The Ghost Stays in the Picture

Shutter and the history of ghostly images

by | May 4, 2008 | Comments

The Ghost Stays in the Picture

Shutter is another J-Horror remake with technology run awry at its core. This time, it’s not videotape but celluloid that betrays the imprint of the supernatural. But having ghosties appear on camera isn’t new – people have been claiming to capture the undead on film ever since the camera was invented.

Is seeing is believing? Not quite. But seeing is fun! Here’s a potted history of ghosts in the picture.


Picture of Dorian Gray
Dorian Gray – Before.

Let’s start off with really old technology – oil paint, plus, well, magic. Oscar Wilde’s classic tale was greeted with lukewarm reviews due to its then disturbing homoerotic subtext, but since has become a firm fave. Dorian Gray, man about town, lets the secret portrait hidden in his attic accept the corruption that his real life endures. Thus he remains beautiful, yet the painting degrades beyond repugnance. Finally of course, the real Dorian is exposed and it all catches up with him. A lesson for all of us, really. And a thumbs up for plastic surgeons.

Picture of Dorian Gray
Dorian Gray – After. Beyond the help of Proactive.


When it comes to ghostly photography, there’s a very thin line between – ‘could that be real?’ and ‘bad fake’. Either way, the thrill and excitement that emerges the first time is worth the cynical retribution that lingers. Famous ghostly images now even have names.

Here’s one of the first – Lord Combermere’s Ghost, taken in 1891 in Combermere Abbey. This photo, purportedly of Lord Combermere, was said to have been taken whilst his funeral was taking place. Oooh, spooky.

Lord Combermere's Ghost
Lord Combermere. After.


The most famous ghostly photo was taken in 1936, by a Captain Provand. It’s known in paranormal circles as ‘The Brown Lady’ and comes pretty close to replicating the classic idea of what a ghost should look like (because we all do have such firm ideas). The ghost is meant to be Lady Townshend, supposedly locked away in Raynham Hall in Norfolk by jealous husband Lord Townshend until her death. She was said to haunt the staircases, and was even spotted by King George the IV, who saw her standing by his bed, in a brown dress. The photo was taken on assignment for Country Life, and was published in the magazine, which made quite the change of pace from the usual horse and hound stories. The fact that she looks like a superimposition of a statue of the Virgin Mary didn’t come up.

The Brown Lady. Transparent.
The Brown Lady. Transparent.


In 1939, Russian scientist Semyon Kirlian accidentally discovered that objects placed on a photographic plate connected to electrodes, gave off an ‘aura’ or coronal discharge. Kirlian photography soon became very popular in metaphysical circles, where it was seen as concrete proof for the ‘aura’ or life force that surrounds all living objects. This was later annotated when inanimate objects were also seen to produce the same effect. Unless of course spanners have life forces.

The most famous photographic exploration of Kirlian auras was the ‘severed leaf’ where the aura of a leaf blade remained intact, even though the leaf section itself had been chopped off. This has later been explained through simple electrodynamics due to moisture on the plate, but still, looks completely awesome. The movie rights are still available, Michael Bay.

The Brown Lady. Transparent.
Kyrlian Photography. You check out any time you like, but you can never leaf.


The delightfully named Mabel Chinnery gave the world yet another piece of evidence for life after death with this image of her dead mother sitting in the back seat of her husband’s car – on the day that they went to visit her mother’s grave. Oooweeooo. Obviously mum didn’t want to hang out in the cemetery any longer, and who could blame her? It was full of ghosts! Apparently the ghost is wearing glasses, and that’s why it looks like a weird photographic trick. Ah 1959, days of innocence.

The Back Seat Ghost.
The Back Seat Ghost: mother-in-laws – eternal back seat drivers.


Taken in 1963, this is one of the great ghost photos that look so fake it seems almost impossible to believe that anyone ever thought it was real. However, the ‘photographic experts’ claimed again and again that this photo had not been tampered with. A Yorkshire clergyman, KF Lord, was behind the shutter, so obviously he was beyond reproach. By scale, the ghost is over 9 feet tall, and for some reason is wearing a sheet with eyeholes over its head, under a black cowl. Bad fashion sense extending into the afterlife? Of course!

The Back Seat Ghost.
The Spectre of Newby Church. Can I take this getup off yet?


Here’s one of the classic ‘why were you taking a photo of a staircase?’ photos, again with the clergy involved. In 1966, a Reverend Ralph Hardy was said to be so enamoured of the wrought iron balustrade in the National Maritime Museum in Greenwich that he just had to take a photo of it. Once again, photographic experts claimed no tampering with the negative.  The building is said to be literally crawling with ghosties, including a maid who mops blood on the staircase. Although, no mention of a dude in a sheet.

The Tulip Staircase Ghost.
The Tulip Staircase Ghost. Creepy.


William Freidkin’s 1973 classic horror film was, er, officially ‘bedevilled’. The set, in fact, burnt to the ground, leading to a six week layoff for reconstruction. The official line is that nine people connected with the film, including actor Jack MacGowran (Burke Dennings) died during production, and Ellen Burstyn suffered a serious back injury (although more thanks to William Friedkin than Satan). The film, when released, was credited with a spate of fainting fits, institutionalisations and one miscarriage. A seventeen year old boy, Nicholas Bell, claimed to have been possessed after seeing the film and killed a girl. He subsequently recanted, saying ‘he made up the story about being possessed by the devil in the hope that the police would let him go’. There has, however, been no earthly explanation for the Paul Schrader’s diabolical time on the infamous prequel.

The Exorcist.
The Exorcist. Yes, you heard what I said about your mother!


One of the classic urban legends that sprang from the bowels of home rental videos, this rather disturbing child was first spotted when people (for some reason) where hiring 1987’s Three Men and a Baby and pausing to see what looked like the unhappy spectre of a child, forever sentenced to remain on the set of Three Men and a Baby, punishment for some obviously hideous crime.

The boy does actually appear in the picture, but he is in fact a cardboard cutout, as real as Ted Danson‘s hair. No mention of the supernatural forces behind Steve Guttenberg‘s career have ever come to light, however. Paranormal investigators are still on the case.

Three men and a Baby.
Three Men and a Baby and a Ghost.


For our final ghostly image we’ll step into our TV. Or in fact out of our TV. Or in actual fact, from the video tape on our TV. Foreshadowed by Tobe Hooper’s Poltergeist (82), the Japanese series of Ring-u movies broke the mold on how Hollywood stole movies from overseas. Whereas before they had stuck to France (say, Three Men and A Baby) the J-Horror movement gave the likes of Sam Raimi a whole new world to plunder. With the original low budget films highly effective in producing scares, the movement soon spread to neighbouring Asian countries, including Thailand, where in 2004, the original Shutter was born. The Asian tradition of evil spirits continues to be reproduced on celluloid, but nothing, as yet, has come close to reproducing the first true chills of Ring-u. Although the American remake, directed by Gore Verbinski, comes close!

The Ring.
The Ring. Your mother was right, sitting too close to the tellie will actually kill you.

Shutter will be in cinemas in Australia on May 15 and in the UK on May 16.

Tag Cloud

witnail Emmy Nominations IFC TV Land Mary Poppins Returns Comedy Comedy Central Heroines what to watch Masterpiece LGBT Mudbound Tomatazos ghosts Opinion spain Binge Guide Rock animated comics Mary Tyler Moore Photos Fox News RT History Teen BET quibi Peacock Arrowverse Certified Fresh based on movie crossover unscripted romantic comedy Dark Horse Comics Star Trek free movies Mary poppins halloween Grammys Spike Esquire GIFs doctor who psycho cancelled TV shows spider-man latino Valentine's Day anime spy thriller Brie Larson 71st Emmy Awards vampires Amazon Prime Video composers Pirates Captain marvel Cartoon Network crime thriller police drama true crime rotten movies we love X-Men Marvel Studios Film Festival mockumentary Song of Ice and Fire Hulu Paramount Network children's TV Winter TV Interview Vudu Calendar RT21 indie psychological thriller TCM Music Fall TV Super Bowl Turner Classic Movies Disney science fiction Premiere Dates TV renewals Disney streaming service Lionsgate SXSW Turner Infographic CBS All Access zero dark thirty TCA 2017 Action Ghostbusters Netflix Christmas movies Apple TV+ MCU canceled CBS DGA cartoon Toys Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Spectrum Originals Spring TV Reality Competition Best and Worst TLC robots 2016 Musicals foreign Rocky Apple Mystery Horror Mindy Kaling History Stephen King Character Guide crime 2017 YouTube Red NBC slashers joker Pride Month Oscars Holidays TV hispanic cults natural history cats 2020 cancelled TV series justice league Trivia breaking bad cancelled Video Games Sneak Peek Comic Book sports sequel A24 Amazon New York Comic Con Walt Disney Pictures WGN IFC Films serial killer Columbia Pictures streaming Logo BBC Nickelodeon APB PBS technology E! Musical travel NYCC Marvel Television movies diversity President VICE Lifetime Animation Martial Arts facebook Extras historical drama boxoffice Shondaland game show GLAAD independent nature Bravo war CW Seed 24 frames LGBTQ Fantasy Warner Bros. Country GoT political drama A&E Winners DC streaming service HBO Max The Purge San Diego Comic-Con television zombie thriller Pet Sematary Ovation finale El Rey TruTV Marathons Family Year in Review Creative Arts Emmys FOX Britbox teaser Classic Film DC Comics Comics on TV golden globes Set visit screenings The Witch Trailer Countdown Black Mirror Shudder Sci-Fi Star Wars Film National Geographic adventure Freeform ESPN Reality dramedy binge cars Pixar mutant BBC America 2019 The Walking Dead ratings Disney+ Disney Plus singing competition cops Superheroe kids Biopics 21st Century Fox DC Universe The CW Marvel Writers Guild of America spinoff werewolf Schedule comiccon First Look Watching Series versus Starz cancelled television Polls and Games SundanceTV canceled TV shows See It Skip It Universal American Society of Cinematographers toy story Cannes 2015 PaleyFest Pop TCA Chernobyl ITV discovery YA 2018 Tarantino anthology jamie lee curtis dceu ABC YouTube social media Box Office strong female leads Disney Channel Lifetime Christmas movies Sundance Now talk show FX tv talk Kids & Family green book spanish language Syfy blockbuster Apple TV Plus VH1 cooking Crunchyroll hist Television Academy casting MSNBC 20th Century Fox award winner HBO Rom-Com miniseries CNN supernatural disaster Epix SDCC WarnerMedia revenge The Arrangement period drama FXX USA Women's History Month docudrama Sundance Podcast richard e. Grant E3 aliens transformers Tumblr Hallmark Christmas movies medical drama MTV TBS ABC Family christmas movies south america 45 festivals Drama Ellie Kemper cinemax Anna Paquin Adult Swim series batman Holiday CMT Thanksgiving politics Summer video OWN Quiz biography harry potter Cosplay book TIFF Paramount TNT crime drama AMC Lucasfilm stand-up comedy space YouTube Premium Awards Tour Showtime game of thrones Emmys Sony Pictures romance Rocketman theme song Nominations dragons Netflix DirecTV renewed TV shows Superheroes elevated horror comic Awards sitcom USA Network 007 First Reviews dc Elton John Trophy Talk Western Crackle Christmas Amazon Prime blaxploitation Acorn TV Disney Plus Red Carpet adaptation Election Hallmark Food Network Nat Geo zombies Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt