Roma, Black Panther, and Netflix Dominate the 20th Golden Tomato Awards

Plus, for the first time ever, we're turning the power over to the fans.

by | January 11, 2019 | Comments

(Photo by Carlos Somonte / © Netflix )

It’s the 20th Golden Tomato Awards and our annual celebration of the best-reviewed movies and TV is bigger than ever. We’ve got more categories than in any previous year – 34, up from 18 last year – and, for the first time ever, we’re giving fans the chance name their own Golden Tomato winners with two new Fans’ Choice Awards. Yes: The Freshness is in your hands.

But we’ll get to that in a moment.

Netflix’s Roma, directed by Alfonso Cuarón, was the biggest winner in the Golden Tomato film categories for 2018, taking three awards: Best-Reviewed Limited Release, Foreign-Language Film, and Spanish-Language Film (a new category created to reflect the growing number of great movies from the Spanish-speaking world being released in American theaters). The other big winners for film were Black Panther (Best-Reviewed Wide Release, Comic Book/Graphic Novel Movie); A Star Is Born (Best-Reviewed Directorial Debut, Musical/Music Movie); and Paddington 2 (Best-Reviewed U.K. Movie, Kids and Family Movie). Yes, Paddington 2 is still at 100%.

In the TV categories, only Amazon’s Homecoming – starring Julia Roberts and Stephan James – managed to nab more than one award: Best-Reviewed New TV Show and Best-Reviewed TV Mystery/Suspense. The second season of Donald Glover’s acclaimed series Atlanta was beloved enough by critics to be named Best-Reviewed Returning TV Show; the series won Best-Reviewed New Show and Best-Reviewed TV Comedy in 2016. This year’s Best-Reviewed TV Comedy was Barry, starring Bill Hader. Best-Reviewed TV Drama went to YouTube Premium’s Karate Kid sequel series, Cobra Kai. And yes, Cobra Kai is also still 100% on the Tomatometer.

(Photo by © FX)

The Golden Tomato Awards are decided by the Tomatometer – with a little math on our side. We take the Tomatometers for movies and TV shows in a category and rank them by Adjusted Score, which uses a weighted formula that accounts for the variation in the number of reviews when comparing the movies or shows. To qualify in a category, a movie needed to have been released in American theaters in 2018 (beyond just a festival release), and have at least 40 reviews; TV seasons or TV movies needed to have premiered in 2018 and have a minimum of 20 reviews, five from Top Critics.

This year you’ll find more genre-based categories in TV, including a separate Horror TV category (AMC’s The Terror snagged that award with The Haunting of Hill House in a close second) and one for Comedy Specials (a category won by internet-breaking Australian comedian Hannah Gadsby’s Netflix special, Nanette). The win for Nanette, combined with film awards for Roma and for Best-Reviewed Superhero TV Show (Daredevil season 3), makes Netflix a big winner with five Golden Tomato Awards total.

(Photo by © Warner Bros. )

In film, we decided to single out Directorial Debuts after such a strong year (Bradley Cooper won for A Star Is Born, but he had fierce competition from Eighth Grade’s Bo Burnham, Sorry to Bother You’s Boots Riley, Hereditary’s Ari Aster, and others). It was also a big year for Westerns, prompting us to honor the best in that genre for the first time; Chloe Zhao’s The Rider was the Best-Reviewed of the bunch.

We also kick off voting in our first-ever fan-voted categories today: Favorite Movie and Favorite TV Show. Over the next two weeks, fans will be able to vote for one Certified Fresh film and one Certified Fresh TV series, limited series, or miniseries. We’ll close voting on Thursday January 24 and announce the winners of the two inaugural Fans’ Choice Golden Tomato Awards on Friday January 25. Will the people’s choices line up with the critics’? Watch this space.

Check out all the winners of the Golden Tomato Awards 2018 here.

Tag Cloud

mutant award winner Disney Winter TV LGBT Spike Disney streaming service See It Skip It Adult Swim Film Festival Hulu GLAAD Apple Vudu 2019 TCA 2017 Dark Horse Comics Teen dc spinoff Watching Series Rock Nominations TruTV cinemax Summer green book Sony Pictures Star Wars Nat Geo Paramount Network Cosplay DirecTV Awards Tour APB Mary poppins TLC space Mindy Kaling historical drama ABC comic The Arrangement transformers binge MCU Mystery foreign 21st Century Fox Drama ABC Family Awards cults Kids & Family TBS Anna Paquin DC Universe vampires spy thriller revenge President DC Comics Crackle Fall TV Sundance crime drama based on movie First Look Marvel Set visit cops Black Mirror Cannes Trailer Interview Warner Bros. Fox News 007 RT21 Action casting finale E! ITV Lucasfilm TNT MSNBC Nickelodeon cars miniseries Disney Channel stand-up comedy SDCC Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Sneak Peek Countdown Chilling Adventures of Sabrina streaming Superheroes teaser hist facebook ratings Paramount Lionsgate hispanic war Character Guide Emmy Nominations Quiz Country Columbia Pictures FXX sitcom composers BBC Film supernatural IFC Toys Epix San Diego Comic-Con anime kids ghosts game show Ellie Kemper Masterpiece Certified Fresh dceu Box Office elevated horror Syfy dragons anthology 2015 Rocky politics CW Seed what to watch Horror LGBTQ Heroines Trivia CBS doctor who PBS justice league quibi sports Reality WarnerMedia Red Carpet Photos comiccon SXSW Super Bowl Holidays psycho spain Brie Larson Shudder HBO Max 2016 Arrowverse Spring TV Acorn TV FX south america Biopics 2017 Superheroe latino Women's History Month 71st Emmy Awards travel Fantasy thriller Martial Arts Thanksgiving true crime mockumentary serial killer Opinion Chernobyl Comedy Trophy Talk Pop Mudbound Binge Guide technology GIFs theme song Musicals Star Trek Oscars SundanceTV singing competition Bravo TCM toy story Pixar aliens spanish language adventure Peacock dramedy Extras Year in Review crime thriller witnail Rom-Com Christmas YA Writers Guild of America animated psychological thriller golden globes VH1 GoT Creative Arts Emmys Tumblr Song of Ice and Fire tv talk crime boxoffice period drama TV Land Infographic IFC Films richard e. Grant USA Network Family Best and Worst Sci-Fi Election New York Comic Con Valentine's Day OWN The Witch Tomatazos Marathons TCA History zero dark thirty police drama blaxploitation 2018 social media ESPN adaptation Reality Competition spider-man Netflix A&E crossover Ghostbusters Tarantino Logo Musical Polls and Games BET zombies children's TV political drama 20th Century Fox Walt Disney Pictures festivals movies Podcast TV DGA Starz YouTube Premium Amazon harry potter Amazon Prime diversity Rocketman USA Television Academy romance NBC docudrama science fiction Emmys WGN Pirates jamie lee curtis strong female leads 45 Video Games robots medical drama cooking Elton John Schedule HBO Comedy Central Universal zombie CNN game of thrones National Geographic Cartoon Network Mary Poppins Returns Amazon Prime Video Winners natural history TIFF sequel Pride Month Sundance Now Esquire 24 frames talk show X-Men AMC Stephen King CMT Britbox MTV First Reviews RT History YouTube Red unscripted PaleyFest Grammys Mary Tyler Moore Shondaland Ovation E3 Calendar nature Spectrum Originals Comics on TV disaster Freeform Pet Sematary FOX series Music Captain marvel cats biography CBS All Access Showtime Western discovery Premiere Dates The CW Lifetime VICE book video Food Network NYCC Comic Book DC streaming service Animation television BBC America American Society of Cinematographers El Rey