Summer Tomatometer Wrap-up #2: The Best of the Wide Releases

by | October 4, 2005 | Comments

The movies that scored with the critics this summer also scored with audiences. That is, the movies with the best Tomatometer scores also tended to perform well at the box office.

At the top of the list, there is a surprise and a disappointment. The surprise was "The 40-Year-Old Virgin," which, at 84 percent on the Tomatometer and $97 million at the box office, was a film with slight expectations that became a runaway success. The modest disappointment was "Cinderella Man," a film that was beloved by critics (also scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer) but took in a not-too-shabby but far-from-blockbuster $61 million in theaters.

The rest of the top five contains fewer surprises box office-wise; less predictable was the critical enthusiasm that greeted "Batman Begins" (83 percent on the Tomatometer), "Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith" (82 percent), and "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" (82 percent). Each of these films surpassed the $200 million mark (with "Sith" at $380 million), as would seemingly befit a "Star Wars" movie, a kids’ flick and a superhero story. However, what was unanticipated was the very real enthusiasm critics and audiences had for these films.

Here’s the complete list of the summer’s fresh wide releases:

84% — Cinderella Man ($61.5M)
84% — The 40-Year-Old Virgin ($97M)
83% — Batman Begins ($205M)
82% — Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith ($380M)
82% — Charlie and the Chocolate Factory ($204M)
81% — The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants ($39M)
81% — Red Eye ($57M)
81% — The Constant Gardener ($27.7M)
81% — Hustle & Flow ($22.1M)
77% — Crash ($55.4M)
73% — Wedding Crashers ($205.5M)
73% — George A. Romero’s Land of the Dead ($20.4M)
72% — War of the Worlds ($233.3M)
68% — Sky High ($62.3M)
66% — Unleashed ($24.4M)
61% — Mr. and Mrs. Smith ($185.6M)

Check out the rest of our coverage:
Summer Tomatometer Wrap-up: Box Office Down, Tomatometer Up

Tag Cloud

dc TCM Thanksgiving concert politics blaxploitation X-Men Ovation RT History Fantasy japan GoT posters space E! Creative Arts Emmys social media Tokyo Olympics USA Network Star Trek Rocky diversity PBS popular crime thriller 2018 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Pop TV facebook blockbuster BET Awards Box Office werewolf news Crunchyroll Paramount Network Character Guide DC Universe Showtime nature BBC America 2019 Sundance TV transformers 4/20 Extras supernatural Set visit reviews OWN Mindy Kaling technology ITV book ABC dexter MTV Trailer black Walt Disney Pictures Alien cancelled criterion Kids & Family football Tumblr international theme song Amazon Studios science fiction pirates of the caribbean australia Film Festival hollywood Starz war reboot doctor who Spectrum Originals Reality Competition archives 2017 marvel comics Stephen King TV renewals SXSW Black Mirror Trivia First Reviews Nickelodeon travel gangster Travel Channel Spike YouTube Red Adult Swim ABC Signature Broadway king kong History Reality movie olympics cults video on demand documentary Black History Month Fox News kaiju Western A24 stoner TV One nfl TCA boxing remakes Acorn TV genre dark Pixar Grammys cops See It Skip It know your critic screen actors guild Writers Guild of America Crackle TNT golden globes El Rey Nominations asian-american cancelled television Music stand-up comedy festivals adaptation The Witch Shondaland Disney Channel Nat Geo toy story serial killer Superheroe Ellie Kemper quibi deadpool TCA Awards halloween tv game of thrones Amazon Prime Video slasher BET finale Film mob new star wars movies Quiz Fall TV VOD golden globe awards wonder woman indiana jones Women's History Month TBS Cannes IFC Bravo Song of Ice and Fire Calendar rt labs critics edition satire USA IMDb TV art house Awards Tour Holidays Hear Us Out 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Spring TV spy thriller Disney Plus robots breaking bad VICE Neflix Super Bowl OneApp GLAAD comiccon Oscars historical drama Sony Pictures 2021 sequels Exclusive Video dragons hispanic heritage month Universal Pictures Election PlayStation Heroines Mudbound DGA Dark Horse Comics biography unscripted indie Instagram Live NBC series adenture french The Purge HBO Max spider-verse a nightmare on elm street comics best venice scary Infographic young adult sopranos Tomatazos kids classics police drama 2020 streaming anime Toys Britbox Comedy Elton John Hulu CNN Mary Tyler Moore basketball Christmas lord of the rings Tarantino CBS All Access 73rd Emmy Awards trailers sitcom sag awards black comedy obituary ID revenge directors Star Wars The Arrangement Hallmark Christmas movies Red Carpet king arthur fresh cartoon Endgame streaming movies japanese monster movies rt labs SundanceTV TCA 2017 Academy Awards 72 Emmy Awards movies dreamworks aliens ratings medical drama cancelled TV shows foreign Apple TV+ spanish language MSNBC DC Comics CW Seed talk show Pacific Islander Premiere Dates TruTV Photos NYCC Mary Poppins Returns ABC Family Video Games Marathons parents Cartoon Network tv talk IFC Films universal monsters Marvel Television Horror Pop Mystery Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt all-time NBA VH1 spanish mcc Comics on TV Syfy Best and Worst Sundance latino cancelled TV series Epix Sneak Peek suspense versus james bond emmy awards hist free movies Country mission: impossible canceled TV shows superman what to watch Lionsgate APB women Comedy Central sequel Paramount FXX based on movie 24 frames Columbia Pictures comic book movies Legendary feel good canceled 20th Century Fox Winners Apple TV Plus harry potter Avengers Valentine's Day Drama zombie documentaries DC streaming service Teen telelvision Marvel marvel cinematic universe FOX dramedy blockbusters vampires Emmys political drama Certified Fresh Disney streaming service cats ghosts comedies worst batman Watching Series jamie lee curtis vs. casting comic books Image Comics spinoff Emmy Nominations slashers prank Martial Arts psychological thriller Cosplay ViacomCBS psycho Superheroes Animation justice league critics rom-coms Awards Television Critics Association CMT worst movies strong female leads The Academy boxoffice hispanic LGBTQ BAFTA video royal family period drama Countdown The Walt Disney Company legend cooking new york Lifetime Anna Paquin Sci-Fi 71st Emmy Awards mockumentary Arrowverse target romance scary movies sports rotten laika saw book adaptation south america crime drama Action Chernobyl Wes Anderson miniseries Ghostbusters scene in color Vudu halloween Family award winner Pet Sematary AMC Plus singing competition Musicals CBS child's play binge YA Disney+ Disney Plus Musical mutant 007 crime TCA Winter 2020 Discovery Channel WarnerMedia TV Land Rocketman comic jurassic park debate Pirates HBO Go high school Rock 21st Century Fox YouTube Fox Searchlight rotten movies we love renewed TV shows HBO Schedule TIFF Comic Book 90s Apple Tubi live event WGN Captain marvel richard e. Grant TV movies comic book movie PaleyFest razzies Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Netflix Christmas movies action-comedy scorecard joker DirecTV Netflix BBC One aapi cars Warner Bros. Pride Month San Diego Comic-Con Classic Film ESPN godzilla 45 Summer The Walking Dead franchise screenings BBC independent Freeform rt archives Binge Guide Amazon Prime TV natural history 93rd Oscars Amazon Food Network disaster dogs heist movie Trophy Talk 99% Biopics Paramount Plus Marvel Studios green book hidden camera thriller Mary poppins spider-man fast and furious Logo Rom-Com Peacock President christmas movies live action GIFs AMC italian Sundance Now romantic comedy docuseries Turner Classic Movies animated 2016 E3 game show Winter TV RT21 Shudder LGBT zero dark thirty adventure festival television biopic name the review children's TV The CW FX A&E Hallmark new zealand elevated horror Masterpiece critic resources kong Year in Review Television Academy films Lucasfilm Interview Esquire zombies discovery teaser TLC First Look Brie Larson SDCC YouTube Premium Funimation true crime composers American Society of Cinematographers National Geographic 2015 anthology New York Comic Con nbcuniversal dceu witnail Podcast Lifetime Christmas movies Opinion Baby Yoda 1990s crossover chucky twilight Polls and Games Universal Turner docudrama FX on Hulu die hard cinemax toronto superhero spain stop motion Holiday Disney MCU