Trophy Talk

The Golden Globes May Be Over, and Here's Why

Need a full-blown explainer on this Golden Globes situation? We're breaking down the Hollywood Foreign Press Association's path to its critical split with broadcaster NBC.

by | May 11, 2021 | Comments

Golden Globes trophies

(Photo by Frazer Harrison/Getty Images)

On Monday morning, NBC announced that it would not broadcast the 2022 Golden Globe Awards in what was seen as a crippling blow to the Hollywood Foreign Press Association (HFPA), the organization that hands out the annual prizes and which has been mired in bad headlines over the past several months. The statement from NBC, which is a part of Rotten Tomatoes’ parent company NBCUniversal, read:

“We continue to believe that the HFPA is committed to meaningful reform. However, change of this magnitude takes time and work, and we feel strongly that the HFPA needs time to do it right. As such, NBC will not air the 2022 Golden Globes. Assuming the organization executes on its plan, we are hopeful we will be in a position to air the show in January 2023.”

Though many entertainment insiders have long derided the HFPA for its lack of diversity, unprofessional actions by its members, and the extravagant gifts those members receive, most believed the group was immune to any real reform. However, today’s announcement from NBC, which comes on the heels of fallout from a bombshell LA Times report back in February that detailed decades of self-dealing, unethical actions, homophobia, sexism, and racism by several members, may prove to be the end of the organization as we know it.

But why exactly is NBC – along with entertainment powerhouses like Netflix, Amazon, Warner Bros., and Tom Cruise(!) – cutting ties with the once-coveted awards show? Here’s a breakdown…

HFPA Building

(Photo by Valerie Macon/Getty Images)

First, let’s talk about the organization itself. The Hollywood Foreign Press Association is a small group of around 90 journalists who cover entertainment for international audiences while based in Southern California. The group, which has been around since 1944, has been the subject of several controversies, criticized for everything from a poor selection of nominated films to blatant bribery. Some say that some of the HFPA’s members have tenuous ties to Hollywood and/or lack journalistic bona fides, and in the Times report, it was confirmed that the group had not had a Black member in over 20 years. The report also noted that several seemingly qualified journalists have been rejected for membership, with one applicant suing the organization just last year, dubbing them an entertainment “cartel.”

Five-time Golden Globes host Ricky Gervais himself once compared the Globes unfavorably to the Oscars in 2012, saying the former was “a bit louder, a bit trashier, a bit drunker, and more easily bought – allegedly.” His comments drew big laughs and big applause on the night because many in the room judged the quip to be all too true.

Ricky Gervais hosts the 2012 Golden Gloves

(Photo by NBC/Getty Images)

The questionable nominations had also been the talk of the industry since well before the Times report. This year, pop star Sia’s controversial film Music earned two nominations despite being blasted by critics to the point that its Tomatometer score stands at just 8%. (Its Audience Score is a similarly paltry 13%.) The assumed justification for this is that, because Sia is very camera shy, the nomination would compel the musician to make herself available for interviews and selfies – something the HFPA has become notorious for asking of every celebrity. In 2017 after Tom Ford, the fashion-designer-turned-director of Nocturnal Animals, gifted HFPA members a swag bag of his own branded fragrances, his star Aaron Taylor Johnson was chosen as Best Supporting Actor over eventual Oscar winner Mahershala Ali (Moonlight), a decision that left many scratching their heads and some crying foul. The backlash was so loud the group was told to return the gifts by the HFPA board. In any given year, pundits point to a handful of confounding nominations that are attributable less to the quality of performances and more to the HFPA’s desire to have certain famous faces show up for their red carpets.

Still, despite the constant controversy and silly choices, the show was considered a fun watch by most; organizers’ choices of tables instead of theater seats allowed A-listers to mingle together and perhaps tip a glass with Oprah, Beyoncé, Tom Hanks, or Lady Gaga… all while we watched, looking for fun, meme-able moments. It’s worth noting too, that the Globes have also managed a relatively consistent viewership, save its Zoom-filled event this year, which came just weeks after the LA Times piece but was still on par with an Oscars ceremony that boasted full attendance and a red carpet. (Hosts Tina Fey and Amy Poehler, as well as HFPA members, had to address the controversy during the show.) All the glitz of the event, plus those ratings, are largely why many Hollywood players have begrudgingly played along, hoping to help their Oscar chances with a win or good moment and boost awards-season ticket sales and ratings for the nominated films and TV shows.

Tina Fey and Amy Poehler at the 2021 Golden Globes

(Photo by Kevin Mazur/Getty Images)

Studios have been all too happy to participate in pricey private HFPA press conferences, send members glitzy swag (sometimes), host dinners for them, and even fly them out to set visits at luxury locales. Last year, for example, the entire HFPA was flown to Paris to visit the set of Emily in Paris and treated to a stay at a 5-star hotel, which was brought up quickly after the group gave the widely panned Netflix series two nominations. Netflix, however, was not the only or the most egregious offender; in fact, that was how most of the town operated – because the incentives outweighed the downside. That was until now.

After the LA Times story broke, the HFPA was quick to say a change was coming. The membership, which had long bristled at adding new members and diversifying its ranks – in order to guarantee predictable results, according to the LA Times – was now under immense pressure to do just that or risk losing its lucrative television contract, the group’s primary source of revenue. The HFPA quickly hired a diversity consultant and crisis PR management team to help facilitate the change they announced was coming, first via a statement and again during the live awards show broadcast.

Lily Collins in Emily in Paris

(Photo by Carole Bethuel/©Netflix)

As the talks happened behind the scenes, the industry’s most powerful PR agencies banded together on March 15th with a pointed warning that they would no longer engage with the group unless the changes were substantial, quick, and long-lasting. This was significant, as PR firms typically try to avoid weighing in on such controversies, but as the gatekeepers to the top talent in Hollywood, they hold immeasurable power over whether the HFPA can have those desirable A-listers attend their show. Moreover, the idea of high-powered competitors banding together on anything like this is a clear illustration of how frustrated they are with the situation and how committed they are to fixing the underlying issues. The HFPA replied that they were taking time to consult various stakeholders, including NBC, the awards show’s producers, Dick Clark Productions, and industry leaders, and their plans would be announced on May 5.

The proposed reforms and the new timeline they released after NBC pulled the TV Contract are as follows:

Week of May 3

  • Members meet, consider, and overwhelmingly vote to approve and implement the Board’s plan for transformational change
  • Board continues to meet with advocacy groups to develop initiatives to fulfill the HFPA’s commitment to add at least 20 new members by August 2021 and increase membership by 50% in 18 months
  • Eradicating the new member one-year moratorium on voting; all new members will have all voting rights on day one
  • Board and members approve the hiring of Ropes & Gray to amend and restate bylaws and other governing documents to implement a member-approved plan for transformational change

Weeks of May 10 and 17

  • Revise and approve new Code of Conduct in consultation with publicists and studios
  • Continue outreach to potential new member candidates
  • Publish Code of Conduct and establish hotline for reporting of violations
  • Engage independent third-party investigator to review and respond promptly to all hotline claims
  • Interview candidates and engage new Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (“DEI”) consultant
  • Identify and recruit independent, outside professionals and non-board members and form Accountability/Oversight Board (“Advisory Board”) to oversee HFPA Board in implementing a plan for transformational change
  • Interview executive search firms to commence search for Chief DEI/HR Officer and identification of potential CEO/CFO and other executives to lead HFPA
  • HFPA website to be continuously updated to show progress against plan and to list promised member information (biographies, publications, affiliations, etc.)

Weeks of May 24 and 31

  • New DEI Consultant and other outside experts conduct mandatory member training for DEI and sexual harassment
  • Board and Advisory Board continue work on the identification of applicants to fulfill commitment to add at least 20 new members by August 2021
  • Grants Officer and subcommittee of members continue work to increase support of internship, mentorship, and scholarship programs for students from underrepresented backgrounds interested in international journalism
  • Identify and recruit independent, outside professionals for new Credentials Committee, which will oversee new membership application process and reaccreditation of current members based on same criteria as new members
  • Continue review of committee structure/compensation
  • First reading of Bylaw Amendments at General Membership Meeting (“GMM”)

Weeks of June 7, 14, and 21

  • Focus groups with members, Advisory Board, and Ropes & Gray to review amendments to Bylaws and other governing documents
  • Board assesses and evaluates recommendations of Executive Search Firm for new Executive Officer team
  • Form new Credentials Committee
  • All above workstreams on training, mentorship, and recruitment continue

Week of June 28

  • Second reading of Bylaw Amendments at GMM
  • Ballots for voting on Bylaw Amendments mailed to members
  • Implement new policies on Gifts, Travel, Conflicts of Interest, and Press Conferences

Week of July 5

  • Members vote on Bylaw Amendments by ballot

Weeks of 12 and 19

  • Approved Bylaw Amendments become effective
  • New Officer and Board elections under amended and restated Bylaws
  • New membership process opens per new criteria enacted in amended and restated Bylaws
  • All existing members required to meet same standards as new members for re-accreditation of their membership

Week of July 26

  • New member process continues
  • Reaccreditation continues

Week of August 2

  • New members admitted to HFPA
  • New Board elected, including independent members, in accordance with amended and restated Bylaws
  • New CEO/CFO and other Executive Team approved and engaged to manage HFPA
  • Existing Board and Officers resign upon election of New Board and hiring of Executive Team

The initial proposals were leaked before the deadline without a clear timeline, and the reaction throughout Hollywood was a swift and immediate chorus of “do better.” No word yet on how the new timeline will be received, but the HFPA was clear these measures would be enacted regardless of the 2022 television broadcast. Still, many are unsatisfied primarily because, more than the membership and self-dealing, the HFPA has been accused of shameful bouts of unprofessionalism over the years. Stories from Ava DuVernay, Shonda Rhimes, and Brendan Fraser have detailed abuses that many viewed can’t be fixed by the initial proposals, which were also considered too slow-moving to address the membership issues.

Ava DuVernay at the 2018 Golden Globes

(Photo by Kevork Djansezian/NBC/Getty Images)

Inclusivity activist organization Time’s Up released a statement that decried the proposed changes as window dressing, while the PR firms who first proposed a boycott of HFPA events were slightly more measured, saying this was a good step but not near enough and far too slow for a group of so few members. Then on Friday, a letter from Netflix Co-CEO Ted Sarandos took what was already a crisis for the HFPA and turned it into a full-blown disaster when he announced Netflix would not participate in any HFPA events until more changes were made and made quickly. In a message directed to the organization, Sarandos stated: “Today’s is an important first step, however, we don’t believe these proposed new policies — particularly around the size and speed of membership growth — will tackle the HFPA’s systemic diversity and inclusion challenges, or the lack of clear standards for how your members should operate.” Amazon and Warner Bros. soon followed with similar statements.

It was a game-changing move. In truth, for everything said up to this point, if the studios were satisfied with the HFPA’s proposals, nothing was going to change, as they held all the power. But with the weight of the increasingly powerful streamers and a major studio joining in, the winds were shifting.

It didn’t help that at the height of the organization’s current woes, both the diversity consultant and PR crisis manager discontinued their work with the HFPA, nor that fresh issues have emerged: A couple of weeks ago, a current member mistook Daniel Kaluuya for Leslie Odom Jr. in the Oscars press room – a gaffe that left Kaluuya stunned and for which the journalist has refused to apologize. It’s little wonder that this week three-time Golden Globe winner Tom Cruise sent his awards back to the HFPA in protest of their actions.

Daniel Kaluuya and Leslie Odom Jr. at the 2021 Oscars

(Photo by ©AMPAS courtesy Everett Collection)

With NBC’s announcement that it will not air the broadcast they had paid $60 million to secure just last year, the crisis is now existential for the HFPA. As things compound, many cannot help but ask, “Can the Golden Globes survive?”

Some have suggested the HFPA can indeed weather the storm with a severe overhaul, while others say the situation is too far gone to repair, and perhaps NBC and other networks should look at a different set of awards to spotlight with a major broadcast, as some have suggested. It’s difficult to dislodge anything with this much history in Hollywood, and funnily enough, all of this has happened before.

In 1968, NBC pulled their TV contract with the Golden Globes when an FCC report detailed that the HFPA “substantially misleads the public as to how the winners were chosen and the procedures followed in choosing them.” At that time, the group did not actually vote on category winners, as it was assumed, but rather decided winners via a lobbying committee. After changes were made and a professional accounting firm was hired to compile the vote, NBC ended up televising the show, and that is what we think will likely occur this time around.

If the Golden Globes disappear, that leaves a gap in the awards calendar in early January, something that second-tier shows like the Screen Actors Guild Awards or Critics’ Choice Awards could fill. But unless they’re partnered with a major broadcaster like NBC – with its global reach and top hosting and presenting talent from a pool of SNL alums and late-night leaders – it’s unlikely they would hold into it if NBC and the Globes eventually make nice. For now, we can all agree that the Globes must make swift changes, or they will cease to exist; it still remains to be seen, however, if that is possible, given the current membership’s reputations.

On an Apple device? Follow Rotten Tomatoes on Apple News.

Tag Cloud

Warner Bros. posters richard e. Grant Quiz Marvel independent comics HBO Go discovery Vudu archives comic book movies sequel obituary Sundance CBS All Access rt labs IFC movie Legendary VICE 71st Emmy Awards king kong X-Men Dark Horse Comics Endgame scorecard Song of Ice and Fire Box Office Amazon Prime Video Pacific Islander Oscars The CW transformers The Witch Pride Month docudrama Funimation Alien spanish language SDCC reboot pirates of the caribbean black animated Best and Worst spy thriller breaking bad Mary Tyler Moore satire Writers Guild of America Ghostbusters monster movies Netflix NBC Spike Cannes films international Discovery Channel Summer Valentine's Day television Trophy Talk Anna Paquin psycho Red Carpet romantic comedy Disney+ Disney Plus marvel cinematic universe indie social media Martial Arts finale tv talk biopic YA serial killer Amazon Studios cats quibi mcc Sci-Fi high school DGA BAFTA golden globes crime drama godzilla The Purge 2018 ID Freeform BBC spanish Adult Swim zombie TV australia TCM Disney Channel Baby Yoda Family asian-american robots aliens disaster Countdown Tomatazos rom-coms Opinion child's play blockbuster Women's History Month RT History cancelled television adaptation Black History Month saw WGN dceu revenge Acorn TV basketball stoner superhero CW Seed Hallmark Christmas movies TV Land classics Sundance TV E3 worst Crackle vampires YouTube Biopics 21st Century Fox History YouTube Premium Calendar halloween tv justice league police drama Black Mirror Binge Guide award winner hist Stephen King women Wes Anderson Mudbound PBS heist movie Television Academy TCA Awards scene in color Premiere Dates superman parents Pirates gangster TNT game of thrones new york crime thriller TV renewals free movies suspense TCA 2017 die hard zero dark thirty directors stop motion Tokyo Olympics Image Comics Polls and Games jamie lee curtis BBC One Interview Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Animation VOD Brie Larson legend screen actors guild versus boxing streaming video boxoffice Masterpiece canceled Disney Plus DC Comics New York Comic Con documentary Star Trek italian reviews A24 aapi jurassic park dramedy ViacomCBS Comic Book Reality Trivia PaleyFest dexter medical drama Lucasfilm blaxploitation Comic-Con@Home 2021 dc DirecTV Ovation target Nickelodeon blockbusters batman Rock GIFs Pop TV james bond Superheroe The Arrangement Columbia Pictures Toys Marvel Studios nfl Shudder true crime children's TV Awards Emmy Nominations Tarantino Set visit slasher critics GLAAD Christmas french Election what to watch 2016 dark Universal Winter TV know your critic spain Tubi slashers First Look The Walt Disney Company 90s MTV news LGBT elevated horror Holidays IFC Films Captain marvel nature chucky strong female leads Apple TV Plus debate cops biography Western OneApp wonder woman movies feel good NBA APB criterion all-time Year in Review hollywood south america period drama Creative Arts Emmys comiccon Exclusive Video YouTube Red ESPN spinoff kids TV movies Watching Series universal monsters Marathons Paramount Network Tumblr renewed TV shows USA Network Mary poppins PlayStation diversity National Geographic concert rotten movies we love ABC 73rd Emmy Awards El Rey TruTV Pop golden globe awards Nat Geo remakes HBO Hear Us Out Music 2015 Infographic The Walking Dead laika critic resources unscripted Ellie Kemper crime Nominations cancelled FXX fresh festival football harry potter prank DC Universe cancelled TV shows Video Games Classic Film 24 frames Television Critics Association war comic adenture CNN book 2021 supernatural kaiju Comedy binge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt indiana jones ABC Signature Photos BET Awards Certified Fresh casting game show travel Sony Pictures joker nbcuniversal royal family Thanksgiving Logo Cosplay Schedule Super Bowl talk show docuseries 20th Century Fox screenings Podcast doctor who crossover a nightmare on elm street Spring TV USA composers anime TV One Walt Disney Pictures BET DC streaming service Marvel Television mission: impossible Amazon Prime San Diego Comic-Con Britbox Rocketman mutant President HBO Max Mystery NYCC twilight Shondaland Lifetime Elton John FOX space comedies teaser Pixar Fox News Turner Classic Movies ITV Holiday singing competition Grammys RT21 Food Network Lionsgate dragons TLC Star Wars Comedy Central worst movies documentaries new zealand Travel Channel young adult cancelled TV series cinemax The Academy 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards cooking See It Skip It historical drama sitcom werewolf Avengers trailers Film TIFF Drama CMT American Society of Cinematographers marvel comics Paramount Fall TV Spectrum Originals foreign rt archives Film Festival series fast and furious Trailer Syfy Peacock adventure Crunchyroll SXSW sports video on demand mockumentary A&E Bravo Hulu razzies cars Apple 007 ghosts LGBTQ Epix TBS Academy Awards Awards Tour Teen FX Arrowverse BBC America MCU Action Musical Rom-Com festivals 2019 GoT scary movies popular hispanic toy story Amazon 99% action-comedy miniseries 1990s spider-man Netflix Christmas movies king arthur hidden camera Superheroes venice Emmys Showtime dogs TCA psychological thriller romance Esquire 72 Emmy Awards Fox Searchlight live action streaming movies based on movie technology hispanic heritage month Turner 2020 MSNBC Mary Poppins Returns Rocky Horror Hallmark latino Kids & Family 45 93rd Oscars AMC Pet Sematary TCA Winter 2020 FX on Hulu natural history cults japan deadpool Lifetime Christmas movies Cartoon Network Winners Extras Musicals toronto ABC Family book adaptation Starz emmy awards Apple TV+ thriller 2017 Comics on TV kong SundanceTV facebook olympics 4/20 theme song sag awards christmas movies stand-up comedy Mindy Kaling anthology political drama Reality Competition best CBS japanese Sundance Now halloween Fantasy politics new star wars movies First Reviews franchise Broadway Sneak Peek witnail comic books Heroines cartoon Chernobyl zombies rt labs critics edition canceled TV shows Disney streaming service OWN VH1 Disney name the review sequels green book WarnerMedia E! rotten Character Guide comic book movie Country lord of the rings science fiction Paramount Plus telelvision ratings