Summer Tomatometer Wrap-up #2: The Best of the Wide Releases

by | October 4, 2005 | Comments

The movies that scored with the critics this summer also scored with audiences. That is, the movies with the best Tomatometer scores also tended to perform well at the box office.

At the top of the list, there is a surprise and a disappointment. The surprise was "The 40-Year-Old Virgin," which, at 84 percent on the Tomatometer and $97 million at the box office, was a film with slight expectations that became a runaway success. The modest disappointment was "Cinderella Man," a film that was beloved by critics (also scoring 84 percent on the Tomatometer) but took in a not-too-shabby but far-from-blockbuster $61 million in theaters.

The rest of the top five contains fewer surprises box office-wise; less predictable was the critical enthusiasm that greeted "Batman Begins" (83 percent on the Tomatometer), "Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith" (82 percent), and "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" (82 percent). Each of these films surpassed the $200 million mark (with "Sith" at $380 million), as would seemingly befit a "Star Wars" movie, a kids’ flick and a superhero story. However, what was unanticipated was the very real enthusiasm critics and audiences had for these films.

Here’s the complete list of the summer’s fresh wide releases:

84% — Cinderella Man ($61.5M)
84% — The 40-Year-Old Virgin ($97M)
83% — Batman Begins ($205M)
82% — Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith ($380M)
82% — Charlie and the Chocolate Factory ($204M)
81% — The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants ($39M)
81% — Red Eye ($57M)
81% — The Constant Gardener ($27.7M)
81% — Hustle & Flow ($22.1M)
77% — Crash ($55.4M)
73% — Wedding Crashers ($205.5M)
73% — George A. Romero’s Land of the Dead ($20.4M)
72% — War of the Worlds ($233.3M)
68% — Sky High ($62.3M)
66% — Unleashed ($24.4M)
61% — Mr. and Mrs. Smith ($185.6M)

Check out the rest of our coverage:
Summer Tomatometer Wrap-up: Box Office Down, Tomatometer Up

Tag Cloud

historical drama Schedule game of thrones Netflix Christmas movies police drama Warner Bros. Sundance scorecard Showtime Box Office romantic comedy Western adaptation a nightmare on elm street GLAAD Premiere Dates Set visit Calendar free movies Winter TV Superheroes Opinion Comedy Central CBS italian hist natural history ITV 007 Martial Arts sequels American Society of Cinematographers Pride Month TCM Mary Poppins Returns documentary joker Mystery finale quibi thriller Best and Worst CMT cinemax Hallmark Christmas movies 24 frames LGBTQ animated Awards Spectrum Originals Extras true crime Rock YouTube Red Tomatazos Academy Awards Logo reviews Britbox criterion Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Election serial killer Comedy E! Comics on TV sitcom television SDCC biography DirecTV Video Games Masterpiece award winner best cancelled Photos Pirates Dark Horse Comics Disney green book child's play indiana jones Family comiccon nature nbcuniversal tv talk screen actors guild nfl spanish language A24 based on movie First Look directors Certified Fresh Tumblr binge Binge Guide 71st Emmy Awards Fall TV crime thriller TV Land Peacock MCU sequel revenge ABC Character Guide justice league Starz Cosplay 2016 Crackle news breaking bad Year in Review jamie lee curtis VICE Fox Searchlight spy thriller Food Network cartoon Lifetime Christmas movies 4/20 dogs The Academy Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Star Wars Freeform discovery Sci-Fi political drama Brie Larson festivals PBS Avengers Walt Disney Pictures critics reboot Ellie Kemper Television Critics Association The Purge CW Seed movie AMC FX travel APB Biopics Trivia Podcast game show President scary movies 21st Century Fox YouTube Premium singing competition MSNBC Sony Pictures Tubi TBS Shondaland Stephen King ratings all-time IFC Tarantino Writers Guild of America Holidays werewolf A&E aliens Nickelodeon Holiday TIFF canceled OWN X-Men golden globes teaser BBC archives BBC America parents Television Academy BET Awards Mindy Kaling psychological thriller video on demand GoT Awards Tour stand-up comedy south america facebook politics children's TV satire IFC Films Hallmark streaming latino Pet Sematary 72 Emmy Awards Lionsgate Winners Esquire Disney Plus name the review batman Travel Channel Rom-Com YouTube The CW dc Valentine's Day zero dark thirty Black Mirror New York Comic Con San Diego Comic-Con Toys DGA Spike christmas movies Thanksgiving Rocky GIFs Turner cancelled TV series Kids & Family worst Pop TV Grammys Paramount Network CNN 2020 sports Disney streaming service Adult Swim Shudder Watching Series Vudu zombie National Geographic Pop theme song Musicals comics chucky cults Quiz concert Marvel History versus PlayStation rotten movies we love blockbuster Apple docudrama Musical Super Bowl hispanic RT21 The Arrangement Emmy Nominations obituary series TNT halloween TLC ESPN Endgame Anna Paquin WGN Film Festival universal monsters Fantasy venice japanese MTV cars french boxoffice toy story anime Interview BBC One casting science fiction Columbia Pictures book TV renewals Women's History Month 2017 TCA Awards miniseries PaleyFest Horror Baby Yoda witnail fast and furious dragons ABC Family supernatural rotten Sundance Now laika Cannes TV Fox News elevated horror Epix CBS All Access screenings Universal remakes Creative Arts Emmys period drama hollywood SXSW unscripted HBO Go cats Red Carpet 2019 kids mockumentary medical drama TCA Song of Ice and Fire romance VH1 dramedy 45 festival Disney+ Disney Plus Chernobyl talk show mission: impossible NYCC RT History The Walking Dead Lucasfilm classics strong female leads Cartoon Network See It Skip It asian-american superhero Sneak Peek Disney Channel Superheroe Star Trek robots Amazon Prime Video spider-man SundanceTV 2015 what to watch space First Reviews Marathons Paramount LGBT Summer Mary Tyler Moore Lifetime die hard spanish war Heroines Black History Month disaster crime FOX Country technology renewed TV shows Syfy BET slashers toronto cooking cancelled TV shows HBO Max TCA 2017 Sundance TV transformers Mary poppins Ovation Music Emmys Hulu vampires USA Network The Witch Drama anthology worst movies Action Mudbound TruTV stoner dceu Rocketman Polls and Games Elton John FXX Reality Animation USA stop motion blaxploitation halloween tv ghosts 2018 documentaries diversity Apple TV Plus Ghostbusters Comic Book doctor who Captain marvel social media DC streaming service independent football twilight Nat Geo Hear Us Out Film movies mutant Infographic Classic Film emmy awards BAFTA psycho Amazon harry potter OneApp zombies Oscars Spring TV DC Universe spinoff El Rey NBC Netflix comedies dark Reality Competition adventure Marvel Studios Christmas sag awards YA HBO cops Arrowverse Teen Crunchyroll Amazon Studios video E3 20th Century Fox indie Bravo Marvel Television Funimation foreign VOD Amazon Prime FX on Hulu DC Comics Trailer cancelled television spain crime drama franchise Pixar WarnerMedia Turner Classic Movies composers TCA Winter 2020 Discovery Channel Trophy Talk Acorn TV canceled TV shows Nominations crossover films richard e. Grant Apple TV+ comic Countdown