News

21 Most Memorable Movie Moments: The Snap from Avengers: Infinity War (2018)

Directors Joe and Anthony Russo reveal the story behind the cliffhanger that left fans reeling – and guessing – for 12 months.

by | July 30, 2019 | Comments

Watch: Directors Joe and Anthony Russo on the making of Avengers: Infinity War above.

In 2019, Rotten Tomatoes turns 21, and to mark the occasion we’re celebrating the 21 Most Memorable Moments from the movies over the last 21 years. In this special video series, we speak to the actors and filmmakers who made those moments happen, revealing behind-the-scenes details of how they came to be and diving deep into why they’ve stuck with us for so long. Once we’ve announced all 21, it will be up to you, the fans, to vote for which is the most memorable moment of all. In this episode of our ‘21 Most Memorable Moments’ series, directors Joe and Anthony Russo break down how they created one of the movies’ most shocking cliffhangers. 

VOTE FOR THIS MOMENT IN OUR 21 MOST MEMORABLE MOVIE MOMENTS POLL


The Movie: Avengers: Infinity War (2018) 85%

Avengers: Infinity War was something moviegoers had never seen before: an epic movie crossover event that dwarfed the two previous Avengers films in scale and ambition and threw more beloved characters at the screen than perhaps any other movie in history. Also, uniquely for a film about a (very large) band of (very beloved) superheroes, it centered its narrative around its singular villain, one that Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige and the filmmakers of the Marvel Cinematic Universe had been seeding for years: “Thanos is coming” isn’t just the panicked warning of Bruce Banner in Infinity War’s early scenes, it was the tease Marvel had been giving us since Phase One. And Infinity War is the Mad Titan’s movie. It’s his search for the Infinity Stones that drives the narrative, and it’s the snap of his be-gloved fingers that ends it.

Joe and Anthony Russo, who joined the MCU with The Winter Soldier, had a mammoth task with Infinity War. Not only did they have to set up a cliffhanger for the ages and provide, working with Josh Brolin, a villain worthy of so many years of buildup, but they were helming one of the most expensive movies ever made and a story whose threads and characters had mostly been established by other filmmakers across 10 years of movies. Here, the brothers explain how they prepared for Infinity War, the logic behind their narrative choices, and working with Brolin to create a villain for the ages – one with whom some might even sympathize.

The central idea of Civil War was for us to break up the Avengers and shatter that relationship between Steve Rogers and Tony Stark.”

Anthony Russo: Civil War is where [the story] started to come into our brains. The central idea of that movie was for us to… we wanted to break up the Avengers and shatter that relationship between Steve Rogers and Tony Stark. As we were executing it and we realized how well we were sort of achieving that on an emotional level with the characters, that’s when I think our brains started to open up to, ‘My God, they’re so vulnerable now.’ Now, you’re like, what happens when Thanos comes? And that’s when our brains started stepping through where the story could go.”

Captain America: Civil War

In Civil War the Avengers are divided. (Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marvel Studios)

“We very thoroughly explore a lot of different ideas before we lock into what’s exciting us most.”

Anthony: “Our process is to spend many, many, many months in that room with [writers] Christopher Marcus and Stephen McFeely, with Kevin [Feige], talking through different story ideas, different possibilities. We very thoroughly explore a lot of different ideas before we lock into what’s exciting us most. So, at some point [while writing Infinity War], yeah, sure, there are many variations [of what could happen], but once the story starts to take shape it really forms in a muscular way around a single idea. And then we spend months working on that.”

“I think a lot of people respect Thanos’s monastic dedication to his task. He’ll die for it.”

Joe Russo: “[Thanos is a] complicated character. He’s a profoundly interesting villain who is equal parts empathetic and loathsome. He’s also frightening and intimidating and nearly invincible. He’s driven, philosophically driven. I think a lot of people respect his monastic dedication to his task. He’ll die for it. And what’s interesting about the end of that movie is he shuns all materialism. He’s got this amazingly powerful gauntlet that can alter the very fabric of the universe, and he retires to a shack, you know, clearly on some desolate planet.”

For the Russos, Infinity War was Thanos’s story. (Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marvel Studios)

“We did tests with Josh Brolin where he would come in, perform, and we would work on it for several months and try to figure out the best version of it.”

Anthony: “We knew we wanted to center the movie on the character, and we knew that we can only do that if we pulled off the most realistic-feeling performance that you could possibly imagine in a movie. So, we started very early on with our visual effects team, specifically our visual effects supervisor, Dan DeLeeuw, and trying to figure out how the technology can work and we can actually achieve this. We did a lot of tests, we did tests with Josh Brolin where he would come in, perform, and we would work on it for several months and try to figure out the best version of it. So yeah, that character was built methodically over the entire span of the development of the film.”


The Moment: Thanos Snaps

Though the world knew Infinity War was one half of a two-part Avengers epic, both parts of which were shot concurrently, few believed the movie would end the way it did: with half the universe dusted – and with some of most beloved MCU characters among the fallen. It was unfathomable. Thanos… won? Shocked audiences wept through the credits – comforted somewhat by that brilliant Captain Marvel teaser – and took to social media to express their despair through every variation of crying/devastated memes. Then came the recriminations: Why the hell didn’t Thor go for the head? Peter Quill was totally to blame for this, right? It felt certain that the universe would be restored in about 12 months – Endgame would release almost a year to the day after Infinity War – but there was no certainty. After all, with “The Snap” the Russos and Marvel Studios showed the world nothing and nobody was sacred and anything was possible.

Thanos has an almost monastic dedication to his mission. (Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marvel Studios)

“There’s no bigger way to write ourselves into a corner than killing half the characters.”

Anthony: “We actually never thought of it as a cliffhanger. In our own brains, for us, we were telling a complete story, this was Thanos’s movie, he was the lead of the film, and we gave him a complete arc – a proper ending.”

Joe: “Anth and I, through our entire experience at Marvel, always tried to make very disruptive choices with each film. The end of Winter Soldier, good guys and the bad guys, we flip everything on its head. In Civil War we divorce the Avengers. With Infinity War we knew we wanted to make a strong narrative choice. There’s an adage where you write yourself into a corner, and you try to figure out how to get out. That usually creates really dramatic moments for the audience. There’s no bigger way to write ourselves into a corner than killing half the characters.”

“As far as who went to dust, everything’s always built upon story.”

Joe: “The visualization was purely just we thought about the elemental aspect of your body and what happens to it. And that’s sort of accelerating the decomposing process in a way. As far as who went to dust, everything’s always built upon story. We’ll just say that there’s a reason the original six Avengers are left.”

They Russos say the Snap was not a cliffhanger in their mind. (Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marvel Studios)

“Tony Stark and Peter Parker developed a father-son relationship over the course of two films. We felt like that would be hard to watch.” 

Joe: “Spider-Man was my favorite character growing up; it was this notion of a child who had been burdened with this incredible responsibility and through very tragic circumstances, with the death of his uncle. So I think we always felt that would be [a key emotional moment]. Tony Stark and Peter Parker developed a father-son relationship over the course of two films. We felt like that would be hard to watch, and it was: it was hard to watch on set, and it was hard to watch for the audience, I think.”


The Impact: Anything Is Possible

The commercial success of Infinity War, and then Endgame after it, was monumental: Infinity War is now the fifth highest-grossing movie of all time, Endgame is number one. The impact of both goes beyond the box office, though: few movies, perhaps ever, have so dominated the pop-culture conversation. Infinity War was a global cliffhanger the likes of which we’d never seen and the feverish anticipation it built would be what made Endgame the most successful movie ever. As the culmination of the first decade of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, the two films cemented that brand’s dominance at the movies – something that looks set to continue with an exciting and expanding Phase 4 and 5. There is a sense that, with its universe-building and crossovers, Marvel and the MCU are changing the very nature – and certainly the business – of commercial cinema (for better or worse, depending on your perspective). For Joe and Anthony Russo, who have directed more films within the MCU than any other director or directing pair, the key to the brand’s success is less about the razzle-dazzle of special effects, or even about the narrative daring it takes to dust half of your leads – it’s about character. The reason the MCU is as massive as it is, and the reason Infinity War and Endgame are a kind of phenomenon, lies in our connection to Tony, Steve, Peter, Natasha, T’Challa, and, yes, even Thanos.

Joe and Anthony Russo

Joe and Anthony Russo on set with Chris Evans. (Photo by Chuck Zlotnick / ©Marvel Studios 2018)

“Mark [Ruffalo] turned around in the theater and he thought, ‘Alright, I gotta get out of here before someone hurts me.’”

Anthony: “At the premiere and many of the early screenings that we attended, we anticipated the ending being complicated for people because it was complicated for ourselves, but no, we didn’t anticipate the depth of emotion that people would experience from that ending.”

Joe: “[Mark] Ruffalo was in a theater in New York, and he was in a cap and glasses, and he was there with his son and his son’s friends, and he said when it got to the end, literally people just sat in the audience for 10 minutes and a guy ripped his shirt off and started screaming, ‘Why?!’ at the screen. Mark turned around in the theater and he thought, ‘Alright, I gotta get out of here before someone hurts me,’ and he snuck out the side door. So we didn’t expect that level of emotional response to it.”

“In our minds, that’s why the Avengers lost in Infinity War – the fact that they were divided.”

Anthony: “Look, [Tony and Cap are] the heart and soul of the Avengers, you know. Tony is sorta like an extroverted leader and Cap is like the heart and soul, the moral core of them. For the two of them to have a falling out and have an irreconcilable problem was really devastating to the team as a whole. You know in our minds, that’s why the Avengers lost in Infinity War – the fact that they were divided. They weren’t functioning as a team in that movie any longer, so they weren’t prepared for the universe’s greatest threat. But the journey they’re on is very much at the heart of the entire story.”

Avengers: Infinity War stars Benedict Cumberbatch, Robert Downey Jr. (©Marvel/©Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures)

Robert Downey Jr. in an early Infinity War scene. (Photo by © Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, © Marvel Studios)

“All these characters have emotional vulnerabilities that complicate their ability to do what needs to be done.”

Joe: “Part of telling stories is learning empathy. I don’t know if people can empathize with Thanos, but they can empathize with Star-Lord – the love of his life was murdered by the guy in front of him, and he made a very emotional choice. I think that’s the human choice, and that’s the truthful choice that you would make in those circumstances. He paid for it with his life, Star-Lord.”

Anthony: “Exactly. As storytellers, we find that one of the most empathetic moments in the story. Also, the other thing to focus on his choice, I mean all of these characters make flawed choices. If Thor had not been so angry, and so revenge-driven, he may have killed Thanos faster than he did. The fact that he wanted revenge, he wanted to see in Thanos’s eyes as he was killing him, that gave Thanos a window to reverse things on him. All these characters have emotional vulnerabilities that complicate their ability to do what needs to be done. Us watching them fight through that is part of the fun.”

Joe: “It’s makes them interesting to watch. If all they did was make the right choice every time, it’s a fairly predictable and boring story after a while.”


Avengers: Infinity War was released April 27, 2018. Buy or rent it at FandangoNOW.

#1
#1
Adjusted Score: 106.031%
Critics Consensus: Avengers: Infinity War ably juggles a dizzying array of MCU heroes in the fight against their gravest threat yet, and the result is a thrilling, emotionally resonant blockbuster that (mostly) realizes its gargantuan ambitions.
Synopsis: An unprecedented cinematic journey ten years in the making and spanning the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe, Marvel Studios' "Avengers: Infinity... [More]
Directed By: Anthony Russo

Tag Cloud

Fall TV teaser Crunchyroll FX History sequels worst movies Tomatazos Disney Plus Marathons Classic Film transformers Certified Fresh Marvel Studios Mindy Kaling El Rey Cosplay what to watch Turner Classic Movies First Look Heroines The Academy Amazon Prime Video Mary poppins richard e. Grant miniseries festival laika dramedy classics Western batman APB Shudder disaster fresh RT21 Sundance Now USA Network cops anime Star Wars VOD Alien Netflix Christmas movies concert television reboot Interview trailers comic sequel 2015 OWN nbcuniversal cartoon strong female leads Turner Lifetime Christmas movies TIFF Masterpiece space crime SXSW Hallmark Christmas movies 71st Emmy Awards Reality Competition HBO Go screenings YA crossover Trivia james bond TCA MCU spinoff halloween CBS All Access talk show TBS 2018 BBC America Best and Worst ABC Signature Premiere Dates 21st Century Fox Awards Tour Binge Guide Toys TCA Winter 2020 E3 hispanic black VH1 BBC animated cars The Arrangement Sundance TV pirates of the caribbean superhero Quiz social media crime drama Grammys ABC die hard Captain marvel MTV jurassic park San Diego Comic-Con dark emmy awards Apple mutant Dark Horse Comics Super Bowl Year in Review parents Cartoon Network festivals New York Comic Con Comedy serial killer streaming Mystery OneApp video on demand discovery ID game show elevated horror biography football dc TV renewals Amazon Studios cancelled Box Office DirecTV See It Skip It deadpool HBO Max comic books TV Mary Poppins Returns Countdown sports composers FXX technology Film Festival Biopics Mary Tyler Moore rotten movies we love political drama spanish language TCA Awards Holidays sag awards 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards Winners Nickelodeon ghosts natural history Christmas Superheroe DC Comics all-time Sci-Fi supernatural Tubi game of thrones zombies cancelled TV series cancelled TV shows Vudu Sneak Peek The Witch Music renewed TV shows Pet Sematary Acorn TV Rock fast and furious 72 Emmy Awards FOX Star Trek psycho stand-up comedy stop motion Paramount DC streaming service canceled TV shows Song of Ice and Fire binge breaking bad Adult Swim Lucasfilm Warner Bros. werewolf tv talk franchise Netflix The Purge Drama Television Critics Association dceu Fox Searchlight Video Games casting Martial Arts SundanceTV BET Awards Podcast aliens Chernobyl Mudbound historical drama PaleyFest movie Arrowverse TCA 2017 YouTube Marvel Television President stoner Holiday Epix Food Network E! Disney reviews 007 cinemax CBS DGA Red Carpet Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 4/20 Creative Arts Emmys critics 2017 rom-coms docudrama latino Elton John golden globe awards TNT child's play police drama Television Academy Emmys A24 Lifetime singing competition Comic Book WarnerMedia LGBT Emmy Nominations Apple TV+ USA Nat Geo french Crackle universal monsters Walt Disney Pictures Film American Society of Cinematographers Trophy Talk 2016 TV One twilight vampires free movies Polls and Games Country GoT remakes name the review 24 frames ABC Family boxoffice Writers Guild of America Hallmark Syfy films rt archives archives spain toronto Disney Channel Brie Larson christmas movies Musicals facebook Photos politics ratings true crime Amazon Prime Universal Spectrum Originals Fantasy Freeform Discovery Channel Kids & Family comiccon romance worst Nominations video Travel Channel revenge cancelled television Hear Us Out a nightmare on elm street toy story Musical Schedule dragons The Walt Disney Company 2020 YouTube Red screen actors guild Opinion documentaries anthology spy thriller war DC Universe 99% Apple TV Plus Rocky Rom-Com nature period drama TLC WGN robots Anna Paquin asian-american indie theme song jamie lee curtis rotten Black History Month BBC One australia National Geographic indiana jones AMC NYCC Bravo PlayStation NBC nfl Summer best cooking thriller diversity TV Land venice medical drama blaxploitation documentary zero dark thirty green book scorecard Amazon 45 VICE hist hollywood directors south america Trailer Logo obituary mission: impossible Family golden globes Fox News Paramount Network Pirates Comedy Central TCM dogs RT History MSNBC italian comics Comics on TV movies HBO adventure witnail joker slashers X-Men Pop Pixar Animation halloween tv Reality Avengers Columbia Pictures Academy Awards adaptation criterion Esquire CW Seed The Walking Dead TruTV Spike quibi First Reviews justice league crime thriller Disney+ Disney Plus Cannes Women's History Month based on movie 2019 kids Tumblr canceled Disney streaming service versus Thanksgiving zombie Valentine's Day Awards independent Pride Month Endgame Oscars spider-man Pop TV Sony Pictures Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Calendar PBS romantic comedy The CW IFC Films children's TV Peacock Teen Election GIFs ITV cults chucky science fiction cats Horror Character Guide Action Hulu A&E Ghostbusters Stephen King Starz FX on Hulu scary movies travel news 20th Century Fox Funimation ESPN Lionsgate SDCC Spring TV Extras Ellie Kemper award winner IFC sitcom Infographic Shondaland GLAAD psychological thriller Rocketman mockumentary comedies Showtime spanish YouTube Premium harry potter doctor who Watching Series series finale BET Baby Yoda Ovation japanese boxing Marvel blockbuster LGBTQ Sundance unscripted BAFTA Set visit CNN satire CMT foreign Tarantino Britbox Black Mirror Winter TV book Superheroes