News

Revisiting Seminal LGBTQ Film A Fantastic Woman

Critic and writer Ian Thomas Malone says casting is key to the strength of this Oscar winner about Chilean trans woman Marina.

by | June 5, 2019 | Comments

This year, Rotten Tomatoes expanded our list of the best-reviewed LGBTQ movies of all time to 200 films. To celebrate those works and mark Pride month, we asked a number of Tomatometer-approved critics to reflect on the LGBTQ movies that influenced their lives and their work. 

One of the great challenges transgender people face is learning to deal with those who think we deserve to be treated differently because of who we are. For some, facing this idea that universal human rights are not actually meant to be universal can lead to outrage. In Sebastián Lelio’s A Fantastic Woman, protagonist Marina meets the challenge again and again as she is put in positions that undermine not only her gender identity, but also her basic dignity as a human being. As we follow her, the film offers a painstakingly authentic portrayal of transgender life.

Too often, transgender narratives in film center themselves on the mechanics of transition, placing great emphasis on the pain of a soul in conflict with the nature of its being. A Fantastic Woman is a film set after all of that dust has settled, starring a transgender woman firmly settled in her post-transition world. Marina thrives in her new environment, able to share her talents as a singer in Santiago, Chile on he­r terms, presenting as the individual she always knew herself to be. She shares her life with her partner, Orlando, an older man with an open heart and a thirst for life.

Daniela Vega and Francisco Reyes in A Fantastic Woman, 2017 (Sony Pictures Classics/Everett Collection)

Daniela Vega and Francisco Reyes in A Fantastic Woman. (Photo by Sony Pictures Classics/Everett Collection)

The conflict in A Fantastic Woman comes not from Marina’s inner turmoil, but from the prejudice of others. Orlando’s sudden death from a brain aneurysm brings out the worst in his family, who treat Marina as an abomination; to them, their relationship is proof that he must have been suffering from dementia. The police similarly view their relationship with suspicion, harassing Marina at work and subjecting her to invasive bodily inspections as she struggles to cope with her sudden loss. Of all the many ways transgender people find rejection from society at large, the idea that Marina would not even be allowed to grieve with dignity strikes at the core of injustice.

Daniela Vega as Marina in A Fantastic Woman (Sony Pictures Classics/Everett Collection)

Daniela Vega as Marina in A Fantastic Woman. (Photo by Sony Pictures Classics/Everett Collection)

Lead actress Daniela Vega, in just her second film role, makes a strong case for the power of casting transgender people in trans roles. Marina pushes back on the various indignities she’s expected to endure with resounding grace, acknowledging the realities of her situation but never backing down even after being physically assaulted. Vega’s subtle expressions speak volumes as she stares bigotry square in the face, and refuses to stay away from the wake or funeral. A cisgender actor can ponder the meaning of the “trapped in the wrong body” trope, but Vega carries herself as a woman who knows what it’s like to have someone try and strip you of your humanity.

Director Sebastián Lelio accepts Best Foreign Language Film for A Fantastic Woman with cast/crew onstage at the 90th Annual Academy Awards. (Photo by Photo by Kevin Winter/Getty Images)

A Fantastic Woman, which won the Oscar for Best Foreign Language Film at last year’s Academy Awards, is a powerful testament to the universality of the transgender experience. The hardships that Marina endured in Chile are uncomfortably similar to many of my own here in America. A transgender person’s romantic relationships are subject to so many unnecessary lines of inquiry by a world that too often refuses to accept the normalcy of our existence. Throughout the world, we live, we love, and we prosper each and every day.

The onslaught of transphobia that Marina faces throughout the film is an unnecessary fact of life for many of us, and A Fantastic Woman triumphs through Marina’s resiliency despite her circumstances. Transgender people live life fully aware that bigotry cannot be vanquished overnight – we just want a chance to find some sense of happiness.

Ian Thomas Malone is an author and podcast host based out of Long Beach, California. Check out her latest reviews here.


Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

#1
#1
Adjusted Score: 104586%
Critics Consensus: Subtle and tender, A Fantastic Woman handles its timely, sensitive subject matter with care.
Synopsis: A transgender singer faces scorn and discrimination after the sudden death of her older boyfriend.... [More]
Directed By: Sebastián Lelio

Tag Cloud

Song of Ice and Fire FOX Pop TV Kids & Family halloween tv binge pirates of the caribbean know your critic 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards directors slashers YouTube Red zombie comedies Sci-Fi superman cults prank CW Seed TCM king kong thriller Alien kong comiccon OWN Apple TV+ Comics on TV romantic comedy anime Grammys Reality hispanic worst movies rotten Esquire Chernobyl Columbia Pictures Year in Review medical drama festival Elton John History new star wars movies kids teaser indie hist Crunchyroll HBO Max DC Universe Sundance Lifetime American Society of Cinematographers Black History Month TV Land book adaptation aapi Amazon Prime Pop jurassic park Arrowverse The Purge YouTube science fiction popular doctor who travel NBA spider-man YouTube Premium serial killer nfl TV monster movies Spring TV National Geographic Anna Paquin scene in color asian-american WGN deadpool rt labs Spectrum Originals cancelled TV shows universal monsters marvel cinematic universe japan comics politics RT21 biography MCU composers french SundanceTV mutant chucky Film Festival Netflix theme song Paramount Plus VICE Disney Plus Mudbound Star Trek IFC comic books Discovery Channel 4/20 what to watch dragons Cosplay Winners archives LGBTQ USA Disney Channel a nightmare on elm street 72 Emmy Awards Toys italian book Animation rt labs critics edition game of thrones Britbox breaking bad Marvel Television Fox News Western legend basketball classics BET Disney Black Mirror Walt Disney Pictures CNN emmy awards crime thriller Trivia 24 frames Lucasfilm President Academy Awards CBS All Access festivals DGA HBO Go live action Mary Poppins Returns FX on Hulu A&E 45 tv talk video Winter TV spinoff quibi Wes Anderson children's TV Paramount Ellie Kemper CMT werewolf SXSW Tokyo Olympics Television Critics Association Video Games Set visit ID Shudder independent nature Paramount Network new york aliens space Countdown BAFTA witnail Holidays facebook NBC Nat Geo Emmys comic book movies Creative Arts Emmys Warner Bros. joker sequel Comedy TV movies 007 telelvision PaleyFest true crime 2020 Mindy Kaling ghosts royal family Pacific Islander Shondaland Comic Book RT History free movies adenture TV One Mary Tyler Moore PBS Avengers YA USA Network streaming movies Schedule X-Men Peacock Vudu Dark Horse Comics boxoffice TCA Winter 2020 dark El Rey streaming crime drama kaiju best halloween zombies unscripted adventure New York Comic Con Captain marvel Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Cannes Superheroes MSNBC Universal Exclusive Video 2017 GoT renewed TV shows Quiz japanese Hallmark Christmas movies Rocketman Marvel Studios The Witch Podcast Netflix Christmas movies docudrama BBC Mary poppins IFC Films Horror Lionsgate vampires Nominations superhero critics Star Wars Extras Calendar Ghostbusters rt archives Heroines sitcom Pixar Broadway stoner 20th Century Fox trailers debate Sneak Peek Biopics spanish language films screen actors guild cancelled television Baby Yoda reboot versus ITV Endgame reviews Holiday 90s TCA 2017 Super Bowl Rom-Com suspense die hard award winner LGBT HBO Christmas canceled NYCC documentaries screenings christmas movies biopic high school movie Red Carpet The CW TBS new zealand GLAAD fresh Opinion Tumblr feel good TCA Awards dc golden globe awards 71st Emmy Awards Apple psychological thriller laika scary movies Valentine's Day hidden camera 99% Masterpiece sequels finale Brie Larson Epix revenge crime Nickelodeon Awards Tour adaptation technology spanish harry potter GIFs criterion king arthur BBC America 93rd Oscars cancelled ratings heist movie Watching Series obituary historical drama TCA child's play ABC international Character Guide Pet Sematary cartoon FXX diversity Amazon cats A24 Crackle slasher australia DirecTV cinemax Teen stand-up comedy richard e. Grant Freeform dexter critic resources TV renewals indiana jones spain concert fast and furious south america cancelled TV series zero dark thirty Legendary E3 green book First Look DC streaming service Stephen King black documentary disaster ABC Signature The Arrangement wonder woman Acorn TV The Walt Disney Company Cartoon Network ABC Family SDCC Superheroe mcc scorecard psycho VOD Television Academy Interview gangster Box Office blockbuster animated young adult FX Hear Us Out Musicals dogs toy story BBC One 2016 Disney streaming service movies Mystery Disney+ Disney Plus saw Women's History Month Rock Trailer TLC APB Ovation Reality Competition 2021 football anthology satire venice all-time razzies Marathons cooking discovery worst Drama Showtime supernatural Martial Arts name the review AMC Trophy Talk boxing Oscars news jamie lee curtis Emmy Nominations Sony Pictures robots The Walking Dead Musical olympics See It Skip It posters Bravo Pirates Thanksgiving sag awards Awards war foreign target miniseries Rocky MTV stop motion mission: impossible Binge Guide romance Amazon Studios Hulu Writers Guild of America political drama Sundance TV 2018 series BET Awards toronto godzilla Spike Certified Fresh casting TNT Polls and Games rom-coms Fantasy singing competition lord of the rings ViacomCBS The Academy Country franchise comic book movie Apple TV Plus Fall TV Funimation Action elevated horror OneApp sports dramedy VH1 spy thriller First Reviews golden globes Fox Searchlight blaxploitation Photos twilight hollywood police drama Logo Infographic Syfy Food Network Election Starz PlayStation Chilling Adventures of Sabrina TIFF San Diego Comic-Con hispanic heritage month talk show batman dceu action-comedy cops latino women docuseries Image Comics E! Amazon Prime Video TruTV Hallmark parents Comedy Central marvel comics Summer natural history WarnerMedia 21st Century Fox DC Comics game show Marvel social media crossover 2019 strong female leads period drama Tomatazos CBS Lifetime Christmas movies justice league 73rd Emmy Awards 2015 Best and Worst Tarantino remakes Sundance Now Turner Classic Movies transformers Comic-Con@Home 2021 Travel Channel based on movie Tubi Music Premiere Dates comic rotten movies we love Turner mockumentary nbcuniversal Adult Swim television blockbusters Classic Film canceled TV shows Film ESPN Pride Month video on demand cars Family 1990s james bond