Critics Consensus

Hunter Killer Is Substandard

Plus, Mid90s, Bodyguard, The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, and Burning are Certified Fresh.

by | October 25, 2018 | Comments

This weekend at the movies, we’ve got underwater intrigue (Hunter Killer, starring Gerard Butler and Gary Oldman), Jonah Hill‘s coming-of-age coming-out party (Mid90s, starring Sunny Suljic and Lucas Hedges), and a faith-based military drama (Indivisible, starring Justin Bruening and Sarah Drew). What are the critics saying?


Hunter Killer (2018) 36%

There’s solid drama to be mined from the undersea adventures of dozens of men tossed into a weaponized metal tube and expected to traverse the ocean in covert exercises. See Das Boot, The Hunt for Red October, or Crimson Tide, for starters. This week’s Hunter Killer, which stars Gerard Butler and Gary Oldman in a thriller about a high-stakes submarine rescue mission, aims to join the ranks of those classics by combining geopolitics and good, old-fashioned blockbuster action. Unfortunately, critics say the film is neither thoughtful enough to fully explore any complex themes nor directed with enough pizzazz to work even as an effective B-grade time-killer. Hunter Killer may satisfy those looking for an undemanding, by-the-numbers actioner, but it’s not likely to excite anyone who’s ever seen any submarine thriller before.


Mid90s (2018) 76%

With so many films about youth culture available for anyone with a streaming account to watch, it’s increasingly rare to find a coming-of-age film that isn’t either frustratingly derivative or cloyingly sentimental, much less one that’s also a directorial debut. Luckily, Jonah Hill has apparently managed to avoid doing that in his first feature behind the camera. Mid90s follows the life of 13-year-old Stevie (Sunny Suljic), a Los Angeleno who hooks up with a new group of friends at his local skate shop and experiences a summer of discovery, and critics say it’s a touching, earnest look at growing up that depicts the titular decade affectionately without fetishizing it. It’s a promising first outing for Hill in the director’s chair and a reminder that he’s come a long way from his stoner comedies just a decade ago.


Indivisible (2018) 71%

The hardships endured by military families are well familiar to a vast swath of the population, and the toll they exact is ripe material for sensitive storytelling. Enter Pure Flix’s Indivisible, based on the true story of a U.S. Army chaplain who was deployed to Iraq not long after graduating from seminary school, leaving behind his wife and three children. While we’d love to tell you what the reviews say about the drama, it wasn’t screened for critics. Faith-based films typically rely on a built-in audience and word of mouth, but you know the drill. Guess that Tomatometer!


What’s New on TV

Bodyguard: Series 1 (2018) 98%

Bodyguard maintains a palpable tension throughout its pulpy proceedings to create an absorbing and addicting psychological thriller.


Chilling Adventures of Sabrina: Season 1 (2018) 90%

Bewitchingly beautiful and wickedly macabre, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina casts an intoxicating spell and provides a perfect showcase for Kiernan Shipka‘s magical talents.


Heathers: Season 1 (2018) 30%

Despite promising performers, Heathers‘ aspirational angst is let down by its blunt, misguided attempts at social commentary.


Also Opening This Week In Limited Release

  • Shirkers (2018) , a documentary following director Sandi Tan‘s efforts to recover a film she made as a teen in 1992 that was stolen by a collaborator, is at 100%
  • A Bread Factory, Part One: For the Sake of Gold (2018) , the first half of Patrick Wang‘s two-part drama about a community-driven art collective fighting to keep its funding, is at 100%.
  • A Bread Factory, Part Two: Walk with Me a While (2018) , the companion piece to A Bread Factory: For the Sake of Gold, is at 100%.
  • Weed the People (2018) , a documentary chronicling the effort of parents to track down cannabis oil as an alternative treatment for their children’s cancer, is at 100%.
  • Border (Gräns) (2018) , a mystery from Sweden about a customs agent with an uncanny sense of smell who falls for a man who blunts her power, is at 97%.
  • 1985 (2018) , about a closeted gay man who returns home to Texas and contends with his religious parents and an old friend, is at 95%.
  • Burning (Beoning) (2018) , South Korean director Lee Chang-dong‘s mystery about an explosive love triangle, is Certified Fresh at 92%.
  • Life and Nothing More (La Vida y Nada Más) (2018) , about a single mother struggling to keep her teenage son out of trouble with the law, is at 92%.
  • The Dark (2018) , a horror film about a troubled man who forms a bond with the spirit of a murdered girl in the woods, is at 92%.
  • Monrovia, Indiana (2018) , a documentary focusing on the titular city to illustrate rural, small-town American culture, is at 91%.
  • Suspiria (2018)Luca Guadagnino‘s remake of Dario Argento’s 1977 horror film of the same name, is at 72%.
  • Viper Club (2018) , starring Susan Sarandon in a drama about a nurse’s efforts to free her journalist son from terrorists, is at 71%.
  • Don't Go (2018) , about a grieving couple haunted by visions of their dead daughter, is at 50%.
  • Silencio (2018) , a sci-fi drama about a woman searching for a powerful meteorite that might save her son’s life, is at 43%.
  • Johnny English Strikes Again (2018) , starring Rowan Atkinson as the bumbling British agent, who is pulled out of retirement to prevent a technological catastrophe, is at 31%.
  • London Fields (2018) , starring Billy Bob Thornton in a thriller about a dying author who finds inspiration for his last book in a group of new acquaintances, is at 0%.

Tag Cloud

Musical DirecTV E! vampires Walt Disney Pictures period drama LGBTQ romance adventure Grammys cooking TCA Amazon Warner Bros. Oscars TruTV SDCC Fox News Comedy TIFF anime golden globes Spike DC Universe aliens Sneak Peek Bravo Musicals X-Men SundanceTV Reality Marvel sitcom thriller Starz 20th Century Fox Disney Channel Marathons Ghostbusters spy thriller Election GIFs 21st Century Fox FOX travel Lifetime Mary Tyler Moore Toys zombies serial killer ABC USA Network GoT Nominations E3 Trailer Awards Calendar A&E Year in Review what to watch Superheroe dceu BBC Food Network cinemax SXSW Nat Geo composers The Arrangement TLC social media ITV Biopics Photos Columbia Pictures WGN TV Masterpiece Superheroes Mindy Kaling Super Bowl GLAAD dc Britbox Opinion historical drama streaming Video Games technology Certified Fresh Premiere Dates Red Carpet Comedy Central Teen See It Skip It Christmas Pop Pirates Music Thanksgiving harry potter CNN Valentine's Day Spring TV Lionsgate singing competition finale San Diego Comic-Con TV Land Sony Pictures Animation 2016 dramedy New York Comic Con hist Lucasfilm OWN Western ABC Family Cosplay BBC America YA Fall TV blaxploitation crossover Drama CBS All Access HBO crime Ovation Best and Worst police drama biography Freeform TCA 2017 robots VICE television Dark Horse Comics ratings cats DC streaming service crime drama 007 Adult Swim zombie 2017 MSNBC CW Seed History Netflix sports Apple Ellie Kemper diversity TBS RT History talk show BET PBS Epix binge Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt APB science fiction psycho Reality Competition discovery IFC Films Nickelodeon Watching Series Character Guide TCM President Horror Interview NYCC National Geographic Star Wars Song of Ice and Fire Set visit crime thriller USA Rom-Com Hulu 24 frames Star Trek YouTube Red festivals political drama Polls and Games Creative Arts Emmys Country Fantasy FX Pixar boxoffice Mystery Disney Schedule Sundance Syfy Martial Arts doctor who medical drama Winners Sci-Fi Esquire 45 war Winter TV Shondaland Infographic Rocky NBC Logo ESPN TNT Action The CW Trivia Box Office Cartoon Network cops VH1 El Rey 2015 comiccon CBS Comic Book First Look Universal Crackle Quiz CMT DC Comics Chilling Adventures of Sabrina Shudder politics unscripted Comics on TV Emmys Kids & Family comic FXX Acorn TV AMC transformers supernatural Podcast PaleyFest Paramount Tomatazos justice league Summer mutant Countdown Tumblr Writers Guild of America based on movie Sundance Now jamie lee curtis American Society of Cinematographers IFC Holidays docudrama YouTube Premium Rock Paramount Network Extras MTV Showtime cults