RTIndie: An Art-House Catfight for the Oscars?

by | November 8, 2006 | Comments

Helen Mirren‘s astoundingly successful biopic "The Queen" is getting some serious competition from Pedro Almodovar‘s latest, as "Volver" has emerged a frontrunner for the box-office returns (and Awards Season affections) of the artsy crowd.

"The Queen," directed by Stephen Frears, was picked up in October 2005 by Miramax, who then cited the pick-up as the desire to build "an eclectic, wide-ranging slate of specialty projects." With a good-sized (at least for a studio indie) budget estimated at $15 M, it seems Miramax’s acquisition of the quiet Brit royalty drama was a stroke of genius; since debuting in a scant three-theater limited release at the end of September, the film has built unrelenting momentum into a domestic gross of $10.1 M.

Of course, box-office recognition for "The Queen" has mirrored the response of critics, making it both a successful money-maker and a deserving prestige pic. That wave of laurels can be traced back to September, when it debuted to great acclaim at the Venice Film Festival and went on to win three of that festival’s awards (for Best Screenplay, Best Actress, and the FIPRESCI Prize; Frears lost the Golden Lion to Zhang Ke Jia‘s "Still Life").

"The Queen" is currently Certified Fresh and sitting pretty at 98 percent on the Tomatometer, only three out of 120 critics having disliked it (including Stella Papamichael of the BBC, who wrote of it "The tabloid appeal is obvious, but Morgan’s script is tomorrow’s chip paper."). Most critics, however, agree with the Toronto Star‘s Peter Howell that the picture is "led by Mirren in a title role that demands Oscar glory."

But on the whole the critics are raving; it’s no surprise, then, that Helen Mirren has been pegged for months as a shoe-in for Best Actress. She knows it, too; her steely, powdery visage on the film’s poster screams confidence — "It’s mine, all you other actresses get out of my way!" — a statuette finally in her hands, after two previous unrealized nominations (for "The Madness of King George" in 1995, and "Gosford Park" in 2002). Plus, Mirren’s on a royal roll, having just won an Emmy for playing another Elizabeth, Elizabeth I, in the acclaimed 2005 HBO miniseries.

But last weekend a contender emerged to threaten Helen Mirren’s near-lock on the Best Actress award. And her name is Penelope.

Penelope Cruz, carrying an equally strong ensemble piece, is simply luminous in "Volver," a quasi-magical tragicomedy by Spanish director Pedro Almodovar released by Sony Pictures Classics last week. Like "The Queen," "Volver" has reaped praise from critics the world over. And although it only just opened in limited release in the U.S., it’s also poised to make big bucks — and make it’s leading lady a strong candidate for Oscar.

A foreign film after all, "Volver" premiered in Almodovar’s native Spain last March and proceeded to rake in the dough on its tour across Europe, Latin America, and other markets. It also hit up the festival circuit — Almodovar is a certified auteur, and proved so by nabbing a Best Screenplay award at this year’s Cannes, (although he lost the Palme d’or to Ken Loach‘s IRA drama "The Wind That Shakes the Barley"). His film also won the festival’s Best Actress prize — a shared honor awarded to the six female leads of "Volver."

"Volver" is no slouch when it comes to the Tomatometer, either; it’s currently at 93 percent, with 60 reviews. And what of the numbers?

Since debuting this spring overseas, the Almodovar film has grossed $61.5 M worldwide; last weekend it posted "Queen"-like numbers, averaging $40,400 per screen in only five theaters (when "The Queen" debuted in three theaters this fall, it took in a similar $40,671 per site). On November 22 "Volver" will hit 20 more theaters, with more and more playdates as its platform release continues — and, you can be sure, as it keeps filling seats.

All of this is has set Oscar-watchers abuzz, as Cruz — certainly known to American audiences, albeit for eye-candy roles and the spectacle of a Spanish beauty circulating in Hollywood — seems a compelling Best Actress alternative to Mirren. As the beleaguered yet beautiful young mother Raimunda, Cruz’s performance is revelatory; IGN Movies critic Todd Gilchrist muses "she is strong, weak, tender, tough, sexy, and maternal, often all at once." Slant Magazine writer Ed Gonzalez writes "‘Mildred Pierce’ won Joan Crawford an Oscar, and Almodóvar’s quaint riff on the Michael Curtiz classic may do the same for Penélope Cruz."

The LA Times’ Gold Derby columnist Tom O’Neill calls Mirren "the Best Actress frontrunner" but also that "Penelope Cruz has The Babe Factor in a race crowded with older gals." And while these two are certainly reigning over awards contention right now, a handful of other names have been thrown into the ring, including four-time nominee Kate Winslet for "Little Children," multiple-time nominee and twice-winner Meryl Streep for "The Devil Wears Prada," and three-time nominee Annette Bening (for the critical dud "Running With Scissors."

But there’s plenty of time left in the year for more nominees, and a trio of forthcoming flicks have more potential Best Actress-worthy thesps: Dame Judi Dench, for "Notes on a Scandal" (December 25), her co-star Cate Blanchett for Steven Soderbergh‘s "The Good German" (December 15), and — surprise, surprise — Chinese actress Gong Li for "Curse of the Golden Flower," the forthcoming period epic from Zhang Yimou (December 22).

Li’s entrance into the speculative arena is the most recent, and the most interesting; with turns in her first two American movies within the last year ("Memoirs of a Geisha," "Miami Vice") Li has certainly bumped up her exposure stateside. Plus, anyone remotely familiar with Chinese cinema knows she has the skills to be in contention (see "Raise the Red Lantern," "Ju Dou," or any other films she made with director Yimou). But "Curse of the Golden Flower," to be released by Sony Pictures Classics, will have the barriers of language and culture to overcome, and while the same can be said of Almodovar, Cruz, and "Volver," it will certainly be a bigger hurdle for Yimou, Li, and "Flower."

Tag Cloud

Mindy Kaling IFC dragons Countdown Disney Plus Winter TV Calendar Showtime 20th Century Fox supernatural Red Carpet Valentine's Day The Walking Dead Women's History Month comiccon GoT versus APB jamie lee curtis USA Network boxoffice El Rey DC Universe Watching Series Horror stand-up comedy Columbia Pictures cops mockumentary The Arrangement TV renewals Schedule TV Land Drama Classic Film 2018 Pixar ghosts CMT cancelled TV shows Premiere Dates Emmys TruTV Holiday MCU Pet Sematary kids Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Box Office ESPN cancelled spider-man Lionsgate Acorn TV dceu harry potter DC Comics ITV TNT strong female leads Crackle DC streaming service cinemax slashers quibi canceled TV shows Academy Awards The CW Podcast X-Men Election YouTube festivals game of thrones zombie Tubi teaser elevated horror batman Lucasfilm thriller richard e. Grant what to watch Film Festival Winners historical drama Netflix Christmas movies First Look theme song cancelled television Lifetime Christmas movies docudrama Interview Brie Larson award winner The Witch television AMC CBS All Access Spring TV Marvel Studios Rom-Com Masterpiece cults FX American Society of Cinematographers Pop game show Sundance TV Universal halloween Musical spanish language OneApp series Comics on TV composers RT21 crime drama Photos dramedy justice league Comic Book Marathons Reality Competition Family Amazon Prime Video Lifetime Nat Geo 2017 Arrowverse Spike 21st Century Fox mutant Syfy TV 2019 vampires The Purge adventure Action ABC Shondaland Disney+ Disney Plus President talk show political drama police drama tv talk History Pride Month social media Thanksgiving Tumblr Ellie Kemper 24 frames TCM ABC Family 2016 sequel Summer Animation PaleyFest YA hispanic facebook renewed TV shows breaking bad LGBTQ CBS witnail Spectrum Originals biography Cosplay Nickelodeon E3 Amazon free movies Trailer Fantasy SXSW zero dark thirty Apple Sci-Fi Cannes GIFs Marvel spain Shudder Trophy Talk Sony Pictures Teen werewolf Sneak Peek rotten movies we love Super Bowl RT History robots Video Games A&E golden globes Opinion Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TBS Music Awards Tour anthology New York Comic Con MSNBC toy story Western singing competition ratings Martial Arts streaming transformers video comics Bravo psychological thriller Awards blockbuster 71st Emmy Awards Avengers Crunchyroll comic south america natural history Freeform cars technology movies Chernobyl MTV Polls and Games SundanceTV serial killer Comedy crossover VICE BET Disney Paramount Network cooking disaster Fall TV LGBT Toys joker Binge Guide period drama Reality Ovation spy thriller OWN Sundance Now anime christmas movies See It Skip It Oscars science fiction Film medical drama Year in Review foreign Cartoon Network revenge romantic comedy PBS hist FXX Superheroe Holidays Stephen King Discovery Channel Adult Swim USA 007 Walt Disney Pictures Creative Arts Emmys Amazon Prime Biopics San Diego Comic-Con independent Food Network Set visit Hallmark travel WGN YouTube Premium Captain marvel TCA spinoff Pirates NYCC Ghostbusters blaxploitation Hulu Hallmark Christmas movies cancelled TV series Heroines First Reviews sports Turner Musicals Superheroes HBO adaptation Anna Paquin Turner Classic Movies screen actors guild Apple TV+ Logo cartoon indie Writers Guild of America Mary Tyler Moore TCA Winter 2020 Apple TV Plus Nominations unscripted Vudu Epix doctor who children's TV Rock DGA true crime zombies Britbox BBC America Tomatazos GLAAD Extras Quiz Rocky Certified Fresh 2015 WarnerMedia screenings Peacock Sundance Warner Bros. Emmy Nominations National Geographic politics romance Song of Ice and Fire Infographic CNN Fox News Baby Yoda Rocketman CW Seed Paramount Country based on movie crime Christmas Marvel Television war aliens 2020 space Mudbound Grammys canceled SDCC Television Academy animated Comedy Central Mary poppins reboot sag awards DirecTV A24 Esquire nature E! Mary Poppins Returns HBO Max Endgame Elton John latino Black Mirror Netflix green book diversity NBC book Dark Horse Comics finale Disney streaming service casting IFC Films cats 45 Trivia dc TLC BBC TIFF psycho Star Trek FOX Character Guide Disney Channel Star Wars miniseries crime thriller binge name the review Mystery YouTube Red Starz TCA 2017 Tarantino directors VH1 discovery sitcom Kids & Family Best and Worst