Marvel Movie Madness! Part 6: Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

Closing out the Fantastic week.

by | May 20, 2011 | Comments

Enter Marvel Movie Madness, wherein Rotten Tomatoes watches all of the significant Marvel movies ever made. Full Marvel Movie Madness list here. Tune in! We give you our thoughts, and you give us yours.


Part 6: Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer (2007, 37% @ 166 reviews)

Directed by Tim Story, starring Ioan Gruffudd, Jessica Alba, Michael Chiklis, Chris Evans

Ryan: If you thought 2005’s Fantastic Four was bad, then you probably won’t be too surprised by anything in Rise of the Silver Surfer. But if you, like me, thought FF ’05 was OK despite its flaws, then RotSS will irritate you. It will probably make you regret giving the first one a fair shake.

Rise of the Silver Surfer is, at first, relatively familiar. Ioan Gruffud still suffers from an unhideable accent, Jessica Alba is still nothing more than a pretty face, Michael Chiklis is still the archetypal “big softie,” and Chris Evans again outshines his co-stars as the only properly cast character. The special effects are pretty solid, save for a bit of dodgy, of-its-time CGI in the form of the Silver Surfer, and the action pops a little bit, even if it’s ultimately forgettable — so, yeah, pretty much like the first installment.

The core problem (not the only one, mind you) with the movie is that it can’t seem to decide if it wants to be a kid flick or something for older audiences. The writing is terribly simplistic and the humor is broad (extended stretchy dance number, anyone?), but it’s intermixed with some sexual innuendo (how does The Thing, you know, “do it?”) and winks at the audience that kids just wouldn’t get. There’s just not enough of either to skew the film one way or the other, so it ends up being half entertaining for adult moviegoers and half beffuddling for kids. The first movie had a bit of that, but this was a big step down, in my opinion.

Alex: You know how some movies blur, making you aware you’re really just staring at a wall for two hours? This is one of them. Did anything of remote interest happen here? The first Fantastic Four edged itself between hokey and fun and came out on top, but everything here just toppled over at the slightest bit of drama. No good dialogue, Silver Surfer did nothing, and we see another Marvel superhero go to the dark side…by getting down on the dancefloor. How scandalous.

And, Jesus, I forgave Doctor Doom in the first movie, but this one? Julian McMahon looks barely fit to rule a Radio Shack. Hey, Fox: It’s been a few years. Please sell the rights to Marvel Studios. Tony Stark needs to set up drone strikes in Latveria.

Wait…there is something about this movie I remember…

There were Ray Bans. I need Ray Bans. And Midway’s fine video game, Hydro Thunder, available where Gillette razors are sold. And did you just say there’s a to-scale fully functional Fantasticar replica for purchase?! Wait, hold up… This Fantasticar is not manufactured by Dodge and it doesn’t have a Hemi as verbally endorsed by Mr. Fantastic and Human Torch? Well!! Good day, madam, I tip my top hat to you and bid farewell.


Ryan: Seriously! Morgan Spurlock even namechecks that exact scene as part of his inspiration for Greatest Movie Ever Sold. What’s funny is, Johnny Storm enters a scene early on in the movie holding up a NASCAR-like bodysuit emblazoned with various logos, and the others poke fun at him for being a brand whore. Haha, so meta!

Oh, and Doom? I almost laughed out loud when he spoke his first lines from the shadows of his cloak. Julian McMahon’s voice isn’t really the type to make me reach for an extra pair of boxers; he sounds like someone I might hear complaining loudly at my bank.

Jeff: I’m so mad at you guys for making me watch this movie. Someone could have at least told me that you can pretty much skip the first hour without missing anything.

Alex: It’s clear filming was compromised. Everything looks rushed. It shoots product placement out the ass non-stop. No wonder everybody walked away from this franchise.


Matt: This movie especially suffers if you’ve watched it right after the sitting through the 2005 movie. I watched both of them with a seven-year-old, and even he was getting bored with this movie.

What’s really frustrating about this franchise is that the filmmakers seem to have read a CliffsNotes version of what’s important to the Fantastic Four legacy, and then completely missed the point by making everything so bland that you just don’t care what’s happening. Doctor Doom, a wonderfully rich character in the comics comes off as merely slimy here. The Silver Surfer loses most of his nobility. Galactus is no longer a staggeringly powerful sentient being, but is now a mindless cloud of destruction; not to nerd out here, but one of the more interesting parts of the original comics plot was how Mr. Fantastic actually confronted Galactus. Even the idea of Johnny Storm using everyone’s powers at once is a bastardization of an old story about the Fantastic Four faced with the challenge of an alien soldier (the Super-Skrull) that shares all of their abilities, and could change shape to boot.

I think the Fantastic Four could be made into a great movie franchise someday, and I can only hope that the rights to these characters fall back under the Marvel umbrella someday. Marvel may not have a perfect record, but they can’t do anything worse to the Fantastic Four than what’s already been done.

More Marvel Movie Madness:

Tag Cloud

marvel cinematic universe Infographic Watching Series Black History Month book adaptation Bravo First Reviews PlayStation ratings VH1 Chilling Adventures of Sabrina kaiju independent theme song President TV Binge Guide Food Network a nightmare on elm street christmas movies The Walking Dead ABC Signature new york Set visit Box Office Lifetime award winner golden globes Best and Worst telelvision Captain marvel die hard joker hollywood legend dogs 90s Country twilight science fiction Turner cartoon diversity Hear Us Out Trivia DGA Crackle target all-time news Ovation Emmys Reality Freeform Comic Book chucky Apple canceled Oscars free movies supernatural cops Warner Bros. Classic Film medical drama stoner APB golden globe awards video 2015 BBC America Video Games series VICE docuseries historical drama video on demand finale Mary Tyler Moore children's TV crime The Purge TV renewals aliens streaming hidden camera screen actors guild BBC One Elton John Winners romantic comedy Marvel Television Quiz rt archives Trophy Talk Exclusive Video adventure Musical war El Rey Disney Plus New York Comic Con aapi sports Chernobyl DC Universe Interview Year in Review LGBTQ fast and furious 72 Emmy Awards Logo Television Academy 45 sitcom biography transformers quibi Image Comics Baby Yoda MSNBC know your critic The Arrangement superman facebook blockbuster critics comedies Pacific Islander Esquire YouTube Premium Countdown kids Superheroe Paramount what to watch Cosplay Walt Disney Pictures jamie lee curtis Mystery Apple TV Plus mission: impossible TV Land Rock BBC 1990s Creative Arts Emmys Masterpiece prank Netflix Sundance Disney Fall TV Horror A&E Cannes trailers fresh MTV emmy awards 2019 spanish best CMT talk show kong Disney Channel laika Family Tomatazos blockbusters cancelled Disney streaming service stand-up comedy Opinion Starz natural history indie Rom-Com Pet Sematary festival comiccon psycho Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt saw Pride Month Comedy Lifetime Christmas movies CNN GIFs justice league DC Comics godzilla obituary Polls and Games Lionsgate Anna Paquin animated TruTV spain nbcuniversal Podcast documentaries Sundance TV OWN Adult Swim dc BET FOX 4/20 Columbia Pictures Syfy 20th Century Fox BET Awards dramedy NBA ITV Awards dceu CBS All Access Film Festival heist movie USA Network Peacock Thanksgiving AMC tv talk comic books Cartoon Network Amazon Prime Video serial killer discovery Pirates composers Sci-Fi rotten binge asian-american Martial Arts sag awards Black Mirror travel Western 2021 thriller Pop TV FX child's play Marvel Studios mockumentary TCA Winter 2020 Fox Searchlight 2018 Ellie Kemper Ghostbusters TBS Stephen King high school The Walt Disney Company Nat Geo zombie true crime FX on Hulu Vudu doctor who monster movies comic X-Men FXX cults USA movie Writers Guild of America venice National Geographic cats TLC Women's History Month worst movies indiana jones Music dragons french Wes Anderson anime Grammys TIFF cancelled TV shows game of thrones renewed TV shows Marathons HBO Max crime drama Nickelodeon ABC Family 99% Photos Song of Ice and Fire deadpool Film spanish language Shondaland Premiere Dates Star Wars Animation green book CW Seed HBO docudrama 2016 ABC TV movies Sony Pictures Character Guide latino dark zombies based on movie remakes harry potter king kong 2020 pirates of the caribbean social media political drama new zealand toronto unscripted CBS Dark Horse Comics DirecTV Paramount Plus Alien strong female leads E3 Nominations reviews casting franchise Election worst Turner Classic Movies ViacomCBS batman sequel Calendar spy thriller king arthur adaptation The Witch lord of the rings foreign Super Bowl Holidays cinemax Reality Competition police drama SDCC italian Schedule Brie Larson Certified Fresh Summer hispanic cancelled television films cancelled TV series zero dark thirty Emmy Nominations WarnerMedia hist crossover directors Awards Tour sequels olympics Lucasfilm RT History streaming movies Heroines Funimation Red Carpet halloween Valentine's Day SundanceTV Shudder San Diego Comic-Con Kids & Family Amazon reboot Sneak Peek SXSW Winter TV nfl politics wonder woman crime thriller E! live action OneApp game show Mindy Kaling versus GLAAD Star Trek MCU vampires scary movies anthology 2017 nature HBO Go See It Skip It TCM RT21 werewolf Sundance Now scene in color A24 YouTube spinoff Britbox WGN Avengers Acorn TV period drama BAFTA TCA Amazon Prime miniseries screenings satire documentary Pop Spring TV Hallmark Christmas movies festivals comics TV One romance Amazon Studios Superheroes Hallmark Television Critics Association History Discovery Channel IFC japan football canceled TV shows Rocketman 24 frames television Drama YA teaser Apple TV+ women international Spectrum Originals Disney+ Disney Plus cars NBC james bond popular Hulu Travel Channel Marvel Mudbound scorecard Holiday mutant TCA Awards Epix name the review basketball NYCC Tumblr robots TCA 2017 Comic-Con@Home 2021 Tubi cooking Universal halloween tv slashers GoT Extras ESPN universal monsters Spike 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards boxoffice stop motion Mary Poppins Returns toy story Musicals technology Teen Toys suspense YouTube Red richard e. Grant PBS The Academy LGBT Paramount Network movies 21st Century Fox First Look Tokyo Olympics parents Fantasy Netflix Christmas movies Action criterion japanese ghosts razzies TNT Trailer rotten movies we love breaking bad PaleyFest south america adenture Crunchyroll Mary poppins Broadway 93rd Oscars black concert witnail singing competition book 71st Emmy Awards new star wars movies Legendary elevated horror Comics on TV Biopics Comedy Central spider-man archives IFC Films DC streaming service disaster Rocky Fox News ID Arrowverse australia revenge boxing Tarantino The CW rom-coms blaxploitation 007 Showtime jurassic park Pixar Academy Awards classics space Endgame Christmas VOD psychological thriller superhero American Society of Cinematographers