Roma, Black Panther, and Netflix Dominate the 20th Golden Tomato Awards

Plus, for the first time ever, we're turning the power over to the fans.

by | January 11, 2019 | Comments


(Photo by Carlos Somonte / © Netflix )

It’s the 20th Golden Tomato Awards and our annual celebration of the best-reviewed movies and TV is bigger than ever. We’ve got more categories than in any previous year – 34, up from 18 last year – and, for the first time ever, we’re giving fans the chance name their own Golden Tomato winners with two new Fans’ Choice Awards. Yes: The Freshness is in your hands.

But we’ll get to that in a moment.

Netflix’s Roma, directed by Alfonso Cuarón, was the biggest winner in the Golden Tomato film categories for 2018, taking three awards: Best-Reviewed Limited Release, Foreign-Language Film, and Spanish-Language Film (a new category created to reflect the growing number of great movies from the Spanish-speaking world being released in American theaters). The other big winners for film were Black Panther (Best-Reviewed Wide Release, Comic Book/Graphic Novel Movie); A Star Is Born (Best-Reviewed Directorial Debut, Musical/Music Movie); and Paddington 2 (Best-Reviewed U.K. Movie, Kids and Family Movie). Yes, Paddington 2 is still at 100%.

In the TV categories, only Amazon’s Homecoming – starring Julia Roberts and Stephan James – managed to nab more than one award: Best-Reviewed New TV Show and Best-Reviewed TV Mystery/Suspense. The second season of Donald Glover’s acclaimed series Atlanta was beloved enough by critics to be named Best-Reviewed Returning TV Show; the series won Best-Reviewed New Show and Best-Reviewed TV Comedy in 2016. This year’s Best-Reviewed TV Comedy was Barry, starring Bill Hader. Best-Reviewed TV Drama went to YouTube Premium’s Karate Kid sequel series, Cobra Kai. And yes, Cobra Kai is also still 100% on the Tomatometer.

(Photo by © FX)

The Golden Tomato Awards are decided by the Tomatometer – with a little math on our side. We take the Tomatometers for movies and TV shows in a category and rank them by Adjusted Score, which uses a weighted formula that accounts for the variation in the number of reviews when comparing the movies or shows. To qualify in a category, a movie needed to have been released in American theaters in 2018 (beyond just a festival release), and have at least 40 reviews; TV seasons or TV movies needed to have premiered in 2018 and have a minimum of 20 reviews, five from Top Critics.

This year you’ll find more genre-based categories in TV, including a separate Horror TV category (AMC’s The Terror snagged that award with The Haunting of Hill House in a close second) and one for Comedy Specials (a category won by internet-breaking Australian comedian Hannah Gadsby’s Netflix special, Nanette). The win for Nanette, combined with film awards for Roma and for Best-Reviewed Superhero TV Show (Daredevil season 3), makes Netflix a big winner with five Golden Tomato Awards total.

(Photo by © Warner Bros. )

In film, we decided to single out Directorial Debuts after such a strong year (Bradley Cooper won for A Star Is Born, but he had fierce competition from Eighth Grade’s Bo Burnham, Sorry to Bother You’s Boots Riley, Hereditary’s Ari Aster, and others). It was also a big year for Westerns, prompting us to honor the best in that genre for the first time; Chloe Zhao’s The Rider was the Best-Reviewed of the bunch.

We also kick off voting in our first-ever fan-voted categories today: Favorite Movie and Favorite TV Show. Over the next two weeks, fans will be able to vote for one Certified Fresh film and one Certified Fresh TV series, limited series, or miniseries. We’ll close voting on Thursday January 24 and announce the winners of the two inaugural Fans’ Choice Golden Tomato Awards on Friday January 25. Will the people’s choices line up with the critics’? Watch this space.

Check out all the winners of the Golden Tomato Awards 2018 here.

Tag Cloud

Emmy Nominations binge 20th Century Fox cartoon Sundance TV ID PBS strong female leads ABC Family Cartoon Network Nickelodeon movie Mary Tyler Moore X-Men biography anime Syfy 72 Emmy Awards Hallmark Christmas movies Super Bowl TCA Awards spinoff Cannes singing competition canceled spanish language MCU BET Awards 21st Century Fox CNN President DC Universe psychological thriller anthology Sci-Fi screen actors guild Creative Arts Emmys sag awards Mystery Apple TV+ indie zombies Binge Guide Lifetime chucky Amazon Studios Vudu documentary classics comic books hollywood italian dceu ratings breaking bad Baby Yoda laika Black History Month Anna Paquin obituary Rock Disney streaming service Sundance HBO Go Dark Horse Comics streaming Black Mirror franchise animated Best and Worst Holidays Pixar miniseries batman rotten spy thriller based on movie Winter TV Television Critics Association vampires thriller cancelled TV series Marathons WGN Mindy Kaling Paramount 4/20 Netflix Christmas movies BET zombie DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Disney Channel Country Fall TV green book Columbia Pictures Spectrum Originals dramedy football Opinion A24 San Diego Comic-Con Paramount Network superhero Film Festival disaster Adult Swim WarnerMedia Tubi Red Carpet Heroines golden globes RT History spanish kids TNT Crunchyroll war stop motion First Reviews Calendar Oscars die hard Music Photos YouTube Premium Sony Pictures TCA 2017 scorecard FX Amazon Prime cinemax Podcast Lionsgate VOD Trailer festivals Infographic Spike Year in Review Bravo Mary poppins Election Comedy Winners YA 45 Martial Arts Mudbound HBO Amazon Ovation NBC zero dark thirty robots The Academy sports Netflix doctor who TCM Ghostbusters Amazon Prime Video Song of Ice and Fire Comedy Central Fox Searchlight Classic Film mission: impossible crime drama finale travel satire LGBTQ hispanic USA Extras composers Esquire Mary Poppins Returns asian-american revenge talk show japanese directors child's play ITV NYCC south america rotten movies we love New York Comic Con Cosplay Character Guide Hallmark politics Pop TruTV APB period drama Acorn TV news witnail teaser Action series IFC CBS All Access Stephen King dc FXX Box Office toronto Reality adventure Awards Tour Sundance Now venice Food Network fast and furious YouTube Red E! GoT TIFF CW Seed Television Academy tv talk AMC 2020 TLC Logo australia Pet Sematary 2015 joker Horror werewolf movies comics Family MSNBC National Geographic Reality Competition nbcuniversal criterion 2018 Marvel Studios psycho BBC canceled TV shows Film Schedule Marvel comiccon USA Network medical drama Tomatazos blaxploitation TCA Teen theme song Fantasy Epix 2019 cancelled crime cults Peacock 2016 Hulu Animation romance video Spring TV reviews Quiz critics cops Comic Book Set visit remakes Marvel Television justice league SDCC concert nfl Star Wars Rocketman Interview cooking sequels jamie lee curtis The Purge Avengers Universal BBC America Premiere Dates E3 hist TV Land 007 Christmas Sneak Peek Superheroe 24 frames Showtime VH1 Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt cars ABC Turner Classic Movies El Rey IFC Films Rocky LGBT Awards Women's History Month Hear Us Out TCA Winter 2020 comedies children's TV boxoffice festival reboot HBO Max Discovery Channel best Shudder CMT independent Certified Fresh Fox News elevated horror dragons stand-up comedy 2017 First Look Academy Awards harry potter comic TV renewals richard e. Grant space Nominations Starz Pirates Masterpiece Disney PlayStation scary movies parents supernatural slashers Apple TV Plus dogs DirecTV Lucasfilm History blockbuster Turner christmas movies natural history political drama Video Games TV facebook Nat Geo crime thriller versus Watching Series GLAAD renewed TV shows SundanceTV casting a nightmare on elm street Drama Summer aliens Walt Disney Pictures Travel Channel CBS award winner french Freeform Apple films cancelled TV shows See It Skip It stoner YouTube Comics on TV Writers Guild of America Disney+ Disney Plus screenings docudrama toy story TBS cats MTV transformers RT21 Holiday historical drama Pop TV The CW ghosts SXSW Tumblr nature police drama worst movies Tarantino free movies Britbox what to watch social media sitcom Grammys Arrowverse American Society of Cinematographers indiana jones all-time Musicals Captain marvel Superheroes quibi Musical unscripted mockumentary Countdown A&E Biopics GIFs worst true crime latino technology OWN DC streaming service Brie Larson documentaries Crackle 71st Emmy Awards dark halloween The Arrangement spider-man foreign Ellie Kemper ESPN Trivia Funimation BBC One twilight PaleyFest romantic comedy Chernobyl television emmy awards video on demand Toys sequel FOX Star Trek game of thrones discovery Polls and Games Disney Plus Kids & Family OneApp Warner Bros. Endgame spain archives adaptation Pride Month Thanksgiving game show halloween tv mutant Western DGA Rom-Com name the review book universal monsters diversity Lifetime Christmas movies cancelled television crossover Trophy Talk Emmys Elton John VICE science fiction Shondaland BAFTA The Witch black serial killer Valentine's Day The Walking Dead FX on Hulu