Jay Cassidy on Into the Wild: The RT Interview

The Oscar-nominated editor discusses Sean Penn and making films in the wilds of Alaska

by | March 27, 2008 | Comments

Jay Cassidy waited eight years to help tell the true story of Christopher McCandless, the young man who hitchhiked into the Alaskan wilderness and never returned. Cassidy is an editor and long-time collaborator of director, Sean Penn, whose drive and passion finally brought the 2007 film, Into the Wild, to the screen.

With over thirty years of experience in the industry, Cassidy received a nomination for the 2008 Achievement in Film Editing Academy Award for his work on this adaptation of John Krakauer’s startling and inspiring novel. This is a story that could have slipped unnoticed except for a short piece in a small tabloid newspaper but rather, now stands as a reminder to pause and reflect more deeply on the many senseless deaths in the media.

Jay Cassidy talks to RT about working with Sean Penn, the Alaskan wilderness and the importance of losing his social skills for his art.


What originally attracted you to a career in editing?

Jay Cassidy: I have been editing for a long time. I began in the early 70s, working on political advertising and documentaries. At that moment, editing was, for me, the most compelling part of the filmmaking process. The documentary could be filmed over many years, but you made the film in the editing room.

If a documentary is made in the editing suite, how much is the editing process considered during filming? For example, at what point did you step into Into the Wild?

JC: I have worked with Sean Penn on all of the theatrical films he has done, so I was aware of this project for many years. I knew the book and knew about Sean’s ups and downs in getting it made. He would not make this film without the permission of the family and they were reluctant to go ahead for many years. So in this case, I was involved for a long time. I read early drafts of the script and sat in on script readings with the actors. This is the exception but I have a very long relationship with Sean.

At what point did you start contributing to conversations about how it will appear in the edit?

JC: This film was shot over eight months with many breaks. There were times when I wasn’t with the company and there were times when I was with them for weeks at a time. On the occasions when I wasn’t on the shoot, I simply saw the film when it came from the laboratory and we had no discussion about it. We knew roughly what Sean wanted as he went into each shoot. Alaska being a difficult place to work, you may go in with one intention, but you can certainly come out with something else, so in those cases we didn’t really discuss anything until I had a cut of the material and he had seen that cut. This shoot was a little peculiar in that the schedule was so rigorous that he sometimes didn’t see dailies until weeks later.

That suggests a real professional trust between the two of you.

JC: We would talk about the flow of it as we went and he would ask about specific shots. The interesting thing about this shoot was that, because the production had to follow the weather in Alaska, we would work for a while and then we would have to wait. Also, Emile Hirsch had this tremendous weight loss that he went through that necessitated halting the production while he lost the last 15 pounds. Sean and I would spend time together during those pauses to look at cuts and the dailies he hadn’t seen, and I could catch up with the production so that when we went into the next phase, we already knew what we had.

Sean Penn’s public persona is one of incredible intensity. How have you found working with him throughout your collaboration?

JC: I don’t know the public perception of Sean Penn, I only have a personal one and I would say that he certainly has a great passion which is confused for intensity. That passion is a large part of his leadership quality. People are willing to march into the Grand Canyon with him because they know he believes in what he is doing. He is a generous person and a story teller – the process of telling a story being an act of generosity – and he is also very generous with the crew.

As the character of Chris McCandless goes through his journey, the look and feel of the film seems to change. How did you use the editing to reflect his journey?

JC: An operating principle of this film was that we had to go someplace to shoot, so we may as well go to the actual places that Chris McCandless visited. And for the most part we did, sometimes to the exact spot. For example, when Chris was in a flash flood in his car, we filmed down to GPS accuracy where that actually happened. We could stand on set with photographs Chris McCandless had taken and match them up to where we were standing. Given that approach to filming, the whole movie was going to have a varying palette of texture, colour and nature. Some of those places were pretty far flung so you end up with a movie that has a view of the American West from many points of view and geography. We maintained that through the editing. The photographic treatment of Chris McCandless changed quite radically when he went to Alaska and he got in trouble. It is all a process of earning the trust of the audience so that when you end up in a place where the photography is quite distressed as well as the situation for the character, the audience have been led there visually, allowing them to accept it.

Do you have a signature editing style?

JC: I think an editing style is something that is ascribed to the work after-the-fact. I don’t think you go in with a particular intention, but I think if there is an integrity to the work and the material you are working with, the work comes from the nature of that material; essentially the person who creates what is being called ‘after-the–fact’ style shouldn’t be aware of it.

For someone aspiring to enter your profession, could you outline what a typical working day is like for you?

JC: I always like to tell people who are interested in the business, and the acquired wisdom I give my children, is to stay out of show business. There are better ways to lead your life. You might end up being happier and spend more time with your family and make more money if you don’t work in the film business. That advice, however, usually goes to no avail for the people who aspire to it. In a certain regard, it is a horrible life because, if you are really working on something intensely, your social skills fall away and you are not fit to be brought out into public. That is, if you are truly involved in a film and if you are going to do any kind of good work, you have to have that full commitment to the work. If you aren’t willing to do that, or if that is not in your nature, I say steer clear of it.

Has your approach to watching a film been affected by your role as a film editor?

JC: I am so delighted when I get to see a really good movie. In that experience the artifice of movie making, the photography or the cutting style, falls away because you are inside the movie. Part of the discipline of being an editor is that you have to be a good audience member; your work is to be a surrogate audience member on the films you are working on. I certainly don’t have any trouble watching movies. I love the movies.

And finally, you talked earlier about the respect Penn had for the McCandless family and the importance of having their support in the making of this film. Do you think the family are happy with Into the Wild?

JC:I think Chris’ sister, Carine McCandless, certainly was. She was involved all along and saw cuts and worked on the voice over, because it was actually her voice. For his parents, it was a bit of an up and down experience. I think they have come to terms with it and I think they are very happy it was made, despite the fact that there are times in the film when they are not portrayed in the best light. For them, I believe, it is some manner of forgiveness for them to have participated in the making of this film about their son’s life.

Into the Wild is now available on DVD.

Tag Cloud

Infographic 73rd Emmy Awards Lionsgate VOD Disney streaming service Paramount Plus Instagram Live kong christmas movies Travel Channel book TCM live event nfl chucky crime Comics on TV Avengers political drama BBC Marvel trailers Family HBO Go Red Carpet historical drama high school Comic Book scene in color film series X-Men nbcuniversal Classic Film TCA 2017 LGBT crossover Mudbound Film Festival Drama Best Actress directors Superheroe Shudder kaiju thriller Calendar DC Comics Prime Video spider-man Tumblr Paramount Network Showtime harry potter E! TCA Awards The Witch comedies video DGA posters Black History Month SXSW 2022 National Geographic 90s Interview genre telelvision Neflix VH1 Crackle Disney diversity japanese canceled Pet Sematary mockumentary CMT Marathons Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt summer TV olympics 79th Golden Globes Awards Heroines robots vs. Musical Baby Yoda A&E Hulu fast and furious docuseries saw The Arrangement italian streaming Disney Channel superhero black comedy Rom-Com spider-verse Amazon Best Director TCA Warner Bros. news DC Universe screen actors guild Chernobyl OneApp TV renewals Mystery San Diego Comic-Con space worst movies Sony Pictures adaptation Captain marvel TV Creative Arts Emmys ID latino criterion Black Mirror The Walt Disney Company sag awards remakes black cancelled television parents BET Awards CW Seed Binge Guide politics suspense stoner FOX scene in color series summer TV preview singing competition Awards Tour elevated horror cancelled pirates of the caribbean Shondaland twilight theme song cults Animation south america festivals japan golden globe awards cops werewolf ABC Family razzies Set visit Country documentaries comiccon Music deadpool toronto romantic comedy Premiere Dates based on movie popular BAFTA Countdown young adult basketball monster movies dc technology See It Skip It GIFs Opinion Spring TV Native Women's History Month wonder woman foreign blaxploitation Tags: Comedy MCU witnail Winter TV universal monsters joker blockbuster target scene in color Year in Review Alien 2020 TCA Winter 2020 teaser comic books Crunchyroll USA TV Land President movies travel Reality Competition Columbia Pictures superman Amazon Prime Video Polls and Games award winner Trivia Dark Horse Comics Christmas ghosts Reality Universal Paramount Song of Ice and Fire binge feel good biopic all-time Stephen King game show new star wars movies action-comedy zombies TBS Geeked Week spinoff BBC America 007 Vudu new york CBS rt labs Biopics Spike Fargo 2016 FX on Hulu canceled TV shows festival Elton John comic book movie Marvel Television zero dark thirty Endgame rt archives finale Star Trek Amazon Prime Fall TV MSNBC TV One heist movie cancelled TV shows Rocketman international Discovery Channel critics SDCC Wes Anderson APB Universal Pictures PaleyFest DC streaming service summer preview obi wan Exclusive Video Musicals Arrowverse 2021 slasher screenings social media Logo Character Guide scorecard MTV CNN Oscars Epix Schedule PBS Britbox Hallmark Christmas movies Thanksgiving true crime war psycho cartoon biography CBS All Access emmy awards batman dexter HBO The Purge spy thriller Lucasfilm mutant Sneak Peek First Look Winners cooking animated transformers leaderboard Turner E3 debate vampires 1990s godzilla 4/20 OWN serial killer SXSW First Reviews women best dark Walt Disney Pictures Television Academy YouTube target franchise Academy Awards Freeform Indigenous Ghostbusters gangster 71st Emmy Awards Apple TV Plus Emmys fresh Disney Plus halloween Television Critics Association period drama hist halloween tv Pop trophy prank hispanic heritage month Image Comics dceu cinemax Horror anthology Lifetime Christmas movies revenge Turner Classic Movies Netflix Sci-Fi documentary WGN comic marvel comics FXX Video Games Box Office TruTV rotten Focus Features anime disaster dogs classics lord of the rings Amazon Studios Mindy Kaling broadcast WarnerMedia spanish language king arthur art house Nominations versus Sundance Now Apple TV+ what to watch Photos 24 frames ViacomCBS Awards a nightmare on elm street IMDb TV die hard Bravo NBC quibi IFC Films The Walking Dead unscripted indiana jones crime thriller History A24 Writers Guild of America ESPN asian-american TLC Funimation Hallmark AMC Hollywood Foreign Press Association Best Picture laika PlayStation legend supernatural sequel USA Network Apple Oscar HFPA YouTube Premium Acorn TV comics mob New York Comic Con Film Peacock cancelled TV series aliens Certified Fresh TV movies cars Cosplay casting name the review Pirates children's TV cats scary movies renewed TV shows Food Network Tarantino Sony Pop TV richard e. Grant television Nat Geo Broadway hollywood mission: impossible NYCC 2017 Western dramedy facebook Valentine's Day mcc Sundance TV child's play Lifetime breaking bad reviews GLAAD toy story Teen stop motion rotten movies we love 20th Century Fox scene in color TNT kids GoT ITV YouTube Red Brie Larson Ovation crime drama know your critic MGM Holiday justice league strong female leads Syfy AMC Plus Adult Swim Election Comedy Fox News Action YA Pride Month American Society of Cinematographers Toys Cartoon Network satire psychological thriller Watching Series marvel cinematic universe Cannes critic resources Summer Star Wars Netflix Christmas movies Masterpiece Emmy Nominations 93rd Oscars football rom-coms 78th Annual Golden Globe Awards discovery free movies Extras dreamworks Anna Paquin talk show sports VICE Kids & Family Trophy Talk streaming movies Martial Arts Rocky blockbusters TIFF interviews docudrama Marvel Studios video on demand 2015 films obituary sopranos sequels Pixar live action reboot king kong Mary Tyler Moore police drama Pacific Islander Disney+ Disney Plus South by Southwest Film Festival Comedy Central Mary poppins hidden camera HBO Max spanish Ellie Kemper 2019 IFC Spectrum Originals series Tomatazos Esquire comic book movies Podcast stand-up comedy Comic-Con@Home 2021 BET jamie lee curtis scary royal family Trailer 99% jurassic park Grammys archives dragons doctor who Star Wars Celebration natural history miniseries The CW adventure worst nature Quiz green book science fiction BBC One Paramount Pictures indie LGBTQ DirecTV Fantasy Tubi slashers FX Starz Chilling Adventures of Sabrina 2018 Nickelodeon streamig hispanic Best Actor zombie tv talk Rock book adaptation golden globes adenture australia new zealand Holidays Superheroes 21st Century Fox The Academy movie composers SundanceTV 94th Oscars Super Bowl Tokyo Olympics ABC Mary Poppins Returns spain 72 Emmy Awards ABC Signature independent venice french game of thrones Legendary rt labs critics edition sitcom concert boxing Fox Searchlight james bond 45 aapi Hear Us Out NBA RT21 Sundance ratings El Rey romance Best and Worst boxoffice RT History medical drama