Negan's Gory New Plan in The Walking Dead Has Legs

Allegiances are tested in "Dead or Alive Or" as the TWD heroes regroup after losing one of their own.

by | March 11, 2018 | Comments

Lauren Cohan as Maggie Greene - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 11 - Photo Credit: Gene Page/AMC

With the effects of Carl’s (Chandler Riggs) death rippling through the second half of The Walking Dead season 8, Sunday’s Rick-less (Andrew Lincoln) episode, “Dead or Alive Or,” highlighted the blurred morality that distinguishes Maggie’s (Lauren Cohan) Hilltop from Negan’s (Jeffrey Dean Morgan) Saviors. And while Carl’s charity toward Siddiq (Avi Nash) may have been the precursor to his demise, his humanitarian move could ultimately inspire change in Maggie’s leadership strategy.


Seth Gilliam as Father Gabriel Stokes; single - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 11 - Photo Credit: Gene Page/AMC

“Dead or Alive Or” continues the zombie series’ exploration of the concept of right and wrong within this broken world, where the rule of law is as twisted and bloody as the barbed wire wrapped around Negan’s bat. The episode mostly focuses on unanswered questions from the past, but gives audiences some much-needed, albeit temporary, hope in the form of Father Gabriel’s (Seth Gilliam) continued redemption. With blood seemingly on everyone’s hands, you have to wonder: Is it possible God even exists in the zombie apocalypse?

Fans took to Twitter to share their thoughts on the biggest moments from Sunday’s episode.


As soon as Dwight (Austin Amelio) suggested Daryl (Norman Reedus), Tara (Alanna Masterson), and Rosita (Christian Serratos) lead the Alexandria refugees through the swamps, it became clear that bloated zombies would be crawling out of the muck.

Over the years, the series has showcased Greg Nicotero and crew’s creativity and impeccable skills in bringing a variety of walkers to life. Among the best are some gory nods to classic horror movies. These walkers — err, swimmers? — feel like another nod to Dan O’Bannon’s The Return of the Living Dead. But instead of one Tarman, our heroes are faced with a gaggle of muddy walkers, all emerging from the swamp for a taste of some delicious brains.


Daryl and Rosita were keeping Dwight alive for helpful insight into Negan’s operation, but Tara was having none of it. Let’s remember, he killed off her girlfriend Denise (Merritt Wever) back in season 6 — with Daryl’s crossbow, no less. Even after his heartfelt apology, Tara, who not that long ago fought alongside the Governor (David Morrissey), sought her own hypocritical revenge.

Then the Saviors showed up. Instead of tattling, Dwight sacrificed his freedom, leading Negan’s goons the other way. As hypocritical as this whole thing was, it looks like Tara has finally changed her tune. When they meet again, will things be copacetic?


Seth Gilliam and R. Keith Harris - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 11 - Photo Credit: Gene Page/AMC

Each step of their journey, Father Gabriel and Dr. Carson (R. Keith Harris) faced one convenience after another: An abandoned cabin, antibiotics to break Gabriel’s fever, car keys, and a map. All this time, Gabriel insisted that God set them on this path and that this was all a part of His plan. And then Carson fell into a bear trap, leading to gunshots fired at the looming walker threat.

The Saviors came, of course, leading Carson to grab their captor’s gun — empowered by Gabriel’s faith — only to be shot dead. So, uh, who’s going to deliver Maggie’s baby? Great timing, Siddiq.


Josh McDermitt as Dr. Eugene Porter; single - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 11 - Photo Credit: Gene Page/AMC

It seems the more annoying Eugene (Josh McDermitt) gets, the more Negan seems to trust him. Aside from the sheer aggravation of seeing Abraham’s (Michael Cudlitz) former sidekick live it up in the Sanctuary — with all the wine and pickles at his disposal — there’s a strong possibility that Negan gave him his own bullet-making outpost to keep a close eye on him.

More than ever, Eugene’s got enough power and influence to treat everyone else like trash. But with the return of the near-blind Father Gabriel, the man he secretly helped escape, it’s beginning to feel that Eugene’s days may be numbered.


Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Negan; group - The Walking Dead _ Season 8, Episode 11 - Photo Credit: Gene Page/AMC

In his attempt to keep Negan from discovering he freed Gabriel and Carson, Eugene suggested a more visceral approach to attacking the Hilltop Using a catapult to launch zombie guts over the wall seems silly, but Eugene’s ramblings inspire a new plan.

“Dead or Alive Or” ends with Negan burying Lucille in a walker’s bloody maw. His new strategy is to infect everyone who gets in his way with the tip of his bloody bat. Gory possibilities aside, does this even make sense? The Walking Dead has long established the zombie virus is airborne, which means infected blood doesn’t turn people. Are the rules about to change, or does Negan know something we don’t?

What did you think about the episode? Tell us in the comments.

The Walking Dead airs Sundays at 9/8C on AMC.

Tag Cloud

USA BBC America Cannes Tarantino San Diego Comic-Con quibi Watching Series Summer Star Wars TCA 2017 supernatural south america AMC Mudbound Super Bowl Martial Arts E3 sequel travel Apple Stephen King LGBT The Walking Dead batman VICE Ellie Kemper cancelled Western Peacock New York Comic Con halloween Disney+ Disney Plus Trivia Cartoon Network VH1 Netflix Pirates Paramount adventure comiccon TCA blockbuster Lifetime Christmas movies Syfy Walt Disney Pictures Britbox Disney Channel Turner green book Disney Plus Emmys richard e. Grant Comedy Family FX true crime technology Trophy Talk cops Crackle DC Comics Sundance Now ghosts Fantasy History WarnerMedia Ovation romantic comedy The Arrangement video sitcom Pride Month free movies Emmy Nominations 24 frames robots Universal thriller Mary Tyler Moore game of thrones CBS Sneak Peek DirecTV justice league GIFs crime drama dramedy Lionsgate Kids & Family TNT Arrowverse politics CW Seed cults adaptation Freeform TCM mutant CMT Mindy Kaling Grammys Hallmark miniseries Teen Film Festival zombies Bravo cinemax vampires facebook Countdown game show Television Academy Valentine's Day hispanic Food Network FXX American Society of Cinematographers Winners doctor who Certified Fresh Red Carpet Apple TV Plus BBC YouTube Premium cats finale Anna Paquin Film dragons Tomatazos 45 crossover animated Superheroes foreign comics discovery cartoon zombie Marathons Drama Showtime Marvel Superheroe IFC Chilling Adventures of Sabrina spanish language 007 cancelled television Action Box Office revenge 2015 diversity teaser TruTV Cosplay YouTube historical drama dceu spinoff Best and Worst Women's History Month festivals war children's TV elevated horror Awards Tour SXSW streaming Writers Guild of America psycho 2019 period drama social media television Amazon Prime Video unscripted PBS Winter TV Polls and Games ABC GoT Lucasfilm ESPN The Purge A&E 2020 Toys Rom-Com witnail breaking bad anthology mockumentary strong female leads Sundance Pixar TIFF rotten movies we love versus X-Men Calendar Sony Pictures sports PaleyFest Mary Poppins Returns cancelled TV series Holidays Musical canceled Binge Guide YA spy thriller Netflix Christmas movies Elton John docudrama Esquire Captain marvel Spectrum Originals First Look serial killer USA Network Rocketman DC Universe police drama Interview joker LGBTQ comic golden globes Music psychological thriller biography President singing competition Musicals Shudder YouTube Red Nickelodeon See It Skip It Reality Warner Bros. TBS Epix book HBO Max slashers series cancelled TV shows transformers Logo Apple TV+ Year in Review award winner toy story TLC FOX disaster Comedy Central Schedule canceled TV shows 2016 Comics on TV Masterpiece Disney streaming service Vudu NYCC Infographic casting Amazon DGA boxoffice Disney werewolf 20th Century Fox Tumblr Turner Classic Movies MCU Pop Mystery Amazon Prime BET RT History hist independent Photos Election Acorn TV indie Oscars Sci-Fi HBO First Reviews MTV Marvel Studios OWN APB Shondaland dc 71st Emmy Awards blaxploitation latino Awards 2018 based on movie Paramount Network Animation stand-up comedy Country Character Guide IFC Films Song of Ice and Fire composers space Holiday TV CNN Ghostbusters MSNBC Video Games screenings theme song Podcast Fall TV Fox News NBC El Rey political drama kids GLAAD Rock Premiere Dates Spring TV crime thriller cars medical drama crime harry potter Quiz Horror cooking science fiction talk show jamie lee curtis Starz 21st Century Fox what to watch SDCC tv talk zero dark thirty renewed TV shows Star Trek spain WGN Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt aliens SundanceTV Crunchyroll binge A24 Adult Swim CBS All Access Columbia Pictures RT21 TV renewals Thanksgiving Spike Heroines Black Mirror ratings Classic Film Chernobyl The CW Nominations Biopics Dark Horse Comics The Witch TV Land National Geographic Hulu Mary poppins Brie Larson ABC Family Opinion Pet Sematary Comic Book Marvel Television Rocky DC streaming service Reality Competition anime romance Lifetime ITV Trailer Nat Geo Set visit natural history 2017 christmas movies nature Extras spider-man Christmas Hallmark Christmas movies Creative Arts Emmys E! movies