults Black History Month boxing asian-american aliens cinemax MCU Nickelodeon cancelled television Marvel Cannes Showtime space video on demand SDCC joker zombies Britbox Masterpiece teaser 2016 Acorn TV blaxploitation Sneak Peek HBO Go reviews Disney streaming service scorecard USA Network robots Sundance Now french TLC Ghostbusters Television Academy Disney+ Disney Plus spy thriller BBC America black Quiz festivals revenge travel 2017 Apple stand-up comedy Walt Disney Pictures true crime Lionsgate indiana jones Mary Tyler Moore based on movie OWN crime drama directors biography BET Awards GIFs versus movie batman Tomatazos thriller Election vampires BBC One miniseries breaking bad Captain marvel Amazon Prime Video Fall TV binge dceu 45 mockumentary Amazon Prime Musicals christmas movies best sequel talk show fast and furious twilight medical drama Rocky Infographic Martial Arts Peacock police drama Marathons Awards Tour See It Skip It BBC criterion TIFF Television Critics Association technology San Diego Comic-Con PaleyFest Travel Channel 99% Music IFC DC Universe E3 festival