RTIndie: David Lynch, Terry Gilliam Living on the Edge of Hollywood

by | October 23, 2006 | Comments

It’s a tough time to be a veteran in the indie game. Why are celebrated auteurs David Lynch and Terry Gilliam having a hard time getting their films into theaters?

David Lynch has never been a conventional filmmaker, but his latest project, "Inland Empire," may mark an even stranger turn in the director’s career. The three-hour film, starring Laura Dern and Jeremy Irons, has gotten a mixed reception in its festival runs at Venice and New York; it currently stands at 67 percent on the Tomatometer.

The story is, of course, enigmatic: As an actress cast in a doomed film project, Nikki (Dern) becomes confused with her character, lost within the tale of a Polish couple and a trio of giant rabbits (voiced by Naomi Watts, Scott Coffey, and Laura Harring). Her descent into madness is punctuated — in classic Lynch style — by musical dance numbers.

More intriguing, however, may be Lynch’s plan to self-release the film, thereby getting it into theaters and retaining the rights to his work.


David Lynch

Terry Gilliam won’t have to worry about distribution for his latest, "Tideland"; it was recently given a limited release. The story follows a young girl, Jeliza-Rose (Jodelle Ferland), as she is left to survive on an isolated farm when her parents OD on heroin within days of each other.
The film’s exploration of childhood fantasy hinges on exhaustive (or, as many critics have said, exhausting) scenes of Jeliza-Rose playing with her dolls.

At 26 percent, "Tideland" is the worst reviewed film of Gilliam’s career.

His lack of recent commercial success may hinder his ability to make films in the future. Gilliam is famous for feuding with studios (the most famous example is "Brazil" although 2005’s "The Brothers Grimm" found him in something of a squabble with the Weinsteins), and he’s also had a few runs of bad luck (see "Lost in La Mancha").

And although Gilliam met with Warner Bros. about directing "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone," he believes he was never a serious candidate, given the mainstream constraints of the job. He’s also unsure if he’ll secure funding for "Good Omens," which he hopes will be his next project.


Terry Gilliam (left) in "Lost in La Mancha"

While iconoclasts like Lynch and Gilliam may seem like extreme examples, a recent feature in the New York Times points out that a number of established indie directors must find other avenues to make ends meet when they can’t get a green light for their work. Some, like humanist John Sayles, take uncredited script-doctoring gigs, punching up the dialogue on blockbusters. Others, like documentarian Errol Morris, direct commercials. Still others, like Mary Harron and Rose Troche, have found television, particularly HBO series like "Six Feet Under," to be more hospitable to their talents.

In an era that might be described as post-indie, some of the genre’s most successful directors face a surprising return to their roots: Struggling to get their movies produced and distributed without compromising their artistic vision. When marketability still looms as one of the biggest factors in movie making, you have to wonder what impact the independent film boom of the last decade really made on the industry.

This Week’s Indie Openings:

Opening last week in limited release: "51 Birch Street," a documentary exploring the hidden lives of the filmmaker Doug Block’s parents, is at 100 percent on the Tomatometer (with 13 reviews); "Sweet Land," a sweeping tale of the American immigrant experience, is at 95 percent (21 reviews); "Jonestown: The Life and Death of Peoples Temple," a documentary about cult leader Jim Jones and his flock, is at 90 percent (20 reviews); "Requiem," a German tale of epilepsy/demonic possession, is at 88 percent (16 reviews); "Hair High," a perverse animated comedy about a strange high school, is at 67 percent (nine reviews); "Sleeping Dogs Lie," Bobcat Goldthwait‘s sweet, taboo-busting rom-com, is at 54 percent (28 reviews); and "Running with Scissors," a tale of therapy and growing pains starring Annette Bening and Gwyneth Paltrow, is at 25 percent (44 reviews).


In "Sweet Land," we learn about portable music in the days before the iPod.

Tag Cloud

Grammys Adult Swim award winner PBS Ovation IFC Films TBS Valentine's Day comics ratings CNN Tarantino reboot elevated horror sag awards MCU Starz composers Pixar Amazon cops Cannes cinemax LGBT 20th Century Fox what to watch Arrowverse Comics on TV Drama biography 45 game show transformers Fantasy 24 frames Paramount Network batman 007 Best and Worst Disney jamie lee curtis Holiday cats canceled TV shows Warner Bros. name the review Sundance Now series HBO Max dramedy CW Seed Classic Film Oscars Superheroes FOX Election Marathons CMT Pop 2018 mutant Emmy Nominations doctor who quibi Star Wars cults animated green book movies werewolf screen actors guild SXSW Captain marvel serial killer travel FXX cartoon Television Academy Shudder Winter TV singing competition Opinion Sundance A&E Paramount boxoffice Ellie Kemper YouTube Red Hulu slashers technology dc Photos Biopics TNT dragons Fox News cancelled TV series Rom-Com rotten movies we love Disney streaming service independent children's TV dceu Apple TV Plus Trophy Talk Lucasfilm festivals Box Office Awards Tour political drama Masterpiece Spring TV cancelled TV shows New York Comic Con Mystery social media Food Network crime drama History true crime cooking Superheroe GLAAD thriller Marvel Studios streaming hispanic adventure christmas movies Disney+ Disney Plus cancelled television Lionsgate Disney Channel Esquire police drama Winners halloween Horror hist Martial Arts Anna Paquin justice league 2017 Trailer National Geographic Ghostbusters 2016 indie Lifetime CBS Infographic romance Musical TCA 2017 Film Musicals disaster theme song science fiction Bravo WarnerMedia TV renewals breaking bad spinoff E3 south america casting YouTube Premium Acorn TV The CW golden globes Apple TV+ Teen ABC Family Pirates Music CBS All Access Women's History Month Rocky Marvel Mary Tyler Moore First Reviews Black Mirror finale spy thriller zombie Comedy Central anthology talk show El Rey President comic richard e. Grant Logo discovery zombies Shondaland comiccon DC Universe unscripted Animation Nat Geo YA Mindy Kaling Reality Competition robots Awards spanish language vampires TV Freeform Cartoon Network Super Bowl Crackle 2015 Crunchyroll TLC harry potter TIFF LGBTQ Syfy versus Avengers RT History YouTube witnail TCA DC Comics Polls and Games Video Games blockbuster TruTV E! PaleyFest Schedule book Country Heroines cars tv talk Thanksgiving medical drama spider-man Baby Yoda mockumentary Rock Toys Christmas Brie Larson Pride Month Turner Watching Series ghosts Stephen King Cosplay Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 21st Century Fox Writers Guild of America Fall TV ITV The Witch Trivia RT21 Sci-Fi Comedy USA Network Reality VICE GoT FX romantic comedy Red Carpet Universal See It Skip It DGA VH1 Mary poppins San Diego Comic-Con Tumblr psychological thriller space war foreign Chernobyl Quiz A24 Academy Awards Endgame Vudu Interview crossover ESPN Sneak Peek teaser Family Year in Review Binge Guide Summer BET GIFs Amazon Prime Rocketman The Purge TCA Winter 2020 diversity AMC OneApp anime Marvel Television sequel Tomatazos adaptation joker MSNBC Peacock First Look Creative Arts Emmys Countdown Spectrum Originals HBO period drama Spike stand-up comedy Amazon Prime Video WGN Extras revenge Apple Nominations zero dark thirty Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Western historical drama Premiere Dates crime 2019 strong female leads Netflix directors MTV Emmys renewed TV shows free movies game of thrones Britbox binge Set visit Song of Ice and Fire canceled Character Guide blaxploitation American Society of Cinematographers facebook kids TV Land NYCC supernatural psycho miniseries SundanceTV Hallmark DC streaming service X-Men politics USA 71st Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies cancelled Columbia Pictures The Arrangement DirecTV Netflix Christmas movies sports BBC Comic Book Turner Classic Movies Star Trek Sony Pictures spain Disney Plus Certified Fresh Action Epix toy story Nickelodeon Kids & Family nature ABC video IFC television Tubi OWN Mary Poppins Returns TCM Walt Disney Pictures aliens Podcast Discovery Channel Mudbound crime thriller screenings latino sitcom Holidays Calendar docudrama Showtime Dark Horse Comics Pet Sematary natural history BBC America 2020 Lifetime Christmas movies NBC SDCC documentary The Walking Dead Elton John APB Sundance TV based on movie Film Festival