Matthew Rhys On His "Cracked" Perry Mason and the Dark Appeal of HBO's Reboot

The Emmy winner says the famous lawyer is almost unrecognizable in the new serialized limited series, and that's exactly why he got on board.

by | June 20, 2020 | Comments

Perry Mason

(Photo by Merrick Morton/HBO)

Fans of Perry Mason the character may find themselves confused by the first few episodes of Perry Mason, the new HBO limited series. The gritty new show is less a “reboot,” or even a “re-imagining,” than a total overhaul of the character created by author Erle Stanley Gardner and immortalized on the small screen by Raymond Burr in the 1950s-60s TV series and later TV films. The famously sharp criminal defense lawyer isn’t even a lawyer as the HBO series opens in L.A. in 1931; instead, played by Emmy winner Matthew Rhys, he is a private investigator more comfortable sneaking into Hollywood starlets’ homes to snap scandalous photographs than he is in a courtroom.

HBO’s Mason will eventually suit up and stand before the jury as the series progresses, but even then, this Mason is a different beast. Where the lawyer of the novels and beloved TV show was a mostly blank slate, Rhys’s Mason is a WWI veteran struggling with a crisis of faith, a battle to hold onto his family’s farm, and a drinking problem. (The series is set during the tail-end of Prohibition, but no one is adhering to the laws of the day.) Rhys, who joined the project after co-executive producer Robert Downey Jr. pulled out of the lead role, says it’s these “cracks” in the character that drew him in. “Life serves up plenty of cracks,” Rhys told Rotten Tomatoes, “and that’s where my interest certainly lies.”

While the new series may not look much like a traditional Perry Mason series, it does bear the signatures of a traditional HBO prestige drama. It is a single serialized story, lavishly produced, and packed with scene-stealing performances from some big names: Rhys is already earning acclaim as the brooding P.I.-cum-lawyer; John Lithgow shines as his boss and mentor; and Orphan Black star Tatiana Maslany plays evangelical preacher – and potential heretic – Sister Alice, whose church becomes increasingly entwined with the series’ central case of a mother being tried for the kidnapping and murder of her baby boy.

Gotham standout Chris Chalk is on hand too as a reimagined Paul Drake, a P.I. in the novels, here a Black beat cop torn between his loyalty to a corrupt institution that both employs and spurns him, and Mason’s pursuit of true justice. Chalk’s character and plotline, navigating racism both explicit and systemic – almost 100 years ago – feels disarmingly relevant as the series premieres to a nation protesting police brutality against Black Americans.

Ahead of the series’ first episode, Rhys spoke with Rotten Tomatoes about the connection between Perry Mason and the moment we’re in, why “HBO-ifying” the famous lawyer was the best approach for a modern reboot, and whether he would ever return to the role that won him an Emmy, Russian spy Phillip Jennings on FX’s The Americans.

Joel Meares for Rotten Tomatoes: I was reading an interview you gave the New York Times where you had said that your first reaction to hearing that they were rebooting Perry Mason was: “Oh God, why?” Can you talk a little bit about that reaction, and tell us what it was that changed your mind?

Matthew Rhys: Yeah, it’s a relatively simple answer in that I got this message from my agent saying, “I want to talk to you about a remake of Perry Mason.” And then I thought, “God, why do you want to remake Perry Mason?” [I was] thinking it would just be some generic, weekly, case-solved, man-in-a-good-suit… not much depth was my imagining of it. You know what I mean? All great justice, or a servant of justice, et cetera. Then when he got back to me, he said, “Actually HBO want to make it,” and I went “Oh, it’s not going to be a remake, because HBO will HBO-ify it.” Then when I went and met with team Downey [Susan Downey and Robert Downey Jr., wife-and-husband co-executive producers], the producers on it and the writers, it was very apparent very quickly that this wasn’t a remake, but a re-imagining, and a redefining of who I think we believe Perry Mason is.

Perry Mason

(Photo by HBO)

Mason’s been such a blank canvas in so many other iterations. Here, as you say, he’s been “HBO-ified”: he’s divorced, he’s drinking, he’s having a crisis of faith, he was in the Great War. Why the decision to fill in the blanks? And why did the team feel modern audiences would be drawn to this version of Perry Mason?

Rhys: When I met with the writers, they said, “Look, our hope is that we’ve loaded this guy’s bases and that he’s cracked.” You know, that’s what they were interested in portraying and that’s certainly part of the large attraction for me – seeing someone with some very real universal issues that you can relate to. Like I said, I wasn’t interested in the great servant of justice. I liked how fallible he was, how kind of gray his life is. It’s not that it’s depressing, but it’s certainly not black and white. He lives in the cracks.

All of the elements they heaped upon him, I think there’s a foundation, so they come from some very real places. Certainly, his time as a veteran and through the war has informed enormously who he is when we find him. His family, both his own immediate family and his generational family problems, on top of everything else, there were just a number of things I could relate to, or I could see that would be interesting to watch and certainly play.

We don’t get the Mason that I think some audiences might be expecting – the clever, inspirational trial attorney – until later in the series. And there is one sequence which really stands out, when you really give us old-school Perry Mason with a big courtroom reveal, but it’s kind of a bait-and-switch. Was that fun to play? To have a moment where you could be the heroic lawyer, even if it wasn’t necessarily truly happening in the narrative? 

Rhys: Yes, I loved how the whole project was approached. We had to be careful because we were working with Erle Stanley Gardner’s estate. It wasn’t just carte blanche, you couldn’t be willy-nilly and say, “We want to give you this, this, and this.” Things have to be okayed, and they were as game for it as everyone else, which was refreshing. But yeah, there was a sense of mischief in that you knew there’s a certain generation of people probably tuning in hoping to see one thing and going, “Oh, well, I wasn’t expecting that.” And there was an element, possibly, a smug element of the inside joke going, “Everyone might be expecting this, but we’re not going to do it.” There was fun to that as well.

Chris Chalk in Perry Mason

(Photo by Merrick Morton/HBO)

It’s impossible to talk about this show without talking about the time that it’s premiering in – this is a show in which police violence, corruption, and racism is front and center. Was Ferguson and the Black Lives Matter movement alive in the conversation as you guys were developing this series, working out the plot and who the characters would be?

Rhys: Not as specific as you’ve outlined and certainly not as specific as what we’re seeing at the moment. They’re age-old issues that they were interested in showing. There’s a number of reasons. I know Robert Downey Jr was interested in – and certainly with Paul Drake (Chris Chalk) – creating these outsiders who were kind of unified by that element. Los Angeles was always going to play a very interesting character in this piece. And at that time, there was this incredible thing happening where Black policemen were deployed to police their Black neighborhoods, but with White jurisdictions or White suspects, they didn’t have the same equality as their White counterparts. So, it was this incredibly interesting, if incredibly fraught, time. Certainly nothing new, but sadly something that is still relevant in this day and age. That was something they did want to bring to the forefront.

Pivoting a little bit, I wanted to talk about Sister Alice (Tatiana Maslany) and Perry’s relationship with her. But first of all, I just want to know how exhausted Tatiana was after delivering her incredibly lively sermons? I watched her thinking, “Holy s–t, I hope she only had to do one take.”

Rhys: I don’t know how she did that physically. The funeral scene was like two days – she did that sermon to 400 extras and she did not drop in any way in intention, clarity, focus, energy. It was like a feat of endurance to do that for two 14-hour days straight. I don’t know how she did it. It’s a testament to her.

Tatiana Muslany in Perry Mason

(Photo by Merrick Morton/HBO)

When people watch the first couple of episodes, they may start to think, “Who is this person? What is the connection?” Because there are kind of parallel plots happening. Without giving the plot away, how would you describe their emotional and experiential connection? What’s drawing these two characters to circle each other?

Rhys: I think they recognize in each other a number of things. They’re kind of caught in their own set of circumstances, looking out. They’ve had a number of impositions placed upon them, constraints in a way. And, ultimately, they’re very free-thinking, strong-willed people. Mason’s stance on religion – possibly brought about from his own family upbringing but definitely because of the war – where he’s kind of lost his religion, he views any kind of structured religion with great suspicion. So he is very wary of her. He very plainly says to her, “God left me in France.” And thus begins, like you said, the circling, this cat-and-mouse where he’s kind of going, “I think I’ve got your card lady.” And she’s kind of going, “Oh if only you knew the half of it.” They’re just very intrigued with each other, which I think is great. That is very often skirted, we had a very few scenes together. So that always keeps you dangling.

One of the other great relationships Perry has is with John Lithgow’s E.B. Jonathan, his boss and mentor. Had you worked with John before? Were you a fan?

Rhys: No, no, never worked with him. Huge fan, though, even from Footloose. I remember thinking, “When was it I first saw John Lithgow?” And I’m like, “Oh my god, Footloose.” And he’s like an icon now. You realize why [he’s an icon] when he comes on set, because he’s such a pro, in a Herculean scale. He comes on, he’s got all these ideas, he’s so prepared. He’s the real deal. I was awestruck when I saw him. It took me a moment to go, “Oh my god. I’m talking, sharing a screen with John Lithgow.” It was a great moment.

John Lithgow in Perry Mason

(Photo by Merrick Morton/HBO)

You kind of get to impersonate him later in the series. Did you workshop that with him? Has he seen it?

Rhys: I don’t think he’s seen it – I hope he hasn’t seen it. And I was worried because I came to love the man dearly and the last thing you want to do is create any kind of offense. So that worried me a bit. I watched so many YouTubes of him and went, “Oh god, I hope this doesn’t offend.” But we’ll see…

You’ve said you didn’t go back to read the source material or watch the original series starring Raymond Burr. Why did you approach it that way?

Rhys: I’ve done some book adaptations in the past and what I always do, I read the book and then I tend to bring things from the book into the script that script doesn’t necessarily hold up, warrant, or justify. So this time I was like “I’m going to leave the books alone. I’m going to stick purely to the script.” So that’s the Bible, that’s the linear point. So that there’s no other influence.

And I know with my own self, if I was to start watching any Raymond Burr, whether I was aware of it or not, I would have unconsciously or subconsciously probably started imitating or stealing or mimicking or bringing something. Then if you found out, that would be embarrassing. So I didn’t want any influences. I just wanted to kind of build him boots-up on my own.

The Americans, Season 5 (Patrick Harbron/FX/Everett Collection)

(Photo by Patrick Harbron/FX/Everett Collection)

Finally, Rotten Tomatoes users are huge fans of The Americans. Is Phillip Jennings a character you would ever revisit either in a film or some other adaptation that continued his story?

Rhys: Oh my God, I would revisit Phillip in a heartbeat. One of the simple facts is there’s so much foundation work gone in now. Whenever you picked him up, it would be just be so incredibly interesting. Whether you see them in Russia, whether you see them come back to try and find Henry, there’s so much that you could mine from how it was left. I would do it in a heartbeat.

Is there a storyline you’d be most interested in pursuing, or a period that you’d be most interested in going to for Phillip?

Rhys: Yes. One of the things I thought was just heartbreaking, and Joe Weisberg the creator said something interesting [about this], is that there has to be a cost to what they’ve done. As much as we created antiheroes, there has to be a cost to what they’ve done. And the greatest cost is abandoning, leaving their children, which as a kind of new father, I just found incomprehensible. So I think as we joined Phillip, what he would want is to see his children again. And the coming down of the Berlin Wall, I wonder if that would be a kind of good kickstarter for him to try and find Paige and Henry again. And then have a shootout with Stan or something.

OK, but no more U2 or you’ll break me again. That was too much.

Rhys: I know, I can’t listen to that song the same any more.

Perry Mason airs Sundays on HBO from June 21, 2020. 

Adjusted Score: -1%
Critics Consensus: Brimming with top notch performances and dripping in style, Perry Mason's compelling mystery mostly makes up for its messy storytelling.
Directed By: Tim Van Patten

Tag Cloud

venice rt labs trailers 1990s Horror BBC toy story Hear Us Out cartoon 2015 crime The Walking Dead unscripted Television Critics Association Disney streaming service diversity Columbia Pictures SXSW witnail adenture sag awards mockumentary NBC FOX japanese remakes Apple TV Plus festival debate LGBTQ TCA Fantasy binge Sneak Peek El Rey Valentine's Day nfl TCA 2017 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina justice league jamie lee curtis Tomatazos crime drama Lionsgate dark comiccon Travel Channel Wes Anderson Emmy Nominations HFPA Hallmark Elton John documentaries mcc boxing Oscars sopranos obituary based on movie TruTV Black History Month Comics on TV lord of the rings Kids & Family boxoffice die hard adaptation Tarantino The Academy Pirates sports stand-up comedy Year in Review CNN Super Bowl Quiz Disney Plus animated japan BBC One disaster X-Men target Vudu docudrama RT21 spider-man 2020 VOD dceu 71st Emmy Awards supernatural YouTube Red Hollywood Foreign Press Association chucky sitcom cars FX popular screen actors guild french Black Mirror LGBT Freeform ghosts Certified Fresh dramedy movies San Diego Comic-Con razzies Spike nature natural history reviews space MCU sequels CMT harry potter all-time james bond The Witch Baby Yoda Podcast Video Games Schedule elevated horror gangster Pop TV period drama fresh Opinion spain Esquire Ghostbusters quibi 90s Music Mystery kids king arthur First Reviews halloween 2019 Holiday Emmys MTV Mary poppins Netflix Christmas movies television jurassic park 79th Golden Globes Awards YouTube politics PBS Creative Arts Emmys suspense APB Fall TV christmas movies art house A24 Cartoon Network ViacomCBS series spy thriller Heroines monster movies 24 frames Britbox kong thriller Dark Horse Comics TCM rt labs critics edition Walt Disney Pictures Cannes 45 Showtime Marvel Television Cosplay marvel cinematic universe reboot YA Arrowverse ABC ABC Family free movies dragons GoT hollywood Toys transformers ITV ESPN leaderboard Disney+ Disney Plus documentary worst movies superman cooking Adult Swim Martial Arts golden globe awards Star Trek Avengers History scary movies Logo travel Lifetime Christmas movies hispanic 72 Emmy Awards twilight football Superheroe doctor who Tumblr emmy awards BET BBC America Lucasfilm CBS All Access BET Awards genre archives Thanksgiving Food Network 2021 BAFTA posters Acorn TV dreamworks canceled TV shows tv talk 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards theme song Syfy Election technology New York Comic Con The CW Christmas Mary Tyler Moore Film concert screenings VH1 police drama award winner Amazon Studios mob black blaxploitation TCA Winter 2020 halloween tv HBO Go Paramount Plus nbcuniversal DC Universe Sundance TV know your critic medical drama Neflix 21st Century Fox Starz young adult live action WarnerMedia See It Skip It MSNBC Academy Awards VICE Prime Video Sony Pictures TV One Fox News TV renewals Mudbound science fiction Instagram Live Awards zero dark thirty Grammys Countdown war discovery rotten movies we love FX on Hulu game show Fargo toronto Tags: Comedy comics Musical Masterpiece Nickelodeon zombie teaser revenge true crime game of thrones hispanic heritage month anime OWN sequel Peacock Endgame foreign mission: impossible Mindy Kaling Mary Poppins Returns Winners Biopics RT History 73rd Emmy Awards royal family E! Song of Ice and Fire Marathons Animation President Comedy Central Polls and Games Marvel composers Trailer Shudder universal monsters cancelled TV shows Spectrum Originals Ovation mutant crossover Lifetime rt archives batman criterion king kong CBS Netflix Star Wars critic resources Country Turner Classic Movies Comedy HBO Max films joker WGN Box Office Disney Channel IFC spanish golden globes casting comic book movies new york telelvision comedies Image Comics spinoff parents Trivia IFC Films Musicals Crackle south america psychological thriller blockbuster pirates of the caribbean Broadway richard e. Grant romantic comedy TV biography YouTube Premium breaking bad PlayStation wonder woman Apple National Geographic basketball superhero Warner Bros. Interview cats Anna Paquin CW Seed what to watch aapi cults Nominations E3 singing competition strong female leads Set visit dc NYCC classics American Society of Cinematographers spider-verse Pop cancelled TV series Captain marvel Hulu legend Fox Searchlight 93rd Oscars marvel comics 4/20 miniseries adventure news streaming movies comic book movie a nightmare on elm street Western prank Infographic DC streaming service Ellie Kemper Tokyo Olympics Trophy Talk Tubi dogs Sundance Now political drama worst PaleyFest TIFF social media Amazon Prime Video 20th Century Fox Paramount aliens IMDb TV godzilla new zealand spanish language DC Comics Alien NBA Marvel Studios Legendary romance Rocky comic books Film Festival Shondaland Epix GLAAD vs. cinemax Pacific Islander Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Reality Competition serial killer australia rotten Drama Discovery Channel SundanceTV USA 99% directors robots SDCC cancelled television Superheroes Holidays streaming facebook asian-american AMC 2017 Character Guide Best and Worst scorecard Sundance video on demand Pixar live event Disney HBO Pet Sematary new star wars movies AMC Plus talk show Television Academy A&E DGA Family Brie Larson Photos rom-coms Calendar renewed TV shows Turner scary blockbusters werewolf Women's History Month Red Carpet docuseries Spring TV dexter movie FXX TCA Awards OneApp vampires Sci-Fi Apple TV+ Teen black comedy biopic indie trophy Rom-Com action-comedy international feel good stop motion First Look children's TV TLC kaiju laika TBS olympics child's play The Arrangement Winter TV ID Extras Rocketman Classic Film Summer USA Network indiana jones Action finale Paramount Network zombies Funimation Stephen King fast and furious scene in color critics TV movies The Walt Disney Company Premiere Dates GIFs Reality book 2018 anthology saw high school stoner heist movie book adaptation Chernobyl Amazon Prime video deadpool The Purge satire Universal Pictures independent franchise best Nat Geo Watching Series Binge Guide canceled ratings psycho women 2016 historical drama latino Hallmark Christmas movies name the review italian TV Land crime thriller Exclusive Video slashers Pride Month versus slasher DirecTV festivals hist Crunchyroll green book TNT Awards Tour Universal Bravo comic Rock cancelled Amazon hidden camera ABC Signature cops Comic-Con@Home 2021 Writers Guild of America 007 Comic Book