The Twilight Zone Early Reviews: Critics Gush Over Jordan Peele's Reboot of a Classic

Find out what critics are saying about the red-hot producer-director's update of the sci-fi series for streaming.

by | March 28, 2019 | Comments

Industry observers squealed like giddy preteens when they heard that Jordan Peele, director of horror films Get Out and just-released Us, planned to reboot the sci-fi/fantasy/psychological thriller/horror TV series, The Twilight Zone. And, judging by the early reviews, the auteur did not disappoint.

The CBS All Access anthology series’ cast includes some of today’s most celebrated actors, including Kumail Nanjiani (The Big Sick), Jessica Williams (2 Dope Queens), Adam Scott (Parks and Recreation), Taissa Farmiga (American Horror Story), John Cho (Star Trek Beyond), DeWanda Wise (She’s Gotta Have It), Steven Yeun (The Walking Dead), and more, and Peele himself hosts and narrates the series.

While the original Twilight Zone series has an 80% Tomatometer score, Peele has scored an excellent 95% (based on 20 reviews of the four screeners sent to critics) and Certified Fresh status on his adaptation right out the gate.

Can The Twilight Zone: Season 1 (2019) 74% sustain its lofty early Tomatometer score? Check out what critics have to say about the series so far:

Does the series live up to or surpass the original? 

Jordan Peele as The Narrator of the CBS All Access series THE TWILIGHT ZONE. Photo Cr: Robert Falconer/CBS © 2018 CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved.
(Photo by Robert Falconer/CBS)

The Twilight Zone reboot is exciting for both being an homage to the original and updated in all the right places. Some of the episodes are going to work well while others aren’t. Just like the original.” — Tim Surette, TV Guide

“This new Twilight Zone doesn’t have its own stamp yet, merely aping Serling’s, but it has potential. The changes and updates, even when not perfectly executed, are where the show can shine going forward.” — Kyle Anderson, Nerdist

“Jordan Peele proves that you can reboot a show and make it just as good as the original while updating it for a whole new audience. The Twilight Zone is back and, out of the gate, as good as it’s ever been.” — Rafael Motamayor, Bloody Disgusting

“This take on The Twilight Zone is nothing short of masterful and Rod Serling would be proud. Everything about this show is excellent and will make you question your reality in a way that only a rare piece of entertainment can.” — Alex Maidy, JoBlo’s Movie Emporium

“Reworking ideas from the original series in his own inimitable style, Peele’s riff on The Twilight Zone is mesmerizing and unforgettable.” — Brian Tallerico,

What if I haven’t seen the original series?

TWILIGHT ZONE, William Shatner, in the ep: 'Nightmare At 20,000 Feet,' 10/11/63. Season 5
(Photo by Everett Collection)

“It’s an inclusive space as much as a creative one, making the 2019 Twilight Zone a new machine built to last.” — Ben Travers, indieWire

“Proves itself a worthy successor to the original while updating its familiar formula for the modern world we live in.” — Dave Nemetz, TV Line

“In Serling’s original, characters had to look inward before they could discover the truth of their nightmarish circumstances. Despite its moments of levity, the CBS reboot is faithful to Serling in that fundamental respect.” — Adam Epstein, Quartz

“Jordan Peele brings a unique vision to Rod Serling’s landmark series, all without losing the tone, the finesse, and the smoky swagger that made it so iconic and enduring.” — Michael Roffman, Consequence of Sound

How is Peele as the host and narrator?

“The one performer we don’t get enough of is Peele, who admirably fills Rod Serling’s shoes as the onscreen narrator. With a rich, measured voice, and a steady gaze, Peele is so magnetic he immediately draws us in.” — Kristi Turnquist, Oregonian

“Maybe it shouldn’t be a surprise that the last few years also saw the rise of the ideal person to replace the original sci-fi philosopher, Rod Serling. I’m talking about Jordan Peele, the sketch comedian turned modern day horror maestro who — fresh off the record-breaking success of his sophomore feature, Us — is shepherding us back through the spinning door into a dimension as vast as space and as timeless as infinity. (Also known as CBS All Access.) ” — Vinnie Mancuso, Collider

How’s the acting?

"Nightmare at 30,000 Feet" -- Pictured: Adam Scott as Justin Sanderson of the CBS All Access series THE TWILIGHT ZONE available to stream on Monday, April 1st. Photo Cr: Robert Falconer/CBS © 2018 CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved.

“The cast is spectacular, with great actors like Kumail Nanjiani, Adam Scott, Sanaa Lathan, Greg Kinnear, and Steven Yeun as the leads in their respective episodes.” — Kevin Lever, Tell-Tale TV

“‘A Traveler’ is dark, mean, and imaginative. It also has the benefit of being anchored by a spectacular performance from Steven Yeun, an actor who’s star continues to rise and should be bracing for major things.” — Meghan O’Keefe, Decider

Are there any negatives? 

“Peele’s Twilight Zone feels neither like the best of Peele nor much like The Twilight Zone. It’s a mismatch of talents that, in the four episodes provided to critics, falls short of justifying its presence.” — Daniel D’Addario, Variety

“The 2019 Twilight Zone often dabbles in topics that are painfully relevant to today, but the real tragedy is, they were just as prevalent in Serling’s time, too. Our progress has been minimal.” — Chris Evangelista, Slashfilm

“It’s frustrating to see The Twilight Zone end up on CBS All Access instead of cable TV. While CBS gives primetime slots to conservative crime procedurals like NCIS and CSI, it cloisters away its best (and most racially diverse) programming on a subscription service that most people just aren’t going to pay for. That’s why Star Trek: Discovery isn’t the pop culture touchstone it should be, and why The Good Fight isn’t widely recognized as the best ongoing political drama of the Trump era. Maybe Peele’s brand is strong enough to invite an influx of new subscribers, proving CBS’s strategy right.” — Gavia Baker-Whitelaw, The Daily Dot

Any final thoughts? 

"Replay" -- Sanaa Lathan as Nina Harrison and Damson Idris as Dorian Harrison of THE TWILIGHT ZONE for CBS All Access. Photo Cr: Robert Falconer/CBS © 2018 CBS Interactive. All Rights Reserved.
(Photo by Robert Falconer/CBS)

“Like Peele’s films, the show works on multiple levels, weaving together the personal and the political to craft characters as nuanced as its themes.” — Judy Berman, TIME Magazine

“That this series has already figured out that it can be political simply by virtue of the stories it tells, the points of view it adopts, and the actors it employs is further proof that magic can happen in The Twilight Zone.” — Matt Zoller Seitz, New York Magazine/Vulture

Like this? Subscribe to our newsletter and get more features, news, and guides in your inbox every week.

Tag Cloud

TNT Trivia Horror Calendar adaptation Cosplay Western Starz Pride Month VH1 NYCC Musicals romance National Geographic medical drama Freeform Infographic ITV zero dark thirty Tumblr Watching Series Sony Pictures Teen FX robots TLC ESPN Comics on TV USA Network dceu Opinion Biopics CMT FXX Reality Competition Fox News Cannes SundanceTV blaxploitation Oscars Mary Tyler Moore ratings golden globes crime drama E! social media Sundance Elton John 45 Brie Larson GLAAD Film Festival Holidays vampires Premiere Dates boxoffice Tomatazos Walt Disney Pictures Masterpiece DirecTV ABC Family based on movie mutant LGBT YouTube Premium crime Country YouTube Red CNN BBC America 21st Century Fox science fiction Mystery The CW composers Hulu OWN justice league supernatural talk show MTV comic Heroines El Rey IFC toy story game show teaser MCU Awards Tour Year in Review richard e. Grant Martial Arts 24 frames GoT war San Diego Comic-Con docudrama Box Office Super Bowl Awards American Society of Cinematographers Warner Bros. Paramount finale TCM Amazon Prime Captain marvel Musical RT21 Lucasfilm Mudbound E3 cinemax Emmys doctor who Spectrum Originals Kids & Family police drama Star Trek Fantasy Reality TV RT History Food Network zombie Esquire Pixar Podcast Sci-Fi X-Men Britbox travel History psychological thriller Toys CBS transformers MSNBC 2016 Music diversity Animation Set visit adventure space natural history binge Song of Ice and Fire thriller Star Wars DC streaming service Disney award winner Mindy Kaling The Arrangement Sundance Now harry potter Vudu historical drama Chilling Adventures of Sabrina political drama Black Mirror hist PBS Comedy Valentine's Day LGBTQ Spike anthology Anna Paquin Showtime 2018 politics discovery AMC psycho Red Carpet GIFs singing competition Universal green book technology Chernobyl Action Superheroes A&E WarnerMedia TBS spy thriller streaming Apple Drama jamie lee curtis Amazon Thanksgiving Winter TV television cops SDCC unscripted Fall TV 2015 Shondaland period drama Photos dc theme song Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Extras spider-man 20th Century Fox Writers Guild of America crossover dramedy CBS All Access Paramount Network CW Seed elevated horror Countdown Shudder Syfy TCA 2017 VICE Ghostbusters FOX festivals IFC Films what to watch animated ABC Superheroe cooking nature Spring TV TruTV DGA anime Sneak Peek Election Tarantino Christmas true crime Rom-Com Marathons Grammys casting 007 First Look Nat Geo Bravo Adult Swim DC Universe biography HBO spinoff TIFF facebook BBC Logo disaster Emmy Nominations USA Certified Fresh Acorn TV Pirates miniseries 2019 DC Comics Cartoon Network comiccon Summer TCA Ellie Kemper Trailer Schedule Interview Mary Poppins Returns TV Land Pop sports SXSW APB sequel The Witch NBC witnail See It Skip It Nominations cats Rocketman New York Comic Con strong female leads PaleyFest Polls and Games 2017 Disney Channel Character Guide Crackle aliens Marvel Nickelodeon Video Games Trophy Talk Stephen King dragons serial killer YA sitcom cults Winners crime thriller Rock Lifetime Ovation Creative Arts Emmys mockumentary Pet Sematary President Comedy Central Columbia Pictures Best and Worst Dark Horse Comics Quiz WGN Women's History Month Rocky Lionsgate BET HBO Max Epix Comic Book Mary poppins Netflix zombies