The Cloverfield Paradox Wastes Fresh Marketing on Disappointing Release

Critics weigh in as surprise Super Bowl release strategy proves far more successful than the long-in-development film itself.

by | February 5, 2018 | Comments

This Is Who? While NBC was betting Super Bowl LII viewers would keep their TVs tuned to the network after the big game for an emotional episode of its breakout family drama This Is Us, Netflix had other plans. The streaming giant announced its new film, The Cloverfield Paradox, via a multi-million-dollar commercial, then surprise-released it, Beyonce-style, immediately after the Philadelphia Eagles’ win over the New England Patriots.

But was the long-in-development film worth sacrificing sleep to watch? It turns out Netflix might have toyed with viewers’ emotions more than watching a buggy Crock-Pot kill a guy on national television — and the critics are not happy about it. With a Rotten Tomatoes score of 19% on 70 reviews (updated), it appears the movie’s unorthodox release might be more popular than the film itself.

Here’s a short history of how the film came to be, along with the first (mostly rotten) reviews and more feedback from critics:

The History

The Cloverfield Paradox (Netflix)

Originally set up at Paramount as The God Particle in 2012, the film was a $5 million to $10 million budgeted sci-fi movie about “an American space station crew left abandoned after a problem with a Hadron accelerator causes Earth to vanish entirely,” per Variety. Directed by Julius Onah and starring Gugu Mbatha-Raw, David Oyelowo, Daniel Brühl, Chris O’Dowd, Ziyi Zhang, and John Ortiz, the film follows a group of astronauts on a space station.

“It was written before 10 Cloverfield Lane and the expanded Cloverfield universe even existed as a thing,” screenwriter Oren Uziel told Collider in 2017, adding that he rewrote some scenes during production to fit it into the Cloverfield franchise. “I don’t know exactly when it became a Cloverfield movie, but I suspect in this current market where it’s just harder and harder to market an original movie of any kind, a science-fiction movie in particular, but I think everyone just knew if it fits — and it does — into that Cloverfield world, it should, and it can only help,” he said.

The release date for The God Particle was originally February 24, 2017, and shifted several times until, before the surprise release, it was postponed until April 20, 2018.

However, weeks after the final postponed release date was announced, rumors circulated that Netflix was interested in acquiring the film from Paramount. The Hollywood Reporter speculated that the streaming service would release the film internationally, while Paramount would release it domestically, where the first two Cloverfield movies had grossed $70 million to $80 million each.

The Release

The Cloverfield Paradox

Folks in the film community tweeted that something major was afoot on Super Bowl Sunday…

“#FilmTwitter is going to explode tonight. Something is coming that I can hardly believe. Lawd. History in the making.” – Ava DuVernay

…but it wasn’t until a first-quarter commercial for the film teasing that it was “coming very soon” — along with a subsequent press release announcing that it would be available post-game — that viewers knew what was happening.

The Strategy

The Cloverfield Paradox (Netflix)

Considering Netflix CEO Reed Hastings’ opinion of critics in general — “The critics are pretty disconnected from the mass appeal,” he told investors in January, after the Will Smith sci-fi film Bright received a crushing 27% Tomatometer score — the poor reviews for The Cloverfield Paradox might not even matter. He’s more interested in the 86% audience score, he said, and he greenlighted a Bright sequel shortly after its release.

“Critics are an important part of the artistic process, but are pretty disconnected from the commercial prospects of a film,” Hastings said. “If people are watching this movie and loving it, that’s the measurement of success. And if the critics get behind it or don’t, that’s a select group of social media influencers talking to a specific audience.”

That’s one way to spin a Rotten Tomatometer score, but film criticism isn’t going away any time soon, as online tools invite more and more voices to the conversation, including the increasingly partisan, frequently unforgiving, and sometimes vindictive viewing audience.

The Consequences

The Cloverfield Paradox

While the last-minute marketing generated plenty of buzz on Twitter, many critics thought the campaign (or lack thereof) was a way for Netflix to get people excited about a movie that was not very good. And they didn’t mince words.

“Ultimately, it doesn’t even matter whether The Cloverfield Paradox is a good movie or not, thanks to Netflix, it is an instant industry game-changer.” – Barry Hertz, The Globe and Mail

“A theatrical release would likely have been disastrous for this dud; with any luck, it will be forgotten amid tomorrow’s hangovers.” – John DeFore, The Hollywood Reporter

“Picking up a studio’s rejects might not be the best way to burnish Netflix’s brand. (The real winner here may be Paramount, who offloaded an almost-certain flop.) But Netflix didn’t just polish this turd: They served it up on a silver platter, and had everyone rushing to dig in. There’s a certain thrill in getting there first, but when you’re done, you’re still left with a pile of crap.” – Sam Adams, Slate

The Cloverfield Paradox may well prove to be a landmark moment in the history of movies, opening an inter-dimensional portal between films and their audiences. … It’s worth remembering that the Cloverfield movies were only able to successfully disrupt conventional distribution methods because they’re good. The best thing you can say about this one is that it’s free with your Netflix subscription.” – David Ehrlich, IndieWire

“Sounds intriguing, but the actual movie is strangely plain, eyesore-overlit and uselessly frantic. It devolves into clichéd “I can’t let you do that” confrontations on its way to a trifling punch line. As a theatrical movie, it would have been a nonevent; as a Netflix event it is, to coin a phrase, fake news.” – Glenn Kenny, The New York Times

The Cloverfield Paradox is a bit of a scam job, promising to reconcile entries in a series that have little in common save for a shared genre. It fizzles so badly at the end that you might legitimately wonder if it ever had anything to do with the other two films in the first place, or if it was produced independently of the series and retroactively added.” – Matt Zoller Seitz,

“What excitement this movie is able to muster soon gives way to the startling realization that virtually none of its twists, for all their dimension-hopping audacity, have been coherently or intelligently thought through. Narrative incompetence is one of the more venial sins of big-budget filmmaking, but there is something particularly ugly and cynical about the sloppiness of The Cloverfield Paradox, as if its status as a franchise stepping stone excused its blithe contempt for the audience’s satisfaction.” – Justin Chang, The Los Angeles Times

Tag Cloud

TV Land Musicals Valentine's Day Sci-Fi Esquire Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Opinion Fox News Interview adaptation cats Amazon Marvel medical drama biography Fall TV WGN award winner Horror 45 Infographic Acorn TV supernatural composers cinemax Anna Paquin Brie Larson finale Tumblr Video Games Star Trek Character Guide Creative Arts Emmys politics streaming Calendar Syfy Thanksgiving Cosplay TBS Marathons 20th Century Fox A&E dc Sundance TNT dragons green book aliens theme song Britbox CNN psychological thriller Premiere Dates OWN Reality Spike Hulu DGA Ovation MSNBC LGBTQ Trailer DirecTV period drama Shudder anime crime drama Mudbound Photos crossover NYCC Food Network TV Pirates Podcast BBC America CMT Lionsgate History psycho Spectrum Originals Nickelodeon BET hist Biopics Musical miniseries PaleyFest Western Year in Review romance VH1 Dark Horse Comics Sundance Now BBC blaxploitation Apple Pop X-Men Mary Poppins Returns USA Kids & Family Country nature Women's History Month anthology Song of Ice and Fire Rock TLC ITV police drama sitcom 2018 National Geographic Ghostbusters Polls and Games Rom-Com ABC CBS All Access Trivia Disney Trophy Talk TIFF Nat Geo Emmys 24 frames spider-man Comedy Central jamie lee curtis 2015 Disney Channel Quiz The Arrangement Awards Summer docudrama SXSW mutant Red Carpet dramedy Writers Guild of America See It Skip It Best and Worst zero dark thirty zombies DC Comics elevated horror Reality Competition GLAAD DC streaming service Crackle witnail casting travel Comic Book MCU Bravo singing competition natural history cooking serial killer richard e. Grant Fantasy ESPN New York Comic Con Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Comedy GoT RT21 2016 what to watch E! Star Wars sequel NBC Ellie Kemper Schedule cops Columbia Pictures Stephen King dceu facebook American Society of Cinematographers Mystery television PBS Mary poppins MTV cults golden globes Action Superheroes zombie boxoffice Showtime FX Warner Bros. Shondaland Martial Arts 007 Sony Pictures Rocky Holidays TCA 2017 Pixar Winners San Diego Comic-Con teaser El Rey Tomatazos E3 TruTV YouTube Premium Box Office sports Oscars CW Seed social media Sneak Peek Mary Tyler Moore Cartoon Network Masterpiece Lucasfilm Lifetime Watching Series true crime Animation Spring TV Universal mockumentary TCM YA The CW IFC Walt Disney Pictures APB spy thriller TCA CBS Christmas binge doctor who Comics on TV SundanceTV Teen ratings DC Universe VICE comiccon thriller crime 2019 Awards Tour harry potter Nominations talk show robots Captain marvel political drama YouTube Red Winter TV transformers RT History USA Network festivals discovery First Look FOX IFC Films Set visit Extras Drama Music Toys Freeform Grammys historical drama Mindy Kaling FXX based on movie HBO comic diversity ABC Family science fiction 2017 Adult Swim war Superheroe Pet Sematary technology Election Logo Amazon Prime President 21st Century Fox Epix Countdown crime thriller unscripted Paramount Black Mirror GIFs Super Bowl Certified Fresh adventure SDCC AMC justice league Netflix Paramount Network vampires Starz